Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

She has a point...

58 replies

Nanny0gg · 28/02/2022 18:45

www.spiked-online.com/2022/02/27/ukraine-is-not-all-about-you/#.YhuQJN68KWY.twitter

Julie Burchill article

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
millymolls · 01/03/2022 12:31

She’s right

ManicPixie · 01/03/2022 11:53

Another Spiked article that knocks down a generational straw-man so crusty readers can feel less awful about getting old.

frazzledali · 01/03/2022 11:53

god she writes such an absolute load of shite. She's a racist, reactionary bullshitter.

MedusasBadHairDay · 01/03/2022 11:52

@ldontWanna

YABU . Virtue signalling is still virtue signalling regardless of what side it's on.

Ohh I'm better, stronger,tougher,more stoic than you.

Ohh I'm more empathetic,worried, feeling,with more emotional intelligence than you.

Nah mate you both suck. Two opposite sides of the same shitty coin.

Moaning about "celebrity" twattery is like moaning England is wet.

It's like "isn't this generation so shit and snowflakey" bingo.

I think this is mostly where I am with it.

Yes there are people out there who like to make things all about them (I had a "friend" after 9/11 who spent months convinced that a plane was going to be flown into her small village in the UK and existing everyone else to comfort her) but they are thankfully not a huge proportion of the population.

Just getting on with day to day life isn't superior to being upset at what's happening, neither is the other way round. And honestly we kind of need both types in the world, we need people who get emotional and put themselves in the shoes of the people suffering - sure I read a study that showed charities got more donations/volunteers by appealing to empathy. But we also need the stoic ones who get on with the other stuff. And we need all the ones in between too.

What I don't think we really have a use for is people who like to sow division and cause conflict.

AmbushedByCake · 01/03/2022 11:46

She may have a point, but it is such utter nonsense that people who were evacuated and bombed in the UK during WW2 were cheerful and stoic and unaffected. People were deeply mentally scarred for life by it. And she hasn't seen anyone from Ukraine acting afraid? Utter bullshit. Why are people trying to flee their homes in droves if its just a jolly adventure that they can stiff-upper-lip themselves out of? Utter bilge. Burchill should be ashamed of publishing that.

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 01/03/2022 11:41

@loislovesstewie

Actually it would be good if someone could think of the poor train driver who has to deal with the fact that a person has ended their life by chucking themselves in front of their train? I have met several drivers who have had to live with the trauma of seeing a person do this. They apply the brakes knowing that the train won't stop in time and then seeing/dealing with the aftermath. Not to mention the emergency services who have to attend.
By 'someone' you're clearly referring to the people who commit the act of suicide. If you've reached a point of desperation that leads you to hurl yourself into oblivion onto a railway track, you won't be thinking particularly rationally about the effect of that act on others, and certainly not so far ahead as the clean-up operation. It's not a state which is conducive to clarity of thinking.

It IS possible to sympathise with the trauma suffered by train drivers, first responders, and those who commit suicide, at the same time.
Unless you're Jeremy Clarkson, apparently, whilst being all-too willing to cry for sympathy over the death of his dog.

SafeMove · 01/03/2022 11:31

Hmm, I am on the fence about this. Commentary/observation is not action, no. Having opinions or feelings about something and sharing them isn't action, behaviour or system change (because of social media and we see it more frequently and instantly so it is becoming a bigger thing than it was in the past maybe) but I wonder if people think 'awareness raising' is action enough? I see/hear of plenty of people who are actually taking action and plenty of other people offering an opinion, sending solidarity or just voicing their worries. Who are we to place a value judgement on what is less or more valid? It seems a bit 'I am the oracle' and misguided to be so strong about it. These events are being played out, in real time, with sounds and images on the world stage in our houses, for the first time. Judging or telling people how they should or should not be reacting to it seems to lack understanding of how humans work. Relating things back to yourself and processing them with reference to your own reality is normal isn't it? I think social media is so new (it's less than 20 years old remember) and this war in our living rooms on constant stream 24/7 is also new, we are all finding our feet with it, I would be cautious in sneering at people's reactions just yet tbh.

loislovesstewie · 01/03/2022 11:28

Actually it would be good if someone could think of the poor train driver who has to deal with the fact that a person has ended their life by chucking themselves in front of their train? I have met several drivers who have had to live with the trauma of seeing a person do this. They apply the brakes knowing that the train won't stop in time and then seeing/dealing with the aftermath. Not to mention the emergency services who have to attend.

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 01/03/2022 11:17

Her article makes some valid points, but I'd hate to think what she's like on the topic of genuine mental health issues. Presumably those affected should pull themselves up by the bootstraps and stop whining.

Oddly enough it's the same kind of line taken up by the arch-misogynistic, anti-woke-bingo-playing Jeremy Clarkson, who I'd bet a pound to a penny Burchill despises and rightly so.

Hear him on the topic of the poor, desperate human beings who have reached the unimaginable state of ending their lives by throwing themselves onto a railway, thus disrupting HIS journey and causing all that inconvenience to other people. According to JC, they are just selfish bastards. They deserve no empathy, their families deserve no empathy. Won't somebody think of the commuters?

Until his dog carks it and people show him the same degree of sympathy and understanding. Then #BeKind gets wheeled out. Those evil, nasty dog-haters are selfish, heartless, cruel people and they've got no empathy. No shit.

It's interesting when you watch people turning into everything they formerly professed to loathe. Burchill's whining is starting to take on a similar timbre to that of JC.

It's tedious.

