Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel fed up of being poor.

540 replies

laptopba · 01/03/2022 18:38

Just that really. Feeling rubbish about how my life has turned out in relation to finances. Its bloody shit.

OP posts:
Harmonypuss · 03/03/2022 14:13

@BlueSummerBaby

If anyone needs clothes E5P has a £2.50 sale on at the moment.

And where are we meant to find a spare £2.50 per item from, when we're struggling to feed ourselves and can't afford to even turn the lights on?

Harmonypuss · 03/03/2022 14:05

@CarolinaStabril

Right, you say it's "my mindset" that's keeping me poor.

I'm disabled and am physically unable to work which severely restricts just how much cash I can have access to.

So basically, using your 'theory', you're telling me that I'm disabled because my mindset is telling me to 'think' I am and that there's no actual physical reason for my disability and by extension, my lack of cash?

Maverickess · 03/03/2022 13:53

no the NMW is for the kids, everyone over 23 is on the LW which is only about £1 more so its just a rename of the NMW for over 23 year olds (altho I think it used to be the over 25 year olds, just used to be 2 rates of the NMW).

its meaningless its just the tories corrupting a labour idea as they kept saying the people need a real living wage not a minimum one and promising to deliver a living wage if voted in. so the Tories just nicked the word to confuse the hard of thinking.

I think we're saying the same thing here, though for clarity I should have said 'real' living wage.

The living wage foundation calculates the real living wage at an average of the cost of living across the UK, the government calculates their 'living wage' and nmw at 66% of the median income (I think I've understood right), so not based on the actual cost of living.

The real living wage is around £1 an hour more than the government one. But the government one is the least you can legally pay someone per hour (though the rules around unpaid time are a bit murkier, especially when you're in a job where you can't just drop everything and walk out the second your shift ends because it might put someone at risk).

So I totally agree that the government calling it a living wage doesn't mean it actually is, it's spin designed to justify low wages.

HonestwithHope1 · 03/03/2022 13:48

@LiveintheNow

Statistically, the majority are home owners, many are actually multiple home owners (something I completely disagree with btw) who have lower mortgages, a home, a secure home and know they will get a fab pension at the end from their full time for life job, oh and no uni debt, or probably car debt, or any type of debt that is now sadly common.

Forgive me for not weeping for the tiny minority of 60+ who didn't get all those privileges, and also my skepticism of what they were doing with their lives ...

In my family, out of 9 aunts/uncles in a poor northern town doing unskilled jobs for life, the only non home owner out of them, joined her husband in functioning alcoholism decades ago so booze was more important than home for them- she still has a great pension though!... My mum has a 28 year gap between siblings (change of life baby) . My mum is in her late 40s.

People this age and below have a much lower chance of getting everything 2 previous generations had....my generation will have a 1% likelyhood of having all those privileges.

It sucks.

Blondeshavemorefun · 03/03/2022 13:38

@Bromse

I agree with Buddha, it has been very hard for self employed (yes I know it's been hard for others). I was talking to someone a couple of days ago, an accountant who is self employed but managing at the moment, and he was telling me about a friend of his who is also a client who was paid £1300 one month for a kitchen fitting job and his UC stopped. It will take ages for it to start again. Those who dish out UC think if you have a payment, you'll be getting the same every month. This guy hadn't had work for ages! You can't blame people for doing cash in hand jobs in those circumstances.

So many people have financial difficulties, we just don't generally hear about them.

I am concerned about the op and hope today is better for her in some way.

Uc doesn’t work like that

It’s done on his monthly income

So if he earnt £1300 they will take off so much pence per £1 over the mini form floor fir that month

So he might have got less this month

Next month if he doesn’t earn that he will get uc again

It’s a monthly thing

If he is in the system it won’t take months to start up again, he will do his earnings next month and they will calculate on that

But they have now added minimum floor back in so has to work x number of hours x minimum wage

Which they didn’t do for the last two years

So many will get less this month and onwards

Friend works for cab and explained how uc works roughly

LiveintheNow · 03/03/2022 13:32

@HonestwithHope1

I am sooooo f sick of priveleged shit people. Well seen faux sympathy middle class are well alive on mumsnet

Oooh become a chartered accountant
Work in finance!
Education to get a better job stupid

Put a damn sock in it!

