Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel fed up of being poor.

540 replies

laptopba · 01/03/2022 18:38

Just that really. Feeling rubbish about how my life has turned out in relation to finances. Its bloody shit.

OP posts:
GetBackLoretta · 03/03/2022 00:29

Well said Jewel52 - Dibbydoos box clever and piss off! I think there would be more comments on that post if it weren't for the ignorant musings of CarolinaStabril. Carolina, Mrs Thatcher would be proud! You are the latter day champion for her poverty is a personality defect POV. Maybe also consider boxing clever and pissing off!

Hellorhighwater · 03/03/2022 00:18

And no OP, You are not being unreasonable. Being poor is shit. Really shit. Even if it’s not for ever.

And maybe you can Polly-Anna-positive-attitude-and-hard-graft your way your out of it, and maybe you can’t. Either way, you are allowed to moan about it being shit. You can do both simultaneously, you know. I’m down about it, and I am most definitely busting my ass to get out of my rut.

If you are wealthy, you can pay if forward and not judge. People are deserving of food and warmth and some small unnecessary luxuries even if they ARE lazy, unwashed, undeserving twats. Most people aren’t, of course, but even if they are. They wealthy need to let go of the idea that only perfect poor people are deserving of charity. It’s unfair for society to shaft someone and them complain they aren’t whiter than white. Accept that you have have more than your share, and give some away to someone who has less. Not all your wealth, but some. And do it because they need it, not because it meets your conditions of feeling good about it. If your charity has conditions attached, it’s not charity. It’s not for the benefit of others, but for yourself. If you require the recipient to earn your donation through your approval criteria, it’s not charity, it’s employment.

WildImaginings · 02/03/2022 23:57

And I'm aware Olio won't pay the mortgage. But when someone only has £10 left to buy food until payday, it can make a massive difference.

Hellorhighwater · 02/03/2022 23:51

@CarolinaStabril

Obviously people are allowed to disagree and have different opinions, but this is my opinion based on my own experience and those around me 😊
They will, because it is utterly wrong, and shows very limited understanding of poverty as an individual experience or a societal problem.

Over the last ten years I have been comfortable, poor, virtually destitute, on a low income, comfortable again, wealthy and now poor again. It won’t last, but it’s HARD.

And I’m exactly the same person, with the same degrees, experience, side hustles, mindset and drive. It was just circumstances changing. I didn’t even start out poor, and have been able bodied throughout, and I didn’t manage my money badly.

Poverty requires more creativity, drive, energy and grit, and is harder work that being wealthy ever was, and I’m speaking from direct experience of both. You can work really hard and not make it out of poverty. Only fifty percent of people can be better off than average, even if 100 percent of people work hard and have the right mindset etc etc - its basic maths.

In any sphere, there is a finite amount of money to go around. If you have more than average, someone else has less. Wealth is only possible if there is poverty, therefore it is literally not possible for everyone to work their way out of poverty, even if is theoretically equally possible for all individuals to do so (it isn’t, but if it were, the argument still stands). It is in the interests of the wealthy to present the poor as undeserving, because otherwise wealth is morally indefensible. I am not judging anyone with wealth, but it should be acknowledged that wealth is not automatically a result of hard work and mindset, it is mostly luck. Plenty of people work hard and remain poor. A comparative few work hard and get wealthy (And very few don’t work hard and get wealthy. Almost as few don’t work and stay poor). Correlation does not equal causation. Hard work and education do not automatically equal wealth, and poverty does not equal laziness or lack of motivation. No one wants to be poor, and to imply that it is a moral failing is patronising and naive.

WildImaginings · 02/03/2022 23:40

Please download the app Olio.

Local 'food waste heroes' sign up with supermarkets etc and have different weekly slots. They collect their best before food that hasn't sold and list it on the app, usually from around 9.30pm. You then request items, making sure that you give a time you can go and collect. Around here it's mainly Tesco. The amount of food that would be thrown in the bin is absolutely shocking.

There is nothing wrong with best before food and almost everything is freezable. I know it sounds a small thing but it could make a difference; I've not had to buy bread for over three weeks and have lots in the freezer too as I've been given extra by some FWH's where they've had some left. Bread/pastries/bakery are the main items available (SO much bread) but I've also collected stew packs, cauliflowers, cabbages, noodles, salads etc. I've also been able to collect for a family member who is incapacitated at the moment so unable to get out and it's been a massive help to them.

