Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Wants the lifestyle but someone else has to pay for it?

183 replies

cleocleo24 · 01/03/2022 19:43

If you knew someone with this attitude, not benefits related, what would you think of them? Could you be friends?

OP posts:
LuaDipa · 02/03/2022 10:16

Once the dc was at school he was there more. Expected to put dc to bed after working late on her days off. He did more at weekends and school run the two days she was at work. He's extremely hands on and is always the one looking after dc whenever we meet up.

This is very telling op. He was ‘expected’ to put the kids to bed after being at work. He was ‘hands on’ because he looks after his own dc while she is out. I think your expectations of what constitutes a good father are extremely low. You clearly don’t like her, you are definitely not a friend as you frown on her every move while holding her ex up as some sort of saint for basic parenting and on that basis I think you should step away and leave her to it.

Plus, as they were married and it seems she will be taking on the vast majority of care for the dc (he’s obviously not ‘hands on’ enough to fight for 50/50) she will be entitled to the house or financial support to set up another home to raise the dc. He isn’t doing her any favours.

MrsDeadpool · 02/03/2022 10:16

Okay. Ignoring all the circumstances and issues and sides.

You’ve said that whenever you meet, this is all she talks about, and she rants and won’t listen to another side of the discussion, and doesn’t talk about anything else.

I would find this incredibly boring, and would feel I was being used as a recipient for her rants and not as a friend, so I wouldn’t want to spend any more time with her on those grounds.

No need for a moral compass, just a threshold of what friendship means - mutual care and support, fun and enjoyment. She scores zero on those, so I’d be out.

cleocleo24 · 02/03/2022 10:15

@renamer

“I guess it was only because she earns too but wasn't contributing anything to money wise to the bills etc but was still getting money from him on top for food and their dcs activities.”

Well why the hell wouldn’t she?

She was a SAHM - to HIS kids - while he built up the big career salary. Then she worked part-time.

Are you saying she should have lived like a pauper in her own home because she earned less?

The fact she even talks about receiving an “allowance” from her OWN HUSBAND would set-off alarm bells for me. I won’t go so far as to suggest financial abuse, but certainly it sounds controlling on his part.

Why did she not just have access to family money like a normal person?

Wake up OP. What is wrong with you?

I will also ask if you are an MRA or at least a very stingy man because this thread is peculiar.

No. I am saying she probably should have used her earnings to pay into their joint money for bills etc too. She had a massive disposable income while he paid for it all.

Yes it is suspicious that she had no access to his wage except the money he gave her. I expect it was his way of covering the debt he was in. She's never ever said he was financially controlling though. I think she was more than happy with the arrangement and that's why she's cross it's ended.

OP posts:
DrSbaitso · 02/03/2022 10:14

I am not the only one in our group men and women who think this too.

No, I bet you're not! So what?

LetsGoCrazyPurpleBanana · 02/03/2022 10:13

Not a friend but my brother. I've posted this on the lending someone money post. My brother and his wife are a very "keep up with the Jones's" and have alot of debt,Inc £13 grand of my dad's redundancy which they never paid back. Lost 2 houses. Money my late dad lent was to get them out of a sticky latch with debt and them on the verge of separating because of it. They ended up usingsome of the money to go to New York 😡We no longer speak.

DrSbaitso · 02/03/2022 10:12

@cleocleo24

I have said a few times now. He does school run twice a week. She does it the rest. He does majority of weekend care. He would put her to bed the days she's had off once he got back from work.
Yeah yeah. Days "off", doing childcare all day. And God forbid a man who works long hours should be expected to spend an hour or so with his kids when he gets home.

What a crock...CleoCleo.

cleocleo24 · 02/03/2022 10:10

@DrSbaitso

What have I said that has made me look like I despise her

"...shafted financially..."

"...really entitled..."

"...bad mouthing him..."

"What would you think of them? Could you be friends?"

"In what way?" (In response to asking for her side of it, as if the concept is totally baffling.)

"...expected a lot from him..."

