Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think World Buy an expensive costume Day & it's costume buying aren't cricket

112 replies

3Daddy31982 · 28/02/2022 21:51

I don't like world buy an overpriced cosumeday. Not every family can afford £19?
Aibu?

OP posts:
AnneElliott · 02/03/2022 18:28

I don't think you need to buy one surely? DS went as couple of things but one of his favourites was as Bilbo Baggins. We got a stick from the garden and he wore his dads wedding ring on a chain round his neck. Then wore his own clothes and a backpack.

Sherlock Holmes he went with just a magnifying glass and a hat we already had.

Kite22 · 02/03/2022 18:01

I agree @Divebar2021 . I wouldn't assume someone wanted to borrow something because they were "too poor" to buy it, I would assume they were asking to borrow because it makes no sense whatsoever to buy something to wear once.

I've borrowed things for my dc (not just World Book Day, but different activities over the years) and I have lent people things. I have also borrowed the odd thing for myself when it is for an occasion I only am going to need the thing once. Perfectly normal, sensible thing to do in my book, and nothing to do with having the money or not.

@Obira - but dc say "I want....." all the time. That is part of parenting, how you manage expectations. It isn't a reason to not have dc dressing up for WBD.

melodypondisasuperhero · 02/03/2022 17:05

@TheBareTree

I agree OP.

Our school also gave us 6 days notice that children had to make a ‘book in a box’. Anyone else had to do this? If you don’t know what it is, Google it for pictures. It’s basically homework for parents 🙄

I was just saying about the “homework for parents” thing about the book in a box to my friend, we were joking that since it’s so clearly for the parents to do 99% of the work, maybe we should do a “The Metamorphosis” or “The Brothers Karamazov” book box. (We didn’t really, obviously)

As for dressing up, DS is going as Mr Bump. Blue clothes and bandages wrapped around him, sorted.

ForTheHorde · 02/03/2022 17:02

I forgot. It’s the first one. We just routed round DS’s bookshelf and we’re going with the Dinosaur that pooped the planet. No customer - just a toy dinosaur.

Definitely doesn’t need to cost the world (though I think much better prep is key for good costumes that cost very little).

Obira · 02/03/2022 16:55

It is really hard because kids will say “I want to dress up as X” and it’s not a costume you can easily make. My 4yo wanted to be a dinosaur like Dinosaur Roar and he was crying when I said he had to wear his Halloween costume and be Dracula. So I’ve ended up buying a dinosaur and hopefully he can wear it at least twice and I can sell it later on.

Divebar2021 · 02/03/2022 16:48

I don't want to be argumentative but surely that would feel quite humiliating for some people?

Well, I don’t want to speak for anyone else but it would be a pretty normal request among my DDs school parents. I’ve just had a conversation with another parent actually about lending her something. It doesn’t mean I think she’s poor or that I make any other type of judgement.

FanciedChange · 02/03/2022 16:14

@Divebar2021

I just can't see how families in poverty, going to food banks etc can participate

They could borrow something. Put out a message on the class WhatsApp or SM and someone like myself would be happy to help. I can do Cat in Hat, a pirate character, a fireman character, gangster granny, Cruella de ville and no doubt many others.

I don't want to be argumentative but surely that would feel quite humiliating for some people?
Divebar2021 · 02/03/2022 15:58

I just can't see how families in poverty, going to food banks etc can participate

They could borrow something. Put out a message on the class WhatsApp or SM and someone like myself would be happy to help. I can do Cat in Hat, a pirate character, a fireman character, gangster granny, Cruella de ville and no doubt many others.

Realitydawning98 · 02/03/2022 15:47

This reply has been withdrawn

Message from MNHQ: This post has been withdrawn

FanciedChange · 02/03/2022 15:40

For the posters who say anything can just be thrown together for a low cost, I just can't see how families in poverty, going to food banks etc can participate. Even if they go in just PJs (in winter 🥶) as some character or other, it's going to look bloody obvious the next year in the same PJs! Not to mention, children living in poverty tend to have less access to books (yes, libraries but there are still barriers). I just think it's a bad idea, enough children are below the poverty line that it's not going to be an extremely rare issue either.

