Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Have you ever lent someone money and never got it back?

88 replies

marooncat7 · 28/02/2022 14:47

In my early 20s I had a friend, well actually he was a bit more than a friend. He lived abroad and we had met a few times and had a bit of a holiday romance. We spoke online all the time and it was, I believed, a friendship.

But he then lost his job, and was going through financial issues (or so he said). He said he was sleeping in his car and asked me for money to buy food via Western Union. I suggested he ask his family for help, but he came up with lots of excuses. He promised he would pay me back and stupidly I believed him. So I sent him £100 (which goes quite far in his country). He wanted more than that. But I said that's all I could give, as I was a student myself with a small income.

Well, surprise surprise, I never got the money back. I know I was stupid to ever think I would, or to give it in the first place. I am not usually someone who is so easily fooled.

However, he did put pictures on social media within a week of him and his new girlfriend, who he had started to live with. Obviously he wasn't living in his car anymore Confused

I have no idea why he did such a thing to me, and I suppose I never will know. But watching things like The Tinder Swindler brings it all back, even though £100 is a small sum compared to what those women lost.

It taught me to trust no one Angry and that many people out there have no conscience.

OP posts:
GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 01/03/2022 09:50

Banks are for lending. If someone has got to a position where the banks are no longer an option you won’t get your money back.

I have offered to help people fill out applications etc but they always actually seem to want an interest free loan with no mechanism to force repayment.

This is exactly what I think! If I need to borrow money, I’ll do it officially with a bank - means it doesn’t get in the way of friendships or family relationships, or turn them into a business relationship.

No one ever asks me to lend them money funnily enough. I must have “no” written on my forehead or something, but I’d definitely have to say “I can’t afford it” if they did

I’m in the midst of taking exh to court for maintenance arrears (under a court order not csa) if that counts?

SpaceFarce · 01/03/2022 09:49

Yes - I was a student and would know better now. A girl in our friendship group was a total sponge. Always borrowing a fiver here and there, would come for dinner and contribute nothing, and take home any dregs of wine she’d brought with her (and drank most of). I reckon by the time we graduated she owed me the best part of £150-200, and the other girls in our friendship group said the same. Cut her off years ago and apparently she still speaks of me as if I’m the worst person in the world 😂

saturdayhelicopter · 01/03/2022 09:46

My brother. Multiple times. Ultimate man-child, nothing is ever his fault, there's always a reason, he'll always pay me back asap.

The moon will be a ball of Stilton and emmenthal before I see a penny of that money.

I still speak to him but am much more cautious now. We've never been really close but I've seen him cause a lot of hurt and worry to my family so I guess I was trying to reduce the chance of that happening again.

heyitsthistle · 01/03/2022 09:46

In 2007 I lent my newly ex-bf about £1000 so we could go on this long-planned trip to South Africa that I had quit my job for. He was unemployed and almost backed out last minute, so this meant he could come. I think he still owes me about £400 but it was so long ago I've written it off now 😅

When I've lent money to people in recent years I do keep on top of it and get the money back.

AlexaShutUp · 01/03/2022 09:45

My DH did, before we met. He lent substantial sums of money to two "friends" - I am talking about thousands and thousands of pounds that he couldn't afford to lose. That was 30 years ago. He still hasn't given up on getting it back. He also lent £1500 to another "friend" a few years ago and had to take him to court to get it back.

The problem is that DH is a very moral person. He is very honest and would never cheat anyone, but he is incredibly fucking naive because he expects everyone else to be as honest and as moral as he is. He is very disappointed in his "friends" and feels quite disillusioned by the whole thing, but I'm not sure if he has really learned his lesson. I strongly suspect that, if another friend came to him in crisis/with a sob story, he would really struggle not to help. I hope that he would put some sort of formal agreement into place in future, though.

I love his honesty and his generosity. I just wish he wasn't so easy to take advantage of.

LagunaBubbles · 01/03/2022 09:41

taught me to trust no oneand that many people out there have no conscience

Its a shame you've let 1 bad person have this type of life long emotional affect on you.

Pedalpushers · 01/03/2022 09:39

My brother has taken thousands of pounds off me over the years, some lent, some bullied out of me, some stolen. Once I got older and strong enough to say no, he no longer has any reason to speak to me.

IcyWinterWonderland · 01/03/2022 09:37

@Jada1234

I lent 65k to a friend whom was a property developer 17yrs ago they never gave me a penny back. I lost my home back then and my children and I were homeless, just because I was stupid enough to trust someone.
oh my god how awful
Wnikat · 01/03/2022 09:35

I have never been paid back any money I have lent anyone. If someone needs to borrow money it generally means they can’t afford to pay it back

Justilou1 · 01/03/2022 09:33

You’re lucky your inner voice told you to only give him £100. I was flipping through FB the other day and was fascinated by an excerpt from Dr Phil (oh I know…) who was trying to get through to a woman who was choosing to keep her fantasy (to whom she had sent hundreds of thousands of $$$) despite Dr Phil finding the guy’s photo in shutter stock images, journalists going to all the places he told her he had lived and worked (nobody had heard of him or recognised his photo) totally unraveling his story about having his hand sewn back on and saved by his nurse friend in his garage when it was almost severed (He had a micro surgeon explain what would have been required to save the hand in the photo - 20+ hours of microsurgery with very expensive, specialist microsurgery equipment, followed by expensive drug therapy and Physio, etc…) nope… She was having none of it. This man is real and he loves her. People believe what they to fill a hole in their lives.

