Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Wants the lifestyle but someone else has to pay for it?

183 replies

cleocleo24 · 01/03/2022 19:43

If you knew someone with this attitude, not benefits related, what would you think of them? Could you be friends?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
cleocleo24 · 16/03/2022 09:31

It seems she feels very entitled to his earnings even now they are split up and begrudges him anything as she says it will be a stretch for her. But she forgets he's given her a house, works full time and earns significantly more than her.

She doesn't want to downsize the house but expects him to pay towards a house he will get no money from.

OP posts:
cleocleo24 · 16/03/2022 09:28

She's made it everyone's business by continuously talking about it to everyone and slagging him off. We went out for my birthday meal recently and she took over the whole conversation even though if was for my birthday.

Telling everyone he's financially screwed her over. Even down to comparing the cost of their cars and that he's brought himself this car.

She then announced she's going to divorce him. When I pointed out she may well be much worse off if she does, she didn't like that. My understanding is that any legal representative or judge would view the situation as very unfair to her ex if she did.

She's now trying to get more than the monthly amount offered to her and has secured £000 from him in a lump sum payment.

I would understand her point as the amount doesn't sound much but from my reading he's not legally responsible for paying towards her leaving costs only their dc which he's doing. I would also understand her point if he hadn't let her have the entire house and walked away with nothing. But why would he pay towards a house which he will get nothing from financially? They aren't selling it so he gets his share and he's walked away from that huge asset. She then told me her parents pay for xyz for their dc so then the CM seems quite reasonable. It's like she wants him completely broke.

She now does the majority of the childcare but he wanted to have the dc more days but she said no. He has to do all picking up/ taking them to hers.

OP posts:
Luckypom · 02/03/2022 23:24

@cleocleo24

Who needs enemies with you as a friend? You really do come across as nasty and the drip feeds are 'roll our eyes time'.

DrSbaitso · 02/03/2022 22:11

This could all have been avoided if they had sat down together and worked all this out and made difficult decisions rather than her ex just announcing he's going and how much she will have.

But he's not financially controlling and she's the arsehole.

cleocleo24 · 02/03/2022 20:41

@Iamnotamermaid

Appreciate this is a long shot but have the pair of them actually put together a budget for what they need/want with the money available, taking into consideration the extra accommodation now required and the outstanding debts?

It may help focus some of the discussion and manage expectations of lifestyles now they have split.

Good idea, we have mentioned this to her lots of time. I don't think she wants to and isn't willing to budget. She doesn't seem to want to practical things like this or make any hard decisions.

This could all have been avoided if they had sat down together and worked all this out and made difficult decisions rather than her ex just announcing he's going and how much she will have.

OP posts:
Iamnotamermaid · 02/03/2022 15:22

Appreciate this is a long shot but have the pair of them actually put together a budget for what they need/want with the money available, taking into consideration the extra accommodation now required and the outstanding debts?

It may help focus some of the discussion and manage expectations of lifestyles now they have split.

iheartmybeachhut · 02/03/2022 14:32

is op writing about her partners ex and distorting it to make it misleading? Hmm it's odd they haven't commented recently after such a vitrol tirade previously.

MorningStarling · 02/03/2022 14:17

"Someone else" has to pay for anyone's lifestyle. Either someone pays for another's lifestyle directly, or the person acquires the money to pay for it themselves. That money has to come from somebody else, that person is "paying" for their lifestyle.

MistOverTheDowns · 02/03/2022 14:09

Have you got your eye on him OP?

bluebird3 · 02/03/2022 13:56

You say she 'contributed nothing' while he paid for everything. What does this mean exactly?

It sounds like she did all childcare during his long working hours until kids were school age and more than half now. That's not nothing Hmm.

Who did the grocery shopping? Meal planning? Cleaning the house? Organising presents and celebrations for birthdays and christmas? Who organised the children's activities/programmes/school/homework? Who organises and takes the children to the doctor/dentist/opticians? Who takes the car to the garage when it needs servicing? Who organises and stops in when tradesmen are needed to fix the plumbing/dishwasher/refrigerator?

If she really doesn't do any of this and has a cook/cleaner/house manager then she's having her lifestyle 'funded.' If she manages all the household tasks, most of the childcare, and works minimal hours then I'm not surprised she doesn't have the energy or drive to develop a career at this stage. I think it's unfair to say she never wanted one - motivation and confidence diminishes as you get further out of that track and if they'd split everything evenly from the beginning she may have had one. Now she's probably middle aged, feeling like she's put her time in 'working' the 6am-10pm work days he did but from home and now she has nothing to show for it. I'd be bitter too.

BUT she does need to accept the reality of her situation and stop moaning and figure out her next move.

iheartmybeachhut · 02/03/2022 11:18

You seem very invested and know so much detail about this and their lives, I can't help wonder if this woman is actually you.

NewYearNewMinty · 02/03/2022 11:06

Sounds like you're trying to find a rleason to bin off your friend of 10 years so you can go after her ex.

Given the way you feel about her I'd say the 'friendship' is dead in the water regardless.

EuphoriaHigh · 02/03/2022 10:54

Something doesn’t add up here. If this is genuinely what she had told you and you’re not sprinkling little bits in here and there to try and change the overall opinion on here of her then it looks to me like she’s just trying to make her life seem better.

If he does the majority of the childcare why is he paying maintenance at all? He works long hours but does the majority of the care?

