Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Who’s in the wrong? Unsociable or sociable?

541 replies

ShittyFingers · 02/03/2022 08:26

Person A is pretty unsociable. She gets on the bus and looks forward to time alone to sit and think/daydream during her 1 hour journey.

Person B is sociable and looks forward the her 1 hour journey to chat.

Bus has lots of empty seats. Person B decides to sit next to Person A and try to strike up conversation. Person A is polite but makes it obvious she doesn’t want to talk. Person B is a little offended and thinks Person A is a miserable sod. After a few more attempts to make light conversation, person A moves seats. Person B now very upset and this plays on her mind all day.

Let’s say Covid isn’t a thing.

Who is unreasonable?

YABU - person A could have made more effort, it wouldn’t have killed her to chat

YANBU - person Bs wish to socialise doesn’t trump person A’s wish to not socialise

OP posts:
Thisisit2022 · 02/03/2022 16:37

@cherrysthename

This thread brings to mind Planes Trains and Automobiles Grin
I'm going totally against my previous posts now but I'd make an absolute exception for the late John Candy!
RampantIvy · 02/03/2022 16:36

the kneejerk nasty stereotyping of extroverts as loud, crass, overbearing, insensitive, coercively social etc by people who identify as introverts on Mn doesn't do introversion any favours, either. It simply looks like spite directed at people who don't struggle socially.

I couldn't agree with you more

A classic example of a needy extrovert not being able to understand or respect a quiet introvert. They are so fucking irritating.

And this ^^ is a classic example of what @Grinling was referring to.

BoredZelda · 02/03/2022 16:04

if she was a lonely old lady

🤨

thepeopleversuswork · 02/03/2022 16:00

@Grinling

the kneejerk nasty stereotyping of extroverts as loud, crass, overbearing, insensitive, coercively social etc by people who identify as introverts on Mn doesn't do introversion any favours, either. It simply looks like spite directed at people who don't struggle socially.

This in giant neon lights.

Spite, envy and small-mindedness.

Grinling · 02/03/2022 15:40

[quote thepeopleversuswork]@TempleBlossom

Bloody right its touched a nerve. I don't like indiscriminate nastiness or prejudice. Particularly when its in the guise of sticking up for the little guy.[/quote]
It's just very lazy. I absolutely get that introverts have long been 'othered' as quiet/dull/boring/ inadequate etc, and it's good that there's now more of a balance, but the kneejerk nasty stereotyping of extroverts as loud, crass, overbearing, insensitive, coercively social etc by people who identify as introverts on Mn doesn't do introversion any favours, either. It simply looks like spite directed at people who don't struggle socially.

Snog · 02/03/2022 15:35

If I was person A I'd say hello and then say "Sorry I'm not in the mood to chat."

thepeopleversuswork · 02/03/2022 15:17

@TempleBlossom

Bloody right its touched a nerve. I don't like indiscriminate nastiness or prejudice. Particularly when its in the guise of sticking up for the little guy.

ShittyFingers · 02/03/2022 14:56

@Gizacluethen

I love your balls to actually move! We're you in the window seat and have to get passed her? 🤣

Unfortunately extroverts seem to think think they're polite and sociable and introverts are rude and ignorant. Like you don't have a right to not want to chat or hug.

Yes, I made out I was getting off at an upcoming stop but then sheepishly sat down again in another seat 😂 I’m very socially awkward 😂
OP posts:
diddl · 02/03/2022 14:39

@Goldfishmountainclimber

Gosh, I am really surprised by the responses here. I come from another country where the social norm would definitely be Person B’s behaviour. It would be frowned upon to behave like Person A. This thread may be giving me personal insight into behaviour I have encountered in the UK that I have been surprised by.
So if a stranger sits next to you on the bus you have to talk to them for the entire journey?
TempleBlossom · 02/03/2022 14:36

[quote thepeopleversuswork]@TempleBlossom

Well if you are Confused...

About once a week there's a thread on here which goes (roughly): "I Hate People. I don't want to deal with them. Why are extroverts all such arseholes?"

Or alternatively "I'm an introvert. Love Lockdown!!! Can't COVID lockdowns go on for ever?"

Or "I never want to interact with anyone apart from my husband and kids. I hate all other people"

Followed by a long laundry list of such deeply offensive behaviours as people making eye contact on the bus, people commenting on the weather to someone they've known less than a decade or bosses occasionally requiring their employees to come to work.

Some of this is people with genuine social anxiety who are troubled by having to go back to "normal" levels of social interaction. And thus totally understandable.