It does depend what's in your area and where the FWH's are. We have 2 within a 10 min walk, a couple within a 5 min drive and a few slightly further but worth going for a good haul.

There is also a non food section where people can list things for collection. I've donated things like body moisturiser, new colouring books, new make up brushes etc. People also list furniture. Someone near me today was giving away 2 sofas that were in really good condition!

Jewel52 · 02/03/2022 23:27

@Dibbydoos

So having caught back up on this post 8 pages since I first dipped in, it seems everyone who is poor just really wants to moan. So moan away.

As I said originally, the system is designed to keep people poor.

Opportunity if you're not from a privileged background or born into money is so much harder to find. But at some stage, you either accept you're poor or do something about it. It's not about working harder; it's about boxing clever. Everyone who has posted on here explaining how they got out, boxed clever. Qualifications can help to open more doors, but so can good ideas. The reality is, unless you have privilege or money, it is down to you to open doors.

Managerially, one of my preferred roles is a Belbin Shaper. I've used this many times to move people up organisations, i recently helped a member of my team move from an average salary to almost double that salary through promotion. It was a real fight but she got there cos she us amazing and tenatious.
Find a Shaper you know who can help you build your self esteemed and help you see your talents so you can build on them.

Please carry on moaning as much as you like. As I said at some stage you either accept your situ or you break out of it. It's your choice.

And for anyone who says there are loads who bust their guts all their lives and never break out of poverty. I agree there are. But it's not because those advising different approaches are wrong, it's cos they didn't get opportunity at the right time. IMO, that is the missing ingredient. Don't be like them, use your determination to find the right opportunity for you when you are ready.

Good luck to you all

Seriously, you should be ashamed of yourself. From everyone posting on here facing daily financial worries, just Fuck Off
RantyAunty · 02/03/2022 23:22

@NazMedusa I appreciate your inspiring story about your father and your husband.

RantyAunty · 02/03/2022 23:07

@Maverickess best wishes for your DDs interviews. What career is she looking at to get into?

liveforsummer · 02/03/2022 22:57

@Bambooshampoo dd2 has never had a birthday party either. Dd1 has but had to chose between a party or a present. I could afford that when on benefits Not had that options with dd2 because a party would be more than was available to spend now I'm working. They did have decent Xmas this year because a I got a covid isolation grant plus a winter fuel payment just in time when I thought they had nothing. I know I should have saved it but I treated them instead and don't regret it.

RantyAunty · 02/03/2022 22:53

[quote HonestwithHope1]@RantyAunty

Sure thing you foul NIMBY. Go cry when there's mass quitting of every profession you look down on, cause we won't be there to save your health or prevent any crime happening to you. But hey! We will all be rich financd workers right.[/quote]
Interesting that the only one looking down on anyone is you.
I haven't said an unkind word about anyone doing it hard.

You know zero about where I came from or the challenges I've faced to get where I am. None.

CarolinaStabril · 02/03/2022 22:47

TheartJKRowling

Don’t take things so personally, I’m just adding my opinion based on my own experience. Clearly that’s not the case for you and your family which is why yo7 seem quite defensive and angry.

Bambooshampoo · 02/03/2022 22:47

Being poor is so terribly expensive.
My kids are just beginning to understand we are poor. It hurts.
They’ve never had a birthday party, it’s all they want. Was served a section 21 from landlord and had to move before xmas, so cannot afford a birthday party 😔
Feel like such a failure for them, if only their birthdays had been a bit later, I’d have another pay packet to fund it.
Damn landlord.

Alcoholabuse · 02/03/2022 22:42

@5329871e

I 100% agree with parents in poverty trying to push their kids out of poverty but this isn’t the thread for it.

OP is obviously struggling and fed up. Being poor is bloody shit. Living in the cold, paying a premium for using the corner shop as you can’t afford to run a car to Aldi/Lidl because it’s an hour walk from the nearest bus stop (not quite sure what Ops situation is but I’m sure she’s just needing a rant from holding up appearances to her kids/friends/society).

There is a race to the bottom in this country, as a kid saying ‘you can call my mum if you want to but she says that history is pointless’. — I’ve worked in education and it’s a fighting against the tide—.

I grew up in absolute poverty, my parents married young, mum stayed at home and after the divorce she was left with a huge mortgage that she couldn’t afford to move. She had zero qualifications (left school at 15), had no work experience and no transferable skills. Living on tinned microwaved food as the oven was too expensive, sleeping with our clothes in our bed to get changed under the duvet as the house was always cold and Xmas presents were essentials/things for extra curricular activities.

