Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who’s in the wrong? Unsociable or sociable?

541 replies

ShittyFingers · 02/03/2022 08:26

Person A is pretty unsociable. She gets on the bus and looks forward to time alone to sit and think/daydream during her 1 hour journey.

Person B is sociable and looks forward the her 1 hour journey to chat.

Bus has lots of empty seats. Person B decides to sit next to Person A and try to strike up conversation. Person A is polite but makes it obvious she doesn’t want to talk. Person B is a little offended and thinks Person A is a miserable sod. After a few more attempts to make light conversation, person A moves seats. Person B now very upset and this plays on her mind all day.

Let’s say Covid isn’t a thing.

Who is unreasonable?

YABU - person A could have made more effort, it wouldn’t have killed her to chat

YANBU - person Bs wish to socialise doesn’t trump person A’s wish to not socialise

OP posts:
BogRollBOGOF · 02/03/2022 10:46

I'm not averse to some naturally arising small talk, but it is generally rude to not take the hint and ignore cues such as baggage on a seat (when seating is abundant) and distract from someone occupied by looking out of the window/ reading/ giving perfunctory responses.

Occasionally people can't interpret a hint. I have to be direct with DS1 when he wants to monologue at me about his interests and say "I'm doing x right now, I can listen to you after y". With his ASD he's fine with the direct style as he understands the purpose then and there's a clear expectation. However, he'd be a person A and swerve random interactions on a bus anyway.

Ultimately B has created the issue by approaching A and forced A into modifying their behaviour.

Herewegoagain84 · 02/03/2022 10:44

Oh god as strangers who just recognise each other from the bus, person B needs to sod off. I'd congratulate person A for having the courage to move - I would be too pathetic and spend an excruciating hour talking to person B and resenting it the whole time.

Cognoscenti · 02/03/2022 10:42

Person B is overbearing and intrusive. If they're feeling upset that they harassed A to the point of having to move seats because they couldn't take a very obvious hint, fair enough. Otherwise, they really need to learn to back off in situations like this.
I feel sorry for A, I have ASD and would have found person B's behaviour quite distressing.

TempleBlossom · 02/03/2022 10:42

@Heytheredemons

Person A is not unsociable. They enjoy their alone time, which they are entitled to do, without other people they hardly know demanding their attention.

Person B is not sociable, they are a massive pain in the arse that has no social skills and needs to learn to read the room.

This! Also people who dont get their own way always label other people as " rude"
EmpressaurusWitchDoesntBurn · 02/03/2022 10:42

Person B is U. My public transport time is for reading, not socialising. I’ve moved carriages on the tube before to get away from someone wanting to chat - admittedly a bus would be trickier, but being in London, if I really needed to I could get off & wait for the next one.

(And I have plenty of friends but haven’t met any of them on random bus journeys!)

MoonOnASpoon · 02/03/2022 10:41

How do you know how person B felt all day?

Maybe OP is person A and person B told them this.

Ionlydomassiveones · 02/03/2022 10:40

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn at the poster's request.

hugocat · 02/03/2022 10:38

Are you person A?

NotTryingHardEnough · 02/03/2022 10:38

It’s funny, isn’t it, that in all my various encounters with Person B types over the years, not one has ever chatted for a bit, stopped, then said 'Well, I can see you’re trying to read/think/have some quiet time, so I’ll leave you alone. It was nice talking to you for a while though.'

They’ve just kept right on bulldozing through.

hugocat · 02/03/2022 10:38

Person B is really annoying

HadEnough798 · 02/03/2022 10:37

I take the point about possibly B is lonely but A's needs absolutely do trump B's needs.

Unwanted social interaction and forced conversation on A, can be exhausting and overwhelming in a way that unwanted quiet time for B cannot.

They're not comparable. B is absolutely 100% unreasonable.

Kinko · 02/03/2022 10:36

I wouldn't stonewall anyone. But I'd probably say something like - I'm really sorry I've got an email to write or I'm listening to a training that I have to do before arriving at work. And get my phone out.

That way you spare the feelings of the other person who is just trying to be friendly. You've signalled you can't talk but without making it about not wanting to talk to them.

TimeToMakeACupofTea · 02/03/2022 10:36

I used to get on the same train to work as a colleague and we had a pact that neither of us would expect the other to chat whilst waiting for or on the train. I can’t be arsed first thing on a morning and like to chill out during the commute.

AryaStarkWolf · 02/03/2022 10:32

@CloseYourEyesAndSee

How do you know how person B felt all day?
This, unless you are Person B but you seem to have very in depth knowledge of Person A's thoughts and feelings too
CallMeDaddy58 · 02/03/2022 10:30

@sillysmiles

She was achingly lonely and lost. I'm glad I spent 20 minutes chatting to her.