But a fair chunk of it is people who for whatever reason are threatened by seeing other people having normal social interactions. And the form is to attack them with really vindictive, spiteful comments about the hated "extroverts": basically they're thick, they can't read social cues, they are unresourceful, they they can't function on their own, they are show-offs, etc etc.

It's absolutely everywhere. If I sound exercised about it its because I am - I'm really tired of it. It's spitefulness masquerading as a protected characteristic.[/quote]
Cant say Ive read anything like that.
I would describe myself as a sociable introvert.
I enjoy being around people to a point but also enjoy being alone.
I think when things annoy us this much , its probably touched a nerve...

thepeopleversuswork · 02/03/2022 14:32

@TempleBlossom

Well if you are Confused...

About once a week there's a thread on here which goes (roughly): "I Hate People. I don't want to deal with them. Why are extroverts all such arseholes?"

Or alternatively "I'm an introvert. Love Lockdown!!! Can't COVID lockdowns go on for ever?"

Or "I never want to interact with anyone apart from my husband and kids. I hate all other people"

Followed by a long laundry list of such deeply offensive behaviours as people making eye contact on the bus, people commenting on the weather to someone they've known less than a decade or bosses occasionally requiring their employees to come to work.

Some of this is people with genuine social anxiety who are troubled by having to go back to "normal" levels of social interaction. And thus totally understandable.

But a fair chunk of it is people who for whatever reason are threatened by seeing other people having normal social interactions. And the form is to attack them with really vindictive, spiteful comments about the hated "extroverts": basically they're thick, they can't read social cues, they are unresourceful, they they can't function on their own, they are show-offs, etc etc.

It's absolutely everywhere. If I sound exercised about it its because I am - I'm really tired of it. It's spitefulness masquerading as a protected characteristic.

whiteworldgettingwhiter · 02/03/2022 14:30

Yanbu.

If you don't know someone, sitting beside them and assuming they want to chat to you is quite rude.

She could have asked if you'd mind if she sat by you. But then, you could have chatted to her for five mins then excused yourself, said you had some work to do or whatever.

But it's not your responsibility if she thinks about it all day.

Grinling · 02/03/2022 14:24

[quote Gizacluethen]@thepeopleversuswork
Honestly because introverts have been called rude and antisocial and nerds and loners and a million other things. By most of society for God knows how long and are actually a bit sick of it and I think lockdown gave them the breathing space they needed to realise what life could be like if you could just tell the extrovert on the bus to leave you alone instead of sitting there while they talk your ear off for the next hour and sit too close and talk too loud but you can't be rude.[/quote]
Why then is it necessary to be spiteful about those you perceive to be extrovert? I don't think there's any reason why A on the bus was necessarily an extrovert, either -- a significant proportion of non-stop chatterers do so because they're nervous in social situations, are terrified by silence ('Am I boring X? Better talk!') and would have sat beside B because they were afraid of looking rude if they sat elsewhere.

She might be an extrovert. She might be a socially-nervous introvert who is afflicted with verbal diarrhoea in social situations (my mother would do exactly this -- she appears to be unable to stop even in situations where the people involved are either unable or unwilling to talk (monosyllabic black cab drivers, busy waiters in a crowded restaurant). She might be a desperately lonely individual whose partner just died. She might be a tiresome bore whose colleagues dread her arrival because she talks non-stop till the end of the day. We don't have the evidence to say.

TempleBlossom · 02/03/2022 14:22

Im not referring to this particular situation. I'm referring to the fact that there's this huge drive (both on here and in RL) to paint all people who enjoy socialising and are socially confident as arseholes who have no social radar. I'm really tired of it and I'm not going to let it pass unchallenged any more. It's just insulting

Ok Confused

XenoBitch · 02/03/2022 14:20

I am in the A camp too. I have had man shout at me for not engaging with his idol chat. Also, another who sat next to me at a bus stop... was telling me all sorts of things, said I am a good listener (I was just nodding and smiling), than asked if he could hold my hand until the bus came (I left at that point and missed my bus).

B is the one who is unreasonable. It will do them no harm to sit in silence, or find someone else to talk at on the bus.

thepeopleversuswork · 02/03/2022 14:17

[quote TempleBlossom]@thepeopleversuswork
Extroverts dont ignore other peoples social cues though.
They would chat to the person who was interested and leave the person alone if they werent.
This is someone who is completely ignoring the feelings, needs and social cues of another person.
Talking at them for an hour
Clearly the person has serious issues with how they relate to others,possibly ND.

We however are entitled to maintain our own boundaries about how we interact with others.[/quote]
I understand that... which is why I went out of my way to explain that I thought Person B was completely in the wrong.

I'm not referring to this particular situation. I'm referring to the fact that there's this huge drive (both on here and in RL) to paint all people who enjoy socialising and are socially confident as arseholes who have no social radar. I'm really tired of it and I'm not going to let it pass unchallenged any more. It's just insulting.

