Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not understand why people dislike buzz cuts on little boys?

364 replies

brightmonitorx2 · 28/02/2022 21:23

I did not realise this was a thing until I buzzed my 3 year olds hair in lockdown (had tried and failed to cut it so had to buzz).
My mother hated it, friends made comments. I then googled and people say it's trashy or something 🤷‍♀️
I thought it was cute and he is asking me to do it again because longer hair annoys him.
It was also way easier to bath/dry as he hates hair wash etc.

I want to do it again but so people thing it looks trashy/chavy whatever?

I know I shouldn't care what others think but I do 😬

OP posts:
MadgeMak · 01/03/2022 22:34

I only further explained what my initial post was pertaining to because you got the wrong end of the stick in the first place, perhaps if you'd actually considered what I was actually saying instead of knee jerk reacting with how dare you call me a racist then I wouldn't have had to.

Thanks for your (also patronising) explanation of a discussion board. People offer opinions, other people respond in agreement or otherwise. Which is what I'm doing.

Borland · 01/03/2022 22:18

@MadgeMak

I'm not back tracking or being disingenuous, not my fault you didn't understand the point I was making, that stereotypes are harmful regardless of whether they are based in your personal reality. It's irrelevant that you were supposedly only referencing kids you know personally, isn't it? Just like it's harmful if someone was to invoke a stereotype about black people to prove their point too.
I haven't misunderstood anything but I think you are missing the point of a discussion board, people discuss their own experiences and give their opinions based on what the OP was asking. The OP asked why people don't like buzz cuts on kids therefore inviting people's personal opinions, and my experience of kids with buzz cuts is what I gave. It's not really in your gift to police the thread and chastise other posters. Thanks so much for your patronising explanation of the dangers of stereotypes though, you've really made the world a better place tonight.
Skydaze · 01/03/2022 22:13

For those who are amused at boys being "annoyed" by longer hair, DS1 (9 at the time) wanted a floppy haircut so he grew it and we had it styled. It looked amazing. However, he also is prone to developing physical tics and within a week had developed a very noticeable head-jerk motion to flip the hair across his forehead - every few minutes with increasing force and completely involuntary. Classmates picked up on it, it caused extremely tight sore neck muscles and headaches, and ended in DS highly distressed in tears one night because he couldn't stop the tic and he was in so much pain. He chose a #4 the next day and we've kept it short to medium-short ever since - his choice.

DS2 conversely embraces the Westie bogan look and would wear his surfer hair forever and a day - we mostly let him and only cut when he says it's too hot / in his ears. I agree with PP who said people don't generally grow boys hair to the same length as girls, so it's often more annoying and difficult to manage as ponytails, buns and hair clips / bands aren't as much of an option for boys. Some of our local schools have even banned "man buns" or ponytails on boys which is just ridiculous. Hair is just hair, and it shouldn't be the domain of anyone but the person who it belongs to.

HAF1119 · 01/03/2022 21:53

Whatever hair style you and DC like is all that matters :)

Mine has it shaved on occasion, he's 2.5 but he gets really excited by having it really short and when he sees it is really happy. He says 'hair too long' when it's getting long

When he was younger he had it longer but I must admit I find it smarter short (it's not as short as a buzz when shaved - either a 3 or 4 slightly longer on top - but it is short)

I think the boys all look cute whatever length. Personal preference, genuinely not worried what anyone else thinks

And I have had a few (grandparents) say 'that's too short he won't like that' but he says 'I like my hair short I like hair cut' lol then they go quiet

MadgeMak · 01/03/2022 21:52

I'm not back tracking or being disingenuous, not my fault you didn't understand the point I was making, that stereotypes are harmful regardless of whether they are based in your personal reality. It's irrelevant that you were supposedly only referencing kids you know personally, isn't it? Just like it's harmful if someone was to invoke a stereotype about black people to prove their point too.

ButtockUp · 01/03/2022 21:47

Buzz cuts will die out soon enough.
Like long hair on boys have.

