Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Ukrainians should just be given a three year stay in UK, no visa needed.

181 replies

Kendodd · 01/03/2022 08:37

And they should be allowed to work, but not claim asylum.
And before people start jumping up and down 'they're not coming here, we're full up' minimal state support should be given to appease you lot. A network should be set up tso people with space, spare rooms etc can offer accommodation. Some of the people coming will be teachers, they can be supported in setting up informal or online schools for the children.
This is temporary, we are better than this. I know the Tories don't want it but they don't have to get over involved, individual people will step up and take people in. I know it's not perfect, but it's better than nothing.

Yabu - No
Yanbu Let them come

OP posts:
bellac11 · 01/03/2022 10:27

I agree OP

And as for people saying we are 'full up', we have the means and ability to build more housing, more schools, fund and train the NHS fully, have more GP services, have better public transport, have more dentists and other public services.

We simply dont have the political will, or in face the public support for those things.

We more than have the money for those things, look at the billions paid out to private companies and organisations during covid, all going into private hands of course for not very evidenced outcomes.

Soffit · 01/03/2022 10:23

The fact of the matter is that once you agree to take in people from overseas for whatever length of time/reasons, it is statistically proven that a chunk of those will never go back. In the UK in particular, there is very little deterrent to discouraging people from overstaying.

The Ukrainians are fat more likely to want to move to Germany, Poland and Scandinavia if they were making long term plans. I am sure that many would prefer their country to regain stability so that they can move back there. However, if it ends up behind the iron curtain again then some (not all) will never go back.

Post 1980 or so, the whole process of displacing hoards of people as a response to war and economic hardship has disadvantaged more people than it has benefitted if absolutely everything/everyone's interests are factored in.

Toocooltoboogie · 01/03/2022 10:19

Sensible post lonelyapple. I agree.

x2boys · 01/03/2022 10:19

[quote GirlInACountrySong]@bumblenbean this is mumsnet. People don't really THINK of how these people will feel
They are expected to arrive here, put in someone's spare room and just find a job

No thought for their feelings and emotions [/quote]
And not just that but how will they support themselves whilst looking for work ,not everyone will be highly educated and be able to walk into a teaching job etc ,I'm guessing they wouldn't have access to public funds ,whose going to feed them and clothe them in the meantime ,would it be the people offering the spare room ,in reality whose going to be that generous to a near stranger in the long term
What's happening ,is absolutely awful ,but it's not a simple problem to solve .

KonTikki · 01/03/2022 10:16

I second using Royal Palaces (the Queen can keep Windsor), second homes, Oligarch and Gulf States empty mansions and politicians courtesy homes (Chevening) to allay the housing crisis ....
with Ukranians on 1 year visas having first dibs.

labyrinthlaziness · 01/03/2022 10:16

The neighbouring states are far more culturally similar

FFS. This is just xenophobia.

Just say 'I am a narrominded bigot who is scared of people not born in my country' and be proud of who you are.

ChocolateDeficitDisorder · 01/03/2022 10:13

Most of the U.K. population doesn’t own a spare bedroom.

I saw a stat the other day that 1/3 of UK homes have 2 or more spare bedrooms. I can't find the stat but it sounds about right.

We don't have an accommodation problem, we have an attitude problem.

GirlInACountrySong · 01/03/2022 10:09

@bumblenbean this is mumsnet. People don't really THINK of how these people will feel
They are expected to arrive here, put in someone's spare room and just find a job

No thought for their feelings and emotions

oviraptor21 · 01/03/2022 10:08

Realistically the logical approach would be the bloody huge palaces and second houses the royal family and other extraordinarily rich people have.

Most of the seriously large properties are owned by overseas investors.

GirlInACountrySong · 01/03/2022 10:08

@gamerchick what's weird is when something is just taken from its context to try to shut someone up

Weird. But then it's mumsnet I shouldn't expect any better

bumblenbean · 01/03/2022 10:05

I don’t necessarily disagree with you in theory OP but I do think there could be unforeseen issues with joe bloggs off the street taking in refugees without any real checks of their suitability. It is an admirable and decent thing to do, and I agree many people would be happy to do it in theory, but I think once the reality of having one or several strangers living in your spare room (who may well not speak English and/ or are incredibly traumatised) sets in, things might look very different.

