Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Ukrainians should just be given a three year stay in UK, no visa needed.

181 replies

Kendodd · 01/03/2022 08:37

And they should be allowed to work, but not claim asylum.
And before people start jumping up and down 'they're not coming here, we're full up' minimal state support should be given to appease you lot. A network should be set up tso people with space, spare rooms etc can offer accommodation. Some of the people coming will be teachers, they can be supported in setting up informal or online schools for the children.
This is temporary, we are better than this. I know the Tories don't want it but they don't have to get over involved, individual people will step up and take people in. I know it's not perfect, but it's better than nothing.

Yabu - No
Yanbu Let them come

OP posts:
Kendodd · 01/03/2022 09:02

To address the “let then work” why treat them differently from all other refugees....ie the nonwhite ones from Africa and Afghanistan? That smacks of racial preference for white refugees and racism against nonwhite refugees.

I've been arguing for ages refugees should be allowed to work. It makes absolutely no sense to me that they can't.
I think they Ukrainian crisis isn't the same as Afghanistan or Syria, my feeling is this will be temporary, so no need to claim asylum and clogging up an already overloaded system. Ukrainians actually have less need than the other two groups, imo, in that even if they stayed and Putin won, life would be nothing compared to the horrors of living under the Taliban or ISIS. Anyway, I don't think long term Putin will win and so hosting Ukrainians will be short term, and if it's not, we'll cross that bridge when we come to it.

OP posts:
EmpressCixi · 01/03/2022 09:01

@Kendodd

the reality is that we are more than “full up” with such a high rate of homelessness.

Well 1,000,000 EU citizens have left since Brexit and 150,000 people have received died from covid, I make that room for 1,150,000 people. Plus don't we have 1,000,000 job vacancies.
I have a spare room, I can take a couple. Loads and loads of people do and would.

Nice numbers but the rate of homelessness is still 1 in 200 per the 2021 statistics from Shelter.

You are obscuring the fact that we still had net immigration of around 300,000 per year and also all the births on top of that, meaning the UK population is actually 1 million higher now than it was in 2019 pre Covid, and over 2 million higher than since the Brexit vote in 2016.

www.worldometers.info/world-population/uk-population/

pinkrhubarb · 01/03/2022 09:00

If it were that simple I'd agree. But there are too many complications such as non Ukrainians abusing this offer. That is a problem not just in human terms but in terms of public security as well.
We don't have decent facilities in place to manage day to day immigration alone an uncontrolled visa system.
Ukrainians are actually probably better off being relocated to Eastern European countries for their own benefits until they are more able to return home. I'm quite sure that most do not want to be put in a completely different culture for three years with their families and or dc only to have to return to their own culture a few years later.

x2boys · 01/03/2022 09:00

@Kendodd

the reality is that we are more than “full up” with such a high rate of homelessness.

Well 1,000,000 EU citizens have left since Brexit and 150,000 people have received died from covid, I make that room for 1,150,000 people. Plus don't we have 1,000,000 job vacancies.
I have a spare room, I can take a couple. Loads and loads of people do and would.

That's way to simplistic ,my parents have four spare rooms , however they are both nearly eighty my mum is extremely vulnerable both physically and mentally no way would they be in a position to offer a spare room .
labyrinthlaziness · 01/03/2022 09:00

@x2boys

Where are we going to find the billions it's going to cost to house people it's all very well saying people can offer spare rooms etc ,but there's a world of difference offering your spare room to a well educated ,middle class women than to a young lad with no real qualifications ,in reality all this takes planning and money .
Just repeating out my regular reminder if we can afford to throw money away on Brexit, which is costing us a fucking fortune every week, we can't bleat on about money.

Brexit is the epitome of pissing away wealth.

Immigrants are net contributors anyway, the economic growth generated in Germany from the million they let in is huge.

lonelyapple · 01/03/2022 08:58

@Kendodd

the reality is that we are more than “full up” with such a high rate of homelessness.

Well 1,000,000 EU citizens have left since Brexit and 150,000 people have received died from covid, I make that room for 1,150,000 people. Plus don't we have 1,000,000 job vacancies.
I have a spare room, I can take a couple. Loads and loads of people do and would.

2020 had one of the highest net migration figures to the UK of all time.

Perhaps the Government should make a law that anyone with more bedrooms than they need has to house refugees as an emergency temporary solution? Do you think that would be a good idea rather than pushing homeless people to the back of the queue?

Onionpatch · 01/03/2022 08:57

I think britain is crap with refugeees and we dont take our fair share from any conflict.

Cloudsarebright · 01/03/2022 08:57

the reality is that we are more than “full up” with such a high rate of homelessness.

That’s because we have a ridiculous system where young people have a future ahead of them of being forced to rent for a large proportion of their adult lives.

Rich landlords and overseas investors are buying up properties as investments and many of them are sitting empty.

We have more than enough capacity for housing, a lot of it is just inaccessible.

RedWingBoots · 01/03/2022 08:57

@EmpressCixi we know the government is racist. If the Ukrainian refugees are given more privileges then they that can be used as a stick to beat them with later.

Oh and this shitty government couldn't get Afghans out who worked for the UK.

GreeboIsMySpiritAnimal · 01/03/2022 08:57

"Realistically the logical approach would be the bloody huge palaces and second houses the royal family and other extraordinarily rich people have."

Now there's an idea. Half of London is full of massive empty properties owned by Russian oligarchs for tax purposes. We'll claim them back and house Ukrainian refugees in them.

labyrinthlaziness · 01/03/2022 08:57

Most of the U.K. population doesn’t own a spare bedroom this is opinion not fact.

