Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel fed up of being poor.

540 replies

laptopba · 01/03/2022 18:38

Just that really. Feeling rubbish about how my life has turned out in relation to finances. Its bloody shit.

OP posts:
BlueSummerBaby · 03/03/2022 16:53

@liveforsummer

It's obvious because the clue was in the title. She asked if she was I reasonable to be fed up. She did not at any time ask for advice. Generally (a tip for the future perhaps) people will do so if they wish it.
That's your perception of it. My perception of someone being pissed off with their situation is to see if I can help them. Although as the OP hasn't been back, my post was really aimed at anyone in this situation who might be reading and have found it helpful. I can't be arsed to argue with you any more. It's ok for me to be me and it's ok for you to not like that. There's really nothing more to say.
liveforsummer · 03/03/2022 16:30

It's obvious because the clue was in the title. She asked if she was I reasonable to be fed up. She did not at any time ask for advice. Generally (a tip for the future perhaps) people will do so if they wish it.

Harmonypuss · 03/03/2022 16:20

@LiveintheNow I am in my fifties and like that. Debt frightens me and I avoid it at all costs.

Same here but unfortunately my ex-H ran up almost £50k debts between when we separated and divorced, then because he was unemployed but I was working, I got saddled with his debts because at the time he accrued the debts we were still 'legally married'.

When I later became unable to work I approached the creditors to attempt to get the debts moved back to him but was told that as soon as is made one payment they became my debts.

I've been paying his debts for the past 25yrs and still owe over £10k. I've never run up a debt myself and am terrified of being in this position well into my dotage or even leaving my DC to pay them after I'm dead.

BlueSummerBaby · 03/03/2022 16:17

[quote liveforsummer]@BlueSummerBaby the thing is it's generally obvious, like to all of the rest of us in the staff rooM at the the time and as with this thread. Just some people lack the perception to lock up on that. [/quote]
Well if they lack the perception they're not going to suddenly develop it just because you wanted them to! So best to point out to your oblivious colleague that you only want a wee moan.

It's not obvious with this thread because the OP hasn't been back to respond to anyone, I don't think? It's obvious some posters just wanted to vent because they're vilifying anyone who offers an opinion or potential solution that isn't along the lines of "there there, never mind, kiss it better" like a child with a grazed knee.

But just because there's a bit of a bitch fight going on that doesn't mean nobody reading (and perhaps not posting, which includes the OP) doesn't want to hear about things that might help.

BlueSummerBaby · 03/03/2022 16:06

[quote alltheapples]@BlueSummerBaby what do you do when someone's problems cant be fixed?[/quote]
Like mine, you mean? Wink

If they're a mate I'll give them a hug if they're down and listen, because that's what friends are for. But my friends do know if they come to me they'll get solutions unless they tell me they're only venting or they're crying and obviously not mentally in a place to hear anything. And plenty are glad of my advice/opinions, deliberately choosing to come to me, whether they take the advice or not. Sometimes a fresh perspective is helpful.

If I don't know them well I'll say something sympathetic, offer a solution or two (because when you barely know someone you don't know if their problems are totally unfixable) and if they don't seem interested then I'll move the conversation on. I can't see the point of me listening to someone's tale of woe who I'm not close to, so don't "owe" them my time out of a sense of duty to the friendship and my strengths are in finding solutions. There's others who are better at tea and sympathy.

I have enough problems of my own without wasting my time listening to someone else moan. It's certainly not what I go to work for.

liveforsummer · 03/03/2022 15:53

@BlueSummerBaby the thing is it's generally obvious, like to all of the rest of us in the staff rooM at the the time and as with this thread. Just some people lack the perception to lock up on that.

alltheapples · 03/03/2022 15:51

@BlueSummerBaby what do you do when someone's problems cant be fixed?

BlueSummerBaby · 03/03/2022 15:50

@liveforsummer

I don't need to examine why I do it. I already know. It's a desire to help people. Nothing wrong with that. If people find a desire to help patronising that's on them, I'm not responsible for their warped IMO emotional response.

