Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

They've cut our tree!

291 replies

Auntieobem · 01/03/2022 15:03

We have a twisty willow at the bottom of the garden. I love it. Had it topped a couple of years ago - cost £££ but looking good. It overhang/ overhung next doors garden. Neighbours moved in a while ago - we've only spoken briefly but all pleasant enough.

I've just noticed that half the tree has been cut off. Tree looks ridiculously lop sided. Why onearth didn't they speak to us? I know they have a right to cut off anything which overhangs, but who not just warn us?? I feel really sad. Poor bloody tree!! Don't know when it was done, I've been working from home and never saw anything? They must have waited until we were all out? Aibu for being a bit annoyed?

OP posts:
BuyDirt · 01/03/2022 17:51

Then I'd put a note through their door. Dear Neighbours, this is the invoice for the work that needed doing after you butchered our tree, it needs to be paid by xx/xx/xx.. If you had spoken to us & said you didn't like our beautiful willow, we would have arranged a professional to come in & sort it out. Replacing a mature Willow Tree will be expensive if it doesn't recover.

🤡

Yes, do this OP. They may need a good laugh. Crazy fuckers on here.

If they didn’t want anything overhanging then their side is as it needs to be. A professional may be able to make it look a bit better but the real issue is that it’s too close to the boundary.

Auntieobem · 01/03/2022 17:50

@OakRowan

As it's a willow you could have it cut down much, much lower, to the base even and grow it as a multi stemmed coppiced shrub or low pollard instead of a tree, thinner stems all from ground level or a foot or two above from a short trunk, it'll still grow higher than the fence, but not as tall or overhanging as much, the shape would be better more even confined within the fence better. This will always be a problem as its so close to the boundary, neighbours will keep cutting it back like a hedge, flat, but you could manage the pruning of it to make it more neighbourly and aesthetically pleasing at the same time. You'd get nicer, younger growth that way too, the 'prettier' corkscrew growth looks nicer and fresher managed that way. Cut right back every 3 to 5 years, or longer cycles, depending on the space, or thin the thickest stems each year. You could even cut it back right down annually, they grow quickly enough.
That's really interesting thank you. Can we do that now that it's so mature?
OP posts:
FantasticFebruary · 01/03/2022 17:49

@Sceptre86

The polite thing to do would have been to cut it back whilst the old neighbours were moving out, before the new lot moved in. I would definitely keep on top of pruning it in the future.
If I had bought the house with a lovely willow tree sharing a bit of airspace in my garden, I'd have been upset to see it cut right back when I moved in!

Some of us love trees. Don't assume everyone is a tree hater

AnotherForumUser · 01/03/2022 17:46

@Wellshellsbells

How would it have been done right though? Cut some of the precious tree on your side??It actually looks like they could have cut more.i bet you’re not offering to go in and pick up the leaves that blow into their garden from it.if you love it that much you should have planted it in the middle of your garden so no neighbour would have to deal with it.
If you care to read the OP's posts around 5pm you'd see that she didn't fucking well plant the tree. So snottily advised by her to plant it in the middle of the garden just makes you look ignorant.
MaudieandMe · 01/03/2022 17:46

I can never understand people cutting down lovely trees unless it was 100ft tall and in danger of toppling over.

Your neighbours will probably install plastic grass next. Hmm

buckeejit · 01/03/2022 17:46

@FantasticFebruary why so hysterical? The neighbours have done nothing wrong, if OP was so keen on manners, they could have planted a thirsty tree in the middle of their garden & removed the one in the wrong place. As for neighbours paying an invoice, that's nuts! OP can get a professional to even up their side if it pleases them. In a small garden I'd want to use my space. The roots of that tree will clearly already be having a negative impact on the neighbours & what they can grow.

OakRowan · 01/03/2022 17:44

As it's a willow you could have it cut down much, much lower, to the base even and grow it as a multi stemmed coppiced shrub or low pollard instead of a tree, thinner stems all from ground level or a foot or two above from a short trunk, it'll still grow higher than the fence, but not as tall or overhanging as much, the shape would be better more even confined within the fence better. This will always be a problem as its so close to the boundary, neighbours will keep cutting it back like a hedge, flat, but you could manage the pruning of it to make it more neighbourly and aesthetically pleasing at the same time. You'd get nicer, younger growth that way too, the 'prettier' corkscrew growth looks nicer and fresher managed that way. Cut right back every 3 to 5 years, or longer cycles, depending on the space, or thin the thickest stems each year. You could even cut it back right down annually, they grow quickly enough.

UggyPow · 01/03/2022 17:42

As someone who has tree problem with the neighbour I would say it is y our responsibility to stay on top of it.
I have asked my neighbour to do something about the 3 leylandii in the corner of his garden but his response is it will look stupid if I cut it straight up but I can only do this so that is how it is going to end up, they block all my afternoon sunshine

fromdownwest · 01/03/2022 17:42

@Ijustreallywantacat

I too like growth in my garden, and not a moss ridden dark depressing corner of my garden, as my neighbour wants to retain a tree.

Moss, shade, puddles, insects and damp, or even dead wood are all unsightly, but important habitats for a variety of life.

As are an abudnance of pollinators that would not thrive in the shade
Equalbutdifferent · 01/03/2022 17:42

I feel your pain OP. Neighbours asked us to cut a beautiful mature tree on the boundary and we paid a tree surgeon to do a proper job. Without saying anything, they decided that wasn't sufficient and lopped a load more off without a discussion, leaving it damaged and disfigured. I've grown a wildly vigorous rambling rose through it which disguises the worst of it.

