Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Are we able to discuss the Black students trapped in Ukraine on here?

421 replies

EddyF · 01/03/2022 17:55

I think I have read most threads on here about Ukraine/Russia but have not seen any discussions on this issue here.

I saw on TikTok (yup, TikTok has so much information/videos on what’s going on) that Jamaica has now managed to get its people out. It’s the majority of African students that are facing problems getting out. I’m wondering what African leaders are doing about it? A lot of the African-American blogs/comments are furious about this issue (rightly so).

OP posts:
spittycup · 02/03/2022 09:11

I’m from Eastern Europe and lived in Africa: in Botswana I was stared at, my hair touched, by random strangers because they had never seen a white person before. I wonder if that counts as racist to the PP? Or not racist because I’m not black? I’m jewish btw.

It's not racist. They do it because yes, they've never seen a white person im real life. White people get treated BETTER when they go to Africa, I'm slightly offended you'd compare that to racism black people get.

I'm willing to bet you got a lot of marriage proposals and admiration. That is not the same as people viewing you as inferior and tearing you badly for your tone.

There is being treated different and being treated badly.

UniCred1 · 02/03/2022 09:04

[quote CheshireChat]@UniCred1 that sounds utterly awful.
I'm Romanian though so if your sister needs help with translating anything or anything like that, I'll see what I can do Smile.[/quote]
Thank you very much. How thoughtful of you ❤
She's awaiting a ticket to go back to our home country tomorrow or after tomorrow. My parents were not sleeping for days and they won't be relieved before seeing her.

UniCred1 · 02/03/2022 08:59

This was a reply to @forinborin

kingat · 02/03/2022 08:59

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Quotes deleted post

UniCred1 · 02/03/2022 08:58

The student who took the knife out was thrown on the floor and sworn at for DAYS. I'm not saying it's the right thing but I would urge you to think of your son or brother in his place. To think the priority is only given to women and young children is a naive fallacy. Students watched everyone allowed to board but not them. If you're not white they won't even listen to you. If you try to speak up they'll violently push you away. My sister watched a Ukrainian girl crying and kissing her Tunisian boyfriend goodbye before boarding as they didn't let him go with her. The student who took the knife out has had enough of feeling like the scum of the earth for days. Imagine being somewhere where people are ignoring you, belittling you and you don't matter because of your skin colour or the language they heard you speaking over the phone. It's not just the transport staff but the locals cheered when these students were denied boarding. Stop acting as if everything is peaceful and la vie est en rose. It's chaos at the moment. You don't want violence then don't use it in the first place. Lead by example they said.

Bluebellsunderthetrees · 02/03/2022 08:57

There is undoubtedly racism in the authorities, police and army in Ukraine. The Azov battalion is often discussed in the UK and its link to far right here

Nov 2020 www.theguardian.com/technology/2020/nov/22/facebook-condemned-for-hosting-neo-nazi-network-with-uk-links

MrsBillyNoJagNoMates · 02/03/2022 08:46

@Brainwave89

As a POC, I have to say that a number of friends who have been to Poland and other parts of Eastern Europe have experienced very open racism. This includes not being served in restaurants, refused taxis and open hostility in public places. For some people the reaction has even been violent. This does not stop what is happening in Ukraine from being very wrong or for it to be right for us all to provide support but given the experience of others few of us would venture to these countries.
Yeah That's what my BIL and my DH's friends are saying as well - open racism in EE They are all West African Yet somehow my DH never experienced it when traveling in EE with me and is baffled by what they are saying... Well he was once called a 'brown Uncle' and pointed at by a small child on a very local train Having said that we /he was harassed in 'West European' countries repeatedly However it is really clear that anyone who is not white is having more issues getting out of Ukraine right now
CheshireChat · 02/03/2022 08:43

@UniCred1 that sounds utterly awful.
I'm Romanian though so if your sister needs help with translating anything or anything like that, I'll see what I can do Smile.