Many people are in crowded housing but also many are in houses too large.

x2boys · 01/03/2022 08:56

Where are we going to find the billions it's going to cost to house people it's all very well saying people can offer spare rooms etc ,but there's a world of difference offering your spare room to a well educated ,middle class women than to a young lad with no real qualifications ,in reality all this takes planning and money .

labyrinthlaziness · 01/03/2022 08:55

@EmpressCixi

To address the “let then work” why treat them differently from all other refugees....ie the nonwhite ones from Africa and Afghanistan? That smacks of racial preference for white refugees and racism against nonwhite refugees.
Agree, but overall UK immigration policy is a self-defeating mess designed only to appease the thick and/or racist so this would at least be in line.

Come by boat or lorry? Bad immigrant.
Come by train? Good immigrant.

EmpressCixi · 01/03/2022 08:54

[quote RedWingBoots]@EmpressCixi We aren't going to get 20 million people. Due to where the UK is located Ukrainians who are fleeing will be spread out around Europe.[/quote]
It’s day 3 and already 500,000 have fled. I know we would not get all 20m, but that is total population from which number of potential refugees would be in the millions. We can’t take 10,000 of the 500,000 that already are seeking asylum.

And to the poster going on about spare rooms. I don’t have a spare room. Most of the U.K. population doesn’t own a spare bedroom.

lonelyapple · 01/03/2022 08:54

Realistically the logical approach would be the bloody huge palaces and second houses the royal family and other extraordinarily rich people have.

Realistically, the best way to help them is to neighbouring states with as much money and practical support as we can to provide shelter and everything they need so they can return home once the war is over. The neighbouring states are far more culturally similar and are much nearer than travelling all the way to the UK.

We cannot ignore the fact that we already have a massive housing crisis which is due to get worse because of the Tories ensuring that housing is basically unaffordable and not doing anything to really help with the cost of living, inflation running rampant. I don't think the solution is to take in a million more people when we already don't have the infrastructure to provide for the people who are already here and homeless etc.

Kendodd · 01/03/2022 08:53

the reality is that we are more than “full up” with such a high rate of homelessness.

Well 1,000,000 EU citizens have left since Brexit and 150,000 people have received died from covid, I make that room for 1,150,000 people. Plus don't we have 1,000,000 job vacancies.
I have a spare room, I can take a couple. Loads and loads of people do and would.

OP posts:
EmpressCixi · 01/03/2022 08:50

To address the “let then work” why treat them differently from all other refugees....ie the nonwhite ones from Africa and Afghanistan? That smacks of racial preference for white refugees and racism against nonwhite refugees.

labyrinthlaziness · 01/03/2022 08:49

Yes the lack of infrastructure is an issue, the Tories have run Britain down to such an awful state. My town looks the way I remember it looking in the early 90s. Tory governments just break everything's and siphon cash to their donors.

However migrants are net contributors economically, if any country needs an economic boost it is the UK.

QuentininQuarantino · 01/03/2022 08:49

Europe is doing this. And giving people with Ukrainian passports free train travel. I’m on a Facebook sofa surfing type group for women hosting women (host a sister) which is full of women offering their sofas or spare rooms to Ukrainian women who are stuck, a lot of them who were just on holiday in Barcelona or Rome when war hit their house and don’t know what to do. Can you imagine being on a sunbed in Tenerife and checking the news to see there’s a shell where your house used to be. It’s heartwarming to see the bonds being forged and it’s also sad that there aren’t any posts offering uk sofas because we can’t.

RedWingBoots · 01/03/2022 08:48

@EmpressCixi We aren't going to get 20 million people. Due to where the UK is located Ukrainians who are fleeing will be spread out around Europe.

girlmom21 · 01/03/2022 08:48

@lonelyapple

The Tories have refused to build any new housing because they want to keep house prices high and only affordable for the rich/people able to get massive mortgages, so I doubt they'll suddenly start building millions of houses in which case, where will millions of refugee families be housed when there is already a million strong waiting list for housing for people living here? There are only so many people willing to give up spare rooms etc.
Building housing wouldn't help them right now anyway.

Make temporary accommodation in community buildings, libraries etc like we do in floods and storms etc.

Realistically the logical approach would be the bloody huge palaces and second houses the royal family and other extraordinarily rich people have.

Kendodd · 01/03/2022 08:48

If you just let people in without doing basic checks do you not think non Ukrainians might abuse the system?

First of all, what people? People pretending to be Ukrainian?
Secondly, their will be basic checks, they will have passports or ID cards.
Thirdly, how exactly will these people without passports, pretending to be Ukrainian, abuse the system? By getting a job?

OP posts:
RedWingBoots · 01/03/2022 08:47

@BarbaraofSeville don't be silly someone's elderly mum, sister-in-law and kids, or niece who last visited the UK in 2019 can't prove who they are.

EmpressCixi · 01/03/2022 08:46

We have a severe housing crisis with 1 in 200 people currently being homeless, we cannot add up to 20 million more people and house them!

I’d love to do it, but you have to understand the reality is that we are more than “full up” with such a high rate of homelessness.

lonelyapple · 01/03/2022 08:45

The Tories have refused to build any new housing because they want to keep house prices high and only affordable for the rich/people able to get massive mortgages, so I doubt they'll suddenly start building millions of houses in which case, where will millions of refugee families be housed when there is already a million strong waiting list for housing for people living here? There are only so many people willing to give up spare rooms etc.