Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Shop saying I'll be self employed

61 replies

Amiselfemployeed · 01/03/2022 17:19

Posting here for traffic, hoping someone can help.

I've been offered a job in a shoe shop in my town. Independent shop, not a chain. It's super convenient for me, the only thing is the owner said I would be self employed.
I'm a bit confused because this doesn't sound right to me, my hours and pay are set - not chosen by me. So it seems like I'm an employee just without the benefits such as holiday & pension?

Can anyone help weigh in on this? I'm a bit confused

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Graphista · 04/03/2022 19:44

Hmrc would be VERY interested indeed this is the job a relative of mine had and usually when a company is committing "minor" infractions like this quite brazenly and openly there's more going on in the background!

I would click "tax evasion" op

Or "fraud or scam"

HMRC likes these type of reports as illegal employee contracts tend to lead to tax evasion schemes crossing other tax classes as the employer has to disguise the payments

Exactly they tangle themselves in knots trying to conceal it

@ANameChangeAgain it's not just that, there are clearly defined rules on what constitutes an employee as opposed to self employed/contractor as linked by a few pps upthread

They can't just "decide" to pay op as a self employed person through choice she has to actually be self employed which retail workers generally aren't

If they expect her to work x hours for y pay in the way they wish and at the premises they wish etc she isn't self employed

@Ohmnomnom there are specific rules governing whether a worker is an employee or self employed

Gig economy at the moment just fall on the right side of the law on this because the way they use their workers is more flexible and (supposedly) because the workers can refuse shifts etc - they superficially have agency on how, when and where they work

Morally very questionable though!

Certainly not for long term staff, but I've employed people this way.

Doesn't matter how long you've been employing staff/plan to employ them for - you've said it yourself "I've EMPLOYED people this way" you employed them you didn't negotiate a contract with them as a self employed entity - you've been acting illegally

DollyDingleberry · 04/03/2022 09:28

This is completely illegal. The fact their excuse was 'too much work' suggests they're potentially naive rather than willfully law breaking? If they're a small local company it's not beyond the realms of possibility that they dont know about IR35, as shocking as that is.

Local to me recently there was a similar thing - small independent underwear shop was 'employing' 4 older ladies (semi-retired). The ladies treated it as cash in hand pin money. One of the ladies left so they needed to hire someone and put the ad in the paper stating that the role was for a self employed bra fitter.

Someone saw the ad, went to the interview with the sole purpose of gathering evidence and then turned the business in to HMRC. The business is still there so I don't think anything really bad happened but they did get audited. I'm not saying the business did nothing wrong - they clearly did but it was through them not realising you can't use self employment as an excuse for casual cash in hand work anymore.

I personally would approach the business and ask them if they're aware what they're advertising doesnt meet the requirements to be considered a self employed role, and then from their reaction judge what your next step is. They might really appreciate the heads up and change you all to zero hours contracts instead.. or they might ignore you in which case, report away!

SamphiretheStickerist · 04/03/2022 09:22

@namechange if you are still employing people like that be prepared for some legal action. Look up IR35 and make your business practices legal.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 04/03/2022 09:20

Outrageous behaviour - and definitely illegal.

Take something worth over a fiver from their shelf, make to put it in your pocket or bag and toss them a pound coin for it. When they protest, tell them that you've tried paying the actual price of goods in shops before, in order to acquire them legally, but you've found it's 'less hassle' to just do whatever suits you instead....

BloodyN0rah · 04/03/2022 09:17

Please report them OP, this is unfair on any other business who are doing things by the book. The other people who work there are probably just cash in hand. HMRC have free payroll software for small companies and it’s very straightforward - they’re just trying to get out of holiday pay and other employment rights.
Cheeky fuckers!

billy1966 · 04/03/2022 08:54

@Viviennemary

They are breaking the law. Don't touch it with a bargepole. Chancers
This.

Completely illegal.

nirvanaviolet · 04/03/2022 08:53

OP, I AM self employed and because I have to cover my own sick pay, holiday pay, etc, I get to choose my rate of pay and hours. That rate of pay that I set is at least four times national minimum wage to cover those costs and lack of benefits.
Your contract will never come outside of IR35 - look up Ir35. It's a tool used to determine whether you are ACTUALLY self employed.
Do not touch this company with a bargepole!

Clymene · 04/03/2022 08:18

@Dontforgetyourbrolly

Don't do it , it's shit They are actually doing nothing wrong but everything is on you , tax returns, NI , pension etc I was desperate when I got made redundant in 2020 and took a similar job ( travel industry) I had no choice but I wish I hadn't done it . No end of hassle and bother with the hmrc , the stress of it brought me to tears . I'm now in a " proper " job and I feel 100% better
They are doing something wrong - they're evading paying PAYE
Dontforgetyourbrolly · 04/03/2022 08:14

Don't do it , it's shit
They are actually doing nothing wrong but everything is on you , tax returns, NI , pension etc

I was desperate when I got made redundant in 2020 and took a similar job ( travel industry)
I had no choice but I wish I hadn't done it . No end of hassle and bother with the hmrc , the stress of it brought me to tears .
I'm now in a " proper " job and I feel 100% better

WhoreOfBabyliss · 04/03/2022 08:10

This is exactly why IR35 was brought in and it has hit the profession I was in.

Report to HMRC.

donquixotedelamancha · 04/03/2022 08:01

If you read my post correctly you will find it is correct and legal. Certainly not for long term staff, but I've employed people this way.

