Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Ukrainians should just be given a three year stay in UK, no visa needed.

181 replies

Kendodd · 01/03/2022 08:37

And they should be allowed to work, but not claim asylum.
And before people start jumping up and down 'they're not coming here, we're full up' minimal state support should be given to appease you lot. A network should be set up tso people with space, spare rooms etc can offer accommodation. Some of the people coming will be teachers, they can be supported in setting up informal or online schools for the children.
This is temporary, we are better than this. I know the Tories don't want it but they don't have to get over involved, individual people will step up and take people in. I know it's not perfect, but it's better than nothing.

Yabu - No
Yanbu Let them come

OP posts:
x2boys · 01/03/2022 15:39

@Soffit

I think that those of us who live in the larger towns and cities to which the immigrants gravitate have a different understanding to somebody pontificating while living in an all white-British rural idyll.

Anybody volunteering rooms out in the sticks should know that the vast majority of immigrants will turn them down without a second thought and it's not mainly to do with employment opportunities either as care sector and service industry shortages are present almost everywhere. Unless you live in a large town/city and rely on the private sector for your schooling, housing and medical care (which I'm sure applies to some people on this forum), then you will be intimately acquainted with the additional pressures created and how longstanding citizens often lose out in the long term.

Another thing is that immigrants often come with ingrained xenophobic attitudes against other immigrant groups and/or against British people. It is actually insulting to them to collectively group them together like a gaggle of cute teddy bears. We need to acknowledge our differences and start talking about them and even celebrate them rather than becoming the gullible victims of deterministic thinking churned out by flawed national, educational policies over a few generations

Very true it's all very well sitting in your detached four bedroom house thinking of course we have as many Ukrainian,s as possible ,knowing full well its never going to impact you personally , Rather different when you live in a low income area with long housing lists ,too few jobs ,over crowded schools .
Pazuzu · 01/03/2022 15:32

@lonelyapple

The Tories have refused to build any new housing because they want to keep house prices high and only affordable for the rich/people able to get massive mortgages, so I doubt they'll suddenly start building millions of houses in which case, where will millions of refugee families be housed when there is already a million strong waiting list for housing for people living here? There are only so many people willing to give up spare rooms etc.
"There were 166,860 estimated new build dwellings starts in the year to June 2021, a 32 per cent increase compared to the year to June 2020. An estimated 183,450 new build dwellings were completed in the year to June 2021, an increase of 26 per cent compared to the year to June 2020."

Out of interest, just how many new builds do you want and more importantly, where exactly would you be putting them?

RedWingBoots · 01/03/2022 15:21

@Daddydog former Yugoslavia. People did go back.

That was also the first time I can remember that people were saying we didn't have room for refugees.

Though I know from the people who I went to school and college with plus who was our local MP at one point, people in the UK were saying that long before that.

Soffit · 01/03/2022 15:18

I think that those of us who live in the larger towns and cities to which the immigrants gravitate have a different understanding to somebody pontificating while living in an all white-British rural idyll.

Anybody volunteering rooms out in the sticks should know that the vast majority of immigrants will turn them down without a second thought and it's not mainly to do with employment opportunities either as care sector and service industry shortages are present almost everywhere. Unless you live in a large town/city and rely on the private sector for your schooling, housing and medical care (which I'm sure applies to some people on this forum), then you will be intimately acquainted with the additional pressures created and how longstanding citizens often lose out in the long term.

Another thing is that immigrants often come with ingrained xenophobic attitudes against other immigrant groups and/or against British people. It is actually insulting to them to collectively group them together like a gaggle of cute teddy bears. We need to acknowledge our differences and start talking about them and even celebrate them rather than becoming the gullible victims of deterministic thinking churned out by flawed national, educational policies over a few generations

Daddydog · 01/03/2022 15:06

[quote RedWingBoots]@Daddydog people do go back. It is said about every single accession state to the EU that they will come in and won't ever leave but most do.[/quote]
But isn't is war not a peaceful country joining the EU? Life, families, homes and jobs will be lost. It's like being burgled, you never feel safe in your own home again. I'm all for helping people and honestly think we don't do nearly enough and can do a lot more if we have a plan - but just surprised with how some people see Ukraines plight as different from other conflicts?

ilovesooty · 01/03/2022 15:05

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

SockFluffInTheBath · 01/03/2022 14:58

It’s not about us having surplus to share, it’s about one set of human beings helping another set who are in absolute dire straits.

Fromablokespoint · 01/03/2022 14:57

So @ilovesooty and @ghostyslovesheets

You would take a Ukrainian Refugee into your house, with very limited background checks?

raeray · 01/03/2022 14:57

@Kendodd

the reality is that we are more than “full up” with such a high rate of homelessness.

Well 1,000,000 EU citizens have left since Brexit and 150,000 people have received died from covid, I make that room for 1,150,000 people. Plus don't we have 1,000,000 job vacancies.
I have a spare room, I can take a couple. Loads and loads of people do and would.