DoorLion · 02/03/2022 14:51

There is no way I would spend £19 on a costume and I don’t see why you think you need to. I think it is the competitive costuming by parents that is the issue not the dressing up in itself. I did once buy a Camp Half Blood T shirt for about £7, but as PP says you could just write it on a T- shirt, and I also once bought a bit of fun fur and cut two holes in it for a Viking waistcoat.
There are so many book characters who are just normal children. Most of the Roald Dahl characters for a start. Just add a prop to show who they are - golden ticket, medicine bottle.

AChocolateOrangeaday · 02/03/2022 14:48

DS 16 is going into his 6th form wearing his VERY well worn Jurassic Park T-shirt.

No extra expense incurred.

Thank you Michael Crichton!

Stomacharmeleon · 02/03/2022 14:43

@Kite22 hilarious Hmm

Soubriquet · 02/03/2022 09:09

@BeingATwatItsABingThing

He had already come under pressure from the teacher who insists he had to dress up but he won’t be.

Confused What teacher is insisting? I tell all of my class that dressing up is completely optional. If they come in in just non-uniform, I don’t even bat an eyelid. It’s meant to be a fun day but dressing up isn’t fun for everyone.

His class teacher.

She is always a bit over-zealous as she runs all the activities every year such as book day, the carol services, the choirs, the clubs, the nativities. Basically, if something if happening at the school, she is running it.

Saying that, ds is a sensitive little soul and takes everything to heart so her encouraging kids to dress up, to him could be interpreted as having to dress up

Kite22 · 01/03/2022 23:20

(Sorry, can't credit the author - was generally being shared on the internet a few years back)

With apologies to the ORT: Wink

The school sent a letter home about World Book Day.
The children were allowed to dress up as their favourite characters from books.
Biff and Chip were very excited.
Mum was not.
‘What is your favourite book?’ Mum asked Biff and Chip.
‘I don’t really like reading books,’ said Biff.
‘Is a computer game a book?’ said Chip.
‘Fuck my life,’ said Mum.
Mum had a good idea. ‘You are already characters in a book. You can go as yourselves.’
Biff and Chip looked at Mum as though she was stupid. ‘Are you stupid?’ asked Biff and Chip.
Dad was looking forward to World Book Day. He gave the children some ideas about what they could dress up as.
‘I’m going to be a dragon!’ said Chip.
‘I’m going to be a robot!’ said Biff.
‘I’m going to be a man-eating snake!’ said Kipper.
‘How am I going to make a dragon, a robot and a man-eating snake costume, you fucking idiot,’ shouted Mum at Dad.
‘Don’t worry,’ said Dad. ‘I will make the costumes.’
‘Oh no,’ said Mum.
Upstairs, the magic key was glowing. It took the children and Floppy the dog to a magical land. In the magical land a dragon, a robot and a man-eating snake were all having a fight.
‘Cooooooooool’ said Chip.
‘Phew,’ said Biff. ‘Now we can wear those costumes to World Book Day, because those characters have appeared in a book, which is this book, about us.’
‘Are you drunk?’ asked Chip.
The key glowed and took the children back home. Half of the walls of their house were missing, and the front garden was on fire. Dad was in the middle of it all.
‘Dad, what have you done?’ asked the children.
‘Whoops, silly me,’ said Dad. ‘I was making your World Book Day costumes.’
‘Oh no,’ said Kipper.
The next day was World Book Day. Dad showed the children their costumes. ‘Floppy needs a costume too,’ they cried.
Dad found a cat mask. ‘Floppy can be a cat,’ he said, putting the mask on Floppy.
Floppy bit Dad’s arm. Floppy did not want to be a cat. ‘Floppy, you fucking liability,’ said Biff.
Dad took the children and Floppy to school. Everyone was dressed up. Mrs May was dressed up as a lady who she said was called Anastasia Steele. The creepy caretaker was standing next to her. ‘I am Christian Gray,’ he said. Mrs May had a rope around her neck.
Dad had brought a can of petrol with him into the classroom. ‘Here comes the dragon!’ he cried. He poured the petrol over the dragon’s head and got out some matches. ‘Watch the dragon breathe fire!’ said Dad.
‘Fuck this,’ said Chip, and took off the dragon costume. Biff, Chip and Kipper ran and hid underneath a table. Dad lit a match.
Later on World Book Day, a policeman came and asked Dad lots of questions. Biff, Chip and Kipper went to see Mrs May.
‘Are you sad that Dad burned your school down, Mrs May?’ they asked.
‘Not really,’ said Mrs May. ‘I never did like teaching you horrible children anyway.’
Biff, Chip and Kipper went home to tell Mum Dad was being sent to prison. They thought Mum would be sad.
Mum was not sad. Mum was furious. Mum was standing in the middle of their broken house looking at her online bank statement.
‘HOW much on World Book Day costumes?’ shouted Mum. ‘Dad is a fucking MORON.’
‘Oh no,’ said Kipper.