If we ever wanted anything we’d be told ‘when you’re older and get a good job you can buy/do…’ from the age of 5 I knew I was going to uni. We weren’t allowed to talk in our ‘local’ accent. My mum saw on the tele that reciting poetry down the stairs helped elocution/public speaking skills/memory. We were forced to watch countdown after school. At 16 each of us was given the yellow pages to call businesses for work experience.

It gave my mum strength that we’d never be in the same situation and all of us have fairly good jobs, the fridge is full, heating on and our kids have the world on their plate. But none of us will forget poverty and we should thank our mum for always driving us.

Very rarely do people get themselves ‘out of poverty’, JK Rowling was a single mum but she had a privileged upbringing, people being down on their luck isn’t the same as being in permanent poverty. And it’s bloody shit, horrible and very rarely does someone send down a ladder that leads to a route to a 40k position.

IheartJKRowling · 02/03/2022 22:40

@CarolinaStabril

But some people just don’t want to better themselves either

Main reason for being poor is mindset not circumstance.

I must tell my daughter, who was left permanently disabled and living on benefits in her early 20's that it's just her mindset and her inability to better herself that keeps her so far below the poverty line, not this government's fucking obscene treatment of people who genuinely need support.

If only she hadn't been remiss enough to have her life and body destroyed in an horrific accident, she too could be living the kind of life you appear to be enjoying.

I would love you to spend a month living with her disability and pain and see how your mindset about bettering yourself is then 🙄

NazMedusa · 02/03/2022 22:40

I grew up in what was known as one of the poorest boroughs in London in the 80s. However, due to my dad's hard graft and intelligence, we had money. My dad was an orphan who worked from the age of 12 (washing dishes in restaurants), saved and worked his way up until he started his own little business. This grew and grew, he got very lucky. His businesses were doing well and he bought properties (that are now providing my parents an income without having to do much) which meant we grew up not wanting for anything. Most of our school friends didn't have the same luck and we did stand out as a result. I did feel very lucky as a child as I could see how our lives could have been.

I met my husband at the age of 16 in college. My husband wasn't as lucky; they grew up struggling as his dad had poor health and was unable to work and his mum was a SAHM to seven children. She also took care of her MIL and FIL who lived with them. They all lived in a small 3 bedroom, 1 bathroom house. We lived in a large 6 bedroom, three bathroom home (I have 4 sisters).

When we were young, I think my husband was in awe of the comforts my father's money had bought us. He used to tell me how different his life and upbringing was to mine and how lucky I was. He took me to McDonald's on our early dates but I could tell even then sometimes he'd struggle to pay. I made jokes and found excuses to pay whenever I could. He got a part time job when we started uni (mobile phone shop, commission based) and he started saving hard. He was very nervous about how my family would view him and his. Before our families started to communicate for our marriage (we're British born Asians), my husband and his family worked hard to improve the way their house looked as they were embarrassed for my family to see it. I felt awful for him and them and no matter what I said about not worrying about that, they carried on. Even taking out a loan for a new kitchen in their council property. After marriage my dad offered us money for a deposit to buy a house instead of renting our flat. My husband refused.

Anyway, my husband has always been determined to work hard to give me a similar lifestyle to the one I grew up with and for him to experience it himself. He got a degree but struggled to find work relating to it. Eventually, he applied to companies offering to work for free and ended up in a top construction company where they hired him within a week.

I watched my husband push himself and push himself. After having our first child and coming to a stumbling block in terms of progression, he decided to complete the ACCA qualification. He took evening classes and stayed up all night revising before each exam. It took 3 years but he did it and it allowed him to take on higher paying roles, buy us a nice home, nice cars, have more children, etc. I had been working PT since having our first child so he shouldered most of the financial responsibilities throughout our marriage.

18 years later, he is still with the same company and earning a six figure salary. I am so proud of how accomplished and happy he is and how far he has come. We enjoy a comfortable lifestyle and don't have to worry about money. All because of his hard work and determination.

Don't give up. I was shocked after leaving my parents home on how hard (and expensive) life is and many times, struggled with my husband to make ends meet. It was depressing. Education, hard work and determination was what took my husband out of it. You can do it too.xx

SquirrelG · 02/03/2022 22:37

But you’re not looking at the bigger picture are you? Your boss pays you nmw because that’s wage of the job you’re doing. Surety you made that decision to get that job?

