Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel fed up of being poor.

540 replies

laptopba · 01/03/2022 18:38

Just that really. Feeling rubbish about how my life has turned out in relation to finances. Its bloody shit.

OP posts:
BuddhaForMary · 02/03/2022 21:44

@CarolinaStabril

But you’re not looking at the bigger picture are you? Your boss pays you nmw because that’s wage of the job you’re doing. Surety you made that decision to get that job?
Or because they lost their better paid job and had to take what was on offer? Which is what the DWP are expecting of new claimants now.

Or because that was the only job available and they needed to pay the bills and feed their family, only to find the wages barely cover either of those things.

Your comments are bordering on offensive.

tyoy · 02/03/2022 21:42

I agree

WombatChocolate · 02/03/2022 21:39

There is never a quick fix if you’re in poverty.

There are hard slog things you can do to improve your chances of creeping out, but they take hard work, often years of sacrifice and usually set-backs along the way. Most people cannot face this ir can’t face it over a long period, so remain in poverty.

One of the things that strikes me, is how when you’re poor and you get just a bit of good luck, like a gift from a family member of money, or some kind of help from elsewhere, because if the grinding day-to-day nature of poverty, people want to treat themselves. It’s totally understandable. And the money is gone. The harder approach which actually boosts the chances of creeping out of poverty is to save that money. Bloody hard if you’ve been scrimping for months on end and have that sense that surely you deserve a treat.

The difficulty is to build up that but if a buffer that’s big enough to be able to take a hit due to need for new schools uniforms, or new washing machine ir whatever, without being back to zero again. Most peop,e on low incomes lives hand to mouth and massively struggle to build that buffer and to keep it. It’s what makes the difference.

Some people are bloody determined though. Despite hideous circumstances they take on another 20 hours work and save every penny. They genuinely never have a takeaway, or any leisure spending. Many think their lives are totally miserable and not worth living, but they are determined and can see their bank balance creeping up by tiny amounts. Sometimes there are set backs and a crisis happens a no the savings mostly vanish, but they don’t become hopeless and keep going.

It’s almost impossible if someone has mental health issues, physical disability, addiction or other issues which make working or budgeting effectively difficult. Some people live lives that are subject to huge crises too….relationship breakdowns, job losses on a frequent basis, many dependents who are unreliable or a big drain for whatever reason, family members who are financial nightmares and run up debt. These things prevent stability and make getting out of debt very very difficult.

The grinding nature of it is exhausting and I understand why people living like this, spend any money that comes their way to have a chance to feel they are able to enjoy the ‘normal’ things of life and to have some pleasure.

Lambkin689 · 02/03/2022 21:36

I do think there is a serious problem in this country with people studying subjects that don't lead to well-paid jobs. There's a reason so many of our software engineers are from Eastern Europe.

tyoy · 02/03/2022 21:29

@CarolinaStabril Have you seen what has happened to wages over the last few decades?

I'm not sure how practical it is for everyone to earn 6 figures.

Plzstopthisstupidity · 02/03/2022 21:28

I’m in the same position as you with my sweet little ones but hearing it from someone else just made me want to cry.

Life is unfair.

Maverickess · 02/03/2022 21:25

@CarolinaStabril

But you’re not looking at the bigger picture are you? Your boss pays you nmw because that’s wage of the job you’re doing. Surety you made that decision to get that job?
Yes, as work experience for nursing.

For a degree I couldn't actually do because I had to step out halfway through the access course due to ill health and racked up some debt with said illness. Couldn't justify going back to college and onto university with bailiffs at the door.
I had to, what's the phrase? Ah yes work hard to dig myself out.
I chose to do vocational qualifications whilst earning/paying debts off (for things like utilities and council tax, not fags, booze and catalogues btw) I have stumbled a few times through not having funding, and through covid the training stopped all together.
I have a plan, it doesn't involve nursing any more.

And that's before you think about how it can be acceptable for someone to take thousands in fees and tax payers money every week, and use it to make themselves rich rather than spend it on the thing that they are being paid for.

Society relies on my job, we don't need to be telling people to get out, we need to be encouraging people in.

Willyoujustbequiet · 02/03/2022 21:24

@CarolinaStabril

I find your suggestion that a mindset can overcome severe lifelong disabilities highly offensive.

disneylover367 · 02/03/2022 21:23

@DoorWasAJar Anyone over 23 should get the living wage im sure?

tyoy · 02/03/2022 21:22

Like other posters the housing market is responsible for so many ills. It's not a good thing to have so much money tied up in housing but can't see it improving.

Sassoon · 02/03/2022 21:21

Jesus there are some grim responses here - work harder, save more, well I have problems too - ignore them OP. Some people just don't think that by the grace of God they could be in the same position.

tyoy · 02/03/2022 21:19

For the vast majority of people that couldn’t be further from the truth

But all the evidence say social mobility is declining so why do you think it isnt?

tyoy · 02/03/2022 21:18

People really underestimate the benefits of family support & a stable background.

Yes people can do well despite their circumstances but for most hard work etc only gets you so far. Im selling my London flat, it's the 3rd one to sell this past yr. All 3 have been bought by parents for their twenty something dc. We are talking 700k plus properties, a good job can't really make up that ground for you.

alltheapples · 02/03/2022 21:14

@Rosebell75

I don’t agree it’s the main reason at all but I can see how these threads might feed into that belief.

