Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not understand why people dislike buzz cuts on little boys?

364 replies

brightmonitorx2 · 28/02/2022 21:23

I did not realise this was a thing until I buzzed my 3 year olds hair in lockdown (had tried and failed to cut it so had to buzz).
My mother hated it, friends made comments. I then googled and people say it's trashy or something 🤷‍♀️
I thought it was cute and he is asking me to do it again because longer hair annoys him.
It was also way easier to bath/dry as he hates hair wash etc.

I want to do it again but so people thing it looks trashy/chavy whatever?

I know I shouldn't care what others think but I do 😬

OP posts:
bellamountain · 01/03/2022 17:02

I think it's money, it can cost a bit every 6 weeks for a decent boys haircut into a style. A simple trim on girls long hair or all over with the clippers on a boy doesn't cost anything. However, I take my son to the salon. I like him to have a smart floppy haircut!

boobot1 · 01/03/2022 16:58

I don't have any negative associations with a buzz cut, I just think its harsh and unforgiving.

Lifedonttalktomeaboutlife · 01/03/2022 16:51

“I'm amused by people who claim they cut their sons hair short for practical reasons (or because 'it annoys them') when they would never buzz cut their girls hair. Girls have magical powers to make long hair practical and not to be annoyed I guess“

@DyingForACuppa - I’m one of those posters. I’m amused by the huge assumption there. If it made my girls life better and she wanted it I would absolutely cut off all her hair same as I did for my son.

mumof2exhausted · 01/03/2022 16:43

It looks thuggish / scally. And also I’d assume that they had nits so all had to be shaved off. Makes young boys look much older which I don’t like either.

boobot1 · 01/03/2022 16:33

@Blueuggboots

I'd much rather see a young boy with a buzz cut than the utterly ridiculous fashion for long curls on young boys that seems to abound currently!
I love long hair on a little boy
OlympicProcrastinator · 01/03/2022 16:11

Should we not have answered the OPs question just to prove we're not snobs? The fact is that our culture causes some things to be linked with others. We could sit here and virtue-signal and polish our halos all day because those links are "not nice", but that doesn't make them any less real

No. Nobody should be saying anything about their disgusting attitudes that have been shown on here. Nobody should be answering the OP’s question by saying, for example, ‘it speaks volumes about the parents’ and about how well the kids might do in life. Nobody should be calling kids chavs or thugs. Do you not realise by offering those opinions you are reinforcing and validating discrimination?

KMTKaren · 01/03/2022 14:43

@IHateWasps

It looks thuggish. It makes me think of This Is England.
Was also going to say it reminds me of this is England. However don’t personally find it thuggish. It is just a hair style after all Smile
CallMeDean · 01/03/2022 14:32

That's great, but the original post was "I don't understand why people dislike buzz cuts on little boys", not "I think everyone with a buzz cut is dodgy with a crap job - prove me wrong with anecdotal evidence".

Was I replying to the OP, or was I replying to someone who said they judge parents as it's not the type of hairstyle to ensure you do well in life? Hmm

AllThingsServeTheBeam · 01/03/2022 14:31

@DyingForACuppa

I'm amused by people who claim they cut their sons hair short for practical reasons (or because 'it annoys them') when they would never buzz cut their girls hair. Girls have magical powers to make long hair practical and not to be annoyed I guess Grin.
My eldest has a buzz cut in lockdown as they were both due a cut. My youngest point blank refused when he saw his dad and brother and hasn't had his hair cut sinc 🤣 its halfway down his back now. He has it ties up and clipped back for school
rainbowmash · 01/03/2022 14:28

@CallMeDean

think this is the sort of hairstyle that will ensure they do well in life

My uncle has always had one and he's done very well in life. Ditto, his sons also have them and he's instilled his amazing work-ethic into them. Some people would say they dress like "chavs", but they are nice young men, both work hard at their jobs, and one is also in university. None are doing badly.

I'm sure there are plenty of people who don't have buzz-cuts who have done worse than them.

That's great, but the original post was "I don't understand why people dislike buzz cuts on little boys", not "I think everyone with a buzz cut is dodgy with a crap job - prove me wrong with anecdotal evidence".

Nobody has claimed that everyone with a #3 cut or shorter is a violent waster.

Half the people here are explaining truthfully that there exists a prevalent cultural link between buzz cuts on toddlers and aggression/trad. gender roles/poverty (whether or not that link is true, nice, or useful). The other half are deciding to take it personally.

LondonWolf · 01/03/2022 14:23

@CallMeDean

think this is the sort of hairstyle that will ensure they do well in life

My uncle has always had one and he's done very well in life. Ditto, his sons also have them and he's instilled his amazing work-ethic into them. Some people would say they dress like "chavs", but they are nice young men, both work hard at their jobs, and one is also in university. None are doing badly.

I'm sure there are plenty of people who don't have buzz-cuts who have done worse than them.

Multiple family members and friends had these cuts because they were military. Some of them have done very well, achieving high rank and living their lives abroad in charge of huge military organisations, learning languages etc, keeping various defence installations secure. I suppose MNetters wouldn't think that as being successful in The Right Way though...
CallMeDean · 01/03/2022 14:20

think this is the sort of hairstyle that will ensure they do well in life

My uncle has always had one and he's done very well in life. Ditto, his sons also have them and he's instilled his amazing work-ethic into them. Some people would say they dress like "chavs", but they are nice young men, both work hard at their jobs, and one is also in university. None are doing badly.

