Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Ukrainians should just be given a three year stay in UK, no visa needed.

181 replies

Kendodd · 01/03/2022 08:37

And they should be allowed to work, but not claim asylum.
And before people start jumping up and down 'they're not coming here, we're full up' minimal state support should be given to appease you lot. A network should be set up tso people with space, spare rooms etc can offer accommodation. Some of the people coming will be teachers, they can be supported in setting up informal or online schools for the children.
This is temporary, we are better than this. I know the Tories don't want it but they don't have to get over involved, individual people will step up and take people in. I know it's not perfect, but it's better than nothing.

Yabu - No
Yanbu Let them come

OP posts:
Mamamia7962 · 01/03/2022 11:13

Kendodd - If you have a spare bedroom and are willing to help a Ukrainian, why do you need to start a thread about it? And what has stopped you from doing this for other refugees before?

Soffit · 01/03/2022 11:11

I almost wish that people would refrain from playing the race card in these discussions. It happens every time on here. I do not think that most people care less about the colour of the skin of the refugees. however, they probably do care about attitudes to integration and cultural sympathies/affinities. It is part of our natural human response. All those mental backflips along racial lines closes down important discussions and leads to the unnecessary self censorship and greater divisiveness.

DearlyBeloathed · 01/03/2022 11:05

@Ilovegreentomatoes

Let's just open up our spare rooms to complete strangers who we have absolutely no idea about. After all what could possibly go wrong?
Indeed.

Laughable how you're told you have an 'attitude problem' on here though if you're not happy to do so.

Soffit · 01/03/2022 11:04

Btw, I fully support the performative activist idea of interested persons taking in as many refugees as they can. However, it is insane to generalize this into a requirement/strong recommendation on practical or moral grounds.

VelvetChairGirl · 01/03/2022 11:03

@Kendodd

And they should be allowed to work, but not claim asylum. And before people start jumping up and down 'they're not coming here, we're full up' minimal state support should be given to appease you lot. A network should be set up tso people with space, spare rooms etc can offer accommodation. Some of the people coming will be teachers, they can be supported in setting up informal or online schools for the children. This is temporary, we are better than this. I know the Tories don't want it but they don't have to get over involved, individual people will step up and take people in. I know it's not perfect, but it's better than nothing.

Yabu - No
Yanbu Let them come

why?

what about those fleeing Yemen or china or whatever do they get it too? all the people on dinghies?

or is it just white people displaced you want to wave thru with special treatment?

ExcuseeeeMe · 01/03/2022 11:02

@ChocolateDeficitDisorder

Most of the U.K. population doesn’t own a spare bedroom.

I saw a stat the other day that 1/3 of UK homes have 2 or more spare bedrooms. I can't find the stat but it sounds about right.

We don't have an accommodation problem, we have an attitude problem.

An attitude problem ? So my 70 year old frail mother should welcome strangers into her house ? What a bizarre thing to say .
Soffit · 01/03/2022 11:00

@Thebestwaytoscareatory

The neighbouring states are far more culturally similar

FFS. This is just xenophobia.

Just say 'I am a narrominded bigot who is scared of people not born in my country' and be proud of who you are.

Just because you don't understand the political, cultural, physical, social, and economic complexities involved here doesn't make it xenophobia.

In my own experience, many Ukrainians speak good English and have an amazing work ethic and outlook. They would integrate far better than some Middle Eastern refugees. A visa scheme specifically designed to address the huge surplus of unfilled vacancies could work.

Now this, this is xenophobia.

Nope- it's my personal experience from having Ukranian staff and a neighbour/good friend. They also feel the same way. In a time when people are desperate to survive in the UK it is hard to view it as cheerily packing people into an inn. Deliberately departing from the economics and heading into wokey-cokey territory is at the root of the problem. However, these movements in consciousness also observe tidal wave patterns and take us from liberal to right wing back to liberal etc. through time
Motherofgorgons · 01/03/2022 10:59

@SlidingInto2022sDMs

I can't hire anyone without that. Not that simple to just 'work' for some people. Would they even have brought over interview clothes with them?

I thought "interview clothes" was weird till I read this...

And to say minimal benefits so they can work is going to put pressure on these people who will probably be feeling a million emotions. They aren't from a third world, they still have pride and standards!!

