Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel fed up of being poor.

540 replies

laptopba · 01/03/2022 18:38

Just that really. Feeling rubbish about how my life has turned out in relation to finances. Its bloody shit.

OP posts:
containsnuts · 01/03/2022 22:11

BoredZelda

"I agree. It’s 1.60 per day. Of course some people might struggle to put that away, but many might be able to do it, we just don’t seem to be a nation of savers."

Saving £1.60 a day doesn't really change anything though does it? It would take you 50 years just to have enough for a deposit for a house. You'd have to live until you were 200 to be able to buy one. Plus somewhere along the line you'll be penalised for having savings and your benefits reduced making you worse off with the savings than you were without.

Poverty is well and truly a trap.

Maverickess · 01/03/2022 22:04

Just that really. Feeling rubbish about how my life has turned out in relation to finances. Its bloody shit.

@BoredZelda that's the OPs first post, and the title is 'Am I being unreasonable to be fed up of being poor'.
And no, from my POV, it's not unreasonable to be fed up with being poor.

I get your point that moaning about it and doing nothing will not make things better, but in all honesty I resent the implication that is all that's ever happening when someone talks about being poor, it's insulting.
I
I'm sure there's some people out there who it applies to, but from my own experience, those around me and from reading threads like this here and other places, it strikes me that it's like I said in my pp, a lot spend a majority of their lives trying to find a solution, and keep going and going, despite the set backs, and to be able to communicate with people about how that makes you feel and have people know what you're talking about and have empathy, gives a little bit of self worth back and is just as important as the advice, no matter how well intentioned that advice is.

I don't know why people would seek to dismiss that really, well I do, it's the age old thing about the poor being poor because they want to be, are too lazy not to be and don't work hard enough.

wherethecrawdadsare · 01/03/2022 22:03

Ok, so this thread has made me think.
I'm very lucky. I'm not poor. I give to charity. But actually, what I want to know is what would practically help local people. Can we have a sort of twinning system? I have a DD. Some children in her class can't afford to pay for the school trips - can somehow I pay anonymously? Or school lunches? I don't want to make people ask for help, so how practically can we do so?
What I really hate is the lack of equality. Like PPs have said. I can buy in bulk and don't have to pay overdraft fees etc. - the poverty premium is real.
In the absence of governmental change/ paying additional taxes etc., what can we do practically that will help local people?

CayrolBaaaskin · 01/03/2022 22:03

@Libraryghost - hard work is enough for many.

notthemum · 01/03/2022 21:59

@Bringsexyback

£12.50 per week sorry, pressed return too quickly

£12.50 per week ? Christ, until very recently I haven't even had that to live on over the past year .

Lambkin689 · 01/03/2022 21:55

@laptopba

BeagleBum2001 it's rubbish isn't it. With the cost of everything going up, I just feel like I'm sinking further.

I felt so sad when my DC asked me the other day which jobs pay well as they didn't want to be poor like mummy.

I think it's a positive thing that your kids asked that - my DH also came from a very poor family, and it motivated him to study something highly technical and well-paid, which allowed him to move to a more prosperous country and have a better life. He's now able to also support his parents. It meant working extra hard to get scholarships, but it gave him a fantastic work ethic.
Libraryghost · 01/03/2022 21:55

@BoredZelda Alexandra is correct. Look at the average age expectancy in Kensington compared to stoke-on-Trent. Look at the difference in exam results in wealthier areas and in deprived areas. You are starting with the cards stacked against you when you are trapped in poverty and hard work isn't enough to get you out of it.

HonestwithHope1 · 01/03/2022 21:54

LetHimHaveIt

So right! Educated HAHAHA. I have a degree because I was told. Get a degree. Get good money. Retrain. Retrained. Volunteer. Volun....f...terred. Did everything right.

I'm soon to be on 23100 (prev 22905) which i suppose is good for up north (don't believe average 31k bs) ... Work 37 hours. I work for CS .... I currently have a 34 people caseload, all vulnerable people, many chaotic. It's 9:50pm and I'm sat stressing over everything i need to do tomorrow, and calculating the inevitable added extra this week when X person doesn't show up to appointment or Z person has a crisis involving an hour screaming/crying phonecall with me on the other end trying to both reassure and get them off the phone because there's not enough time and I'll inevitably be told off 🤷‍♀️

People are leaving in droves. While technically you don't need qualifications, you need experience working with vulnerable people ect ... We are understaffed, soooo sooo sooo undertrained for the complex work we need to do, and entirely underpaid. Take home being around 1500 (on 22905) .....

Who can seriously live on 1500. And by live I mean, good food, savings, rent (what's a mortgage?) and some leisure, you know, that mythical life 90% of everywhere in the country, age 60+ have and had enjoyed! And all for LESS fecking work.

