Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Ukrainians should just be given a three year stay in UK, no visa needed.

181 replies

Kendodd · 01/03/2022 08:37

And they should be allowed to work, but not claim asylum.
And before people start jumping up and down 'they're not coming here, we're full up' minimal state support should be given to appease you lot. A network should be set up tso people with space, spare rooms etc can offer accommodation. Some of the people coming will be teachers, they can be supported in setting up informal or online schools for the children.
This is temporary, we are better than this. I know the Tories don't want it but they don't have to get over involved, individual people will step up and take people in. I know it's not perfect, but it's better than nothing.

Yabu - No
Yanbu Let them come

OP posts:
Drivingish · 01/03/2022 09:29

That's from a study by a housing provider directly the census and ONS data. Overcrowding is not a problem of supply though, we are swimming in spare rooms, but they're being hoarded by people who are scared to move from a large home, people who have been taught owning a big home is aspirational, people who are in less popular areas etc etc. If we are overcrowded due to running out of space in the UK then why are housing lists and homelessness larger in London than Inverness? The problem is social and systemic, not a lack of space, and we can change the system and the society if we wanted to but at the heart of it no-one with the resources cares enough about homeless people or refugees.

Kendodd · 01/03/2022 09:28

Anti-muslim marches are not problems of immigration, they are problems of racist nationals
I agree.

OP posts:
BarbaraofSeville · 01/03/2022 09:27

@GirlInACountrySong

And every employer requires eligibility to work in the U.K.

I can't hire anyone without that. Not that simple to just 'work' for some people. Would they even have brought over interview clothes with them?

Yes, lets focus on what's important.

We shouldn't let people fleeing a warzone come to a safe country and get a job because they aren't dressed nicely.

Just about everyone fleeing Ukraine will have brought their passport/drivers licence/ID card etc which will prove their nationality and if we had a system where the UK was accepting refugees and allowing them to work, that would prove their eligibility to work.

So what if they 'haven't brought interview clothes with them'. Hmm

pinkrhubarb · 01/03/2022 09:27

@labyrinthlaziness what do you mean as usual?! That was my second post.
I am not racist in pointing out that too much immigration is not a good thing so all governments have to balance it. Allowing uncontrolled immigration doesn't work because there are so many things to factor in. Just because you believe it's a good thing doesn't equate to that being a fact.

labyrinthlaziness · 01/03/2022 09:21

@Zilla1

Was mildly surprised at Yvette Cooper? hand waving security checks when asked on R4 Today this morning. Instant admittance but security checks will just be able to happen quickly enough. Would be more impressed if they owned the consequences of what they propose though I suppose practicality and consistency doesn't need to be a feature of Loyal Opposition.
The 'consequences' you allude to basically only exist in your paranoid mind.

Again - look at Germany.

GirlInACountrySong · 01/03/2022 09:21

And every employer requires eligibility to work in the U.K.

I can't hire anyone without that. Not that simple to just 'work' for some people. Would they even have brought over interview clothes with them?

Changes17 · 01/03/2022 09:21

@GreeboIsMySpiritAnimal

"Realistically the logical approach would be the bloody huge palaces and second houses the royal family and other extraordinarily rich people have."

Now there's an idea. Half of London is full of massive empty properties owned by Russian oligarchs for tax purposes. We'll claim them back and house Ukrainian refugees in them.

I could definitely support this!
EmpressCixi · 01/03/2022 09:20

[quote Drivingish]@EmpressCixi "It’s day 3 and already 500,000 have fled. I know we would not get all 20m, but that is total population from which number of potential refugees would be in the millions. We can’t take 10,000 of the 500,000 that already are seeking asylum.

And to the poster going on about spare rooms. I don’t have a spare room. Most of the U.K. population doesn’t own a spare bedroom."

How do you make up your numbers??? 500k fleeing in the first 3 days when people are bound to be, correctly, panicking, does not automatically equal the same level over the days-months following.