I'm sure there are plenty of people who don't have buzz-cuts who have done worse than them.

ImAvingOops · 01/03/2022 14:19

@shrunkenhead

It doesn't assume the 3 year old to be "thuggish", but it speaks volumes about the parents if they think this is the sort of hairstyle that will ensure they do well in life...research the history of skinhead fashion and you might think differently about how to style your child's hair.
My kids had this haircut and have done well in life.
AllThingsServeTheBeam · 01/03/2022 14:15

@Amnotamug

My sons are both in their 20s…absolutely no way would they have their hair destroyed by a buzz cut…they are too cool and definitely do not want to be looking like a chav !!
Destroyed? Get a massive grip.
shrunkenhead · 01/03/2022 14:11

It doesn't assume the 3 year old to be "thuggish", but it speaks volumes about the parents if they think this is the sort of hairstyle that will ensure they do well in life...research the history of skinhead fashion and you might think differently about how to style your child's hair.

LondonWolf · 01/03/2022 14:09

I was reminded of this thread this morning when I saw a sweet little boy with a buzz cut in a London Park with his family. They all had suitcases and were speaking another language, obvs just arrived on holiday. I did wonder to myself how they'd feel if they knew how many people here would be sneering at them and judging their little boy "thuggish" and rough looking.

rainbowmash · 01/03/2022 14:03

"It's not snobbish to point out that these hair cuts have certain negative associations"

"That’s exactly what it is. If you keep pointing out negative connotations associated with someone’s features you are perpetuating the prejudice. Even if you say, ‘well I’m just saying OTHER people think like that but of course I can see past that.’"

Should we not have answered the OPs question just to prove we're not snobs? The fact is that our culture causes some things to be linked with others. We could sit here and virtue-signal and polish our halos all day because those links are "not nice", but that doesn't make them any less real.

I don't think the cultural link between buzz cuts and lower-class brutishness is "nice" either! But it won't go away just because we consider ourselves too pure to even mention it. I think the last thing that's going to perpetuate a stereotype is an open discussion about the cultural connotations involved, and the history/background/context of that stereotype, nice or not.

ImAvingOops · 01/03/2022 14:03

Once those routine checks stopped, nits became more frequent. It needs the whole class and all the families to be checked and treated at the same time ideally to nip it in the bud.
Some parents are very lax at dealing with nits

phoenixrosehere · 01/03/2022 13:53

Feminine isn't a bad thing, but neither is being working class and/or "chavvy". It's like people who look down on the trainers and tracksuit wearers (not gym wear). Why?

That’s what I was saying. Nothing is wrong with either, but people will judge or have certain associations regardless.

I am curious though. Is nits/lice that common here on the U.K.? I remember having those checks in primary school once in a blue moon, but never had them nor knew anyone who had them personally.

Borland · 01/03/2022 13:50

They just look awful, and the kids I know with buzz cuts are wearing their dad's football team's strip from such an early age and are brainwashed into that kind of awful tribalism that football brings out in so many men.

ImAvingOops · 01/03/2022 13:33

My boys have had both short and long hair. There's no toxic masculinity in my house, no football hooligans or neo Nazis or thugs either. Their haircut has literally made zero difference to how they turned out in life. Anyone who would negatively judge a family on this basis are fucking weird and horrible.

notacooldad · 01/03/2022 13:31

thuggish" 3 year olds?
A 3 well 3.5 year old once called me a cunt when I did a home visit to support mum! The child kept getting mums chin and turning it to him to get her attention and wouldnt let me talk to her. I asked if I could talk to mummy for a few minutes and that was the response.
Of course it is learned behaviour but it doesnt bode well. I wont go into whether he had a buzz cut or not!! 🤣

FelixViolet · 01/03/2022 13:27

Girls have magical powers to make long hair practical and not to be annoyed I guess grin.

It's because they don't actually let their sons have hair as long as the girls. t
They grow it to that awkward length where you can't tie it up or braid it out if the way, it just sort of flops there.
If they let it grow to a length where they could put it in a ponytail or a bun, it may not annoy their sons as much.

But, yes, people often feel more comfortable taking a young boy's hair shorter than they do girl's, because society has ingrained that as a gender expectation.

Legomania · 01/03/2022 13:21

@Empressofthemundane

A lot of postes have pointed out the class bias on this thread. The misandry is going unchallenged.

Not all masculinity is toxic. There are traditional masculine virtues: a willingness to take risks to move things forward; discipline; bravery; self sacrifice; protectiveness;etc.

When you look at a buzz cut you can see a skin head or a military man. Your perception says more about you than them. It’s a litmus test for your feelings on masculinity: do you appreciate it? Or are you afraid of it?

That's why people have been specifying toxic masculinity...
Empressofthemundane · 01/03/2022 13:19

A lot of postes have pointed out the class bias on this thread. The misandry is going unchallenged.

Not all masculinity is toxic. There are traditional masculine virtues: a willingness to take risks to move things forward; discipline; bravery; self sacrifice; protectiveness;etc.

When you look at a buzz cut you can see a skin head or a military man. Your perception says more about you than them. It’s a litmus test for your feelings on masculinity: do you appreciate it? Or are you afraid of it?