As a burnt out mid 20s woman. I am done. I can't win working. I can't win on benefits. What is the point of it all.

tillyandmilly · 01/03/2022 21:52

I was privately educated but I in a poorly paid job as I have learning difficulties - going to a private school doesn’t make you academically gifted!

Iputthetrampintrampoline · 01/03/2022 21:51

I think its the sheer effort of just existing and not living thats the worst thing, When you are bone tired of batttling its like wading through treacle Its hard to find motivation. You are doing all the right things every day like everyone else with nothing to show,It costs to be poor and it costs more than money,It makes you ill living on your wits and nerves all the time.Plotting and planning on how to save pennies constantly , I hear you OP xxx

Alexandra2001 · 01/03/2022 21:51

@BoredZelda

The advice given is always so bloody patronising.

If people start from that premise, nothing will ever change.

Will only change when we have better and cheaper housing, better paid work, better benefits and don't say we can't afford it when there are 189 billionaires in the UK with a combined wealth of almost 600 billion!

Stop blaming the poor and have some empathy, its fuckin shit worrying how to pay bills, rent or food, let alone cloths, kids & school stuff.
I watched my mum struggle to bring us all up on her own, it almost killed her and it was a dire up bringing.

fwiw 10k people die in the UK due to cold/poverty, ONS winter excess deaths.

Libraryghost · 01/03/2022 21:51

I said I was poor growing up but it seems different today. I don't remember anyone being cold or going hungry in the 70s and 80s, maybe that's just me but there does seem to be more people who can't even afford the basic necessities in life. I agree with what other posters have said about poverty being expensive. You are trapped into higher interest rates, gas and electric meters, not being able to afford bulk buys etc. i extend my sympathy to anyone struggling and I won't dish out advice because having been in that situation I know you will have already thought of it. The only thing I will say is try not to make a bad situation worse by taking credit out. Not always easy I know but the less debt you have the easier it is to climb out of it.

Maverickess · 01/03/2022 21:49

Genuine question to everyone on this thread who feels poor. What are you doing with your kids to make sure they’re not in the same position? Are you teaching them to work hard, doing homework with them, making sure they’re top of the class and aspiring to a good career?

Well, mines pretty much worked out by watching me through her life that 'hard work' doesn't automatically = financial success, because she has been shunted off to family (and yes I'm damned grateful to have them) until she was old enough to look after herself, so I could work ft+ for most of her life, the older she's got, the more hours she's seen me do, she's also seeing the effects of that hard work on my body as I develop arthritis and have treatment for other joint issues and back problems, and we're not much better off and won't be at all when these rises take full effect.

But yes, I did the homework with her, I attended the parents evenings, I encouraged the extra classes after school, I paid the son of a friend to help her fill in the gaps that school blatantly missed, because I couldn't afford a private tutor and her school were at that time, useless if the kids were doing ok.
I have always said that she should get a degree, because even if she changes her mind after 5 years, she's proved she can work at that professional level and that gives her more choices.

But she never was and never will be top of the class, no matter how hard she works and I accepted that and supported her to accept it, it doesn't mean she doesn't try, it means she plays to her strengths and doesn't stress herself silly trying to attain something she's unlikely to, even with all the work in the world.

If university is what she wants, I will move into my mothers garden shed to facilitate it if I have to, I have supported her to the best of my ability, but my own lack of contacts and knowledge around university and professional careers is a stumbling block, one I've tried hard to get past, but it's not something I've grown up knowing about or having experience of, it's all new to me too.

And, here's the rub, she needs work experience to get in - we don't know anyone in the field and have been turned down by all we've tried, talking to people online about it, most people get their work experience because of who they know, well, we don't know anyone, because we don't have the right connections. College are trying to get her a placement at the moment, it's her last real hope.

And she has no choice but to live away from home because the local university doesn't do the degree she wants to do, so there's no option to save money there living at home, she's probably also going to need to work p/t through university, if she can around the placements she needs to do in order to survive. I will help her as much as I can, but I'm limited.

I sometimes think that people assume us paupers can't be bothered and we make up these problems to cover laziness, because they've never been in the situation, it can't possibly be an issue.

YouOKhun · 01/03/2022 21:47

[quote Photolass]Would any of these ideas work for you?

informi.co.uk/starting-business/41-ways-make-money-home[/quote]
Number 10 on that list is a fucking terrible idea!! They are suggesting that someone already struggling signs up to an MLM (they mention Avon). These types of companies make poverty their hunting grounds. 99.6% of those signing up in the hope of making some money will actually lose money. Seen it so many times. Anyone looking to make money please steer clear, the fewer options people have the more they are tartgeted by these disgusting scams.

