Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who’s in the wrong? Unsociable or sociable?

541 replies

ShittyFingers · 02/03/2022 08:26

Person A is pretty unsociable. She gets on the bus and looks forward to time alone to sit and think/daydream during her 1 hour journey.

Person B is sociable and looks forward the her 1 hour journey to chat.

Bus has lots of empty seats. Person B decides to sit next to Person A and try to strike up conversation. Person A is polite but makes it obvious she doesn’t want to talk. Person B is a little offended and thinks Person A is a miserable sod. After a few more attempts to make light conversation, person A moves seats. Person B now very upset and this plays on her mind all day.

Let’s say Covid isn’t a thing.

Who is unreasonable?

YABU - person A could have made more effort, it wouldn’t have killed her to chat

YANBU - person Bs wish to socialise doesn’t trump person A’s wish to not socialise

OP posts:
RiyaJ · 04/03/2022 07:25

Person A or B shouldn't get offended. Person B was polite and tried to converse with person A.

If person A doesn't wanted to converse then take the hint and sit on another seat.

Don't take it personally, no-one should get offended. You can't force people to converse.

Templeblossom · 04/03/2022 07:12

I find it interesting that the self proclaimed socially skilled chatters dont recognise that being socially skilled is knowing when to speak and when not to speak.
They have adopted chatting as a mark of social skills when actually its the opposite.
Listening and silence is where the skills are.
Recognising the needs of others.

WisherWood · 04/03/2022 07:01

You can get yellow bandanas, leads, and collars for dogs that say 'nervous' on... to show people that their dog needs space.
An equivalent thing for humans would be great.

Possibly. But the human version should be for the dogs that need to chat. Why do people who want quiet need to guard themselves with headphones, books or something adapted from dogs? You want to chat, advertise that fact. Why is that chattiness is seen as the default and not something that needs declaring, whereas the need for quiet is seen as something which should be signposted with some form or armour?

XenoBitch · 04/03/2022 00:28

@SylvieB74

I wouldn’t mind someone talking to me on a bus. I go swimming most mornings a few older people talk and there’s nothing wrong with that, it doesn’t cost anything! All we hear is these days is about crippling loneliness and ‘be kind’ etc, utter balls written on social media about how people are always available, (or so they say) and don’t be alone, mental health blah blah. Then the real feelings of the majority of people on this thread show why there are these problems these days. Well thanks for being honest you utterly horrible people.
People post the things you mention on social media a lot and it is more aimed at people they know. I certainly have, and with online communication, or even just plain phone calls.. you have an element of control if you do not feel able to respond in a way you would like. A stranger approaching you on the bus? Totally different! They sit next to you, and worse, trap you in your seat. Most people might feel a little awkward, and some might get up and move. I have panicked and left the bus... fucking up my journey home. Does that make me such a horrible person? Or maybe the person who insisted on chatting at me should have got the hint and left me alone.
JustLyra · 04/03/2022 00:21

@SylvieB74

I wouldn’t mind someone talking to me on a bus. I go swimming most mornings a few older people talk and there’s nothing wrong with that, it doesn’t cost anything! All we hear is these days is about crippling loneliness and ‘be kind’ etc, utter balls written on social media about how people are always available, (or so they say) and don’t be alone, mental health blah blah. Then the real feelings of the majority of people on this thread show why there are these problems these days. Well thanks for being honest you utterly horrible people.
Why does the “be kind” only apply to the people who want to chat?

What about being kind to the person who is overwhelmed with life and just wants a bit of peace?

Your last sentence says far more about you than someone not wanting to talk to a random stranger on the bus

HoveringDonkeyofKnock · 04/03/2022 00:01

@CloseYourEyesAndSee

How do you know how person B felt all day?
That’s exactly what I thought as soon as I read that odd detail.

Can’t be bothered trtft do we find out?

Isaidnomorecrisps · 03/03/2022 23:23

Had this on a train. Sat in a back seat, 30 minutes of peace after a long day of work calls. Woman deliberately avoided all the commuting men and came opposite me laterally and talked and talked at me. I did make pleasantries and said I have to do a spot of work would you excuse me? She just kept at it and after about five minutes I just ignored her / looked at phone. She still tried. It was like getting a toddler to sleep. Anyway she looked upset and I felt bad afterwards but honestly I didn’t have the energy. I’m with you A.

notjaneausten · 03/03/2022 23:15

I am extremely deaf. It’s so very embarrassing if someone wants to chat, I can’t. It’s bad enough being deaf without somebody taking offence because you’re not chatting.