Motherofgorgons · 02/03/2022 08:39

There is plenty of information out there about why POC students went to Ukraine in the first place and then did not leave. In a nutshell:
lack of affordable education in their own countries where medical education is extremely competitive
unis refused to go online and they would lose a year
ticket prices escalated beyond affordability

"if you don't like it, why not leave?" is exactly what POC in the UK are often told when they raise racism. Crass.

oakleaffy · 02/03/2022 08:29

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Quotes deleted post

Ladylornax12 · 02/03/2022 08:25

It’s awful. I absolutely believe we should help the poor Ukrainians but to me they are looked upon more favorable abs people seem more willing to help and invite them into their countries than for example Syrians because they are white and have similar lifestyles and beliefs to us? Maybe because we can relate more to them.

kingat · 02/03/2022 08:24

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

oakleaffy · 02/03/2022 08:16

@seekinglondonlife

Thank you for starting this thread. We watch a non English news channel at home and this has been widely reported, with lots of accounts from Black students about being assaulted whilst trying to board trains. I'm utterly horrified about how this has highlighted the blatant racism and xenophobia - churches local to me are having special prayer sessions for Ukraine. There wasn't a single one for Syria, Afghanistan, Iraq or Somalia. Oh but.... Ukrainians are "Christian with blue eyes" Hmm
Welcoming White refugees- Look at the razor wire and fences put up against Syrians.
oakleaffy · 02/03/2022 08:14

Racism, out and out racism.

Sadly Eastern Europe is not an Inclusive place

.

seekinglondonlife · 02/03/2022 08:11

Thank you for starting this thread. We watch a non English news channel at home and this has been widely reported, with lots of accounts from Black students about being assaulted whilst trying to board trains. I'm utterly horrified about how this has highlighted the blatant racism and xenophobia - churches local to me are having special prayer sessions for Ukraine. There wasn't a single one for Syria, Afghanistan, Iraq or Somalia. Oh but.... Ukrainians are "Christian with blue eyes" Hmm

BelleHathor · 02/03/2022 07:56

What blatant propaganda? The fact is Black, Asian, Middle Eastern and other races have been stopped/ harrassed/ abused/ extorted and are suffering mistreatment due to the colour of their skin. The propaganda is attempting to minimise their experiences and conduct blatant "If only they'd...." crap.

forinborin · 02/03/2022 07:30

@FarDownTheRiver

The poster says the students were told not to leave by their universities. If you have studied for a long time and paid so much dear of it all being for nothing would be quite scary I imagine.

Forrinborn I also do not understand your motivation on the thread. Is it to state that anyone who has experienced something you have not must clearly be wrong? Despite the links posted here and the anecdotal experiences it seems you think only your view is right.

My motivation is to (a) stop the spread of shock horror about Ukrainians being awfully racist and determined to exterminate foreign students there, especially when blatant propaganda is linked in; (b) to be honest, just talk about what I see and hear every fucking day now for 18 hours as I also don't find it easy to cope, and ashamed for myself that I am in safety in the UK while so many loved ones struggle. And I don't think I made a single absolute statement on this thread.

I'll go now.

FarDownTheRiver · 02/03/2022 07:23

The poster says the students were told not to leave by their universities. If you have studied for a long time and paid so much dear of it all being for nothing would be quite scary I imagine.

Forrinborn I also do not understand your motivation on the thread. Is it to state that anyone who has experienced something you have not must clearly be wrong? Despite the links posted here and the anecdotal experiences it seems you think only your view is right.

forinborin · 02/03/2022 07:16

@ElliePhillips

Nope. Asian students report being told by their uni to NOT leave or they wouldn't be allowed back on their course. People were not told to leave earlier and are now 'taking resources from Ukrainians'.
Should I maybe link announcements from their own embassies? Tell me the country, I will find for you.
ElliePhillips · 02/03/2022 07:08

Nope. Asian students report being told by their uni to NOT leave or they wouldn't be allowed back on their course. People were not told to leave earlier and are now 'taking resources from Ukrainians'.

mnnewbie111 · 02/03/2022 07:05

@TooTiredToSleepRightNow

Ofcourse these white Eastern Europeans can be racist. Being under attack doesn’t change what they believe. Or do we want to deny that so we carry on believing how amazing and super hero like they are, don’t want these annoying black people coming along and shitting on their parade? I don’t understand why else so many white people are in denial about this or minimising it so much. Those countries are extremely racist. I mean, in the U.K. the obviously racist stares I get are from Eastern European people that haven’t been here that long, and not white British people. They seem to think I’ve arrived here on the banana boat, despite my parents having arrived many years ago paying their taxes etc but nope, they are very much like “how dare YOU come over here”. It’s quite pathetic really. What’s more pathetic is people coming onto these boards and denying it’s happening and blaming the Russians, that’s sinking pretty low really. I would give everyone respect if they accepted it to be a massive problem and condemning it but noooo those black people are making it up, those Russians are spreading propaganda. These threads are such an eye opener.
Totally agree. I live close to a lot of EEs and when they come in my restaurant they are really quite vile to me, only me. I'm not sure they know I'm the owner, nor does it matter but honestly I've never known hostility like it. (Not all of the EEs I must add). But I honestly didn't realise until my husband pointed out that they're racist and wonder what the fuc@ I'm doing there
forinborin · 02/03/2022 06:48

[quote ElliePhillips]@forinborin "Tickets are not accepted on the trains anymore. White men are not allowed to board.
I don't know how many times to repeat this."