And the stats showed in 2019 there were over 84 million bedrooms in the UK - there's only 67 million people in the UK and not all of them need their own room so how have you decided 'most of UK doesn't own a spare room'??? Granted not everyone could/should give up their spare room but at least acknowledge it's not a problem of supply!![/quote]
Where are you getting 84 million bedrooms from? And have you deducted vacant foreign owned properties?

All I know is that overcrowding is the highest is has ever been since records started in 1995. Overcrowding is when you have 3 people sharing 1 bedroom...

Ozanj · 01/03/2022 09:20

Most Ukranians have family and social links to other central and eastern european countries, not the UK. I wouldn’t be surprised if the UK did offer asylum - they always tend to offer it when they know take up will be neglible (eg Hong Kong).

SparklyLeprechaun · 01/03/2022 09:19

I agree. There's no need to offer free housing or anything more than the minimum benefits to help them settle, as long as they are allowed to work they will manage, just like the other 2mil+ Eastern European immigrants to the UK have done so far.

A much poorer country like Romania has announced they can take in half a million Ukrainian immigrants, whilst the UK is all talk and no action.

Zilla1 · 01/03/2022 09:17

Was mildly surprised at Yvette Cooper? hand waving security checks when asked on R4 Today this morning. Instant admittance but security checks will just be able to happen quickly enough. Would be more impressed if they owned the consequences of what they propose though I suppose practicality and consistency doesn't need to be a feature of Loyal Opposition.

GirlInACountrySong · 01/03/2022 09:17

Minimal benefits

Can work

Yet the people coming would be elderly, young children and the mothers of the children

How could that group 'work'? The men late not coming over so one adult could stay home/one work

labyrinthlaziness · 01/03/2022 09:16

@pinkrhubarb

Actually Germany has a lot of problems with immigrants too. Have you been there recently? I was in Germany in 2020 and there was an anti Islamic March going on while I was there. It was terrifying and could easily happen here if even more people are let in that's why it has to be balanced. Not everyone in the U.K. agrees that there should be more uncontrolled immigration

There have been what the Germans call 'foreign' people sexually attacking locals. It isn't as rosy as one might believe. I also live in a high immigrant area and things don't go well because men from certain countries are raised that white women are nothing in their eyes. They come to the U.K. for The benefits of living in a western country but want to keep the chauvinistic power of their own cultures at the same time.
Why is it a myth that there could be problems? It's common sense to me that it could lead to trouble.

How would the U.K. deal with people turning up without passports? Turn them away? It isn't that simple.

Anti-muslim marches are not problems of immigration, they are problems of racist nationals.

Your post is full of the same racist crap as usual.

labyrinthlaziness · 01/03/2022 09:14

@x2boys Biscuit

Do try to read the posts before replying.

I'm not suggesting anyone be forced to do anything. I was just correcting a factual error.

Comedycook · 01/03/2022 09:13

I don't object to Ukrainian refugees coming to the UK. What I don't understand about your post is why you think they should be exempt from claiming asylum? If you're fleeing war, you are a refugee. Do you think refugees from other parts of the world should be allowed to come to the UK but not claim asylum?

Duntelchaig · 01/03/2022 09:12

We don’t have the money for this or the infrastructure and I doubt they even want to come here much. One assumes they will want to get home as soon as they can and it will be easier for them from the eastern parts of the EU. This country has big cash problems, we paid a load of people to sit on their arses for nothing, locked down businesses for them to collapse to save the stricken NHS. There is no magic money tree. People squealing that the NHS is on it’s knees and squealing more with a tiny NI raise after spending MONTHS being paid to bake brownies at home. It would be lovely to throw the doors open to all migrants and refugees who need our help but we cannot bloody afford it! We can afford to send them defensive weapons and sanction the Russians and throw diplomacy and support behind them. The Ukrainians shouldn’t have to leave and they don’t want to anyway! We should be trying to stop the situation that forces them out in the first place.