It'll be something else soon... kids hair fashions always change but, strangely enough, baby girls with all of their three strands of hair piled up in a top knot with a stupid oversized bow keeps lingering.

Borland · 01/03/2022 21:40

@MadgeMak

Where did I say you were racist? I was making a point about stereotypes and how harmful they can be. You also didn't attribute the buzz cut wearing kids as being merely "football crazed", you were the insinuating something else entirely.
Of course you implied that by bringing race into it, don't back track and be so disingenuous. I specifically said I was speaking about kids I knew personally so therefore being careful not to stereotype ffs. And I wasn't 'insinuating' anything, I think I was being quite overt.
MadgeMak · 01/03/2022 21:28

Where did I say you were racist? I was making a point about stereotypes and how harmful they can be. You also didn't attribute the buzz cut wearing kids as being merely "football crazed", you were the insinuating something else entirely.

Borland · 01/03/2022 21:23

Not my kid. Replace your phrase "the kids I know with buzz cuts are " with "the kids I know with black skin are " and have a good old think about yourself

What the actual what?! This makes zero sense - the kids I personally know with buzz cuts do come from football crazed families, I never said anything about your kid. But perhaps my remark was too close to the bone for you. By the way I am not white, Interesting you thought that I must be racist because I said something that you didn't like - maybe you are the one who should be having a good think about yourself and your assumptions.

lightisnotwhite · 01/03/2022 21:05

@OlympicProcrastinator

How is black skin got anything to do with a fashion choice

Have you ever considered that for some of us, our natural hair, cultural hair or style is subject to this sort of prejudice and ‘just discussing negative associations’ is actually reinforcing harmful views that many of us can’t just ‘fashion’ ourselves out of.
Even the poster who said ‘oh it’s ok on Afro hair’ might not think they are being racist, but they are. Why is it ‘ok’ for black boys to have a buzz cut if you have so many nasty associations with it? Have a think about it.

So what are you saying black mens hair choices don’t reflect personal choice? A buzz cut, flattop, cornrows, an Afro or dreadlocks for example are just reflections of white societies prejudices?

You can have boring hair , messy hair or extreme hair whatever colour/ race you are,

FelixViolet · 01/03/2022 19:54

Oh, hang on, is it that the post implies the hair needs to be "managed" in the first place? Blush sorry, I was being a bit dense there!! I thought they meant managed as in because it was easier to care for like that, similar with braids... not because we disparage natural black hair (which we do of course). I read it wrong.

FelixViolet · 01/03/2022 19:47

That’s exactly what she meant. And I’m saying that’s racist.

Ah, I thought it wasn't racist because they didn't look at it negatively with black boys. So, it would be less racist for them to have said it's thuggish on everyone, regardless of race. Apologies, thank you for explaining that.

OlympicProcrastinator · 01/03/2022 19:42

I could be wrong, but I interpreted that as she has negative associations with it on white boys (skinheads etc), whereas it's OK on afro hair because it's a way of "managing" the hair. I could be wrong, of course

That’s exactly what she meant. And I’m saying that’s racist.

FelixViolet · 01/03/2022 19:40

Pressed send early

I thought they were saying they don't have negative associations with the style on black boys, just on white ones

FelixViolet · 01/03/2022 19:39

Why is it ‘ok’ for black boys to have a buzz cut if you have so many nasty associations with it? Have a think about it.

I could be wrong, but I interpreted that as she has negative associations with it on white boys (skinheads etc), whereas it's OK on afro hair because it's a way of "managing" the hair. I could be wrong, of course.

Cheekypeach · 01/03/2022 19:36

There was a thread a while back about little boys with long hair. One or two posters said they didn’t like it, that it looked twee and a bit wet. They were absolutely piled on, lots of posts of ‘it’s only hair’ and ‘stop projecting your stereotypes’.

Interesting to see MN doesn’t hold the same view when it comes to ‘chavvy’ haircuts isn’t it?