Wow! This is beyond weird. Now I've confirmed why the saying "third world" and "first world" bothers me so much.

People don't really THINK of how these people will feel
They are expected to arrive here, put in someone's spare room and just find a job

No thought for their feelings and emotions

Unless, of course they're from a "third world". Then who cares about how they feel. After all, they have no pride and standards.Hmm

Indeed. Been reading this thread and others with disbelief. Confirms what some people think of POC. We have no pride or standards unlike Europeans.
thereisonlyoneofme · 01/03/2022 10:55

The Channel migrants numbering over 37,000 already are still being put up in hotels etc at vast expense. Any attempt to house them in old barracks etc is met by opposition. Where will we put them, and the afghan people we have taken in, and the Hong Kong people. The UK does what it can according to the size and infrastructure of the country.
Its not just the housing, its education, health services etc, all of which are stretched to the limit.

Most of the Ukrainians will want to go home if Putin is thwarted.

Ilovegreentomatoes · 01/03/2022 10:55

Let's just open up our spare rooms to complete strangers who we have absolutely no idea about.
After all what could possibly go wrong?

Soffit · 01/03/2022 10:52

@labyrinthlaziness

Post 1980 or so, the whole process of displacing hoards of people as a response to war and economic hardship has disadvantaged more people than it has benefitted if absolutely everything/everyone's interests are factored in

I can't see how leaving people to starve or be killed in a war zone would have improved the sum total of human happiness.

Human happiness is entirely determined by perspective and subjective experiences. Globalization may have given the impression that uniformity should be applied across the world map but that is the fault of the globalists and has led to skewed expectations.

As a result, people in the West are more unhappy, displaced immigrants are also unhappy for different reasons and I find, generally bitter about the role played by the West in bringing about these conflicts (as they see it). Since we have now reached the lowest point of human satisfaction and we have the benefit of hindsight, it is important to go back to the drawing board and reject the failed 'solutions'.

SlidingInto2022sDMs · 01/03/2022 10:48

I can't hire anyone without that. Not that simple to just 'work' for some people. Would they even have brought over interview clothes with them?

I thought "interview clothes" was weird till I read this...

And to say minimal benefits so they can work is going to put pressure on these people who will probably be feeling a million emotions. They aren't from a third world, they still have pride and standards!!

Wow! This is beyond weird. Now I've confirmed why the saying "third world" and "first world" bothers me so much.

People don't really THINK of how these people will feel
They are expected to arrive here, put in someone's spare room and just find a job

No thought for their feelings and emotions

Unless, of course they're from a "third world". Then who cares about how they feel. After all, they have no pride and standards.Hmm

PenStation · 01/03/2022 10:47

YANBU in so far as I love your welcoming approach. We absolutely should offer refuge to people fleeing war. We need to assess what resources we have to offer to offer them a reasonable quality of life - no use escaping bombs if you cannot eat in your new home. Some checks do need to be in place, but they should be quick and simple as possible so that people are able to settle as soon as possible.

The reality on the ground is that there have been appeals for accommodation to house refugees from Afghanistan and in my area, and people really wanted to help. Lots of spare rooms were offered for single people. But the majority fleeing were parents with children and there was not much suitable for them. Families fleeing war are usually traumatized and really need to be housed together if at all possible.

labyrinthlaziness · 01/03/2022 10:47

@lonelyapple

Germany let in a million refugees. It was fine. Economically beneficial.

Is that a joke? Hmm
They have had no end of problems, not heard about the mass sexual assaults of young women or are they just collateral damage?

No human is ever collateral damage.
Thebestwaytoscareatory · 01/03/2022 10:46

The neighbouring states are far more culturally similar

FFS. This is just xenophobia.

Just say 'I am a narrominded bigot who is scared of people not born in my country' and be proud of who you are.

Just because you don't understand the political, cultural, physical, social, and economic complexities involved here doesn't make it xenophobia.

In my own experience, many Ukrainians speak good English and have an amazing work ethic and outlook. They would integrate far better than some Middle Eastern refugees. A visa scheme specifically designed to address the huge surplus of unfilled vacancies could work.

