Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel fed up of being poor.

540 replies

laptopba · 01/03/2022 18:38

Just that really. Feeling rubbish about how my life has turned out in relation to finances. Its bloody shit.

OP posts:
liveforsummer · 01/03/2022 21:23

[quote CayrolBaaaskin]@Ionlydomassiveones - we have an excellent free education in this country. Please don’t tell your kids the only way to get ahead is something they don’t have access to. It’s not true.[/quote]
I work in a school in one of the most deprived areas of the country. The attainment gap is staggering between rich and poor. The free education is not enough however hard we try. Poverty is cyclical

Maverickess · 01/03/2022 21:21

Thanks to @Riseholme and @ICouldBeAnyone for the info/links on recipro, what an amazing idea and so good they have online too.
Many Thanks 💐

liveforsummer · 01/03/2022 21:20

@Bringsexyback

When i was a single mum on benefits i smoked, £12.50 is doable to save for most people
I suspect things have changed since you were on benefits. Tbh I was better off on benefits too. Would I be now? Not sure but it's not an option and I certainly couldn't afford to smoke
CayrolBaaaskin · 01/03/2022 21:20

@Ionlydomassiveones - we have an excellent free education in this country. Please don’t tell your kids the only way to get ahead is something they don’t have access to. It’s not true.

San141 · 01/03/2022 21:19

MN at it's best!!!

£50 savings ?? Wow!
Then if your poor your kids aren't educated!!
I work as much as I can, but I'm poor!
I live from month to month, my eldest is a respiratory nurse that saw all the worst covid patients, My next is a qualified trade person, next is a straight a* predicted gcse student and the youngest is a year ahead of his class with reading and writing so how can poor people not help their children?

LetHimHaveIt · 01/03/2022 21:18

'Genuine question to everyone on this thread who feels poor. What are you doing with your kids to make sure they’re not in the same position? Are you teaching them to work hard, doing homework with them, making sure they’re top of the class and aspiring to a good career?'

Well, I'm sure as shit not peddling the myth that wealthy people are wealthy simply because they work harder than poor people: I am careful, though, to tell them that apparent high-fliers can fall to the ground like everyone else. I point out that the bloke at my school who did the least work, and left at 16, now makes a fabulous living as a carpenter - so they shouldn't consider University the be-all and end-all. That mummy, who has two degrees, isn't sure she should have bothered.

And mine do their own damn homework.

worriedatthemoment · 01/03/2022 21:18

@5329871e you realise not all are academic , many good jobs people are still struggling on due to high rents /.high house prices

OhWhyNot · 01/03/2022 21:15

I think many seem to lack the understanding that some people will never have the confidence to have a successful career. For others there is too much stacked against them (maybe the have physical or mental health issues or supporting family that’s do. Combine that with having little or no money makes life so much harder

It’s so soul destroying to be so broke all the time that you have to constantly make excuses to others why you can’t do things

Gonnagetgoing · 01/03/2022 21:14

@Ionlydomassiveones

Oh the old chestnut that we don’t work hard enough or didn’t do well enough in school. Clearly all our own fault we haven’t had the benefit of inherited money or a private education. Hmm
@lonlydomassiveones - see the thing about my friend in my post - she met someone recently who encouraged her to go to uni and she did and got a degree. They have a business together. She’s done better than me in that sense! You can do it but need support and grit.
CayrolBaaaskin · 01/03/2022 21:14

@EveningOverRooftops - agree re poverty being really time consuming.

JeremyBeadlesTinyHand · 01/03/2022 21:12

I completely understand OP. I was poor for years and the constant struggle wore me down.

I'm not sure if anyone has mentioned it but are you entitled to a help to save account? The government gives you a bonus for any money you can save. It is a significant amount as well.

I managed to build up a store cupboard of food through offers and bulk buying and found it comforting. At least I knew if the kids were off sick and I couldnt work that I had tins and dry food in to feed us.

Gonnagetgoing · 01/03/2022 21:12

I’m fairly lucky as was poor as a child but got better as I got older and always had a job when I left school.

It’s harder now as there’s only me on a single wage and in the past I’ve rented out a room to a lodger and may well have to do that now.

