Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the new cervical screening system will miss cancer cases

79 replies

PeasAndFlour · 02/03/2022 11:02

I think the new system is a blunt tool without room for nuance. E.g. if someone has hpv, then in the next smear they don’t, the previous hpv could have caused cell changes before the infection cleared but these aren’t picked up on, because the cells aren’t looked at anymore.

Privatisation through the back door. This will push women to go private if they have had previous complications.

OP posts:
PeasAndFlour · 02/03/2022 14:30

[quote sunlovingcriminal]**@PeasAndFlour* I'll pay for a colposcopy as I know I have low grade changes. Just hope that the gp manages to get a nhs referral for me. Seems ludicrous that just because my body has cleared the hpv virus, they already* know that I have low grade changes- so should therefore keep an eye on me! Infuriating! [/quote]
Good luck. How much is a private colposcopy where you’re looking? I think a private smear is about £300. It’s not something I can afford either but I’d just put it on my credit card.

OP posts:
sunlovingcriminal · 02/03/2022 14:20

@PeasAndFlour I'll pay for a colposcopy as I know I have low grade changes. Just hope that the gp manages to get a nhs referral for me. Seems ludicrous that just because my body has cleared the hpv virus, they already know that I have low grade changes- so should therefore keep an eye on me! Infuriating!

sunlovingcriminal · 02/03/2022 14:18

@PeasAndFlour my letter also said back to 3 year checks. So I agree that it if your sister is still being offered annual more in-depth checks, that is a postcode lottery!

PeasAndFlour · 02/03/2022 14:16

@sunlovingcriminal

I am in exactly this boat. Previously had pre-cancerous cells and hpv. Last smear, no hpv, so no annual check up on my abnormal cells. So I've had to independently contact the gp, to see if I can get a referral for a colposcopy. Bet they'll come back and say no (only asked last week)- so that'll mean me going for a private colonoscopy which I can't really afford.
Which do you think is worth paying for, colposcopy or smear? Or both? Or colposcopy if you know you have low grade abnormal cells from a previous smear, and maybe smear to start with if you previously just had hpv?
OP posts:
Ozanj · 02/03/2022 14:15

@PeasAndFlour probably.

PeasAndFlour · 02/03/2022 14:13

My letter even said due to no hpv this time I was back to 3 yearly checks. So @Ozanj your sil experience is very different to mine despite both being NHS. Something isn’t right?

OP posts:
PeasAndFlour · 02/03/2022 14:11

@Ozanj

Its incorrect. Sil had hpv. The system recognised she had it last year and she was offered an annual scan this year. Results were no abnormal changes + no hpv but they still want her to have annual checks.
That is not my experience. The cells were not analysed at all despite the previous smear being positive. Would this be a case of postcode lottery?
OP posts:
Ozanj · 02/03/2022 14:09

@sunlovingcriminal

I am in exactly this boat. Previously had pre-cancerous cells and hpv. Last smear, no hpv, so no annual check up on my abnormal cells. So I've had to independently contact the gp, to see if I can get a referral for a colposcopy. Bet they'll come back and say no (only asked last week)- so that'll mean me going for a private colonoscopy which I can't really afford.
Just go to a private GP service and request an NHS referral.
CommonPrimrose · 02/03/2022 14:08

Bitemyarsenic, thanks a much for replying.

That makes it well worth attending then imo.

Ozanj · 02/03/2022 14:08

Its incorrect. Sil had hpv. The system recognised she had it last year and she was offered an annual scan this year. Results were no abnormal changes + no hpv but they still want her to have annual checks.

sunlovingcriminal · 02/03/2022 14:04

I am in exactly this boat. Previously had pre-cancerous cells and hpv. Last smear, no hpv, so no annual check up on my abnormal cells. So I've had to independently contact the gp, to see if I can get a referral for a colposcopy. Bet they'll come back and say no (only asked last week)- so that'll mean me going for a private colonoscopy which I can't really afford.