We have someone like at work and it drives us all batty they they are always coming up with solutions when all we want is a little moan about something. I don't think it's warped at all, it can be so annoying having some Constantly trying to fix things. One my colleagues ended up walking out of the staff room today as they were in pain and the constant (unhelpful) suggestions were infuriating

So just tell people you want to have a moan then. Nobody is psychic. If I know people want to just vent I'll leave them alone. Plenty of people happy to provide a listening ear who aren't fixers. People don't have to be perfect and not everyone needs to be the same. If you don't want solutions and you know someone is a fixer, choose someone else to vent to or if it's a group situation point out you're just venting.
alltheapples · 03/03/2022 15:47

@LiveintheNow I am in my fifties and like that. Debt frightens me and I avoid it at all costs.

liveforsummer · 03/03/2022 15:43

I don't need to examine why I do it. I already know. It's a desire to help people. Nothing wrong with that. If people find a desire to help patronising that's on them, I'm not responsible for their warped IMO emotional response.

We have someone like at work and it drives us all batty they they are always coming up with solutions when all we want is a little moan about something. I don't think it's warped at all, it can be so annoying having some Constantly trying to fix things. One my colleagues ended up walking out of the staff room today as they were in pain and the constant (unhelpful) suggestions were infuriating

LiveintheNow · 03/03/2022 15:43

There may be more home owners but only because time has gone (decades) by and they have paid off their homes.

"they will get a fab pension at the end from their full time for life job, oh and no uni debt, or probably car debt, or any type of debt that is now sadly common. "

Pensions have changed, final salary pensions are no longer an option, public sector pension terms have changed. I think it is people over 70 who may have benefited more but only some of them. Many women of that generation paid the married womens stamp and ended up with reduced state pension or were not allowed to work after marriage.

They won't have uni debt as only 5% ever got to uni...

They won't have much debt as it was something to be avoided at all costs by older people and yes there was less to spend on.

BlueSummerBaby · 03/03/2022 15:37

@Landedonfeet

Someone on bones of their arse may have a 15 year old daughter with an imminent birthday and that link may have really helped
Thank you.

It's not just teenager clothes either. People have posted about needing clothes for work interview. What's wrong with grey poloneck jumper, peach blazer, beige long skirt with a bow at the waist, black loafers? Interview outfit for £10 plus postage.

I needed a new winter coat last month, paid full price £5.00, when it arrived the label said $165.00 Very happy!

Can go the other way though, I've had things that fall apart from two washes. But there's photos, item reviews and details of fabric to help you decide.

kidsatuniemptynester · 03/03/2022 15:20

[quote Katya213]@nanbread

I was told I need to go through social services to use a food bank, I’ve never had any involvement with them and wouldn’t want to start. To think I was on £50,000 a year and holidaying in Barbados etc three times a year. It’s a long story but people, never take anything for granted.[/quote]
That's not true, at least at the FB I volunteer at. Yes, we like you to have a referral form from school, GP, SS or wherever, but just walk in and ask and nobody will turn you away, we have discretion and can give you a decent couple of carrier bags full of food, toiletries etc., also there is a school uniform bank there, and lots of advice and help. Remember, the food is donated, the people are volunteers, nobody is going to turn you away. We have had several recent walk ins from exhausted women who work 50+ hours per week and can't make ends meet, you are not alone

Landedonfeet · 03/03/2022 15:20

Someone on bones of their arse may have a 15 year old daughter with an imminent birthday and that link may have really helped

Landedonfeet · 03/03/2022 15:18

@alltheapples

Leave her alone
She wasn’t suggesting £50 a month
She made a suggestion involving 2.50
Yes 2.50 may be too much for some
But it won’t be for all

HappyWinter · 03/03/2022 15:16

I agree with the other posters who have said that the cost of housing is a big problem, house prices and rents are now so high, they have skyrocketed in the last two decades. They hoover up so much income, leaving less for everything else. Wages and benefits haven't kept up with the price increases, and everything essential like food and energy has gone up so much. It's not sustainable if you have already cut back to the bare minimum and I'm really worried about how people are going to cope.