If their finances were working well whilst they were together then why bring that up? I actually find it quite abusive she had an ‘allowance’ rather than all money going into a joint account and them both having full access just so he can hide his debt. But she had extra money so I guess boo hoo, poor man.

As for this:

It is true, I am finding it hard to respect someone who so openly wants to be looked after and paid for by someone else-

If he’s paying for her then more fool him. I don’t see how that’s any of your business, at all.

DrSbaitso · 02/03/2022 10:50

Your mistake, OP, was trying this on a place like Mumsnet instead of Reddit or some other WomenSuck.com place. We're mostly mothers here (clue's in the name) and we spot stuff like "hiding debt" and "entitled attitude even though she doesn't have free access to the money" and "days with the children are days off" and "expecting him to do bedtime after not seeing the family all day" and "works such long hours yet still does most childcare" and "stellar grade A father for doing basic parenting, even on weekends" and everything else.

As for "what's an MRA", don't make me laugh.

renamer · 02/03/2022 10:45

“ Yes- I think you're right about him not wanting her to access the rest of his earnings. I do think it was to hide how much debt he was in. He's a bit of an entrepreneur and I always found it strange when they said they couldn't afford dh and z when he earns the same as my DH and we can. “

So one minute he’s the poor, high earning, woebegone husband who even DOES CHILDCARE of a weekend.

Now, in reality, he’s a husband with undisclosed debt who doesn’t allow his wife to have full access to HIS salary or even financial transparency?

Ok then ....

DrSbaitso · 02/03/2022 10:45

I think it's different if you are a SAHM. I have been in that situation myself.

And you thought of your days with the children as "days off", did you? And were happy for your husband to come home, having not seen them all day, and just ignore you all?

RitaFires · 02/03/2022 10:42

Maybe she wants to meet someone to look after her because the father of her kids worked from 6am to 10pm and left her to do everything alone? Maybe she wants someone rich because she had a partner that worked outrageous hours yet ended up in large amounts of secret debt?

If you don't want to listen to her anymore then back away the friendship, you seem to be committed to viewing everything she says in the worst possible light while you see secret debt man as a saint.

7eleven · 02/03/2022 10:40

You’re quite obviously green with envy. You ever heard the saying ‘With friends like that, who needs enemies.’? Sums you up.
Focus on your own life and stop clutching your pearls about other people’s. If the bloke doesn’t like the way he’s treated, it’s up to him to sort it.

UnsuitableHat · 02/03/2022 10:38

I have a very strong suspicion that you’re the man here OP. Im not sure what else would justify your level of interest in someone else’s finances and attempt to encourage people to criticise your ‘friend’.
If you actually are her friend, or have been presenting as such as she offloads, then both of you probably have some reevaluation to do.

DrSbaitso · 02/03/2022 10:35

It has made me realise I am going to have a much more open mind to it next time I meet with her and try and see it more from her POV.

If you do actually want to do her a favour, don't meet her again.

cleocleo24 · 02/03/2022 10:32

@renamer

“No. I am saying she probably should have used her earnings to pay into their joint money for bills etc too. She had a massive disposable income while he paid for it all.“

How do you know what her disposable income was, compared to his?

Yes, I’m most families her money and his would just go into a shared account. Then they would just spend what they need.

Sounds like he didn’t want shared finances?

Sounds like him giving her this “allowance” (on top of her part-time wage) was a way controlling or ring-fencing her spending and any money spent on the kids?

Put it this way OP, I am a SAHM. If my husband had ever, even once, breathed a word about giving me an “allowance,” I wouldn’t have had children with him, let alone left my career to SAH. Wtf!

I think it's different if you are a SAHM. I have been in that situation myself. When you have no way of earning yourself.

Yes- I think you're right about him not wanting her to access the rest of his earnings. I do think it was to hide how much debt he was in. He's a bit of an entrepreneur and I always found it strange when they said they couldn't afford dh and z when he earns the same as my DH and we can.

It's certainly put a new slant on it. It has made me realise I am going to have a much more open mind to it next time I meet with her and try and see it more from her POV. I don't think she's helped herself in some of the ways she's spent the money or what she's said about it all. But you are right, it's not as black and white as that.

OP posts:
renamer · 02/03/2022 10:26

“No. I am saying she probably should have used her earnings to pay into their joint money for bills etc too. She had a massive disposable income while he paid for it all.“

How do you know what her disposable income was, compared to his?

Yes, I’m most families her money and his would just go into a shared account. Then they would just spend what they need.

Sounds like he didn’t want shared finances?

Sounds like him giving her this “allowance” (on top of her part-time wage) was a way controlling or ring-fencing her spending and any money spent on the kids?

Put it this way OP, I am a SAHM. If my husband had ever, even once, breathed a word about giving me an “allowance,” I wouldn’t have had children with him, let alone left my career to SAH. Wtf!

DrSbaitso · 02/03/2022 10:24

Yes it is suspicious that she had no access to his wage except the money he gave her. I expect it was his way of covering the debt he was in.

Gracious me.

She's never ever said he was financially controlling though.

Oh, well, that's OK then.

You are incredibly selective about what you choose to take at face value from her and what requires deep critical analysis.

peanutbuttertoasty · 02/03/2022 10:22

It's none of your business, in fairness.

UnsuitableHat · 02/03/2022 10:19

I’m struggling to understand why someone would spend hours and hours detailing their personal problems to a ‘friend’ so critical that they then try to decide whether to dump them.