Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who’s in the wrong? Unsociable or sociable?

541 replies

ShittyFingers · 02/03/2022 08:26

Person A is pretty unsociable. She gets on the bus and looks forward to time alone to sit and think/daydream during her 1 hour journey.

Person B is sociable and looks forward the her 1 hour journey to chat.

Bus has lots of empty seats. Person B decides to sit next to Person A and try to strike up conversation. Person A is polite but makes it obvious she doesn’t want to talk. Person B is a little offended and thinks Person A is a miserable sod. After a few more attempts to make light conversation, person A moves seats. Person B now very upset and this plays on her mind all day.

Let’s say Covid isn’t a thing.

Who is unreasonable?

YABU - person A could have made more effort, it wouldn’t have killed her to chat

YANBU - person Bs wish to socialise doesn’t trump person A’s wish to not socialise

OP posts:
AmoozedBooze · 03/03/2022 11:44

Unless A herself is struggling and really needs the quiet time

A is only allowed quiet time if she is struggling??? Shock

GoldenBlue · 03/03/2022 11:41

I'm definitely with A on this one and really happy that they moved. I wouldn't have felt able to but would have hated to be talked at by B.

The B's of this world that think A's owe it to them to chat and listen as bad as the men that don't take hints either. 'Be kind' has got to stop. We should feel able to move away if uncomfortable and screw whether that hurts someone else's feelings I'm afraid.

B was rude not to take the hint, and if there were any separate seats available was rude to sit next to someone in the first place.

A is my hero for actually upholding a boundary and moving for their own comfort

WisherWood · 03/03/2022 11:20

Take a book. Even if you only pretend to read while you daydream.

I wonder if some of the people on this thread have actually encountered any of the Bs of this world. Honestly, you'd have to smack them round the head with the book and even then they'd persist with the idea that you're in a desperately lonely state and want rescuing with a little bit of chatter. Some people need talk so much themselves that they really cannot grasp that other people do not want it and actually find it intrusive and exhausting at times. Plus, some people like their own company so it's not just that chatter is exhausting, but that quiet is enjoyable. But person B can never really grasp this, because it's so far from how they feel.

CaptaNoctem · 03/03/2022 10:52

Unless A herself is struggling and really needs the quiet time, I think the compassionate response would be to let B chat, because you don't know what is going on in her life that might make her crave that contact.

So only A is required to be compassionate then. Got you!

I'd have moved too OP and there'd have been nothing furtive and apologetic about it.

JustLyra · 03/03/2022 09:50

@lljkk

If sex difference matters then "what if B was a man" is very bad rhetorically. Irrelevant, actually.
It’s really not. It’s all part of the wider picture of women being expected to sit in silence and accept it even when they’re uncomfortable or in company they don’t want.
AlexaShutUp · 03/03/2022 09:13

You don’t know what’s going on in A’s life either, that makes her crave peace and quiet.

No, and I have already acknowledged this.

MoonOnASpoon · 03/03/2022 09:06

You don’t know what’s going on in A’s life either, that makes her crave peace and quiet.

The thing is, B can find another B, somewhere, sooner or later. But Bs should realise that some people crave being left alone, just as they crave interaction.

When life hands me a B, I do exchange a few pleasantries and try to be kind and polite. That is me compromising. Then when I say I need to read, not to chat, etc, that should be respected.

Dino77 · 03/03/2022 09:01

Take a book. Even if you only pretend to read while you daydream.

Livpool · 03/03/2022 09:00

I'm more of a 'B' person but would plonk myself down to speak to someone I barely knew.
And I can take the hint if someone doesn't want to chat.

But A was weird for getting up and moving. Just say you don't want to talk surely?! If B didn't shut up then move and say why?!

diddl · 03/03/2022 08:57

"I think the compassionate response would be to let B chat, because you don't know what is going on in her life that might make her crave that contact."

Maybe she just likes to chat & there isn't anything going on?

phoenixrosehere · 03/03/2022 08:56

Person A should use headphones or EarPods or close her eyes.

Yes, because that stops people who want to chat every time (trust me it doesn’t) and I highly doubt it would have worked on B due to her reputation of talking to people on the bus.

Indeed not, but it's a sad state of affairs if we only focus on what we are responsible for and have no care for anything else. A little compassion would be nice.

Compassion goes both way. Forcing conversation onto a stranger is not compassionate, ignoring their desire to be alone is not compassionate. Considering that they may want to be left alone and waiting to see if someone else would like to chat who may be like you is compassionate.

My understanding from the OP was that they just wanted to sit and daydream, but I accept that there might be more to it than that.

So? What’s wrong with that? Are you really saying that someone has to have a “legitimate” reason to want to be left alone?

I think it a sad state of affairs that women are still expected to “be nice” to strangers and if they’re not they’re called “miserable bores, cu**s, lacking of compassion, etc. If person B was a bloke, OP would be told she did right, but if it was an elderly bloke and also shown another woman regardless of age, she would be called names.

Men are not expected to be nice to a chatty stranger. It wouldn’t matter regardless of gender who spoke to them because still in this day and age, their space is more important than a woman’s.

OP should have just said f**k off if she was going to be seen in the wrong regardless of how polite she was by some posters on here.

AlexaShutUp · 03/03/2022 08:53

@diddl

"No, I agree. As I said, Person B was also unreasonable and should learn to respect other people's wishes."

