Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want Angela Merkel to take charge of the Ukraine situation?

56 replies

WaltzingToWalsingham · 01/03/2022 11:06

Does anybody else wish that Angela Merkel could be persuaded to come out of retirement and sort out this problem with Putin? Despite his silly prank with the dog, I feel that Angela Merkel's blend of firmness and diplomacy is just the right approach for Putin, and he might listen to her. She is the only person I can think of who could put Putin across her knee (metaphorically speaking) and sort him out. I always had confidence in her and I miss her so much in these times of crisis.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
thegcatsmother · 02/03/2022 16:51

God no. As PP have said, the seeds of this were sown on her watch; her and UvdL, who are entirely responsible for the parlous state of the German Armed Forces.

potniatheron · 01/03/2022 14:38

Given that Merkel, during the course of her tenure:

  1. Makde Germany unforgiveably reliant on Russian fossil fuels, and poured money into Putin's coffers, thus helping finance his invasion of Ukraine; and
  2. Flagnrantly neglected German defence spending, leaving the country with its trousers figurately down at a moment of nuclear threat
  • I don't believe her presence would help ameleriate the situation any.
VikingOnTheFridge · 01/03/2022 14:21

I really doubt it OP. There seems to be a fair bit of talk about the impact various politicians are having or could have on the situation. But it all misses the point that this fundamentally is about Putin himself.

People are trying to look for reasons, apply logic, that type of thing. It's understandable but it's wrong.

Martianworld · 01/03/2022 12:57

@WaltzingToWalsingham

I do agree that Scholz et al are doing their best in a very difficult situation: this is no criticism of them. But I also think that Angela and Putin have history; they have worked together for years and I think there's a certain amount of mutual understanding and, perhaps, a grudging respect. As such, I think if anyone can talk Putin down from this, it's Angela.

I also think she's got the right blend of hawk/dove to get the best out of Putin - but I can see most PP's feel that she's been too soft with him previously, so perhaps I'm wrong about that. But I still think she could sweet talk him out of Ukraine in the short term.

Under Merkel's chancellorship, Putin invaded Georgia and annexed The Crimea. And she held back on serious sanctions because she was more interested in protecting trade. And it's her very dove-like behaviour that has encouraged him in his ambitions. I don't see how you take any respect away from their relationship other than you want to see some. She didn't sweet talk him out of his aggression with Georgia and his ongoing aggression towards Ukraine.

Putin didn't invade the Ukraine until Merkel was gone.
No, he just annexed the Crimea. Yes, he was like a pussycat under Merkels rule.

We need a meme of Putin being spanked over Merkel's knee now.
You mean the one where she's screaming, "harder, harder"?

tttigress · 01/03/2022 12:54

Isn't Merkel partially responsible for this?

She should have told the German people if they didn't want nuclear power, they needed to accept a lower standard of living, instead she tried to fudge it by getting the energy from Russia, thus giving Putin more power.

Plumedenom · 01/03/2022 12:54

Merkel's general approach was to watch and wait in any tricky situation until she could see where the thing was going, then reach a compromise. It was often wise. I'd argue now is not the time to watch, wait or compromise. we tried that, it's the policy which let Putin take Crimea. Every Ukrainian I've ever spoken to hates and fears Putin. I know that because during the annexation of Crimea many Ukrainians left and came to nearby nations, knowing it was the beginning of big trouble. When Putin made a land grab for Crimea, why wasn't he over Merkel's knee then, when he defied the Helsinki act among other treaties? The fact that Germany are now finally acting is a good thing. We need to look closer to home though, like waiving visas for Ukrainian refugees for one and giving back the 1.93m pounds from russian oligarchs to the Tory party.

MMBaranova · 01/03/2022 12:53

Merkel: mixed bag. Her time has passed. Hardly stepped up when Greece faced collapse. The current German Government has woken the country from a complacent slumber.

Theluggage15 · 01/03/2022 12:47

That’s right. Putin had so much respect for/ was frightened of Merkel he waited until she had gone. Hahahaha.