Obviously there would be people who could accommodate refugees without issue but in your scenario where there’s a huge influx of people, and ‘usual process’ isn’t followed/ people are housed by random members of the public, I think there’s a danger of well meaning people suddenly baulking when reality sets in. And then what happens to the refugees in their spare room?

VitalsStable · 01/03/2022 10:04

Realistically, the best way to help them is to neighbouring states with as much money and practical support as we can to provide shelter and everything they need so they can return home once the war is over. The neighbouring states are far more culturally similar and are much nearer than travelling all the way to the UK.

^ this. It's stupid to bring people thousands of miles to a country which they don't know when this situation could be very temporary. The Ukrainian people want to fight, they will want to go back as soon as they can. Bringing lots of their young who may end up staying won't do much for the future of the country at all.

It's not about what as refugees they will or won't be able to do, it's not about money or being full. It's about doing the best for the people at this present time. If things go on longer then government policy will no doubt change.

gamerchick · 01/03/2022 10:03

@GirlInACountrySong

And every employer requires eligibility to work in the U.K.

I can't hire anyone without that. Not that simple to just 'work' for some people. Would they even have brought over interview clothes with them?

Man, you live in a proper weird bubble you don't you? Grin
Gowithme · 01/03/2022 10:01

@labyrinthlaziness

Merkel took the really dangerous migrants too, the ones Trump and Farage warned us all about.
But isn't Merkel's open door policy considered to have led to the rise of the far right? Didn't she welcome refugees in because Germany was short on labour at the time but then quickly shut the door again once they had enough and it wasn't popular any more:

Furthermore, once Germany’s willingness to accept refugees diminished, Merkel was instrumental in negotiating international treaties on the behalf of the EU to prevent further migration into Europe. Most notably, Merkel and the EU signed a treaty with Turkey’s President Erdogan to prevent refugees from entering the EU through Greece. Turkey would monitor its coastline to avert further refugee migration into Europe and admit rejected asylum seekers from Greece. In return, Erdogan would receive six billion euros for the care of refugees and a pledge from the EU that it would consider visa free EU entry for Turks. This deal with an increasingly repressive leader on the back of refugees can hardly be explained normatively. However, realism’s focus on power, security, and self-interest offers a rational for such agreement. Precisely, it was in the interest of Germany to prevent and discourage further refugees from taking a journey to the EU. With that goal in mind, there was no room for normative or humanitarian considerations (Funk, 2016: 290).

Even during the open door policy there were still concerns from refugee support groups in Germany:
Refugee support group Pro Asyl slammed what it labelled "detention centres in no-man's land" and charged that German power politics were being played out "on the backs of those in need of protection".

Wasn't the Christmas market bombing supposed to be by refugees? Can't find confirmation either way but this one that was foiled was by people seeking asylum - www.politico.eu/article/six-syrians-arrested-over-german-christmas-market-terror-plot-isil-essen-asylum/

Anyway I don't think Merkel was doing anything out the goodness of her heart - Germany needed the labour and they opened the doors, then the decision became less and less popular and they were quickly slammed shut - she wasn't going out on any limbs for refugees.

I'm not saying for one minute that we shouldn't take Ukranians in - taking Russian oligarchs property and housing them there is a brilliant idea (but one that would never happen under the tories). But we shouldn't be letting anyone in without checks IMO.

I think though letting people in for three years or some other sort of time period really, really doesn't work. They will be very settled here by then and then be kicked out to go back to live in a country that is potentially destroyed both physically and economically - not to mention possibly under occupation or Russian rule where they really may not be welcome. I think that's even more cruel than not taking people in the first place personally.

