Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

why is putin more bothered about ukraine joining nato than seemingly latvia...

35 replies

jobhunter7 · 28/02/2022 21:32

somebody will be more educated than this than me... but other neighbouring countries have joined nato, is is just the final straw for him? or is it because of the breakaway bits of eastern ukraine?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
valerianaofficiana · 01/03/2022 22:49

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/BalticFinnicc_peoples

This explains the situation better.
I do wonder how many Russian Bots are posting on MN right now?
All the panic inducing threads popping up in the last couple of days contain subtle misinformation.
Sharpen these Hawk-eyes, people!😳

valerianaofficiana · 01/03/2022 22:40

The Wiki link has been bastardised and doesn't present the ethnicity in discussion correctly. Russia is sticking it's sticky paw everywhere and sowing misinformation. Amazing🥸

jobhunter7 · 01/03/2022 22:23

Chud:

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chud

OP posts:
valerianaofficiana · 01/03/2022 22:11

Parts of local populace in many of these countries were replaced by ethnic Russians during/after II WW. Local populace thus replaced were either killed outright or sent to Gulags.

DdraigGoch · 01/03/2022 21:58

[quote jobhunter7]@greenteafiend

very good video...


will someone educate me further someone about the breakaway eastern republics of luhansk and donetsk?

is there a genuine desire for independence? or is it more propelled by the russians stirring up one?[/quote]
It depends upon how far back you want to go. Many of the areas in question (not just in Ukraine, there is Georgia too) only have high numbers of ethnic Russians as a result of Stalin's ethnic cleansing.

valerianaofficiana · 01/03/2022 21:24

Papa Putin wants to unify the Great Russia- Russia+Ukraine +Belarus. It was in his speech, if you could call such rambling a speech.

SirVixofVixHall · 01/03/2022 21:22

@MMBaranova

Putin thinks Ukrainians and Belarussians are inferior model Russians (like Slav Orcs) but still to be included in his ethnic ramblings.

He knows that there are ethnic Russians in the Baltic states but that's something from the future.

I suspect, given his looks and area of origin, that he is something of a Chud, but many Russians up in the northern parts probably are if you delve deeply into their heritage - but so what? I wouldn't make that suggestion to his face, given his history.

What is a Chud ?
jobhunter7 · 01/03/2022 21:14

@greenteafiend

very good video...


will someone educate me further someone about the breakaway eastern republics of luhansk and donetsk?

is there a genuine desire for independence? or is it more propelled by the russians stirring up one?

OP posts:
DaisyDozyDee · 01/03/2022 09:48

[quote Postdatedpandemic]Non iced up ports play a part
carnegieendowment.org/2021/05/20/what-is-russia-doing-in-black-sea-pub-84549[/quote]
This. Russia is vulnerable without secure access to ports that don’t freeze up.
Prisoners of Geography by Tim Marshall is a great book for explaining this (either the children’s illustrated version or the original).

SartresSoul · 01/03/2022 09:42

He seems to be doing a Stalin right now, he went through his majorly paranoid stage towards the end of his life. Not sure if Putin is sick or going to die soon as Stalin did but the paranoia is similar. He doesn’t like Ukraine’s leader.

BadHairDayExpert · 01/03/2022 09:40

Eastern even

BadHairDayExpert · 01/03/2022 09:39

Would a peaceful resolution be if the breakaway eastern bits joined Russia?
Well, therein lies the rub - Putin initially said it was a special mission to liberate them/peacekeeping etc but has reneged on that, using Nato and global reaction, to justify an illegal war.
Even if Ukraine had said, here - have them, there may have been a period of quiet, but then there would have been the next thing. He has already said the Baltic states should never have been Nato members so would reverse it if he could.
As for the breakaway Easter bits, do they even want to be part of Russia - I thought they wanted independence in their own names - DPR and LPR.
I do freely admit though that I knew bugger all about the Donbas region until last week. Blush

jobhunter7 · 01/03/2022 09:22

"nobody gave much of a 💩 about him taking over Crimea..."

Crimea was a part of Russia until the 1950s - when Khrushchev (which seems as crazy a move as when it got grabbed back) gave it to them. Did nobody care much because seemingly the people mostly wanted to be in Russia? Not sure if most Ukrainians felt the same way. Or whether we could rely on any polls of what the people wanted in Crimea.

Would a peaceful resolution be if the breakaway eastern bits joined Russia?

OP posts:
HappyAsASandboy · 01/03/2022 03:25

@greenteafiend that video is fantastic, thank you. So many different reasons for Putin to want to control Ukraine Sad

StartupRepair · 01/03/2022 02:31

Finland has never dared to join NATO. They are discussing it in their parliament this week.

greenteafiend · 01/03/2022 02:11
I really recommend watching this good video explainer. Ukraine's geographical position makes it esp important in terms of defending Russian from any attack from Europe. There are also lots of hydrocarbons.
nightwakingmoon · 01/03/2022 02:10

Also their populations are v small compared to Ukraine - there are only around 6m or fewer people in all the Baltic states combined compared to Ukraine’s 40m.