Oh really? Then how do you explain Maksim Chmerkovskiy taking a train out to safety yesterday? [[https://www.huffpost.com/entry/dwts-maksim-chmerkovskiy-ukraine-fleeing]]nn_621de637e4b06e1cc5947f95/amp

Why is it so hard to admit that some police and officials are being racist? It doesn't negate Ukrainian suffering to admit that there is unfairness at play too.
[/quote]
Maksim story could be corruption (or maybe some strings were pulled for him, which is effectively the same). There is a known price for getting out of the city as a man, well out of reach for ordinary citizens. Or, maybe, he was prioritised due to being some sort of celebrity due to PR reasons. He says in his own statement that it broke him to see children being torn apart from their fathers. Well, I hope he can live with it.

I fully admit that some police and officials are very likely being racist, if you read my posts, I even linked the official apology from Ukrainian authorities for their behaviour. What I am trying to argue with is that it is the only, or even the main factor at play here, or there is a systematic state policy against them. I am (truly, not trying to be disingenuous) very sorry that it hasn't been a five-star experience for many foreign students, and that people were horrible to them - I fully accept this likely had happened, the war doesn't bring the best out of anyone. There is some resentment on the ground against foreigners in the country, as most of them were repeatedly told to leave, and there were means for them to leave, but they stayed behind, and are taking resources away from people who have fewer options. Russian families are treated awfully at the moment, through no fault of their own. Foreign citizens of Ukrainian descent are treated horribly - there are British Ukrainian mums who went there with kids for a half term break ffs, ignoring everything. I even learned about the new trend of "danger tourists" - young men who fly into conflict zones for a dose of adrenalin (and then often find themselves unable to deal with the real situation).

Not a single evacuation story I have heard over the last couple of days has been a walk in the park.

ElliePhillips · 02/03/2022 06:23

@forinborin "Tickets are not accepted on the trains anymore. White men are not allowed to board.
I don't know how many times to repeat this."

Oh really? Then how do you explain Maksim Chmerkovskiy taking a train out to safety yesterday? https://www.huffpost.com/entry/dwts-maksim-chmerkovskiy-ukraine-fleeingnn_621de637e4b06e1cc5947f95/amp

Why is it so hard to admit that some police and officials are being racist? It doesn't negate Ukrainian suffering to admit that there is unfairness at play too.

BigHuff · 02/03/2022 06:15

[quote DoorWasAJar]@deragod What free movement was there in the Eastern Bloc? I’d love to know. Until 1989 there was none.[/quote]
Free movement is a bit of a stretch, but there was movement. You could apply to the state to go on holiday, or to study abroad as a student. Plenty of citizens did this and then never came back - significant numbers left (for example) Poland prior to 1989 to settle in other countries (including the UK).

forinborin · 02/03/2022 06:06

@UniCred1

We’re not black but middle eastern. I’m beyond sickened by what my sister went through in the past 5 days in Kyiv. It’s her fourth year doing dentistry. Before the invasion they received a warning from the dean that any students who will leave because they’re scared of a war will have their name taken off the register forever. They even refused to grant days off for students who lost their loved ones back home and wanted to say a final goodbye. When the invasion started the racism against non white students became staggeringly clear. My sister was denied boarding trains and buses alongside other north African students. People watched it and no one did anything. They were called all sorts of names.It is making me terribly sick to think of it. After a fight which involved an exchanged threatening of knives between some students and the transport staff, they were finally allowed to leave and have reached romania at 7pm. Racism didn’t die and I feel so so so sorry for the poor students who endured it during these scary times.
If students take out knives out on the evacuation staff, I don't think it should come as a surprise that they are denied boarding then. My own female relative has been denied boarding four times in the last three days. In one case, taken off the train after boarding as a woman with a newborn child came. She's still there, wasn't able to leave.