You miserable nimbys would be crying on BBC if people in my job quit en mass due to shit as hell pay for complex work

Privileged wankers.

Lets get it right

Every single f job out there should pay enough to have a good quality of life. No ifs ands or buts.

Rent/Mortgage paid- also preferably having rent max caps in place would actually help people -.-
Bills paid (heating, water, gas, electricity, internet- and yes internet is godamn essential!)
Good food
Transport costs whether that's public or petrol
Some savings
Some leisure

Jfc. Aged 60+ generation got all this AND A DAMN LOT MORE FOR LESS WORK, LESS OF A COMMUTE, LESS RESPONSIBILITIES

We aren't asking for much ffs.

The 60+ generation are just like you, still working for poor pay in physically hard jobs for at least another 7 years...
alltheapples · 03/03/2022 13:25

@Bromse

I agree with Buddha, it has been very hard for self employed (yes I know it's been hard for others). I was talking to someone a couple of days ago, an accountant who is self employed but managing at the moment, and he was telling me about a friend of his who is also a client who was paid £1300 one month for a kitchen fitting job and his UC stopped. It will take ages for it to start again. Those who dish out UC think if you have a payment, you'll be getting the same every month. This guy hadn't had work for ages! You can't blame people for doing cash in hand jobs in those circumstances.

So many people have financial difficulties, we just don't generally hear about them.

I am concerned about the op and hope today is better for her in some way.

I agree the system is not set up for people to do ad hoc work.
VelvetChairGirl · 03/03/2022 13:09

@Maverickess

what are you talking about? the only difference between the NMW and the LW is age.

NMW is just that, the minimum that someone can legally be paid, the living wage is one that can, well, be lived on.

According to livingwage.org the nmw has been around £1 an hour behind the nlw.

Calling the nmw a living wage doesn't make it so, it just changes the name.

no the NMW is for the kids, everyone over 23 is on the LW which is only about £1 more so its just a rename of the NMW for over 23 year olds (altho I think it used to be the over 25 year olds, just used to be 2 rates of the NMW).

its meaningless its just the tories corrupting a labour idea as they kept saying the people need a real living wage not a minimum one and promising to deliver a living wage if voted in. so the Tories just nicked the word to confuse the hard of thinking.

Bringsexyback · 03/03/2022 13:08

I most certainly did not get shafted by the government during the pandemic because I paid my taxes and declared my income so I actually did extremely well out of the pandemic.
For the first 12 months of being self-employed you aren’t required to earn the ceiling range in order to be entitled to universal credits so actually you could give self-employment to go for 12 months and still have the security that she got from being on universal credits you’d be no worse off

Bromse · 03/03/2022 13:08

I agree with Buddha, it has been very hard for self employed (yes I know it's been hard for others). I was talking to someone a couple of days ago, an accountant who is self employed but managing at the moment, and he was telling me about a friend of his who is also a client who was paid £1300 one month for a kitchen fitting job and his UC stopped. It will take ages for it to start again. Those who dish out UC think if you have a payment, you'll be getting the same every month. This guy hadn't had work for ages! You can't blame people for doing cash in hand jobs in those circumstances.

So many people have financial difficulties, we just don't generally hear about them.

I am concerned about the op and hope today is better for her in some way.

BlueSummerBaby · 03/03/2022 13:05

If anyone needs clothes E5P has a £2.50 sale on at the moment.

Tevion28 · 03/03/2022 12:56

I have the same problem never any spare money outside of household bills for extras just working to pay bills. I wanted to say that due to mental health issues it's not easy for some people to better themselves.

Maverickess · 03/03/2022 12:53

what are you talking about? the only difference between the NMW and the LW is age.

NMW is just that, the minimum that someone can legally be paid, the living wage is one that can, well, be lived on.

According to livingwage.org the nmw has been around £1 an hour behind the nlw.

Calling the nmw a living wage doesn't make it so, it just changes the name.

VelvetChairGirl · 03/03/2022 12:50

hawk not hark.

HARK AT HER!

VelvetChairGirl · 03/03/2022 12:48

@BuddhaForMary

I'm self employed and for those saying oh just do that, it's HARD. And the income isn't great if you can't find the clients. It's an insecure income, no sick pay, and if you have time off you have no income. Of course you can work your own hours around children, which can be great, but even that can be problematic. Any training you need to further your career comes out of your own pocket.

