Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DH wants to build a bunker/shelter in the basement

207 replies

DHmad · 28/02/2022 22:06

I wish I was kidding!

DH has decided it would be sensible to create a bunker/fall out shelter in the basement in case of nuclear war/war. I feel like he’s gone mad!

OP posts:
saleorbouy · 28/02/2022 23:36

Unless you have the ability to isolate, ve self sufficient with rations for a number of months and have a clean, scrubbed air supply until the radioactivity reduces then it pretty pointless.

LondonQueen · 28/02/2022 23:35

The emergency alert feature has been in the works for some time. Me and my colleagues all got a test alert last November which freaked us all out. It's only ramped up coverage as people are paranoid about nuclear weapons now.

extractorfactor · 28/02/2022 23:34

Oh ffs whales not wales. Obviously Wales can't be a fish -well nor can whales for that matter!

VelvetChairGirl · 28/02/2022 23:34

@OneTC

Once worked on someone's house that had a fully equipped nuclear bunker, rad suits, Geiger counters, a year's supply of food and water, it was pretty impressive

If I had loads of money and didn't live in a flat I would probably have one. If you don't survive the nuclear holocaust you're not gonna get to rip around the desert in turbo charged cars scrapping over petrol, and isn't that what we've all been waiting for? 🤔

it wasnt nukes that caused mad max it was a war in the middle east leading to limited fuel supplies and the destruction civilization as everyone decided it was every man for himself, crime spiraled the police couldnt cope and people fled the cities to the bush to try and avoid each other as they killed each other over fuel and food.
ThymePoultice · 28/02/2022 23:32

@TheMarmaladeYears

I'm an old gimmer who went through the whole 'Protect and Still Get Vaporised' shiz back in the late 70s/early 80s. Even then we knew this was utter nonsense so far as protection from nuclear war was concerned. There was also a particularly chilling TV series called 'Threads" where, amongst other scenarios, the council's emergency planning team took to a nuclear bunker under the Town Hall. You might care to point out to your DH that the upper floors of this building fell down after the bomb dropped and all the staff in this bunker died a lingering and very unpleasant death trapped underneath the remains of the Town Hall with nobody above it in any position to rescue them. So basement bunkers may offer protection from some sorts of warfare but are by no means any great help in a nuclear strike.
This subject is making us all so cheerful! Grin

I’ve just been laughing at the incredibly specific advice in that protect and survive public information film that “if you live in flats of five storeys or more, the top two floors aren’t suitable as fall out rooms”. What on Earth?

Susu49 · 28/02/2022 23:32

Would a cellar be enough to protect you from the radiation?

I was born post Cold War but I don't think there's anything any of us could realistically do to protect ourselves is there?

If your DH needs to do something to feel safe or assert some control over this nightmare which threatens us then, unless it's going to bankrupt you, let him go for it.

You never know, it might just save your lives.

mumwon · 28/02/2022 23:31

argh! I well remember a discussion

OneTC · 28/02/2022 23:30

Once worked on someone's house that had a fully equipped nuclear bunker, rad suits, Geiger counters, a year's supply of food and water, it was pretty impressive

If I had loads of money and didn't live in a flat I would probably have one. If you don't survive the nuclear holocaust you're not gonna get to rip around the desert in turbo charged cars scrapping over petrol, and isn't that what we've all been waiting for? 🤔

mumwon · 28/02/2022 23:30

I was in the forces in the 70's i well a discussion we had about bomb shelters - warning macabre!
either death by BBQ or dry crispy roast
If you were immediately below bomb you wouldn't survive & further away in fallout area you would need a shelter with lead lining probably 10 underground with air purifiers (radiation) & about a years supply of food water & a space for your waste. Plus medical equipment.
If they swamped the country with multiple bombs - well bluntly pray it doesn't happen-

extractorfactor · 28/02/2022 23:29

How can wales be 'royal fish' when they are not fishGrin. Anyway surely if he finds a beached one it's 'finders keepers' or should that be 'flounders keepers'

Let him build the bunker OP, it'll keep him busy and you can enjoy the comfort of your sitting room in peace!

I thought Vlad was meant to be quite keen on the environment? I would have though exploding a bomb full of toxic shite would be an environmental catastrophe, I mean sure, it might deal with a few troublesome humans, but it would also take out a huge amount of wildlife, marine life, trees and well pretty much whole ecosystem. It's not very environmentally friendly is it?

ThymePoultice · 28/02/2022 23:29

I’m in the “wouldn’t want to survive / would want to be vapourised immediately” camp. Thankfully in central London so that’s likely. We do have a cellar, but I’ve watched Threads and I don’t want to spend months down there, eating tinned beans and crapping in a bucket while my teeth and hair fall out.

I used to think that, but now the children who were biddable then, are opinionated young adults, and I now have a third who is still semi-biddable. I can’t imagine saying to them all “right let’s do nothing” in the event it did all kick off. Especially not with the combination of the two age groups.