And this is all just from page 1. Plus your belief that he was the main earner doing long hours yet somehow did most of the childcare, that he shouldnt have to do bedtime after working all day and the fact that he hid debt from her, which you've barely acknowledged.

If you can't see how this is coming across, I can't trust a single bloody thing you're saying about this marriage that totally has no connection to you.

Ok. I take your point. The first two are my opinion. The last is fact. Although I could argue the second point is fact too. I am not the only one in our group men and women who think this too.
OP posts:
cleocleo24 · 02/03/2022 10:09

I have said a few times now. He does school run twice a week. She does it the rest. He does majority of weekend care. He would put her to bed the days she's had off once he got back from work.

OP posts:
DrSbaitso · 02/03/2022 10:08

What have I said that has made me look like I despise her

"...shafted financially..."

"...really entitled..."

"...bad mouthing him..."

"What would you think of them? Could you be friends?"

"In what way?" (In response to asking for her side of it, as if the concept is totally baffling.)

"...expected a lot from him..."

And this is all just from page 1. Plus your belief that he was the main earner doing long hours yet somehow did most of the childcare, that he shouldnt have to do bedtime after working all day and the fact that he hid debt from her, which you've barely acknowledged.

If you can't see how this is coming across, I can't trust a single bloody thing you're saying about this marriage that totally has no connection to you.

LuaDipa · 02/03/2022 10:03

@DrSbaitso

Seems you've already made your mind up, OP.

You may be right, of course. But I'd like to hear the other side of this.

This.

I’m struggling to understand how he can work long hours and also do the vast majority of childcare.

Rosebuud · 02/03/2022 09:55

What have I said that has made me look like I despise her

It’s all of it. If this is how you talk about someone you classify as a friend I would hate to see how you talk about and treat someone you admit to dislike.

You are coming across as obsessed with this woman, and full of resentment. And you keep trying to pretend you’re her friend.

Friends don’t do to one another what you are doing. It’s awful

renamer · 02/03/2022 09:55

Who is the Oh Great Almighty Benevolent Higher Earner in your household OP? You or the DH?

renamer · 02/03/2022 09:52

“I guess it was only because she earns too but wasn't contributing anything to money wise to the bills etc but was still getting money from him on top for food and their dcs activities.”

Well why the hell wouldn’t she?

She was a SAHM - to HIS kids - while he built up the big career salary. Then she worked part-time.

Are you saying she should have lived like a pauper in her own home because she earned less?

The fact she even talks about receiving an “allowance” from her OWN HUSBAND would set-off alarm bells for me. I won’t go so far as to suggest financial abuse, but certainly it sounds controlling on his part.

Why did she not just have access to family money like a normal person?

Wake up OP. What is wrong with you?

I will also ask if you are an MRA or at least a very stingy man because this thread is peculiar.

cleocleo24 · 02/03/2022 09:39

@renamer

How about enlightening us as to the financial set-up in you marriage, OP?

I assume you earn exactly the same as your DH?

I assume you have totally separate finances and never “fund each other’s lifestyle?”

Perhaps he magnanimously “gives” you money every so often to buy the kids stuff?

Living the dream, eh?

Our earnings are vastly different to each other's but we both contribute to a shared account for all expenses and get the same amount personal money out. I know everyone's finances are different and I have many friends in different financial set ups.

I guess it was only because she earns too but wasn't contributing anything to money wise to the bills etc but was still getting money from him on top for food and their dcs activities.

OP posts:
PossiblyDreaming · 02/03/2022 09:36

A relationship where he worked ridiculous hours leaving her to do all the childcare (because he wasn’t expected to do bedtime if he was coming home at 10pm, was he?) and then giving her an “allowance” each month but keeping control of all the bills seems a pretty shitty relationship and certainly not one where she is exploiting him. If he was paying all the bills she wouldn’t have been able to apply for an overdraft/ credit card etc which leaves her pretty trapped in the marriage. In a marriage money is supposed to be shared. You obviously think her ex husband is being exploited by her but I’m sure he’s quite capable of saying the word “no” and she is quite capable of taking legal action if he is not paying fairly to support his family.