Templeblossom · 03/03/2022 22:56

I am an introvert, and whilst I can and do force myself into social situations, it is not easy for me, and it is emotionally very tiring for me. There comes a point where I really,reallyneed some alone time, or at least some time where no-one is talking to me. Even then, if someone is in actual need, I will push myself to help, but if someone just wants a mindless chat, why do their wants outrank my need for some quiet and time to recharge?

Totally agree.
Also getting on a bus to go to work and going for a quiet swim are not really social occasions where you even expect people to be chatting to you.
If people are meeting with friends at the pool then you expect they will chat but actually in the pool its really annoying to hear someone yapping away.
People go to exercise and destress not to listen to someone droning on.
If needing to swim, enjoy the quiet and bliss of the water makes me "horrible" I give zero fucks.

FirewomanSam · 03/03/2022 22:52

You can get yellow bandanas, leads, and collars for dogs that say 'nervous' on... to show people that their dog needs space.

Honestly this has crossed my mind before when I’ve had my most anxious periods. Like putting P plates on the car to tell people you might be a hesitant driver. I could use something that tells people ‘sorry if I appear to be struggling to function, I’m a nervous wreck’ Blush

phoenixrosehere · 03/03/2022 22:43

I wouldn’t mind someone talking to me on a bus. I go swimming most mornings a few older people talk and there’s nothing wrong with that, it doesn’t cost anything! All we hear is these days is about crippling loneliness and ‘be kind’ etc, utter balls written on social media about how people are always available, (or so they say) and don’t be alone, mental health blah blah. Then the real feelings of the majority of people on this thread show why there are these problems these days. Well thanks for being honest you utterly horrible people.

OP’s post about the woman after mentioning it to another bus rider:

“I’m person A. I mentioned the encounter to someone else who often gets the same bus and she said something along the lines of “Oh do you mean Michelle? Bless her she talks to everyone! She’ll have been thinking about it all day after that”.

Person B has form for this so she could have waited until there was someone who wanted to talk to her than making a beeline for someone on an almost empty bus, talking at them, and ignoring their wishes to be left alone where it made them feel fed up to move.

If she is known for this, surely she could have waited until someone boarded who liked to chat with her instead choosing someone who hinted several times they weren’t up for it.

I see it all the time on my regular commute, some regulars are like OP and some are like B will board the bus and chatty people like B chat away while others like A will just give a smile and nod and be left alone. Everyone is content because everyone is being considered. Those who want to be left alone are being left alone and those who are chatty chat to someone else who is chatty.

People like B shouldn’t be entitled to take away from people like OP because of their need to chat.

Fine if you are happy to chat to people and don’t mind but calling people horrible because they don’t want to for their own personal reasons mental health doesn’t make you better and definitely doesn’t make you kind.

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 03/03/2022 22:42

@SylvieB74

I wouldn’t mind someone talking to me on a bus. I go swimming most mornings a few older people talk and there’s nothing wrong with that, it doesn’t cost anything! All we hear is these days is about crippling loneliness and ‘be kind’ etc, utter balls written on social media about how people are always available, (or so they say) and don’t be alone, mental health blah blah. Then the real feelings of the majority of people on this thread show why there are these problems these days. Well thanks for being honest you utterly horrible people.
”….someone's need to chat does not trump someone else's need to have some quiet time…”

Spot on, @WisherWood!

@SylvieB74 - just because you are happy to talk to people on the bus, doesn’t mean everyone feels the same! It sounds as if you are saying that the extroverts, who are happy to chat anywhere, any time, are the lovely ones, and the introverts are utterly horrible - which betrays a complete lack of understanding of what it is like to be an introvert. You seemingly think it is just fine to force someone into a social interaction that is making them uncomfortable - which is what B did to A.

And B was not in massive emotional need - she just wanted a chat. Presumably if she had appeared upset, @ShittyFingers‘ would have responded differently - but that was not the case. A needed peace, quiet and her own thoughts, B wanted a gossip - and you think that B’s wants should trump A’s needs.