But they didn't which is why A moved.

"If Person A is struggling, then that makes their reaction more understandable. My understanding from the OP was that they just wanted to sit and daydream, but I accept that there might be more to it than that."

So what if A just wanted to sit & daydream?

Yes, I said that both were unreasonable.

If A just wanted to sit and daydream, A doesn't have to talk to anyone. But the OP is asking us for opinions, and I'm giving mine. Unless A herself is struggling and really needs the quiet time, I think the compassionate response would be to let B chat, because you don't know what is going on in her life that might make her crave that contact.

diddl · 03/03/2022 08:47

@MintyFreshBreath

You are definitely one of person A and B. I don’t think C exists.
Have you read all of Op's posts?
diddl · 03/03/2022 08:46

"No, I agree. As I said, Person B was also unreasonable and should learn to respect other people's wishes."

But they didn't which is why A moved.

"If Person A is struggling, then that makes their reaction more understandable. My understanding from the OP was that they just wanted to sit and daydream, but I accept that there might be more to it than that."

So what if A just wanted to sit & daydream?

MintyFreshBreath · 03/03/2022 08:33

And for what it’s worth, the chatty one is in the wrong. I hate people who won’t give over when I just want some peace and quiet.

MintyFreshBreath · 03/03/2022 08:32

You are definitely one of person A and B. I don’t think C exists.

Beees · 03/03/2022 08:28

@ShittyFingers

What about a bit of compassion for people who really need to be left alone to mentally prepare for the day? Decompress after a hard day? Come down after masking all day or chill out for an hour before facing a day of exhausting masking?

Or don’t these people matter?

Evidently not. As you have seen countless times across the whole thread people who like the quiet and have a desire to enjoy their travel time in peace are obviously completely unreasonable.

It's laughable how many posters have implied you should be nice and kind to person B (Michelle) but seem oblivious she is not affording you the same compassion and kindness.

AlexaShutUp · 03/03/2022 08:26

@ShittyFingers

What about a bit of compassion for people who really need to be left alone to mentally prepare for the day? Decompress after a hard day? Come down after masking all day or chill out for an hour before facing a day of exhausting masking?

Or don’t these people matter?

No, I agree. As I said, Person B was also unreasonable and should learn to respect other people's wishes.

If Person A is struggling, then that makes their reaction more understandable. My understanding from the OP was that they just wanted to sit and daydream, but I accept that there might be more to it than that.

Grinling · 03/03/2022 08:24

@AlexaShutUp

It's not the responsibility of person A to make sure person B has human contact.

Indeed not, but it's a sad state of affairs if we only focus on what we are responsible for and have no care for anything else. A little compassion would be nice.

I’m not sure why this thread has turned into #BeKind and #HelptheLonely — we know nothing about B, apart from her sex and the fact that she’s a habitual talker according to someone else.

Surely she’s just as likely to be the town bore, a rabid gossip after material or someone who’s just poor at reading social cues as someone terribly lonely and athirst for human contact?

ShittyFingers · 03/03/2022 08:22

What about a bit of compassion for people who really need to be left alone to mentally prepare for the day? Decompress after a hard day? Come down after masking all day or chill out for an hour before facing a day of exhausting masking?

Or don’t these people matter?

OP posts:
AlexaShutUp · 03/03/2022 08:17

It's not the responsibility of person A to make sure person B has human contact.

Indeed not, but it's a sad state of affairs if we only focus on what we are responsible for and have no care for anything else. A little compassion would be nice.

diddl · 03/03/2022 08:15

@AlexaShutUp

Personally, I think both are unreasonable. Person B sounds like an annoying pain in the arse who really needs to learn to interpret social cues more effectively so that they can respect other people's wishes. Person A sounds like a rude, heartless fucker who can't be arsed to chat to someone who might be really struggling and desperate for the human contact.
If B is a pita then A was right to move away.

If B is struggling for contact they need to talk to someone who wants to talk to them.

Sagealicious · 03/03/2022 08:10

@AlexaShutUp

Personally, I think both are unreasonable. Person B sounds like an annoying pain in the arse who really needs to learn to interpret social cues more effectively so that they can respect other people's wishes. Person A sounds like a rude, heartless fucker who can't be arsed to chat to someone who might be really struggling and desperate for the human contact.
It's not the responsibility of person A to make sure person B has human contact.
WisherWood · 03/03/2022 08:04

Because for a lot of Londoners public transport is a car substitute & a time for being quiet, not an opportunity for socialising.

Well no. For a lot of rural people a car is a substitute for a functioning, useable, joined-up public transport service. Cars are not an essential that requires a substitute when they're not present. Transport is essential to the way we live our lives, but cars shouldn't be the default.

Agree with you on the requirement for quiet though. Londoners are so jammed in together that they seem to me to need to reinforce their personal space very assertively. IME people in rural areas will chat away to randoms when they're on public transport in a way that would see Londoners wanting to lob you under a bus. But then people in rural areas have far more opportunity to get away from people when they need to.

AlexaShutUp · 03/03/2022 07:53

Personally, I think both are unreasonable. Person B sounds like an annoying pain in the arse who really needs to learn to interpret social cues more effectively so that they can respect other people's wishes. Person A sounds like a rude, heartless fucker who can't be arsed to chat to someone who might be really struggling and desperate for the human contact.

Swipe left for the next trending thread