For people who are really on the breadline I honestly don’t know what they’ll do. I can imagine some will turn to loan sharks or illegal activities. Years ago my best friend who’d had 2 kids and her first at 18 told me she’d had to make a choice between feeding herself or the kids. Eventually she got into debt and I think did benefit fraud (never actually knew what) but her mum helped her out and she was rehoused miles away near her mum and eventually bought a house through right to buy. The benefit fraud she accused me and another best friend though and it ruined all our friendships…

Ionlydomassiveones · 01/03/2022 21:09

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn at the poster's request.

Dibbydoos · 01/03/2022 21:08

I was brought up on a council estate. I don't remember going without anything, but you could feel poverty in the air.

I broke out of it via education and a mantra that noone is better than me, we are all equal. And I've done well from that mantra. But i know we are all only a few weeks away from poverty even the very rich.

I know from my childhood, poverty meant no toilet paper, no money for electric or gas - candles and matches were close at hand. and dripping otr tomato ketchup butties. There were no food banks and people did low paid odd jobs cash in hand to get by. Theft was rife. People in and out of prison for petty crimes.

I don't know what poverty means today. We have centrally heated homes, but maybe finding money for utilities is just as hard and getting harder as utility companies continue to make billions in profits for their shareholders.

The whole system keeps people poor. What's needed is a full reform.

Can you create a co-op with others in a similar situ to you and provide shared childcare so each of those in the co op can work longer hours? Are you arty/creative? Can you sell any of your work? Have you looked at being an advocate/leader for weight watchers/ Slimming World etc? Can you offer classes - yoga / pilates etc?

I'm sure others have good ideas too.

As my son tells me, if we focus on the negative, that's all we see and experience. If we think about the positives, soon it's all we know. IE change has to come from you OP. I know that's easy to say and your motivation is probably low, so take a deep breath and have a good think about what you want, what you need, how you get to where you want and qgat you'll do when you get there. Then go build the plan abd just do it. :)

Big hugs and good luck.Smile

Katya213 · 01/03/2022 21:08

@Maverickess

Saving 50 quid might not be good advice, but what’s your solution? Just to say “yeah it’s shit isn’t it, lots of people have no money”

Why can't we just do that sometimes? Why can't we take a break from constantly trying to find a 'solution' and talk about how crap it is?
Because 95% of the time I'm trying to find a solution, I'm accepting extra shifts that knacker me out and see me working 14.5 hours for 4/5 days a week and 8 hours on the other 3/4, I'm always looking to shave a few quid off here and there with everything I need to spend on, I'm always looking for a solution and you know what? On top of a more than ft job and running a house and a dependent on my own, a conversation about how crap it is gives me the chance to offload and feel worth something because someone is listening or reading and replying, which gives me the strength to keep trying.
So shoot me.

I’m with you Maverickess!
CayrolBaaaskin · 01/03/2022 21:08

@Mummy3788 I remember going to a posh place with rich mummy friends and spending all day there with a glass of water. But it didn’t bother me as I was there for the company.

Bromse · 01/03/2022 21:05

I was the same in the past. It was horrible; if I think about it, I can still conjour up the hopeless feelings I had at that time and wouldn't want to go back. I do hope things improve for you, they did for me (us) eventually but for a significant amount of time - it was bad. Like some others here, I didn't have £50 (or the equivalent years ago), per month to save - or even spend!

Katya213 · 01/03/2022 21:05

@nanbread

I was told I need to go through social services to use a food bank, I’ve never had any involvement with them and wouldn’t want to start. To think I was on £50,000 a year and holidaying in Barbados etc three times a year. It’s a long story but people, never take anything for granted.

EveningOverRooftops · 01/03/2022 21:04

@musicforsmorks

Cash points that charge for withdrawals are most commonly found in deprived areas

That's honestly disgusting. What a world we live in, eh?
I have heard of the 'poor tax' and it just makes too much sense, unfortunately. It's strange though how people often attempt to paper over this and suggest poverty is always elf created. It reminds me of the Wellness obsession and it's associations with the concept that illness is a symbol of inner impurity.