It's clearly not legal in OP's case because she is working fixed hours for one employer, nothing about the role meets the criteria for self employment.

There have been a number of companies fined for using umbrella companies in the way you describe. Sadly their employees also had to pay back taxes.

If you've employed people in this way then you've acted illegally.

P.S. lovely to see a thread with OP getting such good advice.

DobbyTheHouseElk · 04/03/2022 07:07

Totally illegal. Report them. Yes, tax evasion is the right thing to select.

There are all sorts of rules about hidden employment now, but this is old school tax evasion.

They aren’t even trying to hide what they are doing. Really shocking.

CarrieHughes · 04/03/2022 07:05

@BarbaraofSeville hmm 50/50.
The whole point of ‘gig’ contracts was a way to make extra money. The service isn’t guaranteed either (it’s common in certain areas to have NO riders, or even Uber drivers at certain times of the day).
Uber whoever puts lots of pressure on drivers to accept jobs etc hence it could be argued they’re behaving like an employer. Don’t think Deliveroo does.

Thé real issue is that there are too many low wage jobs - which is why people have been doing ‘gig’ work FT. Which was never the plan. If less people work for them they’ll just close down which isn’t a bad thing!

ANameChangeAgain · 04/03/2022 06:58

@Aprilx we'll agree to disagree, I'm not getting into the pantome argument about this. If done properly I'm certainly not breaking the law.

Aprilx · 04/03/2022 06:35

[quote ANameChangeAgain]@Crimesean
That is incorrect advice, please disregard this OP.
If you read my post correctly you will find it is correct and legal. Certainly not for long term staff, but I've employed people this way.[/quote]
Your post was incorrect in almost every way.

Because you have done things this way does not make it legal, it makes it that you have been breaking the law.

Aprilx · 04/03/2022 06:32

@Amiselfemployeed

Had a follow up today and you guessed right, it is minimum wage. When I questioned why this was a self employed position, they said they ran a business before and employed people but doing the tax, ni pension etc was too much hassle.
Minimum wage applies to employees, not self employed as self employed are paid a fee for services not a wage. So they are happy to follow that bit of law because it suits them. They are breaking the law, I would keep on looking.
RedRobin100 · 04/03/2022 06:27

Fuck that!

Have they not heard of IR35..?!

BarbaraofSeville · 04/03/2022 06:24

@Ohmnomnom

Why is it illegal for a retail shop to employ people on a self-employed basis, but not for companies like deliveroo, maid2clean, etc?
While the likes of Deliveroo etc like to argue that their workers are self employed, it's a bit of a grey area and not particularly fair on the workers, who take all the risk and often don't earn NMW. There have been court cases and appeals etc.

Workers are generally exploited in these types of businesses and there should be a lot more outrage about how badly they're treated, but customers like being able to tap an app and have takeaways magically appear at their door to care.

On the OP, that's outrageous and they're likely to be breaching tax and NMW law, because for the latter, your basic expectation is that you are paid NMW and get at least the minimum holiday allowance, pension contributions and if relevant, sick pay and statutory redundancy.

For you to be self employed, which you wouldn't be for shop work anyway, you'd need to be paid a substantially higher hourly rate to compensate for the lack of employment rights.

Perhaps call their bluff. Tell them that you agree to be self employed and your rate is £20 ph. Plus you won't be available during weeks A, B, C and D, any BHs or between Christmas and New Year because, as a SE person, you have elected to not work as those times, as is your right.

WiddlinDiddlin · 04/03/2022 05:00

I work for a company that owns an app..

I am a self employed contractor -

We sort out our own rota, we sorted out how long our shifts would be, we negotiated how much we'd work for, and we have rejiggled all this several times over the last two years as the role has grown and altered.
We have gone through several tests to see if we are indeed self employed - we are.

We work from home, we supply our own equipment, we can swap shifts with one another without having to check with anyone higher up, we can take time off as necessary.

We are also paid considerably more than min. wage, which we invoice for each month.

That is what self employed but working for a larger company really looks like. This is absolutely not that.

I'd try and get some paperwork out of them if you can, but either way.. report the hell out of this.

SmugOldBag · 04/03/2022 01:11

Fairly sure that there's a purpose test from a legal and HMRC perspective.

If you are perceived as a employee (given set hours, paid hourly by a company) then you are an employee irrespective of what they say.

It's dodgy as hell

ANameChangeAgain · 03/03/2022 21:19

@Crimesean
That is incorrect advice, please disregard this OP.
If you read my post correctly you will find it is correct and legal. Certainly not for long term staff, but I've employed people this way.

nancy75 · 03/03/2022 21:14

Same with jobs like cab driver - they can say no to the £4 fare because they’re waiting for an airport run, if they’ve had enough for the day they can go home.

nancy75 · 03/03/2022 21:11

@Ohmnomnom

Why is it illegal for a retail shop to employ people on a self-employed basis, but not for companies like deliveroo, maid2clean, etc?
Because people working for Deliveroo get a choice in when they work - they can choose just to do Friday & Saturday nights because that’s when they make the most money. If they don’t want to work one Friday night they can choose to stay at home. If you work in a shop you are told your hours, you can’t decide and you also can’t send someone ride to do those hours in your place.
SpikeySmooth · 03/03/2022 20:14

CFs. I'd walk away. Dodgy as hell.

belleoftheball1 · 03/03/2022 20:09

0300 123 2326 - is the number you’re looking for.

I work for compliance in HMRC (not employer compliance or status team) but give that number a go.

Swipe left for the next trending thread