Now this, this is xenophobia.

labyrinthlaziness · 01/03/2022 10:45

Post 1980 or so, the whole process of displacing hoards of people as a response to war and economic hardship has disadvantaged more people than it has benefitted if absolutely everything/everyone's interests are factored in

I can't see how leaving people to starve or be killed in a war zone would have improved the sum total of human happiness.

ILoveAllRainbowsx · 01/03/2022 10:43

@lonelyapple

Germany let in a million refugees. It was fine. Economically beneficial.

Is that a joke? Hmm
They have had no end of problems, not heard about the mass sexual assaults of young women or are they just collateral damage?

Yes, and also the rise of the far right.
lonelyapple · 01/03/2022 10:42

Germany let in a million refugees. It was fine. Economically beneficial.

Is that a joke? Hmm
They have had no end of problems, not heard about the mass sexual assaults of young women or are they just collateral damage?

Soffit · 01/03/2022 10:35

In my own experience, many Ukrainians speak good English and have an amazing work ethic and outlook. They would integrate far better than some Middle Eastern refugees. A visa scheme specifically designed to address the huge surplus of unfilled vacancies could work.

ILoveAllRainbowsx · 01/03/2022 10:35

@lonelyapple

The Tories have refused to build any new housing because they want to keep house prices high and only affordable for the rich/people able to get massive mortgages, so I doubt they'll suddenly start building millions of houses in which case, where will millions of refugee families be housed when there is already a million strong waiting list for housing for people living here? There are only so many people willing to give up spare rooms etc.
No, the main reason that houses aren't being built is because all the NIMBYS threaten to vote Lib Dem if the Tories try to build houses anywhere near them.

The Tories want as many house owners as possible because they are more likely to vote Tory.

They keep trying, but the same people (a lot of whom are on Mumsnet) who want to let refugees in don't want new houses build near them.

bellac11 · 01/03/2022 10:34

@Kendodd

To address the “let then work” why treat them differently from all other refugees....ie the nonwhite ones from Africa and Afghanistan? That smacks of racial preference for white refugees and racism against nonwhite refugees.

I've been arguing for ages refugees should be allowed to work. It makes absolutely no sense to me that they can't.
I think they Ukrainian crisis isn't the same as Afghanistan or Syria, my feeling is this will be temporary, so no need to claim asylum and clogging up an already overloaded system. Ukrainians actually have less need than the other two groups, imo, in that even if they stayed and Putin won, life would be nothing compared to the horrors of living under the Taliban or ISIS. Anyway, I don't think long term Putin will win and so hosting Ukrainians will be short term, and if it's not, we'll cross that bridge when we come to it.

Yes, aslyum seekers, generally speaking (theres always the odd bad apple) want to work, want to integrate, want to build a life here, yet our system which keeps them waiting for up to a decade sometimes, does everything it can to stop them making a life and earing money legally. Ive been saying this for over 20 years!
Juno22 · 01/03/2022 10:30

People coming here will be terrified, shocked at losing their homes, livelihood and friends and family. And many unlikely to speak any English. We should be compassionate and help as much as we can, but I suspect some of the goodwill will be lost. Whether we like it are not there will be a lot of people who don't actually want them here. Which is sad, but we've seen it with other refugees.

We need to work hard and soon to start creating an infrastructure to support them to ensure that they feel as welcome as possible. I don't actually know how we achieve that though.

pinkrhubarb · 01/03/2022 10:29

@labyrinthlaziness I hope you've had breakfast, so much hatred in the morning somethings not quite right there!

Soffit · 01/03/2022 10:28

Wrt putting people in spare rooms, I have loads of spare rooms but I would never feel comfortable letting random people into our family space. It could work out beautifully or it could lead to disastrous consequences but the point is that there is absolutely no way of knowing. I never even did it for the large wad of cash guaranteed to London landlords where full background checks on tenants would be far easier to perform.

x2boys · 01/03/2022 10:28

@ChocolateDeficitDisorder

Most of the U.K. population doesn’t own a spare bedroom.

I saw a stat the other day that 1/3 of UK homes have 2 or more spare bedrooms. I can't find the stat but it sounds about right.

We don't have an accommodation problem, we have an attitude problem.

You may well be happy to give your spare rooms ,up but for many people it's just not feasible for many people ,or maybe they just don't want to share their home with a complete stranger,it's too simplistic to say we have an attitude problem