Stop being friends with her. You’re not friends with her anyway as you hate her Confused. In regards to your original question though - no, I wouldn’t WBD a friendship if a friend ls husband left them and she still expected him to support is family. Because I’m not a complete bellend.

renamer · 02/03/2022 09:35

How about enlightening us as to the financial set-up in you marriage, OP?

I assume you earn exactly the same as your DH?

I assume you have totally separate finances and never “fund each other’s lifestyle?”

Perhaps he magnanimously “gives” you money every so often to buy the kids stuff?

Living the dream, eh?

cleocleo24 · 02/03/2022 09:20

@Thewindwhispers

Honestly you sound like you hate her, so why are you asking the internet if you should be friends with her?

No one outside a relationship ever really knows what goes on inside it, she’ll have her view as you have yours and he has his. Not sure I care about any of it other than it’s a bit uncomfortable reading how much you seem to despise someone you apparently consider a potential friend.

What have I said that has made me look like I despise her? Please tell me. I certainly haven't agreed with her actions but have actually remained very supportive.

I have answered questions. I am her friend. We are in a friendship group with her and her ex. Girls meet up 1-1, the boys meet up 1-1 and we have met up as a group. Over the last 10 years we have all seen the gradual demise of their relationship. It's very sad when they were once so happy together. I do feel for my friend that it has finally ended. They have been in limbo for the past 18 months and we have all heard about it on almost a daily/weekly basis from her. She has kind of got us all involved. Should I have ignored her when she's talked about it during meet ups or messaged about it? This is why we all know so much. We haven't asked, she was told us pretty much every detail as she works through it.

OP posts:
AllOfUsAreDead · 02/03/2022 09:16

@SoberSerena

Aw I know poor menz op

Are you an MRA?

She has a point.

If we turned this around, ops friend is the worker and her husband stays at home, did the childcare for 5 years while spending a lot of money on himself, then the wife can come back home to work so the husband decides that she can work and do most of the childcare when she can, while refusing to get a job with more hours himself and still going out spending money on himself, not the kids. Also saying that he's only with the friend so that she can keep giving him money and that he doesn't care about their relationship.

That OK too? Because when people have said these kind of threads on here before, op is right, the guy gets called a sponger.

DrSbaitso · 02/03/2022 09:15

What's a MRA?

Saucer eyed, eh?

Shark jumped. You can use the Internet well enough to find Mumsnet...

I confess, the double female username had me doubting but I've been thinking lately that I might have been going too hard on that so I was trying to rein it in...

DrSbaitso · 02/03/2022 09:13

End the friendship, OP, because you aren't friends. You are either the new partner, the ex husband or someone with a frankly creepy level of obsession and a reason to oppose her. You don't like her and while you're happy to spend yonks on here disparaging her to the world wide web, you won't answer any questions that would shed light on who exactly you are and why you're so invested. It's giving me the creeps and I don't think I'm the only one.

Thewindwhispers · 02/03/2022 09:13

Honestly you sound like you hate her, so why are you asking the internet if you should be friends with her?

No one outside a relationship ever really knows what goes on inside it, she’ll have her view as you have yours and he has his. Not sure I care about any of it other than it’s a bit uncomfortable reading how much you seem to despise someone you apparently consider a potential friend.

SoberSerena · 02/03/2022 09:09

Do you have google?

cleocleo24 · 02/03/2022 09:07

@SoberSerena

Aw I know poor menz op

Are you an MRA?

What's a MRA?
OP posts:
cleocleo24 · 02/03/2022 09:07

@Mickarooni

You should end this friendship because you have zero respect for her. I don’t know why you’d want to be friends with someone who you’ve described in this way.
It is true, I am finding it hard to respect someone who so openly wants to be looked after and paid for by someone else- her words, not mine. It's so far away from my own views of life. But then I think am I wrong to think this and let the friendship slide because of it when I guess it really doesn't affect me, apart from having to listen to it. I don't know, the attitude doesn't sit well with me when I think so differently.
OP posts:
SoberSerena · 02/03/2022 09:05

Aw I know poor menz op

Are you an MRA?