JimmyDurham · 01/03/2022 02:00

@jobhunter7

somebody will be more educated than this than me... but other neighbouring countries have joined nato, is is just the final straw for him? or is it because of the breakaway bits of eastern ukraine?
With a land border one side and the Russian Baltic Fleet on the other he has the Baltic republics more or less where he wants them. Ukraine's a different matter.
MMBaranova · 01/03/2022 01:57

Putin thinks Ukrainians and Belarussians are inferior model Russians (like Slav Orcs) but still to be included in his ethnic ramblings.

He knows that there are ethnic Russians in the Baltic states but that's something from the future.

I suspect, given his looks and area of origin, that he is something of a Chud, but many Russians up in the northern parts probably are if you delve deeply into their heritage - but so what? I wouldn't make that suggestion to his face, given his history.

SC215 · 01/03/2022 01:41

Latvia, Lithuania and Estonia all got invited to join NATO in 2002, and joined in 2004. I would guess that Putin either wasn't too bothered at the time, because he still had the buffer of Belarus and Ukraine for the majority of Russia's borders, or more likely Russia couldn't afford to attack 3 countries spontaneously at the time, and/or it would have been a massive faff?

Do they feel the same way about any other ex ussr countries? Do they believe Belarus is a part of Russia really? Or just Ukraine?

Belarus is part of Russia, I mean it's not, but it basically is (for now). It was part of the USSR and is now run by a dictator called Lukashenko who was in the USSR and whose been in power since 1994. He relies on Putin's power and money to keep him in power, and Putin wants to keep him in power because he will do what Putin wants, so it's a win win relationship for the two of them. He's a Putin puppet. He will never join NATO and has rigged elections. Belarus did have wide spread protests after the last rigged election, but it got quashed eventually, protests were banned and the leader of the opposition got sent to prison for 18 years.

Whereas Ukraine did over get rid of their pro Russian government in 2014. Before that it was run by Yanukovych, who was Pro Russian and anti Europe, his government tried to distance themselves from relationship with the EU and increase their ties with Russia in 2013. Ukrainian people were not happy, revolted, overthrew the government and Yanukovych had to flee (to Russia). Then Russia invaded Crimea in Ukraine to "protect ethnic Russians" and has technically been at war with Ukraine ever since, so this has been simmering for a long time. Ukraine is now becoming closer to the west, and Putin does not want a Russian speaking democracy on his door step, giving Belarus ideas, especially not one in NATO. Plus he's fucking nuts.

VikingVolva · 01/03/2022 00:31

They were Warsaw Pact rather than former Soviet states.

Yes, Poland, Hungary and Czech Republic joined NATO in 1999 before Putin's first presidency. As well as the Balts, the other former Warsaw Pact countries Slovakia, Slovenia, Bulgaria and Romania joined in 2004, Croatia in 2009, and Montenegro and North Macedonia in 2020.

(Albania withdrew from Warsaw Pact in the late 1960s, joining NATO in 2009)

Russia was in a very weak position in the 00s - I think that might have been a formative time for the wish to see the return of some form of USSR and a restoration of its might on the world stage.

China is still silent on this. Sino-Soviet relations were always somewhat opaque, we're hearing nothing of Russo-Chinese ones now, and Biden quite pointedly refused to comment on state of China-US exchanges right now.

We're perhaps moving from the two superpowers of the post-war 20 the century, via the Pax Americana, to a three superpower world? If Russia succeeds in current campaign, that is

Epli · 01/03/2022 00:07

Baltic states as well as Poland, Hungary and Czech Republic started cooperation with NATO when Russia was economically on its knees and with a very weak army. I think the latter three had joined joined as full members before Putin was even elected. I was very young at that time but I remember the consensus in Poland was that we had to join NATO ASAP to cement our modernization and democratization ambitions, and escape Russia’s influence. All those countries used the window of opportunity very well.

VikingVolva · 01/03/2022 00:04

Timing - the Balts joined NATO in March 2004 and EU in May that year which was as Putin's first term as president was coming to an end.

Putin hadn't got a stranglehold on the state at that time, Russia wasnt as strong internationally, and the salami-slicing that led to this hadn't begun. Also the later stages of the second Chechen War was still underway - when fighting within your own borders, you have less capacity to take on three other states.

Yes, I think recreating USSR is an aim. Not necessarily by conquest - some former soviet states would probably go over to be client states perfectly happily (eg Belarus, probably all four 'stans' too). Not so sure what they'd do about Moldova (war there in the 1990s Russian troops in a breakaway area - sound familiar?) or Georgia and Azerbaijan

Leaving the Balts, and no corridor to Kaliningrad.

MushroomQueen · 28/02/2022 23:41

It was made a few years ago but is so relevant it feels like could have been made the other day

MushroomQueen · 28/02/2022 23:41

This is a bit long but gives a good background and helped me understand some reasoning