Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Are we able to discuss the Black students trapped in Ukraine on here?

421 replies

EddyF · 01/03/2022 17:55

I think I have read most threads on here about Ukraine/Russia but have not seen any discussions on this issue here.

I saw on TikTok (yup, TikTok has so much information/videos on what’s going on) that Jamaica has now managed to get its people out. It’s the majority of African students that are facing problems getting out. I’m wondering what African leaders are doing about it? A lot of the African-American blogs/comments are furious about this issue (rightly so).

OP posts:
BigHuff · 01/03/2022 20:07

@forinborin

*India asked its citizens to leave Ukraine on Feb 15th (soft warning) and immediately on Feb 20th. Way before the war started on the 24th.

Now they are in the same situation as the rest of Ukrainians. Yes, they are in bunkers and there is no food, essential medicines or water in Kharkiv for them as the city is under siege. It is horrendous. It is the same for everyone else though.*

I read earlier today (in an article about the Indian student who was killed) that Indian students were being directed to evacuate via the Russian border but I cannot find the article now. Pretty sure it was in the Guardian. Ah! Found it.

Are we able to discuss the Black students trapped in Ukraine on here?
MangshorJhol · 01/03/2022 20:06

Given that none of the COVID evacuation flights to India were free I can assume these weren’t as well. Anyway as I said the Indian situation is complicated by Modi’s stance on this issue. (Modi being India’s right wing Hindu PM who has backed Putin). So the MEA can’t be overly critical of Russia.

emuloc · 01/03/2022 20:05

I agree with Shola198978. I was not too impressed that the last thread was deleted. MN should not have done that. Lots of posters were posting in good faith. It should have been moderated better if need be, not pulled altogether. It happens too much when race is a factor. It is not good enough.

TooTiredToSleepRightNow · 01/03/2022 20:03

Forinborin sorry who is ‘immediately’ jumping to conclusions, have you ignored all the black and POC stating what is happening or shall we just ignore them. Numerous well documented reports, like I mentioned condemn this and move on, why are you so adamant that it is all propaganda, that somehow only white people can pick reliable sources and us non white people believe anything we see, You are proving everyone’s point here.

shola198978 · 01/03/2022 20:03

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

forinborin · 01/03/2022 20:03

@MangshorJhol

I think the problem is that it’s easy to say ‘leave now.’ But as someone who was an international student in the UK on a limited stipend this was easier said than done. I couldn’t for instance, have bought a ticket home at short notice. I actually didn’t go home for two years.
For India specifically, there have been flights arranged by the government (I think in partnership with Air India). Have no idea whether they were free or commercial.
Why2why · 01/03/2022 20:02

@shola198978, I too often think that Mumsnet turns a blind eye to racism but are quick to respond to the cries of racists who claim to be the victims of people not putting up with their rubbish.

Mumsnet is slow to censor racist posts or ban racists.

MangshorJhol · 01/03/2022 20:01

Yes the deletion post said: we are looking into one or two things behind the scenes and then that was that. Thread was gone.

There was one poster who kept insisting we were all heartless bastards who were saying that Ukraine deserved this. And no amount of ‘can you find me one person who said this’ would deter her from saying it again and again. It was all very tiring.

shola198978 · 01/03/2022 19:57

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

TravellingFrom · 01/03/2022 19:57

Just want to point out that being black doesn’t mean your country of origin is in Africa…

There has been issues with black people who were from non Africa country (some of them in Europe!). I read that as the country in question (Poland) having massive issues with racism themselves.
Let’s try and not get more preconceived ideas on the top of it.

MangshorJhol · 01/03/2022 19:57

I think the problem is that it’s easy to say ‘leave now.’ But as someone who was an international student in the UK on a limited stipend this was easier said than done. I couldn’t for instance, have bought a ticket home at short notice. I actually didn’t go home for two years.

emuloc · 01/03/2022 19:56

[quote MarshmallowSwede]@Trainbear

So you expect black students to fight in the Ukrainian war while Ukrainians flee? Or you mean the men? Because If they are only letting out women and children surely ant black women and their children should have the same priority as Ukrainians.

Also. Going to a nation to study does not mean you need to stay and fight their war.

Many Americans working and studying there fled and no one expected them to stay and fight. Funny.[/quote]
This.

forinborin · 01/03/2022 19:55

[quote MangshorJhol]For what it’s worth, Indian students are also trapped in Ukraine but the situation is a bit more complex. One student was killed yesterday. The Indian govt has sided with Russia and abstained at the UNSC. One MP in Parliament said that those studying medicine in Ukraine had failed to clear Indian medical school exams and were clearly second grade students (implying that they were less worthy of evacuation). But the MEA is trying to organise an evacuation of some sorts I gather.

www.aljazeera.com/amp/news/2022/3/1/indian-student-killed-in-ukraine-amid-criticism-over-evacuation[/quote]
India asked its citizens to leave Ukraine on Feb 15th (soft warning) and immediately on Feb 20th. Way before the war started on the 24th.