The problem with some posters on this thread is that while they're trying to be helpful, they're also coming across as patronising - like those who don't have much money also don't have the common sense to look for ways to better their income or access things like food banks etc. They don't seem to realIe they're talking to EMPLOYED people, some in rolls that we depend upon every day of the week, and they shouldn't even need to be accessing a bloody food bank to feed their families in the 5th richest country in the world!!

I was interested in doing VO work which is self employed as a friend does it, but the difference is she is on her own and works in a full time job, always lives in shared houses.

I am not, I am a mum, I live in a private rent paid from benefits.

for her its a nice little earner on the side for some extra cash which she can save up for whatever (normally with her its better quality recording equipment), for me it would fuck up my benefits and leave me with no where near enough money to pay the rent let alone anything else, even tho I have a much larger voice range then she does.

again its something your better off being in work to do because you have more freedom, you can start your side hussle in your free time unhindered and hopefully grow it so you dont have to work.

where as if your unemployed and you suddenly go self employed, well your not entitled to this that and the other anymore that were keeping you afloat in the first place and what you did get you are suddenly watched like a hark over.

in fact it surprises me how many people say go self employed considering how many self employed people got absolutely shafted by the government over the pandemic, its like everyone has suddenly forgotten.

VelvetChairGirl · 03/03/2022 12:37

@DoorWasAJar

Why do care workers in this country get minimum wage when even cleaners and retail staff get the living wage? The UK is bad and getting worse, but the worst thing about it all is how propagandised people are and how they’ve been trained to be pathetically grateful for the absolute bare minimum.
what are you talking about? the only difference between the NMW and the LW is age.
BuddhaForMary · 03/03/2022 12:36

*roles even. This bloody phone Confused

BuddhaForMary · 03/03/2022 12:35

I'm self employed and for those saying oh just do that, it's HARD. And the income isn't great if you can't find the clients. It's an insecure income, no sick pay, and if you have time off you have no income. Of course you can work your own hours around children, which can be great, but even that can be problematic. Any training you need to further your career comes out of your own pocket.

The problem with some posters on this thread is that while they're trying to be helpful, they're also coming across as patronising - like those who don't have much money also don't have the common sense to look for ways to better their income or access things like food banks etc. They don't seem to realIe they're talking to EMPLOYED people, some in rolls that we depend upon every day of the week, and they shouldn't even need to be accessing a bloody food bank to feed their families in the 5th richest country in the world!!

Maverickess · 03/03/2022 12:21

@5329871e

Well, I regret posting on this thread because it was obviously for people who need to vent (fair enough) and not for advice on how to turn things around.

Vent away. Sorry for intruding.

Yes it was a thread to vent for people in a certain situation, who feel fed up with their situation. And yes, from the thread title on, that was obvious.

Those people may or may not be trying to better themselves, climb their way out or seek to encourage their children out of the cycle, but that part of it wasn't really the point. The point was offloading the mental baggage that being poor brings and feeling heard, and that can be even heavier baggage when you are trying, when you are seeking the openings that you need, fighting for them, and not making any headway.

I'm really glad that you've seen that. Some of the advice given (by many posters, not just you) is really valid, if it had been asked for, some has been downright patronising and bordering on offensive - especially as for the most part, it's been unsolicited.

But I think it speaks to the wider point that I've already made, that the poorest in society are looked down upon, even while being relied upon to provide services we take for granted, and that some use to better their own situation.
Those with illness and injury (or responsibility towards those that do) that put even more barriers in the way, are judged and found wanting by those who have never had the experience of that, or have had it with advantages that others don't have - so a completely different experience.

I find it an interesting look into the mindset of some that their immediate reaction to this topic is to immediately judge, patronise and give unsuitable and unsolicited advice to people instead of empathy and compassion.

VelvetChairGirl · 03/03/2022 12:17

@bemusedmoose

same boat! I made some adjustments to my way of life so i had a tiny bit of wiggle room but with the energy hikes coming it's looking like i will be choosing to pay for heat and light or food. A full new uniform and my son's state school is a good 200 smackers! I've tried to stagger out the getting new bits as he grows as i just cant do it in one hit.

It's only me and the kids and there is only so much money a single parent can bring in! Not the life i had planned admittedly but we do our best. Life in the UK is just too freaking expensive. I'm actually looking at moving counties as rent here is insane. |I think i will cry when i work out the moving costs.