I think it’s parental instinct to want to assuage their fear with purposeful activity. Which, coincidentally, is the spirit in which the original 80s “protect & survive” guidance seems to have been written. 😐 Some of it utterly bonkers, but of course you can’t tell people “when you hear the warning siren, lay down and die”.

m.youtube.com/watch?v=Qwz7JkqF-gk

TheMarmaladeYears · 28/02/2022 23:28

I'm an old gimmer who went through the whole 'Protect and Still Get Vaporised' shiz back in the late 70s/early 80s. Even then we knew this was utter nonsense so far as protection from nuclear war was concerned. There was also a particularly chilling TV series called 'Threads" where, amongst other scenarios, the council's emergency planning team took to a nuclear bunker under the Town Hall. You might care to point out to your DH that the upper floors of this building fell down after the bomb dropped and all the staff in this bunker died a lingering and very unpleasant death trapped underneath the remains of the Town Hall with nobody above it in any position to rescue them. So basement bunkers may offer protection from some sorts of warfare but are by no means any great help in a nuclear strike.

WhereYouLeftIt · 28/02/2022 23:23

@spacehardware

I suggest a family double bill viewing of threads and where the wind blows

He will love it

Never saw Where the Winds Blow, but Threads - I can still remember. With horror. I'd add Blast From the Past, a Brendan Fraser film, but that probably puts too cheery a tone on bomb shelters.

Akire makes some good points - "do you have resources for own water supply, air filters pluming and generators? Space to keep few years worth of food and rubbish?" I'd probably be pointing out this to him, that if he is serious then this is the level of preparation he is talking about.

And then I'd try and lead the conversation to why he feels this is necessary and get him talking about where these excessive fears are coming from; and try and get him to realise that it's an over-reaction. But those fears of his need addressedSad.

ThymePoultice · 28/02/2022 23:23

@listsandbudgets

^ Just taken a look - perhaps it wasn't the basement - funny the tricks memory can play - however I still think they ate the cat!!
Are you thinking of Threads? That definitely involved a basement and possibly a cat? Some pet related issue, anyway.

In CotD, I think they all stayed in the kitchen, with mattresses against the windows & plastic sheeting over the table and the youngest child refused to come out from under there. I remember a dog related it point. Not sure about a cat.

user468375484 · 28/02/2022 23:23

A better use of his time would be creating a "grab bag". 3 changes of clothes each, passports, proof of address (e.g. utility bill),
phone chargers and some long life food (e.g. cereal bars) etc

Not just for war - also useful in the event of a flood, fire or emergency hospital admission.

Interviewdisaster · 28/02/2022 23:21

We lived in tornado alley in the US for a few years when the children were tiny. We used to sit in the closet with our cycle helmets on when the tornado warning sirens went off, which the children thought was a brilliant lark.

I’m in the “wouldn’t want to survive / would want to be vapourised immediately” camp. Thankfully in central London so that’s likely. We do have a cellar, but I’ve watched Threads and I don’t want to spend months down there, eating tinned beans and crapping in a bucket while my teeth and hair fall out.

Luredbyapomegranate · 28/02/2022 23:21

It’s nice to have a hobby..

Akire · 28/02/2022 23:18

@AngelinaFibres

Once you have all done a poop In the emergency portable potty where does he think it will go ?
What to do about the poo? You basically did it in plastic bag lined bucket poured disinfectant on it and lived with it. Leaflet says 14 days mim for after blast.
Drinkyourweaklemondrink · 28/02/2022 23:13

I read a book when I was a teen called Children of the dust. It's all just shit!

FruitToast · 28/02/2022 23:13

@Cecillie

There's a good book called the stranding where two people survive an apocalyptic event by sheltering inside a beached whale . If you could put one of those in your cellar it might work ? Certainly keep him busy looking for one anyway
He just needs to remember whales are deemed 'Royal Fish' and he needs to offer it to the Queen for her own nuclear bunker before he can use it in his own (although whether that's just if he goes whaling rather than stumbles across a beached one I don't know).
whythefuckdoibother · 28/02/2022 23:10

@Deliberateplanning made me laugh, that would be me!

WhiteJellycat · 28/02/2022 23:08

I presume too that is coming from a place of fear. Doing something can be good to regain a feeling of control in stressful situations. I did start to prep in January 2020 and I have to say it did help my MH.

Unless it's going to take lots of time and money I would let him indulge to an extent. But keep talking to him and set firm boundaries.

Nuclear attacks are something I want to resist. I live 30 miles from London and with my limited memory of Threads I wont survive the blast which is probably for the best.

ThymePoultice · 28/02/2022 23:06

100 SECONDS to midnight, I mean.

ThymePoultice · 28/02/2022 23:05

It’s no stupider than insurance. The doomsday clock is at 100 minutes to midnight, which is much gloomier than it was in the early 80s “protect and survive” days.

I’m not expecting to need a bunker, but if I had a cellar ATM, it’s where I’d keep emergency supplies anyway. So let him if it makes him happy.

Stillfunny · 28/02/2022 23:04

Not too long ago , the Irish government issued every household with iodine tablets in case of emergency. I eventually threw them out , wish I hadn't now bit they were probably out of date if there is such a thing.