PeasAndFlour · 02/03/2022 14:04

@SickAndTiredAgain

Does HPV infection cause an increased risk of cancer, even once the infection is gone? I mean for example - I tested positive for HPV a few years ago and some abnormal cells were detected and I had a colposcopy. At my most recent smear, there was no HPV. Is my risk now the same as someone who has never had HPV? And therefore I don’t need my smear test sample to be examined further, unless I tests positive for HPV again?
Really good question, I’d like to know the answer to that too.
OP posts:
bitemyarsenic · 02/03/2022 14:01

@CommonPrimrose

It depends if they are checking visually for changes. My gp did mine after post menopausal bleeding and told me I had polyps for example. Now I have no idea whether a nurse doing a smear would have picked that up. Anyone know?
Yes the nurse picked up a polyp on one of mine which was removed and then I was referred for colposcopy 3 years later because of a cyst seen by the nurse.( cyst can also be rare cancer) I am an HCP and an awful lot of women who present with tumours are picked up by nurses , although often they will attend for a smear due to bleeding etc. Most had missed smears previously. Im concerned about threads on here where women are saying if they only test for HPV they wont bother going. Until even more stats are gathered, I would still attend for now.
SickAndTiredAgain · 02/03/2022 13:58

Does HPV infection cause an increased risk of cancer, even once the infection is gone?
I mean for example - I tested positive for HPV a few years ago and some abnormal cells were detected and I had a colposcopy. At my most recent smear, there was no HPV. Is my risk now the same as someone who has never had HPV? And therefore I don’t need my smear test sample to be examined further, unless I tests positive for HPV again?

megletthesecond · 02/03/2022 13:52

Probably.

CommonPrimrose · 02/03/2022 13:46

It depends if they are checking visually for changes.
My gp did mine after post menopausal bleeding and told me I had polyps for example. Now I have no idea whether a nurse doing a smear would have picked that up. Anyone know?

110APiccadilly · 02/03/2022 13:44

So despite the messaging about anyone being able to get cervical cancer, there now really is no point at all in going if you've not had sex? (Although I was told by a doctor ages ago that there wasn't much point in going anyway if you'd not had sex as you'd be so low risk.)

PeasAndFlour · 02/03/2022 13:43

@RagzRebooted they do not test for cell changes as mine were not, despite the previous smear being positive for HPV, so potentially changes have occurred in the cells but they will not be picked up. This is the specific reason why I’m concerned. The system is just blunt: hpv+ is the only way to get cells analysed. Previous history not taken into consideration.

OP posts:
CommonPrimrose · 02/03/2022 13:37

Non- HPV that should read.

CommonPrimrose · 02/03/2022 13:36

One thing I'm not clear on:
Does the checking of cells pick up non hov related cervical cancers? Or just the HPV related majority?

RagzRebooted · 02/03/2022 13:31

[quote PeasAndFlour]@RagzRebooted what happens to women who have had hpv in a previous smear, which has had the potential to cause changes, but is a negative hpv in the next smear? Is it not “cost effective” anymore to check their cells?[/quote]
We put on the form that it's a follow up after an abnormal one (this will be on their system too) and I believe (not 100%) that they are also checked for cell changes (I will have to confirm that with my colleague).

For those saying they had precancerous changes without HPV, was this a while ago? I had CIN3 at my first smear and I was never told I had HPV, but they didn't test/tell you back then.

HPV generally takes quite a few years to cause cancer, precancerous changes can reverse by themselves without treatment. Most people will get HPV and clear it within a year or two.

DetailMouse · 02/03/2022 13:08

Can they test for HPV without doing a smear then? If so, it seems far more sensible to do that and only give smear tests to those who need them?

PeasAndFlour · 02/03/2022 12:44

@brokenstone

I’ve also had precancerous cells (CIN3) but not had HPV.
In my opinion people who have previously had cell changes like this without HPV should be analysed for cell changes when they have a smear. It doesn’t make any sense that they are not.
OP posts:
brokenstone · 02/03/2022 12:16

I’ve also had precancerous cells (CIN3) but not had HPV.

FelicityBennett · 02/03/2022 12:15

I think this explains it well
As up thread it has been switched to this as a better test
The reason for carrying on with the smear process is 1 the nurse can look when the smear is take. 2 if HPV is detected the sample is then examined without the need for a second test
www.jostrust.org.uk/information/cervical-screening/primary-hpv-testing