Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Have you ever lent someone money and never got it back?

88 replies

marooncat7 · 28/02/2022 14:47

In my early 20s I had a friend, well actually he was a bit more than a friend. He lived abroad and we had met a few times and had a bit of a holiday romance. We spoke online all the time and it was, I believed, a friendship.

But he then lost his job, and was going through financial issues (or so he said). He said he was sleeping in his car and asked me for money to buy food via Western Union. I suggested he ask his family for help, but he came up with lots of excuses. He promised he would pay me back and stupidly I believed him. So I sent him £100 (which goes quite far in his country). He wanted more than that. But I said that's all I could give, as I was a student myself with a small income.

Well, surprise surprise, I never got the money back. I know I was stupid to ever think I would, or to give it in the first place. I am not usually someone who is so easily fooled.

However, he did put pictures on social media within a week of him and his new girlfriend, who he had started to live with. Obviously he wasn't living in his car anymore Confused

I have no idea why he did such a thing to me, and I suppose I never will know. But watching things like The Tinder Swindler brings it all back, even though £100 is a small sum compared to what those women lost.

It taught me to trust no one Angry and that many people out there have no conscience.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Unitedstations · 02/03/2022 11:00

Yes, to the tune of hundreds of pounds a good two decades ago. He did a literal midnight flit leaving chaos behind him ( I was not the worst debt he left), and he now runs one of the breakaway churches as their ‘Archbishop’. It’s nauseating really.

Funkyslippers · 02/03/2022 10:05

Yes, 3 times when I was much younger. 2 were friends, 1 my brother. He was paying me back by standing order but I forgot to check it and after a while the payments just fizzled out. I've learnt my lesson though and I'll never lend money to anyone apart from my kids

bellalou1234 · 02/03/2022 09:54

Yes I loaned a uni friend about 700 about 4-5 years ago. Left uni she made a couple of payments. Then boom blocked. I'm still angry about. We were both on a nursing course, she's now a clinical lead. Trustworthy that's a joke.

WalkingOnTheCracks · 02/03/2022 09:47

As Flo Capp points out, "Giving money. Lending money. Costs about the same..."

Mum2jenny · 01/03/2022 21:36

I only lend when if I don’t get it back, I don’t care. Most recently I lent a colleague £500 and got it back within a couple of months, so all was good.

Previously I lent a friend £400 and he committed suicide before repaying me.

It’s totally up to an individual if they choose to lend money, but always be prepared to never see it again!!

WhatsTheEffingPoint · 01/03/2022 21:29

Three times...more fool me!
£1000 to my sister, nothing ever repaid...too long a story to go into.

£1000 to my ex Sil, about £100 paid back. She denied it was ever a loan, turns out if that's what it cost to get her, my ex and their rotten family out my life then it was worth it.

£100 to an ex work colleague, paid back about £40, I left the job never saw them again. Put that down to bad judgement of character!

lawandgin · 01/03/2022 21:22

@ButtockUp maybe. I'm probably a bit over sensitive about it tbh. It's all still very raw for me as we're still in the thick of the issues that necessitated the loan.

LovelyYellowLabrador · 01/03/2022 21:15

Yes but never huge amounts like 20 quid etc

ButtockUp · 01/03/2022 21:14

But that's exactly the point, surely @lawandgin ... you learn from the point of being let down by the ones you love. So that you move forward and stop being let down by the ones you love.

Saracen · 01/03/2022 21:12

Never more than a few pounds, which I could easily afford and didn't mind.

If asked for the loan of a significant sum by someone who was in a bad way, a few times I have given them the money. I wouldn't lend that amount - too much risk of hard feelings.

lawandgin · 01/03/2022 20:45

All those who say "only lend what you can afford to lose" - it's hardly the point is it? I think a lot of people who have been badly let down by those who are supposed to love and care for them are entitled to be upset their loved ones had such little regard for them as to treat them this way.

