Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not understand why people dislike buzz cuts on little boys?

364 replies

brightmonitorx2 · 28/02/2022 21:23

I did not realise this was a thing until I buzzed my 3 year olds hair in lockdown (had tried and failed to cut it so had to buzz).
My mother hated it, friends made comments. I then googled and people say it's trashy or something 🤷‍♀️
I thought it was cute and he is asking me to do it again because longer hair annoys him.
It was also way easier to bath/dry as he hates hair wash etc.

I want to do it again but so people thing it looks trashy/chavy whatever?

I know I shouldn't care what others think but I do 😬

OP posts:
DyingForACuppa · 01/03/2022 13:16

I'm amused by people who claim they cut their sons hair short for practical reasons (or because 'it annoys them') when they would never buzz cut their girls hair. Girls have magical powers to make long hair practical and not to be annoyed I guess Grin.

FelixViolet · 01/03/2022 13:09

Because poor people don't have to look like chavs? It's not a culture... it's a look. Don't want to look like a chav? Then don't.

I know they don't. But if they like wearing that style of clothes, what's the issue? Why do they deserve scorn for dressing a certain way? I just don't get what's wrong with the "chav" look anyway Confused

CourtRand · 01/03/2022 13:05

@FelixViolet

Why is it OK to look down on "chavs"? Hmm
Because poor people don't have to look like chavs? It's not a culture... it's a look. Don't want to look like a chav? Then don't.
aSofaNearYou · 01/03/2022 13:01

I have knee jerk, negative reactions to both buzz cuts on young boys and floppy haired do's, tbh. It doesn't mean you can't look past them to see the individual doesn't fit your gut response, but it is a natural part of how people think.

OlympicProcrastinator · 01/03/2022 13:00

It's not snobbish to point out that these hair cuts have certain negative associations

That’s exactly what it is. If you keep pointing out negative connotations associated with someone’s features you are perpetuating the prejudice. Even if you say, ‘well I’m just saying OTHER people think like that but of course I can see past that.’

thepeopleversuswork · 01/03/2022 12:57

@JunkIsland

Nobody has a ‘tiny mind’ because that mind has soaked up certain images presented by society. Places I’ve seen shaved heads recently: TV dramas where the protagonist is being punished or coerced (it’s a cliche), reports on prisoners in other countries, a really upsetting article about a teenager whose father shaved her head as punishment. This fits with what I’ve seen over the course of my life and as a result I associate this style with loss of control and individuality.

Tiny minds comes into it when we refuse to accept that those images may not be the end of the story - people choose it for themselves! it can really suit them! - but I don’t think I’m disgusting or unacceptable for an initial reaction.

This. We don't live in a social vacuum.

It would be horribly snobbish to decide that someone was automatically a chav or a thug because they shaved their kid's head.

It's not snobbish to point out that these hair cuts have certain negative associations.

OlympicProcrastinator · 01/03/2022 12:49

When my son was 4 he saw stars being shaved into hair at the barbers and wanted it for himself. He was 4. It made him happy. I took him to a playgroup and it was brilliant. I quickly got to see who made sarky comments and gave us funny looks and who just saw a little boy who enjoyed a buzz cut with stars in his hair and complimented him.
I knew straight away who I definitely wouldn’t be making friends with and who was worth developing friendships with.
Years later we still have a couple of friends from that group.
And my son is now 16 and still hasn’t committed a crime or whatever else some people judged us over his hair thought he’d do.

RumpoleoftheBaileys · 01/03/2022 12:47

@HouseofHolbein

You really remind me of Miranda Richardson (and totally rock the buzz cut).

JunkIsland · 01/03/2022 12:46

Nobody has a ‘tiny mind’ because that mind has soaked up certain images presented by society. Places I’ve seen shaved heads recently: TV dramas where the protagonist is being punished or coerced (it’s a cliche), reports on prisoners in other countries, a really upsetting article about a teenager whose father shaved her head as punishment. This fits with what I’ve seen over the course of my life and as a result I associate this style with loss of control and individuality.

Tiny minds comes into it when we refuse to accept that those images may not be the end of the story - people choose it for themselves! it can really suit them! - but I don’t think I’m disgusting or unacceptable for an initial reaction.

Roarsomemore · 01/03/2022 12:45

@brightmonitorx2
I was thinking of River Phonix too! These little boys remind me of my brother in the 80s. He was so sweet. Everyone brings their different perceptions and experiences, don't they.

Legomania · 01/03/2022 12:38

A lot of the whole class wars thing wrt appearance is based on different perceptions of what is age appropriate. So if my DH chooses a grade 3, or an older boy chooses a more fashion look, that doesn't mean I want the same for my young primary aged children.

brightmonitorx2 · 01/03/2022 12:31

@Roarsomemore that's it! That is pretty much exactly what my little boys hair was like and how he wants it again. Same colour as well.
I didn't know it was grown out 🤷‍♀️

Everyone saying to do a longer one, my practical problem is that I can't blend the shorter sides into the longer top myself (I've watched the videos and tried, I am just crap at it).

Interesting point about the tv characters and buzz cuts. I was thinking about River Phoenix in Stand By Me because that's sort of how my boy looks but I suppose he was meant to be the "bad kid" in the show, and actually he goes on to disprove all those (and these current) horrible stereotypes. Main theme of the film.