Drivingish · 01/03/2022 09:11

@EmpressCixi "It’s day 3 and already 500,000 have fled. I know we would not get all 20m, but that is total population from which number of potential refugees would be in the millions. We can’t take 10,000 of the 500,000 that already are seeking asylum.

And to the poster going on about spare rooms. I don’t have a spare room. Most of the U.K. population doesn’t own a spare bedroom."

How do you make up your numbers??? 500k fleeing in the first 3 days when people are bound to be, correctly, panicking, does not automatically equal the same level over the days-months following.

And the stats showed in 2019 there were over 84 million bedrooms in the UK - there's only 67 million people in the UK and not all of them need their own room so how have you decided 'most of UK doesn't own a spare room'??? Granted not everyone could/should give up their spare room but at least acknowledge it's not a problem of supply!!

Kendodd · 01/03/2022 09:10

Oh and this shitty government couldn't get Afghans out who worked for the UK.

I know. It was absolutely shameful. Those people were Jews fleeing Nazi's, the horror of what they were facing couldn't be clearer.

OP posts:
x2boys · 01/03/2022 09:09

@labyrinthlaziness

Most of the U.K. population doesn’t own a spare bedroom this is opinion not fact.

Many people are in crowded housing but also many are in houses too large.

And ? You can't just force people to take in asylum seekers because they have too many spare rooms ,my parents dont use half their house due to my mum's very ,very limited mobility,they are far to old and frail to offer their spare bedrooms,this s house that they own outright .
pinkrhubarb · 01/03/2022 09:08

Actually Germany has a lot of problems with immigrants too. Have you been there recently? I was in Germany in 2020 and there was an anti Islamic March going on while I was there. It was terrifying and could easily happen here if even more people are let in that's why it has to be balanced. Not everyone in the U.K. agrees that there should be more uncontrolled immigration

There have been what the Germans call 'foreign' people sexually attacking locals. It isn't as rosy as one might believe. I also live in a high immigrant area and things don't go well because men from certain countries are raised that white women are nothing in their eyes. They come to the U.K. for The benefits of living in a western country but want to keep the chauvinistic power of their own cultures at the same time.
Why is it a myth that there could be problems? It's common sense to me that it could lead to trouble.

How would the U.K. deal with people turning up without passports? Turn them away? It isn't that simple.

icelolly12 · 01/03/2022 09:08

There's always people who ruin the system for everyone by taking advantage. I can imagine gangs trafficking people etc for costs. Checks need to be done even though it's a war - they have other safe countries to reside in much closer.

EmpressCixi · 01/03/2022 09:08

@Kendodd

homelessness is still 1 in 200 per the 2021 And whole fault is that? Refugees who have absolutely no power to do anything about that, they can't even vote. Or the government?
It’s our fault obviously but to argue we have plenty of room and can house tens of thousands of refugees when we have close to a million already here that we cannot and are not housing sort proves my point. We don’t have room. We don’t have housing. Are you suggesting we just build tent city refugee camps? Because that’s what would have to happen.
Kendodd · 01/03/2022 09:05

homelessness is still 1 in 200 per the 2021
And whole fault is that? Refugees who have absolutely no power to do anything about that, they can't even vote. Or the government?

OP posts:
maddy68 · 01/03/2022 09:02

The EU have waived any visa requirements. All Ukrainians are welcome. Shame on the UK

labyrinthlaziness · 01/03/2022 09:02

@pinkrhubarb

If it were that simple I'd agree. But there are too many complications such as non Ukrainians abusing this offer. That is a problem not just in human terms but in terms of public security as well. We don't have decent facilities in place to manage day to day immigration alone an uncontrolled visa system. Ukrainians are actually probably better off being relocated to Eastern European countries for their own benefits until they are more able to return home. I'm quite sure that most do not want to be put in a completely different culture for three years with their families and or dc only to have to return to their own culture a few years later.
Ah, the security myth again.

Trump was keen on this rubbish, as was Farage.

Germany let in a million refugees. It was fine. Economically beneficial.