I'm assuming you've spoken to the school about help with uniforms?

Maybe its because they all know I am unemployed they offer stuff without me asking, they have like secondhand shops for the uniforms, the schools have washing machines and dryers you can use if needs be etc, there is quite a lot and even if your school doesnt have anything there is at least one charity in this country to do with uniforms, they are online and facebook I cant remember what they are called, they advertise for old uniforms with the logos and all that and you can go on their site and search by school to see if they have anything. I stumbled upon them when trying to get rid of primary school stuff.

VelvetChairGirl · 03/03/2022 12:12

@5329871e

Well, I regret posting on this thread because it was obviously for people who need to vent (fair enough) and not for advice on how to turn things around.

Vent away. Sorry for intruding.

you'll be back for attention soon enough I am sure
BuddhaForMary · 03/03/2022 12:08

@HonestwithHope1

I am sooooo f sick of priveleged shit people. Well seen faux sympathy middle class are well alive on mumsnet

Oooh become a chartered accountant
Work in finance!
Education to get a better job stupid

Put a damn sock in it!

You miserable nimbys would be crying on BBC if people in my job quit en mass due to shit as hell pay for complex work

Privileged wankers.

Lets get it right

Every single f job out there should pay enough to have a good quality of life. No ifs ands or buts.

Rent/Mortgage paid- also preferably having rent max caps in place would actually help people -.-
Bills paid (heating, water, gas, electricity, internet- and yes internet is godamn essential!)
Good food
Transport costs whether that's public or petrol
Some savings
Some leisure

Jfc. Aged 60+ generation got all this AND A DAMN LOT MORE FOR LESS WORK, LESS OF A COMMUTE, LESS RESPONSIBILITIES

We aren't asking for much ffs.

Very well said.
VelvetChairGirl · 03/03/2022 12:08

*Because studying full time is something of a luxury

If no children, then studying is something you should be doing alongside employment

If children, then much more difficult to be employed AND study AND parent children*

of you have kids and no employment its harder to study too, I have noticed most courses in anything but basic computer skills, English and maths are after school hours, because they expect you do in work 9-5 and going to class after work, not looking after kids after 3.30.

theres very little going on during the day when the kids are at school.

VelvetChairGirl · 03/03/2022 11:51

I really felt for you reading this and I just wanted to ask if you'd thought about alternative ways of making money like going self employed?

Oh I'd be far too frightened to do that, frankly I only just started having to pay bills and rent etc in 2017, I was akept woman before then first by my parents then the ex, the thought of self assessment ta returns, hell no.

If you're ok with dogs there's an app called rover where you can literally sign up tomorrow and look after other people's pets for cash. My sister in law is doing it right now and she's getting £600 to watch someone's two bulldogs whilst they go on holiday

never looked after dogs in my life, worked six months at a animal in 2001 with the cats/kittens and rabbits and rodents but not dogs, only people with experience of dogs worked with the dogs.

With Amazon it's so easy to sign up and become a driver now too.

cant drive but I have heard terrible things about currier jobs that they barely pay enough to scrap by and if you get stuck in traffic using petrol there goes all your money because they pay a piddly amount and pay by the parcel delivered rather then time. I've applied for Amazon Fresh a couple of times they do pay above minimum wage.

Life is about to get really hard for everyone, make sure you can keep food on the table and the lights on x

oh I'm doing fine and theres always my dad, with all his money seems kind of a waste to get to his age with that much, he's never even had a passport not interested in doing anything and he has a car, never goes anywhere other then the shops, never did.

and no he didnt grow up poor so is frightened of being poor and hoarding money, his family came from chiswick lived in a 3 story 1880s house, owned a nice car, his father was a free lance sports photographer so I have no idea where his tightness came from.

Bostromani · 03/03/2022 11:43

Jesus, there's some totally missing the point posts on here .

So real stealth brags as well, basically accusing the OP of wallowing in poverty instead of ' getting on their bike' and doing the magical retraining ( which needs time , energy and travel money that some just don't have).

As for the saving £50 a month thing..I'm baffled as to why that was suggested..being poor means not having £50 a month to save. I know the post was well meaning but it shows a complete ignorance of the OP's situation.

OP, good luck for the future, I know it's not easy but remember to cherish what you have, as well as being fed up with what you haven't.