Love this answer!
TarcasticSwat · 01/03/2022 14:57

@lonelyapple

The Tories have refused to build any new housing because they want to keep house prices high and only affordable for the rich/people able to get massive mortgages, so I doubt they'll suddenly start building millions of houses in which case, where will millions of refugee families be housed when there is already a million strong waiting list for housing for people living here? There are only so many people willing to give up spare rooms etc.
As someone who works in construction I have been on several social housing schemes recently - they are being built! They mostly go to immigrants, bypassing the queue of people who have waited years for social housing.

At the same time luxury housing is also being built and being sold to foreign investors who don't step foot in them. THAT'S the housing crisis issue there!! It's really demoralising working in my industry and seeing the housing crisis being exacerbated in full view.

forinborin · 01/03/2022 14:56

I have a spare room, and I would very gladly sign a waiver that my parents, if they are allowed to come and stay with me, won't use a penny from public funds in their lives.

RedWingBoots · 01/03/2022 14:54

@KMTKaren that's been the excuse since 1999.

RedWingBoots · 01/03/2022 14:51

@Daddydog people do go back. It is said about every single accession state to the EU that they will come in and won't ever leave but most do.

RedWingBoots · 01/03/2022 14:49

But @Chasingaftermidnight they are the wrong type of "immigrant" unless they are fruit pickers according to Kevin Foster, the MP for Torbay and Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State for Safe and Legal Migration Hmm

Daddydog · 01/03/2022 14:46

Let's be real for a moment - this won't be temporary, Ukraine's GDP is the second lowest in Europe - (second only to Kosovo) ranked about 110 in the world. Why when anyone who can have a chance to live and work in the UK (or any other EU country with better prospects) want to go back and go back to what? Not saying we shouldn't do our part and take in who we can - but we hand out visas so begrudgingly to commonwealth citizens, balked at taking Syrians or Afganis and deported a load of British 'Caribbeans' during the whole windrush deportee fiasco - why are Ukrainians seen as model asylum seekers? They deserve our help but so does everyone in that situation. What about the Uyghur if they had the means to get to the UK?

tttigress · 01/03/2022 14:45

@Chasingaftermidnight

I must live in a different U.K. to the one some other posters live in - in the one I live in, we’re absolutely desperate for labour in loads of sectors.
Not really, we are desperate for skilled labour at minimum wage levels.

Pay more and all labour shortages will be solved.

Chasingaftermidnight · 01/03/2022 14:40

I must live in a different U.K. to the one some other posters live in - in the one I live in, we’re absolutely desperate for labour in loads of sectors.

RaskolnikovsGarret · 01/03/2022 14:38

Sorry that was to the people opposing letting them
in.

RaskolnikovsGarret · 01/03/2022 14:35

Would you rather they were killed?

The UK takes far fewer refugees than many poorer countries.

KMTKaren · 01/03/2022 14:06

How does the existing infrastructure which is currently insufficient cope? All for supporting the Ukrainians and getting them to safety but it is more complicated than made out

SockFluffInTheBath · 01/03/2022 13:59

@ghostyslovesheets 👏

ilovesooty · 01/03/2022 13:36

Great post ghosty

ghostyslovesheets · 01/03/2022 13:33

@jytdtysrht

I would agree if there were no other countries able to help and we were nearer. As it is, these poor refugees would literally cross massive, far less densely populated countries like France and Germany to come to us? It doesn't make sense. Let's also just remember that our schools are full and our waiting list for NHS care can be over a year. Our cities have disgusting air quality and terrible traffic jams. We are failing to recognise that we are actually in crisis ourselves here in the UK. Tried seeing a GP recently?
yes having to wait two weeks to see a GP is the same as having the shit bombed out of you night and day - I see your point.

Maybe these refugees could WORK IN THE NHS - you know and help reduce waiting lists?

We are not over populated and German and France have already taking way more people than us

As for people bleating on about homelessness - do some research - UK homelessness is NOT due to lack of properties - it's due to PTSD, drug and alcohol dependency, criminal records and lack of support for released offenders - plus the decimation by this government of the services that used to try and address these problems - you could build a million new flats - you would still have homeless people unless you offered support with the other stuff

VladmirsPoutine · 01/03/2022 13:30

What will be interesting is that the country is quite xenophobic c.f. brexit and the popular 'we're full up' discourse that's been running for decades now. The gov are going to have to carefully balance between appeasing the xenophobes yet appearing to 'do something'.

ilovesooty · 01/03/2022 13:27

@jytdtysrht

I would agree if there were no other countries able to help and we were nearer. As it is, these poor refugees would literally cross massive, far less densely populated countries like France and Germany to come to us? It doesn't make sense. Let's also just remember that our schools are full and our waiting list for NHS care can be over a year. Our cities have disgusting air quality and terrible traffic jams. We are failing to recognise that we are actually in crisis ourselves here in the UK. Tried seeing a GP recently?
Yes. I saw a GP last week.

This is just a dressing up of "we shouldn't help because we're an island and they pass through other safe countries before they get to us".