Yellownotblue · 01/03/2022 22:20

Just dress your child in their best clothes. They’re one of the orphans from a Series of unfortunate events.

My DS is going in his penguin onesie. He’s decided he’s Penguin Publishing House.

TheChosenTwo · 01/03/2022 21:52

I always buy costumes because I have no imagination, no handy ‘props’ at home that seems to fit any theme and although I do have the time I just can’t be arsed to spend it being creative with costumes.
Ds is going as Harry Potter (genuinely his favourite book character) - bought a cape for £17, he has normal clothes for underneath, £4 on the glasses and we have a wand already. Last year we didn’t have dressing up day, they brought in their favourite book and each did a 90 second book talk.
When my dds were at school they were Matilda a few times, blue dress, red ribbon in hair, held a book. Cost me the ribbon as we had the other bits.
Our school says you absolutely do not need to dress up, you can participate in the day in a variety of ways.
I’m going as Demon Dentist this year. And yes, I’ve bought it all as I don’t have a bloody lab coat lying around the house but Lots of children in my class have been reading it and I thought they’d find it a bit of fun. DD has made me a toothy necklace though out of clay (which I did have to buy!).
Join in with a costume, don’t if you don’t want to, there will be lots of kids just in mufti as generic characters. Or just send in uniform, it’s all fine.
So no, yanbu to think not every family can afford £19 per child on WBD costumes which will be worn for one day but yabu to look down on others who buy them.

frazzledasarock · 01/03/2022 21:39

DD is going as Sophie from the tiger who came to tea. She’s taking her stuffed tiger with her (DH was trying to convince me she needed a toy kettle to for the tea, I’m not adding that).

One year DC went as red riding hood, she had a red rain mac (it had lady birds on it but worked) and took her sisters play picnic basket which I put her packed lunch in.

We’ve also done the cat in the hat, I made the hat using cardboard and DC wore a black outfit with a white cardigan.
Dr Doolittle again I made the hat and DC wore normal clothes and blazer on top and took along some cuddly toys we already had.

My favourite year was the year my eldest class decided to be characters from a book similar to the chalet school, and they all went in wearing similar colour clothes as school uniform. That required no effort from me whatsoever.

gah2teenagers · 01/03/2022 21:23

DGS 4 is going as the hungry caterpillar. Green tracksuit he had and a red hat We have drawn some eyes, fruit and cakes etc and stuck on. It’s bloody hilarious.

TheBareTree · 01/03/2022 21:22

I agree OP.

Our school also gave us 6 days notice that children had to make a ‘book in a box’. Anyone else had to do this? If you don’t know what it is, Google it for pictures. It’s basically homework for parents 🙄

10storeylovesong · 01/03/2022 21:19

My son's school is also doing a word thing. I've got an old orange t-shirt of his, wrote Camp Half Blood on the front, he will wear jeans and the tee and is going as "demi-god". Total cost £0

Sienna9522 · 01/03/2022 21:01

I’ve bought a costume because I’m lazy, but the best ones I’ve seen are the ones that are made. I love seeing all the kids in their costumes.

Im2022 · 01/03/2022 20:54

What does cricket have to do with it?

I can’t be arsed this year. Covid has made me realise WBD is a sham. How the fuck is Buzz Lightyear a storybook character?! Toy Story is a bloody film, not an actual story 😒

DoobryWhatsit · 01/03/2022 20:53

"just make something" 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

Our school have gone for "dress up like a word" which is great- super keenos can go all out, my kids will just be wearing whatever costumes they already have, and then we'll pick a word that fits (thinking about the last bloody costumes I had to buy, my kids' words will very likely be nativity themed 😏)

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 01/03/2022 20:48

At our school you can basically only win a prize if you’ve made the costume yourself. So yes, some people wear expensive costumes, but you won’t win a prize.

I’m acing it this year as teen dd has helped ds make his costume with no help from me! (Yes the same one who makes the pancakes, for the eagle eyed amongst you. And no I’m not sorry!)