Yep. I live in one of the most deprived areas of my town.

The nearest cash machine is in the corner shop and charges £1.75 to withdraw.

I’d have to walk a mile to get to a free one which doesn’t sound far but that trip there and back could take 30-40 minutes. That could mean leaving over an hour early in the morning to get cash out to pay for the bus.

Being poor costs a lot of money but it also costs a ridiculous amount of time where we could be EARNING money. Instead we’re walking or waiting for buses or walking to the cheap supermarket because you’ve only got a corner shop or a Coop really close.

There’s some above minimum wage jobs here but they require 2 buses to get too that could easily take 90 minutes or more if the roads are smooth reducing the hours you can work. This is especially hard if you need wrap around care so many locals here work locally in the lowest paid jobs because they can’t afford the time to travel or the extra earned in wages and cost of bus fare would mean the same take home pay as the lower paid job BUT the benefit top ups would be lower.

lollipoprainbow · 01/03/2022 21:04

@cookiemon666 same we have rented for 9 years had a brilliant landlord who never put the rent up now he is selling up. I haven't been served a section 21 yet but I know it's coming, feel constantly like a weight on my shoulders with it all. Rental properties round here are like gold dust I'm so so worried but I try to take a day at a time.

CayrolBaaaskin · 01/03/2022 21:03

I just wanted to add here to a previous posters post - she said she grew up poor and had a good childhood. I was the same -poor single mum but never lacked aspiration. My grandparents generation are immigrants and our poverty was their luxury. We are lucky in lots of ways in this country to have food security and relative economic stability.

Things could be better of course. I’ve been poor as an adult abs it’s relentless. But we have a wealth of opportunities compared to many.

Mummy3788 · 01/03/2022 21:01

@liveforsummer

And ha at the idea of saving 50 pm. I have 40 automatically moved from my account in to my savings each month and in the last 4 years since setting it up the tens not been more than a few days pass before I've had to transfer it back to eat or pay an essential bill
The exact same Iv set it up and then I have to transfer it back again!! So depressing! Currently have £30 to last the next 2 weeks on food!! Oh and fuel! No idea how this happened this month!!! I find it difficult when mummy friends want to meet for a coffee somewhere or stay out for lunch! I hate telling them people I have no money for that!!
MyGhastIsFlabbered · 01/03/2022 21:01

@FantasticFebruary glad to make you smile

Maverickess · 01/03/2022 21:01

Saving 50 quid might not be good advice, but what’s your solution? Just to say “yeah it’s shit isn’t it, lots of people have no money”

Why can't we just do that sometimes? Why can't we take a break from constantly trying to find a 'solution' and talk about how crap it is?
Because 95% of the time I'm trying to find a solution, I'm accepting extra shifts that knacker me out and see me working 14.5 hours for 4/5 days a week and 8 hours on the other 3/4, I'm always looking to shave a few quid off here and there with everything I need to spend on, I'm always looking for a solution and you know what? On top of a more than ft job and running a house and a dependent on my own, a conversation about how crap it is gives me the chance to offload and feel worth something because someone is listening or reading and replying, which gives me the strength to keep trying.
So shoot me.

LetHimHaveIt · 01/03/2022 21:01

'Right, but for some, that is something which will help.

Retraining if you can, for a job that will earn better money, is not a bad suggestion. People do actually do that.'

But OP wasn't asking for suggestions on how to lift herself out of poverty. She was asking if she was being unreasonable to be fed up with being poor: the answer to which is - no, you're not. And it isn't merely an intellectual exercise - everyone knows that there are routes out. That's stating the bleedin' obvious. But there are obstacles, too. Saying anyone can be a doctor/software developer/hedge fund manager isn't the same as saying everyone can. There will always be redundancies; lay-offs; recessions. Familial collapses. Heath crises. You can 'work your way up' as far as you like; 'educate yourself' as much as you can - but the bottom can still drop out of your world. It did for my dad. He was already educated, and had been very senior. But in the mid 80s, as now, there wasn't exactly a surfeit of jobs for those in late-middle-age. He did all sorts of jobs to make ends meet, from fruit-picker to postman to support worker. But we were never comfortable.