I know this isn't the answer, there really needs to be a major change in our society to enable everyone to be able to pay for a comfortable life (by comfortable, I mean being able to house, heat and feed themselves, being able to have a few treats and not live under the constant stress of poverty). Anyone, on any wage in the UK in 2022 should be able to afford the essentials, it is a travesty that they can't and the explosion of food banks since 2010 is a testament to how much people are struggling. There is an earn £10 a day thread on here, it might help a tiny bit, things like online surveys can help with a few pounds and they don't take up too much time and there is no risk involved.

www.mumsnet.com/Talk/legal_money_matters/4493783-Earn-10-a-day-Marching-into-March

Landedonfeet · 03/03/2022 15:15

Act 345

Just checked the charity commission site for financial accounts

Hands down the BEST charity financial accounts in terms of how much they ACTUALLY give away that I have ever come across

It will be my new charity of choice

BlueSummerBaby · 03/03/2022 14:54

[quote alltheapples]@BlueSummerBaby I think you need to self examine why you do that.
It is often a very patronising response because often people do know what needs doing and are trying to do it, but it is very difficult to actually achieve.
I suspect it is about your discomfort if you simply acknowledged personal situations that are difficult.[/quote]
I don't need to examine why I do it. I already know. It's a desire to help people. Nothing wrong with that. If people find a desire to help patronising that's on them, I'm not responsible for their warped IMO emotional response.

CayrolBaaaskin · 03/03/2022 14:52

I think is what is so sad about these threads (or one of the things) is the insults to those trying genuinely to help. Some can be patronizing but not all.

BlueSummerBaby · 03/03/2022 14:50

[quote Harmonypuss]@BlueSummerBaby

If anyone needs clothes E5P has a £2.50 sale on at the moment.

And where are we meant to find a spare £2.50 per item from, when we're struggling to feed ourselves and can't afford to even turn the lights on?[/quote]
Some people reading will have a little spare cash, not known about the sale and be glad I posted.

If that doesn't apply to you just scroll by, instead of being oversensitive and taking every post you personally don't find helpful to be a personal insult aimed deliberate to upset you.

My intention is to help.

You getting angry/upset/a bit miffed etc because you didn't find my information helpful only hurts you. It has no impact on me, so what's the point of it? (That's a rhetorical question, I'm not asking you to explain yourself.)

BuddhaForMary · 03/03/2022 14:47

@VelvetChairGirl it's certainly not the bed of roses people make it out to be. I've been self employed for 7 years now, pay my taxes yadayada. I'm a single mum on legacy benefits, and after my marriage ended I decided to put my degree to good use and became a freelancer. For the first 4 years it was great, but the pandemic was awful and I still haven't recovered from loss of clients. I've got some tough decisions ahead if it doesn't pick up soon.

alltheapples · 03/03/2022 14:45

@BlueSummerBaby I think you need to self examine why you do that.
It is often a very patronising response because often people do know what needs doing and are trying to do it, but it is very difficult to actually achieve.
I suspect it is about your discomfort if you simply acknowledged personal situations that are difficult.

BlueSummerBaby · 03/03/2022 14:43

I find it an interesting look into the mindset of some that their immediate reaction to this topic is to immediately judge, patronise and give unsuitable and unsolicited advice to people instead of empathy and compassion.

That's how it looks to you. It's your perception. Its not necessarily how people feel. I'm a "fixer" always have been, I'm proactive if I or a friend have a problem. The compassion and empathy is along the lines of thinking OMG this situation is awful, how can this be fixed, what possible solutions are there and trying to give help and advice (not knowing the person on the internet at all you don't know if they've heard of the basic stuff, so you include that). Putting your thinking cap on and giving up some time to try to offer someone hope. Some ideas might seem unrealistic because the advisor doesn't understand the situation but most people are just trying to help, not judge. It's really not always obvious when people only want to vent.

Lampzade · 03/03/2022 14:27

Thanks to the poster who mentioned acts435
I have just donated

Lampzade · 03/03/2022 14:17

@Libraryghost

This might just be me but the wealthiest people I know didn’t go to university. I know some bricklayers and plumbers etc that are living a more affluent lifestyle than say a teacher or a nurse. I know plenty of graduates that are struggling especially those who have got the ten a penny degrees like business studies. Having a good education is a must for so many reasons but please don’t think it guarantees you a great salary, far from it.
Absolutely true The builder working on my house is not an educated man ( doesn’t have GCSEs, ) but is earning a small fortune and lines in a five bed detached in Kent
Swipe left for the next trending thread