Now they are in the same situation as the rest of Ukrainians. Yes, they are in bunkers and there is no food, essential medicines or water in Kharkiv for them as the city is under siege. It is horrendous. It is the same for everyone else though.

MangshorJhol · 01/03/2022 19:54

Yes I can donate to say the Red Cross and say that I find all this talk of ‘but this is happening in a civilised country’ deeply racist. I think there was one journalist who said, this is a civilised country not like Iraq. As if Iraq wasn’t literally home to the one of the world’s oldest civilisations…

sadpapercourtesan · 01/03/2022 19:54

I do wonder whether the "oh, but it's probably not racism...maybe it's because they're men/non-citizens/it's Tuesday" brigade actually believe the excuses they are making. Or whether they are actually just racists, and it serves their agenda better to gaslight and obfuscate and make people doubt the evidence of their own eyes and ears.

MarshmallowSwede · 01/03/2022 19:53

@Trainbear

So you expect black students to fight in the Ukrainian war while Ukrainians flee? Or you mean the men? Because If they are only letting out women and children surely ant black women and their children should have the same priority as Ukrainians.

Also. Going to a nation to study does not mean you need to stay and fight their war.

Many Americans working and studying there fled and no one expected them to stay and fight. Funny.

lemongreentea · 01/03/2022 19:52

@Hshuznw

There’s a lot of racism involved in the fall out of Russia’s invasion. From the treatment of black people in Ukraine to the media’s portrayal of the invasion against other invasions and wars (I mean, there are journalists who are even saying / writing that things like this don’t happen to countries like Ukraine).

People don’t like it when racism is called out though. Calling out racism is a far greater offence than challenging it or accepting something is racist.

And as PP said, it is very very possible to feel the utmost sympathy for Ukrainians, whilst also being disappointed at racism. The two are not mutually exclusive.

This!
VladmirsPoutine · 01/03/2022 19:52

There was a very long thread on this but it was deleted. IIRC even in the face of on the ground footage a lot of people were like "HmM nOt QùItÉ SuRę tHis Iz TrUè."

MangshorJhol · 01/03/2022 19:50

The international refugee regime began with the 1951 convention which defined refugees in European terms. This is why many South Asian countries to this day haven’t signed it. (Definition was later changed).

This by Ulrike Krause.
link.springer.com/article/10.1057/s41268-020-00205-9
Pia Oberoi on why India and Pakistan didn’t sign:
refuge.journals.yorku.ca/index.php/refuge/article/view/21228/19899

I also generally recommend the work of Peter Gattrell on refugees in general.

Impier · 01/03/2022 19:48

I thought the borders were closed by Ukraine to men of fighting age, with the expectation they defend their country. Isn't any male making his way to the border going to be suspected of being a draft dodger.

Saucery · 01/03/2022 19:48

Paraic O’Brien addressing this on Ch4 News. Issues with the sound, but hope they return to his report later.

Ontheblink · 01/03/2022 19:47

Ofcourse there is a ridiculous amount of racism in Eastern Europe. Has everyone forgotten that Poland wanted to build a wall to keep out Syrian refugees fleeing war but have welcomed the Ukrainians with open arms? Unashamedly racist

MangshorJhol · 01/03/2022 19:47

For what it’s worth, Indian students are also trapped in Ukraine but the situation is a bit more complex. One student was killed yesterday. The Indian govt has sided with Russia and abstained at the UNSC. One MP in Parliament said that those studying medicine in Ukraine had failed to clear Indian medical school exams and were clearly second grade students (implying that they were less worthy of evacuation). But the MEA is trying to organise an evacuation of some sorts I gather.

www.aljazeera.com/amp/news/2022/3/1/indian-student-killed-in-ukraine-amid-criticism-over-evacuation

Why2why · 01/03/2022 19:46

There’s a lot of racism on display all over Mumsnet. It’s a real shame. It renders Mumsnet of little relevance to a huge part of the UK population. It’s not a safe space for women of colour.

Hshuznw · 01/03/2022 19:46

@MangshorJhol

I posted quite patiently on the previous thread but was told repeatedly that raising any questions about racism without saying that Putin was the aggressor made us ‘woke British women.’

I then tried to talk about the international refugee regime itself which is quite racist (in its origins and operations)- I am an academic. I have been writing about it for over a decade and I teach this stuff (race and migration) at a big US university. A poster told me my understanding of it was ‘rudimentary’ and then when I posted some links from my UG reading list told me she didn’t have time to read random stuff on the internet.

So in general I gave up.

I would love those links.

I’ve just had an almighty falling out with my husband who told me my views were outrageous and offence for highlighting the racism the black students were experiencing and also the way the media has reported on the invasion. I’ve never been so disappointed in him (he’s while, I’m not). But one of the things I have tried to explain before is the way international refugees are treated, so I would love to support my arguments with academic evidence.

Swipe left for the next trending thread