Any potential idea or suggestion is promptly thrown back at posters. Any positive example of how people have managed to change their situation is shut down. Anyone who has achieved anything at all in life has only done so by having it handed to them on a plate or born with a silver spoon.

For the vast majority of people that couldn’t be further from the truth.

I come from a very poor background. Life is better for me now but I know how hard it is to get out of that when there is no one who can help you with basic things like interview clothes or travel to interviews. I got out partly due to a loan from my trade union for a course fee. My mum read to me every night and cared about my homework, but you do need some hard cash as well.
Davros · 02/03/2022 21:10

I don't know if this has been mentioned:
www.libraryofthings.co.uk
It's shit, I feel bad for people unable to see a way out

dottydodah · 02/03/2022 21:10

It makes me laugh as so many times we get why didnt so and so work harder in School? Well guess what a lot of people did! Nurses and Teachers are both needing a degree now .However pay, esp in big cities is not excessive and many teachers still struggle .The Guardian article "Homeless Teachers" highlights their plight . The right wing media seems intent on pushing "The American /English "dream on us .The reality is many people can hit hard times or be a JAM ,the cost of living gets hiked up month after month and suddenly are in difficult circumstances .I have been trying to save 50 pounds per month but often dip into it !

CarolinaStabril · 02/03/2022 21:10

But you’re not looking at the bigger picture are you? Your boss pays you nmw because that’s wage of the job you’re doing. Surety you made that decision to get that job?

Rosebell75 · 02/03/2022 21:08

I don’t agree it’s the main reason at all but I can see how these threads might feed into that belief.

Any potential idea or suggestion is promptly thrown back at posters. Any positive example of how people have managed to change their situation is shut down. Anyone who has achieved anything at all in life has only done so by having it handed to them on a plate or born with a silver spoon.

For the vast majority of people that couldn’t be further from the truth.

Maverickess · 02/03/2022 21:07

@CarolinaStabril

But some people just don’t want to better themselves either

Main reason for being poor is mindset not circumstance.

By goodness you've solved it.

I really didn't realise that my boss only pays nmw because I've got a poor mindset! And that it won't cover the increases we're seeing and those to come is because of my mindset and not the fact that what comes in doesn't extend to what goes out.
🤦

CarolinaStabril · 02/03/2022 21:06

@BuddhaForMary

Main reason for being poor is mindset not circumstance.

You've got to be kidding right??

Not at all, as soon as my mindset changed everything else improved and fell in to place. Poverty is a viscous cycle that is very difficult to break out of and it of course effects mental health
Morgysmum · 02/03/2022 21:03

I know that feeling. We haven't had a holiday in ages, and only just cleared the credit card from the last one.
I had use Groupon, to be able to afford it, then sold some stuff on Ebay for spending money. Unfortunately my partner couldn't just stay at the holiday park, but had to do other stuff as well, which is nice, but cost a small fortune, for our budget.
He doesn't seem to have a concept about money, saying we need to put x amount of money away a month, which would be nice, but 9 times out of 10, i am skint before next payday.
He makes more money than me, but likes to buy nibbles, think chocolate, sweets and lots of junk food, pretty much every day, so that's a fiver plus a day. He has stopped drinking, but would easily send £10 on booze then nibbles. I am hoping, that he hasn't had a drink for a couple of months as I had said I am desperate for a holiday and it's his fault as, he is always eating and drinking our savings away.
But then he whinges, that he is skint and borrowing money off me, till payday 🤦‍♀️he is preaching to the choir here. He is on a really good wage too, I am on minium wage, I even started cycling to work ti try and save, the bus fare, but nearly a year down the road, I am no better off.
I did try to retain, but due to been dyslexic and not good at maths, employers don't want to know. Another kick, is because I was tested before statements were a thing, now everyone wants a statement, £700 plus to say I am dyslexic, I can help yo towards the cost, but that still leaving me over £100, it might as well be the full price. Its like sorry without this peice of paper, I am making it up, So I am stuck.

BuddhaForMary · 02/03/2022 21:03

Main reason for being poor is mindset not circumstance.

You've got to be kidding right??

CarolinaStabril · 02/03/2022 21:03

[quote Willyoujustbequiet]@CarolinaStabril

Breathtaking stupidity.[/quote]
As I said it’s just my opinion based on my own experience. You don’t have to agree but there’s no need to be rude

BuddhaForMary · 02/03/2022 21:01

God my phone's autocorrect is on one tonight.

Maverickess · 02/03/2022 21:01

@Lifetheuniverseandeverything

YANBU.

Lots of good advice on here so my suggestion is actually for people who are doing ok - who aren’t drowning in debt/bills/section 21/refugee/sanctions/low pay/financial abuse/zero hours contracts/disability/childcare/rising living costs.
Think about ring theory. What can you do in your privileged position to help someone out instead of burdening them with more judgement? Not just financially. Maybe remove some smaller expectations on people like charity requests at school and on Facebook. Maybe offer someone a job or a pay rise. Maybe don’t judge if they fuck up in the first week or they don’t fit in because they haven’t got the right clothes/style or school has phoned to collect their child. Just give people a break.

Yes, it's not just about money, but losing the judgement around people with less and seeing how maybe instead of being judgemental and doling out advice like some kind of guru, and thinking that you've done your bit and told poor people what their problems are, how they've caused them and how they perpetuate them and how to fix them, just be more open minded and stop behaving like not having enough money to live on is a moral failing that can be solved by trying harder.
Swipe left for the next trending thread