Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you go to a&e if you thought you had sprained your ankle?

213 replies

Awarethebear · 02/03/2022 13:51

Hi, I ended up twisting my ankle whilst stepping off of a large step and onto unbeknownst to me slippy mud on the school run yesterday afternoon, it hurt straightaway but I was able to walk the twenty minute journey after ( in pain and with a limp). When I arrived home I noticed my ankle was swollen and after a couple of hours the bruising began. It's really painful to walk on almost 24 hours later, I'm wondering is it just sprained or could it be broken. Would you go to the hospital if this was you?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
5
Beveren · 05/03/2022 08:21

Our local minor injuries unit is brilliant. They have a doctor on hand but much of the work is done by nurse practitioners who are very thorough and professional. I went to ours recently because it was the weekend and I felt it couldn't wait, they assigned me to the doctor who diagnosed shingles affecting my eyes and was referred immediately to the most local eye hospital. One of those days that makes you grateful for the NHS.

Getmeoutaherenow · 05/03/2022 05:35

Suspected concussion

Getmeoutaherenow · 04/03/2022 23:21

Ds hit his head at school - su at pecked concussion, called GP who said you need to go to minor injuries 10 miles away, as he needed an x ray to assess, waited 2 hours at miu to be seen by a nurse as they didn’t have doctors in the unit and anyway they wouldn’t x ray a child’s head only a limb if pushed and someone was there - so he ended up being assessed by a nurse who wondered why the hell a GP had sent us to her! Don’t see the point of a minor injuries unit beyond getting simple wounds dressed they are bloody useless.

NativityDreaming · 04/03/2022 22:16

@WeirdlyKind my comment was directed at someone else who quoted my reply when I said what I would do, saying my approach was useless. I can’t quote the previous reply, as they quoted me, so included a screenshot of their reply.

Your reply actually confirms mine, we all need to do what works in our area. All the people telling the OP go to minor injuries when she had already said there wasn’t one obviously haven’t rtft. And all the people saying that she doesn’t need an X-ray when NHS advice clearly states to get one are similarly wrong.

WeirdlyKind · 04/03/2022 22:09

@NativityDreaming

When are people going to stop being so ignorant as to assume every area of the U.K. operates the same way? You cannot just attend A&E where I am, going through your GP or OOH is the only way to get an appointment at the A&E assessment unit (barring a life or limb emergency).

It is not pointless where I am to go through your GP for a suspected sprain, it is the correct course of action.

But it is pointless to see the GP in my area - they won't deal with anything accident related and just send you on to urgent care (which is part of the local A&E department.)
NativityDreaming · 04/03/2022 21:09

When are people going to stop being so ignorant as to assume every area of the U.K. operates the same way? You cannot just attend A&E where I am, going through your GP or OOH is the only way to get an appointment at the A&E assessment unit (barring a life or limb emergency).

It is not pointless where I am to go through your GP for a suspected sprain, it is the correct course of action.

Would you go to a&e if you thought you had sprained your ankle?
PickAChew · 04/03/2022 20:58

We have minor injuries in some community hospitals around our county though they're not fully open, full time. No such thing in my part of the county but that's because we have a big teaching hospital with an A&E.

Abraxan · 04/03/2022 20:47

@NativityDreaming

I would see my GP, they do assessments like this and send you to the hospital if they think an X-ray is warranted.
Pointless seeing a GP for such an injury IME. Unless they have an xray machine most GPS will refer you to a more suitable department - minor injuries unit (if you have one, I know many areas don't) or A&E if not.

Being able to walk on it or move it doesn't mean it might not be broken. I've known a number of people have similar injuries and it be broken - leaving it and walking on it can make the break more of an issue.

Ideally a minor injuries unit would be the place to go, if you have one.

Ime A&E staff aren't going ti treat you with disdain because you have used the service for an accident and injury like this. You may have a long wait depending on what your area is like.

feeona123 · 04/03/2022 20:34

I went to minor injuries with my ‘sprained’ ankle only to have it poked then sent away with a leaflet and told if it is broken treatment is the same.

purplesequins · 04/03/2022 20:24

having had what I thought was a sprained ankle turned out to be a broken bone (swelled up, bruised, could weight bear) I would have it x-rayed.
in some areas it's a&e in others walk in clinics or no urgent care.

JustLyra · 04/03/2022 20:14

@Frankola

When I hurt my ankle and couldn't bear weight on it I went to the walk in centre at my local hospital. Not A&E.

Please don't go to A&E. There are walk in centres everywhere

Why would you assume there are “walk in centres everywhere” when the OP has quite clearly stated there is A&E or GP where she is.