Movingsoon21 · 01/03/2022 09:32

Yes, but they were in dire straights and I knew not being paid back was a possibility when I made the decision to lend it, so had accepted that and not given more than I could afford to lose.

Was still disappointed that they weren’t honest with me and all contact stopped after I asked them for repayment a couple of months later.

OldTinHat · 01/03/2022 09:26

When I had my own business I took on a great new employee, he had excellent references and I knew him anyway. He asked for £10k as an advance on his wages which he would work off. I took out a business loan, gave him the money and never saw him or the money ever again.

I then leant a friend £6k (borrowed against my house) five years ago as they were about to be repossessed and had been made redundant. They pay a regular amount every month and will be all cleared by May this year.

MatildaTheCat · 01/03/2022 09:25

DH had a work friend who was/is living way beyond his means. He kept changing jobs and sometimes did have really impressive roles but never stayed put.

Over several years he approached DH 3 times begging for a loan of 5-10k. Twice DH said no. Third time he was asked in ‘absolute desperation’ for £5k for school fees just before term started or else the DC couldn’t start the term. He caved in and paid the school directly. CF swore the money would be repaid within days. That was 2.5 years ago.

We have a huge string of texts which are almost comical in their repetitive nonsense about deals/ sales which are imminent. About 3 months ago he randomly sent £2k. Maybe the rest will follow one day.

I can’t imagine living that way. I imagine he has a whole string of people/ institutions he is constantly fobbing off/ sending small amounts to. He’s an idiot, a CF and has lost his reputation in their industry.

As far as I know his wife doesn’t even work. Ind probably those DC are still in their expensive school.

SartresSoul · 01/03/2022 09:18

Yup. I was in a relationship years ago with an abusive twat who had a ket addiction against my knowledge to begin with. He lost his job a few months after we met and started asking to ‘borrow money’. He ‘borrowed’ about £200 in the end and he gave me a paltry sum back at Christmas that year, about £20 I think. Never saw the rest of it, I ended things when he held a knife to my throat. Stalked me for months after the split and assaulted me in the street eventually, I wrote the money off as £180 well spent just to get rid of him iykwim.

Sometimes it’s better just writing the money off.

Jada1234 · 01/03/2022 09:18

It was a business partner I lent the money to. Some was savings and collateral.
We are fine now, lucky enough to be mortgage free. Now living with severe health problems.

Mermaidkisses · 01/03/2022 09:14

My 30 year old step son (his dad and I were only dating at the time) £100 from my tiny £500 savings! He took the money, no thank you and then slagged me off to his sisters because it was only £100 and "she must be rolling in it"
He asked again this week!

lawandgin · 01/03/2022 08:51

Yes. About £1200 to my coke head brother. I didn't know the first time (£500). The second time I did, but did it was to try and save him from getting his head kicked in by his dealer and on the proviso he paid me back the minute he got the cash advance on the credit card he'd just applied for. I've learnt a lot since then.

Bigfishlittlepuddle · 01/03/2022 08:43

I got told as a child that the best way to get rid of a friend is to loan them money. I'll give someone money, with the proviso that I can afford it and if its repaid whoopee, if not, no loss.

DillonPanthersTexas · 01/03/2022 08:35

Yes, an old school friend, it was a decent sum of money supposedly to help him out on a new training course. Seeing him on Facebook partying at high end bars etc a few days afterwards was a bit annoying. Turned out he had borrowed money from several people to fund a champagne lifestyle he could not afford himself. Needless to say he ended up losing a lot of friends.

Mumoblue · 01/03/2022 08:34

I lent a co-worker a tenner and never saw it again. I was very young and she gave me a (probably true) sob story about not having enough money. I also didn’t have enough money so I said a tenner was the most I could do. She was quite pushy and even walked with me to the cash point.

Maybe I’m just a bleeding heart but I still feel kind of bad for her, but I wouldn’t do it again.

DrManhattan · 01/03/2022 08:31

Nope, never lent money. I can help people in other ways, childcare etc but lending money is just pushing the issue into the next month.

Thirkettle · 01/03/2022 08:29

No, I'm not stupid enough to ever lend people money.

pinkyredrose · 01/03/2022 08:22

I lent 65k to a friend whom was a property developer 17yrs ago they never gave me a penny back. I lost my home back then and my children and I were homeless, just because I was stupid enough to trust someone.

65k! Shock Why on earth did you lend so much? Did you use your house as collateral?

De88 · 01/03/2022 08:20

Yes, to a so called friend who knew I was a poor student at the time with a baby on the way. Kept promising repayments and then just nothing so I stopped contacting.. In my head I wrote it off as money I would have spent going out etc with him over the years.

Asdf12345 · 01/03/2022 08:10

Banks are for lending. If someone has got to a position where the banks are no longer an option you won’t get your money back.

I have offered to help people fill out applications etc but they always actually seem to want an interest free loan with no mechanism to force repayment.