Lavender24 · 02/03/2022 14:15

I think Person B is in the wrong. It took some balls for you to get up and move and I can see why this upset them but who on earth thinks it's acceptable to sit next to a person you barely know and try to engage them when they clearly don't want it? I tend to get on the bus with the same few people but apart from "no, you get on first" or a rare comment about it being freezing we don't speak. to each other.

thepeopleversuswork · 02/03/2022 14:14

@Gizacluethen

Yes and by God did we get to hear about this during lockdown. All the endless threads about how wonderful it was not having to deal with the hated "people" etc. Stealth competition for the smallest amount of people you could have seen in a year.

Up to a point I get this... society does reward extroverts at some level and I can see its nice for people to have been able to establish some boundaries and signal that they can be happy just being who they are.

But the anti-extrovert rhetoric has become pretty extreme and quite vindictive now. That poster upthread basically said all extroverts are "needy"... imagine turning that around and saying "all introverts are dull and have no social graces." We'd rightly get shot down in flames for this.

Can we not just agree that a lot of this is temperament, its not political and that there are pros and cons of both approaches? Instead of treating like a long social revenge note by introverts....

TempleBlossom · 02/03/2022 14:14

@thepeopleversuswork
Extroverts dont ignore other peoples social cues though.
They would chat to the person who was interested and leave the person alone if they werent.
This is someone who is completely ignoring the feelings, needs and social cues of another person.
Talking at them for an hour
Clearly the person has serious issues with how they relate to others,possibly ND.

We however are entitled to maintain our own boundaries about how we interact with others.

FirewomanSam · 02/03/2022 14:11

Yeah this isn’t an introvert/extrovert thing, it’s a social cues and etiquette thing. I’m an extrovert and a right chatterbox when I’m in the right mood. Sometimes an unexpectedly deep and meaningful chat with a stranger is the thing that makes my day. I once shared a bottle of wine with two strangers after striking up a conversation on a long train journey and had a great time.

I’d still be horrified if someone wanted to make small talk with me for my entire commute and wouldn’t leave me alone. I’d find that exhausting and upsetting. Even as an extrovert!

PinkSyCo · 02/03/2022 14:07

Gosh, I am really surprised by the responses here. I come from another country where the social norm would definitely be Person B’s behaviour. It would be frowned upon to behave like Person A. This thread may be giving me personal insight into behaviour I have encountered in the UK that I have been surprised by.

This is Mumsnet where people spill out their whole life to strangers but won’t even open their front doors to their family unless the family member has made an appointment first. I am in the UK but no one I know behaves like this irl.

buddylicious · 02/03/2022 14:07

I think person B was just being friendly.

However, they overstepped the mark and should have quickly realised that you didn't want to talk.

I also think person A is entitled to sit quietly, but getting up and moving seat is rude.

If I was person A I would probably have said something to person B, such as "please don't think I'm being rude but I'm feeling tired so am going to sit quietly".

Gizacluethen · 02/03/2022 14:06

@thepeopleversuswork
Honestly because introverts have been called rude and antisocial and nerds and loners and a million other things. By most of society for God knows how long and are actually a bit sick of it and I think lockdown gave them the breathing space they needed to realise what life could be like if you could just tell the extrovert on the bus to leave you alone instead of sitting there while they talk your ear off for the next hour and sit too close and talk too loud but you can't be rude.

Gizacluethen · 02/03/2022 14:03

I love your balls to actually move! We're you in the window seat and have to get passed her? 🤣

Unfortunately extroverts seem to think think they're polite and sociable and introverts are rude and ignorant. Like you don't have a right to not want to chat or hug.

thepeopleversuswork · 02/03/2022 13:59

@FuckThatBullshit

A classic example of a needy extrovert not being able to understand or respect a quiet introvert. They are so fucking irritating.
I'm totally in the Person B is an arsehole camp.

But why are these threads always open season for people to kick extroverts?

It's become totally acceptable these days for people who are introverted or have social anxiety to lash out at people aren't as "needy"/unable to read a room/selfish etc etc.

In this case this absolutely applies but why do people feel that having any degree of social confidence whatsoever or any appetite for socialising is an opportunity for a blanket insult? I'm really tired of the fact that this passes without any challenge. COVID really amplified this and I've count of the threads on here which basically call out non-introverts as arseholes/stupid/needy/vain/lacking in social radar etc.

We all understand that some people find indiscriminate social interaction harder than others. We all totally get that everyone has a right not to want to chat to strangers etc. Why is it necessary to be so unpleasant about people who have a different temperament?