Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DH wants to build a bunker/shelter in the basement

207 replies

DHmad · 28/02/2022 22:06

I wish I was kidding!

DH has decided it would be sensible to create a bunker/fall out shelter in the basement in case of nuclear war/war. I feel like he’s gone mad!

OP posts:
Dottdoo · 01/03/2022 02:06

[quote mumwon]@Dottdoo 2 weeks ??? If they started a war there would be a hell of a lot more than 1 bomb which means much higher radiation - (think Chernobyl why do you think they still have an exclusion zone nb they also have one in Japan) radiation may have gone down but 2 weeks is really being optimistic (misguided) & a decrease in radiation doesn't mean its safe. Think months minimum[/quote]
But then which one of us is being the dramatic doomsdayer here?

Also remember that the number of deaths from Chernobyl was 31 (maybe 50 some squabbles over the number internationally).....afterwards that increased because of cancer rates but that was a nuclear power plant. Thousands of people were evacuated from Chernobyl and they were OK. Hundreds got cancer particularly thyroid but they still lived for 10-20yrs+

People survived hiroshima and nagasaki. Chernobyl was 400 times more powerful in terms of radiation than hiroshima because it wasn't a bomb. Hiroshima was far more immediately destructive. Two completely different nuclear incidents. Here we are talking about nuclear bombs specifically.

Survival can be achieved if you're outside the radius. People live in Hiroshima now but you can't in Chernobyl. It's different. So you can't use Chernobyl as an example as the effects and fall out for a nuclear bomb.

A nuclear bomb is devastating but it doesn't mean the entire country dies if people don't have a lead enforced bunker to live in for years. That's just not how radiation from a bomb would work.

Even a nuclear war doesn't necessarily mean that. It would be catastrophic but it doesn't mean end of world for everyone.

I'm not being optimistic - I'm just stating facts. Also you're quoting hiroshima as an example of why everyone in the UK would die suddenly makes no sense - did everyone in Japan die? No. Just those within the radius of the blast. Japan continues, life did not suddenly end throughout all of Japan. It was horrendous but two nuclear bombs didn't wipe Japan off the map, did it?

You're making an awful lot of assumptions that one nuclear bomb would mean all NATO countries would suddenly go on self destruct and start nuking everywhere. That makes no sense either.

So if someone wants to turn a basement into a second bedroom but also a potential place to hold up in a disaster more generally it's not that ridiculous.

It's more ridiculous to say one nuclear bomb is end of the world.

I think my view is more balanced and less doomsday.

If London got nuked and you're up in Manchester or Newcastle in a basement and you can ride it out for a good few weeks - you stand a decent chance of survival depending on the nature, scale and quantity of bombs.

RVN123 · 01/03/2022 02:01

Chernobyl happened in 1986 and people still can't go near there because of radiation. The aftermath was devastating and still is.
Cancers, birth defects etc.

I think 2 weeks would be a little optimistic.

Personally, I think hiding in a bunker/shelter is just delaying the inevitable.
Obviously depends on the bomb, but the real dangers (if you survived the initial blast and radiation) would be from other humans as we compete for the scarce resources that are left.

Rachelshaircut · 01/03/2022 01:56

Think yourself lucky. My husband just put 4 packets of pasta and sauce on the shopping list, just in case Confused

veevee04 · 01/03/2022 01:43

No you won't survive a nuclear bomb there will be an exchange of 1000s not 1 or 2.

veevee04 · 01/03/2022 01:41

Why would anyone want to live? There will be no food nothing will grow , no technology. I'd rather die in the initial blast than die from slow radiation poisoning and starvation.

mumwon · 01/03/2022 01:32

@Dottdoo 2 weeks ??? If they started a war there would be a hell of a lot more than 1 bomb which means much higher radiation - (think Chernobyl why do you think they still have an exclusion zone nb they also have one in Japan) radiation may have gone down but 2 weeks is really being optimistic (misguided) & a decrease in radiation doesn't mean its safe. Think months minimum

Dottdoo · 01/03/2022 01:25

I wish my DH was more like that.

It's not a bad idea especially if you make it dual use - pantry area, office, spare bedroom etc. What harm can it do?

You can survive a nuclear bomb, depending on where a bomb hit and your location. But if you're 10-50 miles (all depending on the size of the bomb) outside the radius, you have enough food, water, and can haul up somewhere like a bunker/basement for a good few weeks - you'd be OK. If you can protect yourself from the immediate radiation for minimum 2 weeks (meaning not going outside) - any longer even better - seriously you'd do alright. Couldn't say what the world would be like after.... Probably no gas, electricity, halted supply chains, it would be chaos on a scale that has never been witnessed but it doesn't mean all life would be completely obliterated. Again depends on the circumstances, number of bombs, who and where was hit. But if your instinct is to survive at any cost then a bunker seriously increases your odds.