There are no walk in centres around here at all.

CapMarvel · 04/03/2022 20:11

No there isn't. The only walk in NHS facility within 100 miles of me is only open 3 days a week and doesn't have the facility to do xrays.

Frankola · 04/03/2022 20:01

When I hurt my ankle and couldn't bear weight on it I went to the walk in centre at my local hospital. Not A&E.

Please don't go to A&E. There are walk in centres everywhere

TroysMammy · 04/03/2022 19:42

@StationaryMagpie I agree with you. It doesn't stand for anything and everything that some people believe either.

StationaryMagpie · 04/03/2022 14:14

A&E stands for Accident AND Emergency.... Not 'Dying or Emergency'

Not everywhere has a Minor Injury unit, so only place for x-rays, are A&E.

Telling people not to go for injuries that could potentially be a broken bone or severely torn ligament is bloody stupid, and i wish people would stop it.

Blondeshavemorefun · 03/03/2022 22:27

A&e isn’t just for life threatening stuff

All of the ones waiting in the entrance with me weren’t life threatening

A lot of limps like me

Some had hurt their arms as in make shift sling

Others been in fights

None of us were on deaths door

But it’s where you go when a Doctor can’t help

CapMarvel · 03/03/2022 21:40

There is some properly terrible advice in this thread.

Firstly, you CANNOT tell without an x-ray if an injured ankle is sprained or broken. You just can't.

Secondly, not everywhere has minor injury walkin centres, especially ones with x-ray facilities. A&E is often the only option. Don't waste time going to a GP or a pharmacy - they don't have x-rays. They will tell you to go to A&E.

Thirdly, sprains are not "just sprains". They can be as painful or more so than breaks and often require longer periods of rehab and care.

TLDR: If you have injured your ankle severely enough, go to A&E.

JustLyra · 03/03/2022 21:23

@Aikatarina

A&E is for life threatening conditions, so go to a minor injuries unit if there’s one near you (there normally is). You’ll get seen much quicker
If only the OP had stated on the first few pages that there is no Minor Injuries near her to save people giving advice she can’t take…
Luredbyapomegranate · 03/03/2022 21:16

[quote TheMagpie]@Luredbyapomegranate
@FinnulaFloss
@ErrolTheDragon

I'm unsure as to why you're all assuming I'd judge others for doing so, I personally can tell the difference due to experiencing both many times each.[/quote]
We don’t, we’re just bemused by the idea you think the OP could tell the difference.

And if you don’t think she can - why post at all?

Susu49 · 03/03/2022 20:37

Women have a higher biological threshold than men too (fact)

LakieLady · 03/03/2022 20:35

I'd go to A&E. I spoke to a friend today, her husband "sprained" his ankle a few weeks ago, and hobbled about on it for 2 weeks.

It was broken, and he had to have surgery to sort it out.

Cryalot2 · 03/03/2022 20:31

Poor you op.
I fell 10 days ago. ( thank goodness no one saw) It was my own fault. Ankle is badly swollen and painful. Knee is swollen and bruised in 2 areas and cut( carpet type burn) .
I got taken to the chemist to buy supports for both.
I have not been to A&E but would have went . But our local hospitals are at breaking point.
The only difference since is I tried going without one of the supports and could barely walk.
I am on a lot of painkillers as it is. Years ago I had a broken arm for almost 6 weeks before I got to hospital.
If you can get to a hospital that doesn't have huge waiting times go.

Gherkingreen · 03/03/2022 20:13

@Dinoteeth I had an x-ray on the evening I did it, about 5 hours afterwards, and it didn't show a break. It was horrible to be honest, very painful and unable to bear weight for weeks, on crutches for a long time.
It was about 2 weeks before lockdown so I was lucky in that I could work from home but flip side was I wasn't able/didn't feel able to seek medical help for it at the time.
It still niggles every now and again bit I'm back to home workouts and I can walk/run so not all bad.
Won't ever go back to that gym tho, the floor used to get really slippery with condensation during classes and I think that's what caused me to slip and go over hard on my ankle during a combat class Sad

Anonymous48 · 03/03/2022 20:07

[quote worriedatthemoment]@Anonymous48 we sometimes have minor injury units but not allways
But our a & e are for broken bones and stitches and stuff as well in uk not just life threatening
You will just wait a while and they have a non emergency part as such , and you go to a &e if no Minor injury unit nearby or if they don't have an xray there which is sometimes the case [/quote]
Thank you for the explanation. Smile

Dinoteeth · 03/03/2022 19:24

@Gherkingreen that is mighty impressive, I would have gone to A&E with that, are you sure nothing was broken