This is what I thought of when I read the OP's post. Yes some people need quiet head space, but the person who needs to talk isn't necessarily rude, but potentially lonely.
It's unfortunate that the two requirements are so opposed, but I don't see why one persons need to be quiet is more important than another persons need for social interaction.
It's is not the responsibility of the quiet person to fulfil that social interaction need, but that isn't to say that it isn't equally a need and important for their social and mental health.
It's important to understand that both situations are equally valid.

Sorry but both situations aren’t equally valid. It can be incredibly difficult to find time to be quiet and so distressing to have a stranger interrupt that. They could be getting the bus to a hospital to visit a dying relative.

This is some “give us a smile love” type of BS where you are expected to ignore your own emotions to entertain a stranger.

There are endless opportunities for people of all ages to socialise with others. Many of them free or very cheap and you’re more likely to meet someone you have something uncommon with that if you talk to the stranger on the bus.

Heytheredemons · 02/03/2022 10:25

Person A is not unsociable. They enjoy their alone time, which they are entitled to do, without other people they hardly know demanding their attention.

Person B is not sociable, they are a massive pain in the arse that has no social skills and needs to learn to read the room.

sillysmiles · 02/03/2022 10:24

*I don't see why one persons need to be quiet is more important than another persons need for social interaction

Really? One is far more intrusive than the other. It's like saying one person's sleep doesn't outweigh another's "need" to have a loud party until the early hours.*

They really aren't the same thing - and if you had read further, you would have seen that I said that it is not the quiet persons responsibility to provide the social interaction. However, maybe both points of view need to be a little flexible and understand each other - rather than one is right and one is wrong.

CallMeDaddy58 · 02/03/2022 10:21

@Eastpoint

This explains why so many MNetters say they have no friends. Practice saying ‘sorry I haven’t got the headspace to chat today’ and B will understand & leave you alone. B will also still take you to hospital when your partner can’t or babysit when there’s an emergency. Being surly isn’t the way to go.
I’m not asking the random from the bus to babysit my child. I’ll ask my parents, DHs parents, siblings, DHs siblings, the neighbours we’ve known for years, the friends we’ve had for decades.
CallyfromBlakes7 · 02/03/2022 10:17

@sillysmiles

Nobody is asking a person who gets the same bus as them to babysit

No but people become friends through talking.

Yes they do, I did get chatting to people on commutes and made a lifelong friend. It usually happens when the trains are late though ;)

However, I wouldn't bother someone who clearly wanted peace and quiet or said "well it's been nice chatting, now I need to get on with my work/want to get on with my exciting book" etc.

SleepingStandingUp · 02/03/2022 10:17

Omg B, a million times.
Read the room.

DS is 6and cannot pick up when people don't want to talk back so I make sure I do. Unless there's a reason like ASD where A cannot understand body cues etc then she needs to back away and stop pushing herself on other people

IvorCutler · 02/03/2022 10:16

I am person A. This would make me feel so awkward and uncomfortable that I’d probably get off the bus.

CallyfromBlakes7 · 02/03/2022 10:15

I think if the bus has loads of empty seats I think it’s weird and a bit rude actually to deliberately choose to go and sit next to a stranger

I agree, although people also seem to do it when they see a bag in the seat - even if the bus or train will not fill up. The time it happened to me (on a train rather than a bus) I just got up and sat elsewhere. But that is a different point to wanting to chat.

I don't see why one persons need to be quiet is more important than another persons need for social interaction

Really? One is far more intrusive than the other. It's like saying one person's sleep doesn't outweigh another's "need" to have a loud party until the early hours.

PheonixGlitterRepublic · 02/03/2022 10:15

Jesus I’m an extrovert but hate it when strangers speak to me on public transport. It’s annoying and it’s the only time of day I get to myself. Most people who indulge person B do so under duress, they should refrain from bothering people.

Beees · 02/03/2022 10:15

God almighty why not use your words?? "Sorry, I really need this hour alone and quiet" would do it. What the fuck has gone wrong with us that we can't communicate directly and clearly??

I actually let out a hollow laugh at the suggestion that asking nicely to be be left alone would work with someone like person B. I used to get the bus everyday with someone similar. I sometimes chatted out of politeness but mostly she targeted others some willing, some less so.

One day she sat next to me and proceeded to chat and I politely said I had a headache and needed some quiet time that morning. Her response was to completely igore my request with a snarky "it's OK you don't need to talk, you just need to listen to me"

There is no getting through to people like B, getting up and moving is much polite than the torrent of verbal abuse they sometimes deserve for ignoring such bloody obvious social clues.

I hope person A had a much nicer day once her bus journey was over.

Georgeskitchen · 02/03/2022 10:15

Person B is probably a one of 2 types
Type A: a gas bag who wants to know everyone's business and tells everyone their business
Type B: probably quite sad and lonely and probably has an inkling that people think she's annoying, but tries her best anyway

Swipe left for the next trending thread