I am an introvert, and whilst I can and do force myself into social situations, it is not easy for me, and it is emotionally very tiring for me. There comes a point where I really, really need some alone time, or at least some time where no-one is talking to me. Even then, if someone is in actual need, I will push myself to help, but if someone just wants a mindless chat, why do their wants outrank my need for some quiet and time to recharge?

WisherWood · 03/03/2022 22:07

Then the real feelings of the majority of people on this thread show why there are these problems these days. Well thanks for being honest you utterly horrible people.

Erm. Okay then. People will be drawn to this thread by the title, so you're not getting a representative sample. And what many people are saying is that B should just get better at reading social cues. It's not that everyone should stop talking to each other, but that someone's need to chat does not trump someone else's need to have some quiet time.

I'm sorry people are lonely. But there are ways to go about solving that and talking to someone who doesn't want to be talked at is not one of them. People on here aren't horrible. They just want the recognition that sometimes they'd like not to talk to strangers.

Runnerduck34 · 03/03/2022 22:07

I totally relate to person A but I think moving seats is a bit rude, If I didnt want to chat I would read , make short answers, put earphones in, avoid eye contact- although sometimes you can meet interesting people and have a really nice chat!
I think if I was person B I would feel bad if someone moved seats to clearly avoid me, although they should have picked up on signals better, they both should have behaved better tbh, and maybe B is lonely?

LeeN637 · 03/03/2022 22:07

YANBU - Person B is definitely in the wrong.

Dibbydoos · 03/03/2022 22:01

It happened to me on a train. I capitulated in the end. I'm not sure I got much out of the convo, and I'd def have preferred the hour listening to music and playing my mini games.

I thought she was rude; she was American and wouldn't give up. I could have ignored her. I'm normally good at that, but that say I gave in.

No one has the right to expect you to chat to them, esp if they're total strangers! YANBU, and you're also not miserable!

XenoBitch · 03/03/2022 22:00

You can get yellow bandanas, leads, and collars for dogs that say 'nervous' on... to show people that their dog needs space.
An equivalent thing for humans would be great.

I did see a bookmark on Pinterest that said in fancy lettering "Fuck off, I'm reading" Grin

WhackusBonkus · 03/03/2022 22:00

[quote ldontWanna]@WhackusBonkus what if A is going through the same and the only way of keeping it together is letting her thoughts roam and staring out the window in silence?

Why is the benefit and sympathy always towards the "chatty" person? [/quote]
It isn’t @IDontWanna .. I was putting the other side across to @Sizzer40 who had already stated the case for that person who wanted peace

Fluffmum · 03/03/2022 21:58

Person B needs to know her boundaries

CantChatNow · 03/03/2022 21:57

I would make polite chit chat for a minute but I don’t want a long conversation with a random for 30 minutes after work. I remember pretending to be asleep once on a mega bus to get a bloke to fuck off because I was trapped in with him for 4 hours….

SylvieB74 · 03/03/2022 21:51

I wouldn’t mind someone talking to me on a bus. I go swimming most mornings a few older people talk and there’s nothing wrong with that, it doesn’t cost anything! All we hear is these days is about crippling loneliness and ‘be kind’ etc, utter balls written on social media about how people are always available, (or so they say) and don’t be alone, mental health blah blah. Then the real feelings of the majority of people on this thread show why there are these problems these days. Well thanks for being honest you utterly horrible people.

ClemFandangoo · 03/03/2022 21:45

@Ifeelsuchafool

I am person A by nature but would have engaged in conversation if in that situation. There are a lot of very lonely people out there. Maybe it might make all the difference to their day or even their MH to have had some human contact.
There are a lot of very overloaded people out there. Maybe it might make all the difference to their day or even their MH to have had some peace.
Mamamoo12 · 03/03/2022 21:41

Are you person B if you know how they’d be feeling all day about it? I personally like the silence and hate people trying to make conversation. I normally smile, add a nod of Acknowledgment and then get my magazine out or put my headphones in

thenovice · 03/03/2022 21:29

I hate that extroverts are always criticising me and saying there is something wrong with me if I am shy and that I should be more extrovert. WHY? Perhaps they should be more introvert. We are all different but it seems to me that the extrovert types are unable to accept anyone who is not like them.

ldontWanna · 03/03/2022 21:28

@WhackusBonkus what if A is going through the same and the only way of keeping it together is letting her thoughts roam and staring out the window in silence?

Why is the benefit and sympathy always towards the "chatty" person?