What planet are you living on? Some people have no choice in what job they take, it simply comes down to them having to have a job, any job. I am constantly applying for jobs, but get nowhere (I'm 62) - I would take on any job offered to me just to be earning. Also, as I have already mentioned on this thread, SOMEONE has to do the low paid jobs or people like you would be complaining if they weren't done. As long as it's not you, eh?

TmFid · 02/03/2022 22:33

@BatmanCat

Welcome to 1984. Where everyone has nothing.

What I don't understand is why people aren't kicking off and protesting about this to the government? Scotland, wales and Northern Ireland have helped their citizens with fuel costs £200 that doesn't need to be repaid and more for those in poverty.

Us in England get jack shit. It's time for things to change.

Exactly this!
Scaredofburnout · 02/03/2022 22:18

@HonestwithHope1

Oh do shove a sock in it

You would be the first to fecking moan if i didn't work in the area I work in!!!!!! If i didn't work in my area. We would be like the purge.

OH and another f thing.

I have an NHS degree. Turns out. No one wants to hire band 5s AHP SPECIFICALLY BAND 5S! 2 years of unemployment and now my registration has lapsed. My uni tutor, every interview I attended with clinical lead. They all said similar

Tough competition
You were in the top 2/3
If it were up to me I'd hire all ten of you that applied
I've been doing this job 25 years, I've never had as many applicants as this post

And my classic fav from my old tutor who gave me a reference for current job.

I'm not surprised, we can't even get students on placement, it's become that difficult in trusts.

So kindly. Go run and jump.

If you work. You should be able to afford a good lifestyle (everything I previously said). Hell even on benefits you should be able to afford the basics of life.

If nearly 2 generations (my grandparents and aunties/uncles) could definitely achieve a good high quality of living, up north, unskilled as well!. Then why the ever loving hell can't the vast majority of under 50s... And 99% of under 30s.

People like you really piss me off. No i don't give a s... about going into IT or finance or whatever other bollocks you think are deserving of being paid actual money.

That's very unusual, NHS trusts are crying out for staff. Which specialty of AHP are you in if you don't mind me asking?
EveningOverRooftops · 02/03/2022 22:17

@CarolinaStabril

Obviously people are allowed to disagree and have different opinions, but this is my opinion based on my own experience and those around me 😊
So anecdotal and not worth much opinion wise especially against the countless studies that show poverty is caused more often by external factors - low wages, high rents, high energy costs, disability and mental health issues - than someone’s choice or ‘mindset’

Good job Hmm

cuno · 02/03/2022 22:08

@Libraryghost

This might just be me but the wealthiest people I know didn’t go to university. I know some bricklayers and plumbers etc that are living a more affluent lifestyle than say a teacher or a nurse. I know plenty of graduates that are struggling especially those who have got the ten a penny degrees like business studies. Having a good education is a must for so many reasons but please don’t think it guarantees you a great salary, far from it.
Yeah, same here. Of course I know successful people with degrees, and people struggling without them. But university isn't everything, and now we have far too many people with university education and not enough jobs for people with degrees. I have friends working for minimum wage with degrees.
venusmay · 02/03/2022 22:04

I know a lot of people that have so called 'good jobs' who are struggling at the moment so it's not a guarantee for financial stability. We just about manage, no savings but just making ends meet.

Many people are worried about the hike in costs, many more will probably lose jobs on homes because no one factored in the 50% rise in energy bills and sky rocketing petrol costs. Food is sure to go up. It's hard but you're not alone op.

Libraryghost · 02/03/2022 22:03

This might just be me but the wealthiest people I know didn’t go to university. I know some bricklayers and plumbers etc that are living a more affluent lifestyle than say a teacher or a nurse. I know plenty of graduates that are struggling especially those who have got the ten a penny degrees like business studies. Having a good education is a must for so many reasons but please don’t think it guarantees you a great salary, far from it.

alltheapples · 02/03/2022 21:57

Yeah stupid me not choosing to do a job with six-figure salary.

Lineofconcepcion · 02/03/2022 21:57

Please don't vote Tory again, it really was better under Labour . . .

fetchacloth · 02/03/2022 21:53

[quote EatSleepReplete]@OneRingToRuleThemAll I can't even think of a response for that.[/quote]
Nor me. Words fail Confused