Your risk is from what is known as the 'fall out'. It's the radiation particles carried in the dust/wind. They can travel for hundreds of miles and cause radiation poisoning but they don't last long, every day they get weaker and weaker. After 2 weeks the radiation is down to around 1% (again depending on the bomb). If you had a safe place to stay out of the atmosphere for up to 6 weeks, you'd do well.

Most people would be forced to come out due to lack of supplies at home. But it's not like one nuclear bomb would take out the entire country.

Aside from nuclear war basements make a great place to start a wine collection, hide from Alien invasion, the next pandemic or just annoying in-laws, haha! WinkGrin

AuntTwacky · 01/03/2022 01:23

@DHmad

I wish I was kidding!

DH has decided it would be sensible to create a bunker/fall out shelter in the basement in case of nuclear war/war. I feel like he’s gone mad!

Grin
BlackeyedSusan · 01/03/2022 01:13

@AngelinaFibres

Once you have all done a poop In the emergency portable potty where does he think it will go ?
Composting toilet... Earth closet as opposed to water closet

Watched too many campervan videos Blush

HelpfulAlex · 01/03/2022 01:11

This thread has made me wonder and after some googling, the US Government updated this page three days ago… 🥺

www.ready.gov/nuclear-explosion

Canyouhearmehello · 01/03/2022 01:10

Is that you Judy?Reminds me of Richard Madeley when he had a survival cupboard under the stairs because he thought the world would end the year of the millennium.

impossible · 01/03/2022 00:50

He had better get himself a gun too so he can fight off the desperate hoards who will want shelter.

ThinWomansBrain · 01/03/2022 00:32

should have been at school in the 60's - sitting underneath your desk was supposed to be adequate shelter from nuclear attack,

CharSiu · 01/03/2022 00:30

I watched threads as a teenager in the 1980’s it is possibly available on YouTube. At that point I decided I wouldn’t want to be one of the people left struggling by on a devastated planet.

OneTC · 01/03/2022 00:26

I will go by the original film thank you

The original film is part of a trilogy in which nuclear war happens

Also the best ripping about in supercharged vehicles happened in 2, which is post apocalyptic

JesusMaryAndJosephAndTheWeeDon · 01/03/2022 00:22

Buy him a copy of Nevil Shute's On the Beach, it might be old but it is a fantastic novel about the aftermath of nuclear war.

Maybe take him on a trip to the secret nuclear bunker too, so he can see what he needs to create.

VelvetChairGirl · 01/03/2022 00:19

@OneTC

it wasnt nukes that caused mad max it was a war in the middle east leading to limited fuel supplies and the destruction civilization as everyone decided it was every man for himself, crime spiraled the police couldnt cope and people fled the cities to the bush to try and avoid each other as they killed each other over fuel and food

Wasn't there a mushroom cloud in the history/story section of beyond thunderdome?

I will go by the original film thank you.
BlueSummerBaby · 01/03/2022 00:03

Go Google Only Fools And Horses: The Russians Are Coming and have a laugh together instead of stressing

BlueSummerBaby · 28/02/2022 23:56

Where's he going to keep the warehouse worth of food water etc you'll need until it's safe to set foot outside in goodness knows how many years after the radiation has died down? How will he connect this bunker to the sewers? Or is he planning for you all to stand in your own excrement until you die of cholera or sepsis from infected feet or something else equally as nasty? How will you stay in a bunker without daylight and fresh air without killing each other or dying of suffocation? He hasn't really thought this through has he

mumwon · 28/02/2022 23:53

(starts re reading Nevil Shute "On the Beach""

(this is the new version & in several parts but its a really good film)
DixonD · 28/02/2022 23:48

[quote ThoseFestiveLights]It was the official advice in the 80s!

And someone send me this today: looks like the government uploaded this over the weekend. Could be a coincidence. Or could be in case of nuclear attack…

www.gov.uk/alerts[/quote]
No, I’ve known about that coming in for a while.

Other countries do the same thing.

Akire · 28/02/2022 23:47

That video was cheery Grin I’ve heard references to washing in sand but thought some joke but had box sand for doing the dishes? The mind boggles, do Waitrose sell sand?

mumwon · 28/02/2022 23:46

So now we are all experts on viruses, mutations, immunity, different types of vaccines we are going to now learn about types of effective bomb shelters, rations required etc & radiation effectiveness
Isn't life fun & so educational.
If life over the past years hasn't taught us one thing it should have -live for today & hope for the best

OneTC · 28/02/2022 23:46

madmax.fandom.com/wiki/Apocalypse

OneTC · 28/02/2022 23:39

it wasnt nukes that caused mad max it was a war in the middle east leading to limited fuel supplies and the destruction civilization as everyone decided it was every man for himself, crime spiraled the police couldnt cope and people fled the cities to the bush to try and avoid each other as they killed each other over fuel and food

Wasn't there a mushroom cloud in the history/story section of beyond thunderdome?

Swipe left for the next trending thread