OlympicProcrastinator · 01/03/2022 19:34

How is black skin got anything to do with a fashion choice

Have you ever considered that for some of us, our natural hair, cultural hair or style is subject to this sort of prejudice and ‘just discussing negative associations’ is actually reinforcing harmful views that many of us can’t just ‘fashion’ ourselves out of.
Even the poster who said ‘oh it’s ok on Afro hair’ might not think they are being racist, but they are. Why is it ‘ok’ for black boys to have a buzz cut if you have so many nasty associations with it? Have a think about it.

lightisnotwhite · 01/03/2022 19:26

How is black skin got anything to do with a fashion choice?

MadgeMak · 01/03/2022 19:08

@Borland

They just look awful, and the kids I know with buzz cuts are wearing their dad's football team's strip from such an early age and are brainwashed into that kind of awful tribalism that football brings out in so many men.
Not my kid. Replace your phrase "the kids I know with buzz cuts are " with "the kids I know with black skin are " and have a good old think about yourself.
lightisnotwhite · 01/03/2022 19:07

@Empressofthemundane

A lot of postes have pointed out the class bias on this thread. The misandry is going unchallenged.

Not all masculinity is toxic. There are traditional masculine virtues: a willingness to take risks to move things forward; discipline; bravery; self sacrifice; protectiveness;etc.

When you look at a buzz cut you can see a skin head or a military man. Your perception says more about you than them. It’s a litmus test for your feelings on masculinity: do you appreciate it? Or are you afraid of it?

Interesting . I’d have said the opposite. The long hair on rock musicians/ rugby players is far more masculine to my way of thinking.

A shaved head is also about loss of identity. The nuns and monks the army haircut.

Plenty of threads on mumsnet are about women with long hair selling out to the male notions of masculinity. We aren’t all the same and we have choices. Why is it wrong is it discuss them?

RufustheFloralmissingreindeer · 01/03/2022 18:12

@DyingForACuppa

I'm amused by people who claim they cut their sons hair short for practical reasons (or because 'it annoys them') when they would never buzz cut their girls hair. Girls have magical powers to make long hair practical and not to be annoyed I guess Grin.
Dd didn’t want her hair buzz cut

And neither did ds1

So we didn’t do it to either of them

CallMeDean · 01/03/2022 17:50

do some research into skinhead culture, maybe then...

Dr Martens used to have some bad associations, although they are very fashionable now.

I used to match my Doc laces to my hair. I remember having purple hair with purple laces, and blue hair with blue laces. Well, turns out there is a whole culture of symbolism with Dr Martens laces. Purple laces are apparently a gay pride signifier, and blue is something to do with hating law enforcement. But that certainly wasn't why I was wearing them. Red apparently means you are a neo-nazi ("laces of Red, they want Jews dead").

Can't say I would judge someone with red laces in their Docs, even knowing the history. I would judge them for their personality, how they speak about people, their beliefs, their treatment and empathy of others etc.

balalake · 01/03/2022 17:25

Looks awful, and you should be teaching a child to take care and wash their hair, not dodging the issue. Tough love in my view, the sooner any child is aware there are things to do which are not lovely, the better.

HouseofHolbein · 01/03/2022 17:17

My daughter copied me with a buzz cut. My eldest daughter has done the same at times. It’s hair. It grows back 🤷‍♀️

To not understand why people dislike buzz cuts on little boys?
OneTC · 01/03/2022 17:11

Half the people here are explaining truthfully that there exists a prevalent cultural link between buzz cuts on toddlers and aggression/trad. gender roles/poverty (whether or not that link is true, nice, or useful).

It doesn't assume the 3 year old to be "thuggish", but it speaks volumes about the parents if they think this is the sort of hairstyle that will ensure they do well in life...research the history of skinhead fashion and you might think differently about how to style your child's hair

Where does the above comment fit in on that 50:50 divide?

I understand that some people do view it as thuggish, there's enough people itt who've said precisely that is their opinion, not offering an impartial commentary on social attitudes.

When explaining why some people view it as thuggish or aggressive or far right you could just say "because some people are fucking stupid" rather than basically justifying the position