2catsandhappy · 01/03/2022 21:36

Sympathies op. I am this week thinking one step forward and two back. I had finished paying a credit agreement(funeral plan) and cut back media to broadband only. Little bit of money in purse at the end of the week! Then in one week, utilities and council tax notifications of direct debit increase and the water bill.

I was reminded of times when I ate jacket potatoes and home grown tomatoes every meal for weeks at a time. I am seriously considering eating one meal a day.
I am planning my spring/summer planting now. Fingers crossed for a good crop.
Now my children are grown I don't worry so much. Those days were truly grim.

Tdcp · 01/03/2022 21:35

Me too. Things aren't as bad as when I was a kid (no food / clothes etc) so I'm thankful for that but with everything rising so much I'm really worried as I can barely get by now. I'm extremely frugal and I don't drink or smoke etc but I still struggle. I worry for those that have it worse than I do.

BoredZelda · 01/03/2022 21:34

The advice given is always so bloody patronising.

If people start from that premise, nothing will ever change.

BoredZelda · 01/03/2022 21:33

Why can't we just do that sometimes? Why can't we take a break from constantly trying to find a 'solution' and talk about how crap it is?

I'm sure it's fine to do that from time to time.

Not sure that's what OP is looking for, but they might come back and clarify. I'd have thought most people posting on here are looking for advice.

PiddleOfPuppies · 01/03/2022 21:32

Totally agree with you, OP. There is a relentless cold fear that follows you around when you're poor - 10 years ago, I always could tell you to within 5p how much money I had in my account (or how far into my overdraft I was), how much each bill was that week and how much every ingredient in a meal cost. Any extra expense would throw me into a panic - a school mufti day (3 children, so 3 costumes, 3 tombola prizes, 3 £1 coins...). It never really leaves you, even when circumstances improve.

BoredZelda · 01/03/2022 21:30

People die in this country in the tens if thousands every year due to cold damp housing.

I'd be interested in a source for this.

liveforsummer · 01/03/2022 21:30

@Mummy3788 yeh I'm the same. Ended up with £13 for my weeks shop on Monday and I only got paid my monthly salary on Thursday. Tbf id budgeted expecting to get the measly £100 pm for 2dc from ex at the weekend but with no notice he's stopped paying indefinitely. I'd have paid £100 less to the over due electric bill if he'd let me know. It's little things like that that make it all so fragile and there's always something.

EvilPea · 01/03/2022 21:27

[quote lollipoprainbow]@cookiemon666 same we have rented for 9 years had a brilliant landlord who never put the rent up now he is selling up. I haven't been served a section 21 yet but I know it's coming, feel constantly like a weight on my shoulders with it all. Rental properties round here are like gold dust I'm so so worried but I try to take a day at a time. [/quote]
I’m so sorry.
It’s so shit renting with kids and trying to shield them from the uncertainty.

Rent rises round me are making me so twitching for our renewal.

Oblahdeeoblahdoe · 01/03/2022 21:27

So sorry you're in this situation. Have you checked that you're receiving all the benefits you're entitled to?
www.gov.uk/benefits-calculators

Cottagepieandpeas · 01/03/2022 21:26

@Yants

I think what annoys me about money and finance is I never seem to get the little (or often not so little) lucky breaks and windfalls that many other people seem to get from time to time... literally every penny I've got and every penny I've ever had has been entirely through earnings.
I really relate to this. I don’t begrudge others having these extras, but I have never really had a penny that I didn’t earn (apart from being on benefits for a time). I earn a reasonable salary now and life is ok, but only month to month and there is little to fall back on. I really hope things will not be like this for my daughter. She is 30 and will inherit my mum’s house when that time comes so that may give her something. (Please don’t tell me I’m being callous. I have little contact with my mum and we don’t have a good relationship, I’m not hoping she dies, but she will because we all do).
DoorWasAJar · 01/03/2022 21:24

@Katyrosebug

I used to live in a different country and it was a completely different life. We had to go and buy gas canisters and that basically made sure yoi could use your cooker and also heat your water. Sometimes the gas would run out and I couldn't replace it, I'd alrasdy been having cold showers for a few days before, but when that happens you have to have spare money for food that doesn't involve being cooked in a oven or on a hob, I was too poor to afford a microwave as well, sometimes I had €20 for shopping a week and I'd have to buy a big 1k bag of cornflakes and eat that until I got paid again to buy a bottle of gas
It happens in this country too, when you’re on prepay meter and run out of money. People die in this country in the tens if thousands every year due to cold damp housing.
Swipe left for the next trending thread