Juno22 · 01/03/2022 09:58

I suspect we will see a rapid shift from shows of support on social media, eg. knitting toys in Ukrainian colours, changing FB profile pictures, dedicating my daily cold water swim to the people of Ukraine, going to my local church to pray (fair enough, but you don't need to tell everyone) once people are asked to give up their spare rooms to refugees. We'll soon see if charity really does begin at home. Perhaps I'm cynical. But I'm honest enough to say that I would be able to do it for a few weeks, but not open ended for months or years. I don't think my DH would agree to it at all.

I hope that the refugees are welcomed, but the checks should be the same as for other refugees. We should do all we can to help financially.

Zilla1 · 01/03/2022 09:54

@labyrinthlaziness Bit of a stretch to infer paranoia from my post. Perhaps says more about your preoccupations and I suspect I'd be more concerned if you agreed with me if that is your response to my post.

The interviewer asked the question. Yvette didn't say security checks weren't required and the notion they were was paranoid. She implied that security checks could be done so quickly as to not delay admittance nor require any contingencies. I'd have respected her if she'd said they weren't required and admittance should be instant. Or that they are required and here are the contingencies that would result. Saying that they can be done much more quickly and for much higher volumes than normal seemed hand-waving to me.

SockFluffInTheBath · 01/03/2022 09:54

The ‘we’re full’ mentality never fails to disgust me. If it was happening to us, if you were bombed and running with your children for your lives how would you feel if safe affluent countries said you couldn’t stay because someone else might not be genuine, or because you might use their healthcare system that you’d not paid into, or that you might have a religion not on the preferred list or that they were ‘full’? Put yourself in these people’s shoes for a second and find some bloody compassion.

LampLighter414 · 01/03/2022 09:53

Hahaha

no chance

The Brexit supporting, immigrant hating British public would never accept it.

Iwonder08 · 01/03/2022 09:52

Why only Ukrainians? Did we allow 3 year stay with no checks to Yemen people or any other country? And how exactly do you expect them to live here? Who would pay for that? Do you believe all of them can easily work in UK with no language knowledge and earn enough to cover all the living costs?

GirlInACountrySong · 01/03/2022 09:43

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

TheVanguardSix · 01/03/2022 09:43

@Kendodd

the reality is that we are more than “full up” with such a high rate of homelessness.

Well 1,000,000 EU citizens have left since Brexit and 150,000 people have received died from covid, I make that room for 1,150,000 people. Plus don't we have 1,000,000 job vacancies.
I have a spare room, I can take a couple. Loads and loads of people do and would.

It's a tad more complex than your body swap scenario. And is it going to be your voice over the tannoy hollering, "We've got a 150,000 covid corpses that need replacing with live bodies! Who's in?" You get an A* for empathy, however. Those who leave and die are constantly being replaced. The flux hasn't stopped. It's just changed: Fewer people from the EU more from elsewhere. Have you not noticed the influx of people from Hong Kong?
Ifailed · 01/03/2022 09:42

.

Ukrainians should just be given a three year stay in UK, no visa needed.
Thebestwaytoscareatory · 01/03/2022 09:40

Only if they extend that offer to the people of Iraq, Afghanistan, Libya, Syria, Palestine, Yemen and anywhere else we've funded, supported, or been directly involved with militarily activities in.

labyrinthlaziness · 01/03/2022 09:36

[quote pinkrhubarb]@labyrinthlaziness what do you mean as usual?! That was my second post.
I am not racist in pointing out that too much immigration is not a good thing so all governments have to balance it. Allowing uncontrolled immigration doesn't work because there are so many things to factor in. Just because you believe it's a good thing doesn't equate to that being a fact.[/quote]

  1. By 'as usual' I meant the usual type of racist nonsense that is always in these threads, not from you specifically.

  2. Referring to uncontrolled immigration rather than just immigration is a usual trope too - very few are in favour of no borders, certainly not me.

  3. I believe in humanitarian responses to war. So you can shove your fictional 'uncpntrolled immigration' concept wherever you choose but that is not what I believe in because it is made up.

Cam77 · 01/03/2022 09:32

@Kendodd
Loads and loads of people do and would.
I'm sure a few thousand people would do it for a couple of weeks. Until the conflict is resolved and the media coverage does down. Which could happen in a week or a month. Then will they still be happy with a family of strangers imposing on their space?