Fluffymule · 01/03/2022 12:46

But I still think she could sweet talk him out of Ukraine in the short term

No.

Somerford · 01/03/2022 12:45

@teleskopregel

Bollocks *@Somerford*. It took the better part of a year to transition to Scholz, and as soon as it was finalised, Putin was off to the Ukraine. Not a coincidence. An opportune push for power.
You've just decided that the two things are related and declared yourself correct. Forgive me if I'm not at all persuaded.
EvilPea · 01/03/2022 12:44

I had a boss who was ex army.
His advice in all conflicts, from office to war.
You have to give them something to feel like they’ve won something.

Putin isn’t just walking away. He’s not giving up he needs ‘A’ win.

teleskopregel · 01/03/2022 12:43

Bollocks @Somerford. It took the better part of a year to transition to Scholz, and as soon as it was finalised, Putin was off to the Ukraine. Not a coincidence. An opportune push for power.

LampLighter414 · 01/03/2022 12:39

The only way to deal with a war criminal is another war criminal

LampLighter414 · 01/03/2022 12:39

Bring back Blair I say!

Theluggage15 · 01/03/2022 12:38

I find the ignorance of some people just amazing. Merkel happily put Germany up Russia’s arse. Her idiotic decisions led to Germany not letting U.K. fly help to Ukraine through their airspace because they’re so dependent on Russia. She is slow and ponderous and would be absolutely useless in this situation. Putin never respected her!

And anyone who thinks Truss was responsible for the nuclear issue is either thick or a Russian bot. Even Sturgeon who hates Truss said it was laughable.

Somerford · 01/03/2022 12:37

@teleskopregel

Putin didn't invade the Ukraine until Merkel was gone. Whatever their relationship, it was enough to stop him until Scholz took power.
There's absolutely nothing to suggest any correlation whatsoever. You could say the exact same about Donald Trump, afterall Putin didn't invade Ukraine until Trump was gone and Biden took over.

He didn't invade until the new series of Ozark was released either. Or until Bex had appeared on Dancing on Ice. Makes you think doesn't it.

fudging · 01/03/2022 12:36

not

fudging · 01/03/2022 12:35

Oh for goodness sake Putin didn't put the nuclear weapons on standby because of Liz Truss

Sadly, it was because her brilliant diplomacy and understanding of war law:

www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/putin-ukraine-russia-truss-nuclear-b2024839.html

jytdtysrht · 01/03/2022 12:31

What kind of respect do you think Putin has for a woman leader? Absolutely none at all.

Also Germany were slower to get on board with the EU sanctions than others so I don't think that would be the right choice.

Plus the Russian gas situation.

In any case, Putin is demented and won't listen to anyone. An assassin is needed, not Merkel.

Georgeskitchen · 01/03/2022 12:30

Maggie Thatcher would have had the problem solved already

millymolls · 01/03/2022 12:29

Ha ha ha ha ha

teleskopregel · 01/03/2022 12:29

Sorry, what? Are you just arguing for the sake of arguing @annamagnani? Please review the facts about German renewable energy before posting. Also, your comment about Fukushima missed the mark. Forgotten about Chernobyl? Recently in the news again...

AnnaMagnani · 01/03/2022 12:13

She wanted to stop nuclear power after Fukishima

A policy driven by the Greens in Germany, that actually led to an increase reliance on, er, Russian fossil fuels and no accelerated drive to renewables.

Also, how many tsunamis have there been in Germany exactly?

CallyfromBlakes7 · 01/03/2022 12:07

@fudging

Angela Merckel or Liz Truss? Only one has lead to nuclear weapons being put on standby...
Oh for goodness sake Putin didn't put the nuclear weapons on standby because of Liz Truss.

And yes Merkel encouraged a dependence on Russian gas because she wanted to stop nuclear power after Fukishima.

She is also a cool head and doesn't rush into things. The cool head is an asset but we needed swift action here.

teleskopregel · 01/03/2022 12:03

Putin didn't invade the Ukraine until Merkel was gone. Whatever their relationship, it was enough to stop him until Scholz took power.