OnTopOfThePiano · 01/03/2022 17:41

Out of interest how could they have trimmed the tree to keep you happy whilst it not overhanging there garden?

Ijustreallywantacat · 01/03/2022 17:40

Of course trees are even more important for habitats and you know, oxygen.

Ijustreallywantacat · 01/03/2022 17:39

I too like growth in my garden, and not a moss ridden dark depressing corner of my garden, as my neighbour wants to retain a tree.

Moss, shade, puddles, insects and damp, or even dead wood are all unsightly, but important habitats for a variety of life.

godmum56 · 01/03/2022 17:38

@FantasticFebruary

It is the right time of year.

godmum56 · 01/03/2022 17:37

@Booboobibles

I’d be very upset too. It’s at the end of their garden so it isn’t impacting them anyway and it would surely just add beauty to their garden.

I think most of the comments are from people who like tidy gardens, probably with fake grass. It makes me despair…surely we should be planting as many trees as possible and providing space for wildlife?

and again, at least in my case, wrong. my garden is never tidy, my grass is not fake and I leave fallen leaves where they fall.....but I expect my neighbours to have the same freedom of choice as I do.
FantasticFebruary · 01/03/2022 17:35

@Laiste

I agree with majority it has been planted way to close to a boundary fence to maintain an equal spread.

Shame.

Talking to you first wouldn't have done anything much except caused a row imo. There isn't really any middle ground between your tree branches hanging over the fence and your tree branches not hanging over the fence.

@Auntieobem

There isn't really any middle ground between your tree branches hanging over the fence and your tree branches not hanging over the fence

No, but there's a HUGE difference between getting it done professionally at the right time if the year & hacking at it at the wrong time if the year!!!

FantasticFebruary · 01/03/2022 17:32

@MsFogi

Mainly annoying for your neighbours because they had to spend their money cutting your tree.
Well if the nasty, rude idiots had spoken to the OP, maybe she'd have got decent, professional in (again) & paid for it!!

@Auntieobem. That's such a shame, I'd get the specialists back to try to save it & balance it up.

Then I'd put a note through their door. Dear Neighbours, this is the invoice for the work that needed doing after you butchered our tree, it needs to be paid by xx/xx/xx.. If you had spoken to us & said you didn't like our beautiful willow, we would have arranged a professional to come in & sort it out. Replacing a mature Willow Tree will be expensive if it doesn't recover.

Use Your Words. (I wouldn't put this but, but I'd want to!!!)

Regards

Her Next Door.

I would be happy for a willow to spill over into my garden, but then I'm not a daft test & I wouldn't go butchering a tree, even if I wanted it trimmed!!

kittensinthekitchen · 01/03/2022 17:30

It doesn't matter that the neighbours have been there "less than a year", it was encroaching on their property, so they were within their right to cut it back.

We had only been in our home a matter of months before we arranged to have some trees from next door cut back, as they were preventing us putting what we needed to where it needed to go. Now some of their other trees are encroaching on part of our garden, but they aren't causing any issues, so we've said they are fine as they are.

Blossomtoes · 01/03/2022 17:30

if you love it that much you should have planted it in the middle of your garden so no neighbour would have to deal with it

She didn’t plant it.

notanothertakeaway · 01/03/2022 17:30

Perhaps you could get a tree surgeon to tidy up your side of the tree and remove some of the branches so it looks more even. And ask their advice going forward

But your neighbour is entitled to remove branches overhanging their garden, and don't have to justify why they wish to do that

Cookiecrumble22 · 01/03/2022 17:23

This reminds me. I cut a tree back in (my) garden. And the neighbours who backs on to me came banging on my door telling me to stop because. It meant we could see into his daughters room. Yet they had no curtains up.

Anyway op what gonna happened if the people from the back cut it. Will be no tree left

Wellshellsbells · 01/03/2022 17:23

How would it have been done right though? Cut some of the precious tree on your side??It actually looks like they could have cut more.i bet you’re not offering to go in and pick up the leaves that blow into their garden from it.if you love it that much you should have planted it in the middle of your garden so no neighbour would have to deal with it.

MarchXX · 01/03/2022 17:21

@Auntieobem

Tree was there when we moved in has been there for about 20 years. Neighbours there for less than a year. It was already cut so it didn't overhang by much was alittle lopsided. Streetlight is on path behind houses, tree qas cut so it didn't interfere with the light.

I just wish they'd spoken with us first

Yes, it is such a shame, @Auntieobem.

Had they told you their intentions you could have offered to get it done professionally so that it was more uniform and balanced and still wouldn't have been over the boundrary. Your neighbours would have been unable to do that as they didn't have access to the whole tree, so they just lopped off random branches within their boundary.

It wasn't a neighbourly thing to do, but perhaps they thought you would say "no" or something. Fortunately, it will grow back, may be an idea to get a professional tree feller to have a look and advise how to improve the look of it.

AgathaX · 01/03/2022 17:21

That looked like a lot of overhang in a presumably not very large garden. Also, willows are thirsty trees and it probably has quite an impact on what they can grown near to it. It's a shame that the tree has been chopped, but it was in the wrong place to start with.

Jacopo · 01/03/2022 17:21

So you had a eucalyptus too. Totally unsuitable for any garden smaller than Buckingham Palace.