Gowithme · 01/03/2022 11:12

I disagree with it, I think it's the usual armchair lecturing/attention seeking bullcrap from someone who just likes to be controversial and writes junk. If she actually was Ukrainian then I would listen to her, but no, she just sees herself as some sort of tough working class hero who stands up for chavs and deplores snowflakes. It's just another opportunity for her to pull down millennials.

People should 'toughen up' - what does that even mean? Should we be telling our 5 year old son's and daughters this? 'The Eastern Europeans are more like we were in the 1940's' Is this supposed to be some sort of backhanded compliment to the Ukrainians? Silly us for not knowing how to make molotov cocktails like they do, if only we'd grown up with 'material deprivation and existential bullying' then we wouldn't be so' weirdly weak-minded'.

And that last paragraph from JSM, 'patriotic feeling' wtf is that? It's like some sort of romantic view of war where we all (completely untrained and with no idea whatsoever) pick up our guns and defend our country against the baddy aggressor and due to our patrioticness, fervour and top morals we will win the day! Nope I value family far more than 'my country' thanks.

The hysterics wouldn't have been seen 40/50/60 years ago because there wasn't 24/7 media and SM. Those are the reasons everything feel so close to us and we are so affected by it - it has made the world a small place.

WhatATimeToBeAlive · 01/03/2022 11:08

Completely agree. I dread to think what would happen if we actually had to take up arms in combat.

strawberryapricotpie · 01/03/2022 10:58

@ldontWanna

YABU . Virtue signalling is still virtue signalling regardless of what side it's on.

Ohh I'm better, stronger,tougher,more stoic than you.

Ohh I'm more empathetic,worried, feeling,with more emotional intelligence than you.

Nah mate you both suck. Two opposite sides of the same shitty coin.

Moaning about "celebrity" twattery is like moaning England is wet.

It's like "isn't this generation so shit and snowflakey" bingo.

This. Her article makes some valid points, but I'd hate to think what she's like on the topic of genuine mental health issues. Presumably those affected should pull themselves up by the bootstraps and stop whining. Hmm
Narutocrazyfox · 01/03/2022 10:47

Spot on! I was saying almost exactly this to my husband last night!

3peassuit · 01/03/2022 10:44

I don’t agree with everything she writes but she’s nailed it for me on this one.

MarieIVanArkleStinks · 01/03/2022 10:38

Julie Burchill epitomizes that frightening trajectory of becoming more Conservative as you get older. In her case, it's been quite a transition.

I'm beyond sick of seeing that lazy generalization summed up by the words 'snowflake' and 'woke'. 'OK Boomer' does, thankfully, seem to have fallen out of vogue.

Georgeskitchen · 01/03/2022 10:33

The social media virtue signalling is through the roof atm. Just read a load of guff about someone buying 40 boxes of tampons ( yes of course you did) and the retail assistant, on learning they were for for Ukraine, said they would match it. I expect this will be sharing multiple 100s of times by those who need to tell the world they care

GirlInACountrySong · 01/03/2022 10:21

Food for thought indeed

Toocooltoboogie · 01/03/2022 10:16

Circlesandtriangles agree with your post. Things are not so easily divided into such camps. If a war came to our shores we would do the same thing as the Ukrainians young and old.

somanylies · 01/03/2022 10:16

I explain it to my children (age 8 and 5). The 8 year old wanted to take an air rifle and join the Ukrainians. I explained that child soldiers do exist but are generally frowned upon and so I was not allowing him to go.

But generally neither of them are bothered at all about there being a war other than being thrilled at being shown pictures and videos of tanks and explosions.

Kids cope fine.

daimbarsatemydogsbone · 01/03/2022 10:15

@Associatepeggy

How have 15% voted yabu. But not been able to post an actual reason for thinking that way? 😕
They will be the people who despise Birchill for being (as they see her) a TERF - the vote won't be relevant to the actual subject, it's just like the blunderbuss hatred for JK Rowling.
Cocomarine · 01/03/2022 10:06

Someone on the generally very good long Chat thread on Ukraine has actually used the phrase, “as an empath”. Made me think immediately of this thread!

LINABE · 01/03/2022 10:05

Brilliant article by Burchill as usual. I see so much crap written on here and wonder what the hell we have become.
'Sorry if that's triggering...'
'Oops sorry if I have made any spelling errors - so unforgivable...'
'So frightened about the Storm... what do I tell my children...'
It would be laughable if it wasn't so depressing.
Where's the bloody backbone gone?
No wonder so many find Zelensky attractive on here. He represents the many traits that we seem to have lost.
Snowflakes.

OneTC · 01/03/2022 00:52

I'm pretty sure I've heard people of birchills generation berating the younger folk for having never lived under the threat of nuclear war and not knowing what anxiety was

And let's be honest spiked is the epitome of Richard Littlejohn style journalism, it's PC GONE F@+£ING MAD, dog whistle racism and shock jocks that have realised there's coin to be had in penning such shite

pheonixrebirth · 28/02/2022 22:48

I can get on board with feeling empathy for the people of Ukraine but watching this morning and listening to the phone in about peoples anxiety was worrying for the reasons in that article. One woman had taken a day off work because she was so anxious about the situation????? I mean WTAF?!

ldontWanna · 28/02/2022 22:14

YABU . Virtue signalling is still virtue signalling regardless of what side it's on.

Ohh I'm better, stronger,tougher,more stoic than you.

Ohh I'm more empathetic,worried, feeling,with more emotional intelligence than you.

Nah mate you both suck. Two opposite sides of the same shitty coin.

Moaning about "celebrity" twattery is like moaning England is wet.

It's like "isn't this generation so shit and snowflakey" bingo.