Saying that, Vern also has a buzz cut if I remember correctly.

I wonder if it's quite American (I love American!).

OP posts:
FelixViolet · 01/03/2022 12:29

I always thought he looked cute

Cute!? He looks like he'll be smoking at the back of the school by the age of 12, innit Grin

Knew a load of boys with longer hair who did that anyway. Wink

Roarsomemore · 01/03/2022 12:24

Is this a grown out buzz cut? This is the little boy from American Gothic TV show from 1990s. I always thought he look very cute.

To not understand why people dislike buzz cuts on little boys?
Grinling · 01/03/2022 12:09

It's not particularly gendered for me -- I think my barely-conscious associations are with coercion (prisoners, conscription, 'punishments' of female collaborators etc).

People do get incredibly het up about small children's hairstyles, though. I remember when DS was about three and his hair was longer than usual just because he hated having it cut, and a neighbour I barely knew to talk to came up to me just after he'd had it cut, and cried 'Oh, we all WONDERED when you were going to cut it!'. I said I hadn't realised things were so quiet in the village that a toddler's hair could attract such excitement.

thepeopleversuswork · 01/03/2022 12:00

And all this 'Well, short hair equals toxic masculinity in little boys, my son has longer hair because I want to subvert stereotypes' is such a laughable excuse for your attitude. If you really wanted to subvert gender stereotypes, you'd all give your little girls a short back and sides.

People keep trotting out this "what about boys with long hair" thing but its a bit of an irrelevance: it's not particularly about subverting gender stereotypes.

a) Long hair doesn't have any particularly negative political overtones for children of either sex. Certain parents may not like it on boys (and that's a whole other thread) but it isn't associated with the far right.
b) It's not as if your only option is a buzz cut or long hair. There are plenty of standard short haircuts which you can choose which don't scream authoritarianism and toxic masculinity.

I wouldn't be inclined to get a buzz cut for either a boy or a girl for the same reasons, that I think it has overtones which I'm not wildly keen to signal. If a child of mine desperately wanted it it might be a different matter but I wouldn't be thrilled. I would be no more inclined to get it for a girl than a boy.

OneTC · 01/03/2022 11:53

It's easy to call it "snobbery"

Wonder why that is?

Oh wait...

To many people, though, it presents an image of the family as a whole as wanting to appear aggressive, hard, unsophisticated or tough.

ImAvingOops · 01/03/2022 11:50

Most children these days won't know much about football hooligans and all the old associations with buzz cuts. I did my dc's hair in the early 00's and I honestly never gave it a thought - I was thinking about my children's hatred for hair washing and prevalence of nuts in their primary school and nothing else. So all this nasty, snobbish association is being perpetuated by people who really are old enough to know and do better.

FelixViolet · 01/03/2022 11:47

And all this 'Well, short hair equals toxic masculinity in little boys, my son has longer hair because I want to subvert stereotypes' is such a laughable excuse for your attitude. If you really wanted to subvert gender stereotypes, you'd all give your little girls a short back and sides.

Precisely. I hope they put all their little boys in dresses every day and don't let them have anything with dinosaurs on them either, if "masculine stereotypes" are the issue with a buzz-cut. Just because your son has longer hair doesn't mean he doesn't still fit the masculine stereotype, because you're still cutting it shorter than most girls have theirs, and they probably all still wear traditionally masculine clothes the majority of the time.

I'd happily give me son a buzz-cut, I'd happily dress him in Air Max and Nike tracksuits, but I'd equally let him paint his nails and wear floral tops, tell him if he wanted long hair he could have it, let him be the princess.

This idea that you can judge me and my ideas about gender stereotypes just because you saw my child with a buzz-cut in a tracksuit is ridiculous.

BarbaraofSeville · 01/03/2022 11:38

@incognitoforthisone

It's easy to call it "snobbery" but it's not that simple.

I'm afraid it really is that simple. Sorry to burst your bubble.

Exactly. All those people saying that 'short haircuts are associated with X, Y or Z' are the very ones who are perpetuating the stereotype.

Just because you associate short hair with 'thug' in your tiny mind, doesn't make it an acceptable viewpoint to hold.

MangoLipstick · 01/03/2022 11:37

I don’t personally like buzz cuts on kids but it’s not because of some of the odd (and snobbish) reasons on here!

FelixViolet · 01/03/2022 11:36

@FelixViolet I think the girls equivalent is those giant bows in their hair

Unsure how. Girls having long hair is a stereotype just the same as boys having short hair, but boys having really short hair is an issue, but girls having really long hair isn't. It doesn't make any sense.

Length of hair is a stereotype for both.

CallMeDean · 01/03/2022 11:34

I equate really short hair cuts with the same people who dress their children in Nike or Adidas

And what type of people are they, then? Are they really bad people? Hmm

3WildOnes · 01/03/2022 11:34

@FelixViolet I think the girls equivalent is those giant bows in their hair.

puffyisgood · 01/03/2022 11:28

longer/shorter boys' hair really suits some kids, not others. like my now 10 year old son has quite thin, lank hair, prone to being greasy, much as I'd [sometimes] like him to have flowing locks, hair that's longer than a couple of centimetres long just doesn't look good on him. over the last few years he's fairly consistently had short hair, a roughly a # 2 or #3 crop at the back & sides and usually [not always] a grade or two longer on top.