PermanentTemporary · 01/03/2022 20:13

I took a new job and inherited a recruitment process which was down to the last 4 candidates. I picked the 2 who were recruited, my first ever appointments. One didn't turn up on the first day and made it in to work I think two days of the first fortnight. He has several excuses but one was that he couldn't afford the travel. I lent him £250 for a train ticket, I think he turned up the following day but then didn't bother. He might have given me a token tenner or something but I had to sack him in the end and oddly enough he didn't pay me anything more after that.

I'm susceptible to scammers and sob stories, like a pp i was well trained by my dad but am also very like him so a bit chaotic with money myself.

Elphame · 01/03/2022 19:57

No but then I never lend money.

I will gift it (and have done to friends who need it) but I don't want or expect payment back.

ButtockUp · 01/03/2022 19:56

Absolutely @waitingpatientlyforspring
I think the message is to only 'give' what you can afford to lose.

waitingpatientlyforspring · 01/03/2022 19:53

I remember Carol MGiffin on loose women saying she never lends money. If people she cares about needs money and she can afford it then she gives it. If they pay it back then its a bonus but in her mind the money is a gift. That way she isn't upset when it's not given back.

ButtockUp · 01/03/2022 19:42

My story isn't in any way as serious as some of these stories which are quite staggering in their CFness.

I kept finding myself , with a colleague at a sandwich bar , at the same time. I lost count of the number of times that either her card was declined but "I don't understand " so I'd pay or... she couldn't find her debit card, so I'd have to pay.
Embarrassed to say that it took me a while to change my morning routine.

ChocolateCakeYum · 01/03/2022 19:12

I lent my sister several thousand pounds as a teenager (it was some inheritance so not small change) and the day she was due to start paying me back she refused and rubbed it in for years that she wouldn’t ever give me a penny of it. She did the same thing to our mum.

I did eventually get it back though as she came into some money from a business venture a year or two ago and she asked me to deal with all the paperwork and whatnot. I taxed her for my time with interest. No regrets.

Saddlesore · 01/03/2022 18:12

Not money, but time and effort. A "friend" contacted me in desperation one Friday afternoon saying she had been let down by a freelancer and wouldn't be able to meet a Monday morning deadline. I work in the same field as the freelancer and she asked me if I could do the work instead. I agreed, told her the fee (which I gave her at a reduced rate because we sometimes met socially) and spent all weekend on the task. And I mean all weekend, from morning to night. I have invoiced her many times.... OVER THE LAST 9 YEARS.... and still haven't been paid. I have stopped asking but noticed that she actively avoids me. And it can't be because my work wasn't up to scratch as she used it, extensively.

WouldIwasShookspeared · 01/03/2022 18:10

Yup. Just over 24 years ago I loaned a bloke I'd just met £150 to fix his car.

We've been married 24 years now and he still hasn't paid me back. 😁

EdithStourton · 01/03/2022 18:07

Yep. DH and I, several grand to a relative.
Fucker is still sitting on half of it, about 10 years down the track.

It's amazing how fast you can go off someone when they prove to be untrustworthy.

Ragwort · 01/03/2022 17:58

Yes, twice (stupidly), both times to help someone with deposit/rent up front to prevent them being homeless. Never got it back, disappointing that people are so disrespectful, I think they assumed 'we could afford it' and had no conscience about repaying us.

CleanseUsAcidRain · 01/03/2022 17:51

I paid for a new computer on finance for my mum's boyfriend at the time. It was a buy now, pay later deal and he couldn't pay for it at the time but said he'd pay it off before it cost me anything. An expensive lesson, because I paid that thing off for 3 years totalling around £1.5k, despite many times taking my bank details and promising to set up repayments. I think I saw £50 back. I should have had much more of a backbone about it, but I was 18 and had already been conditioned after years of handing over my savings/birthday money etc. to my mum whenever they needed it to buy food (since the food money had been spent on drugs...). Never saw any of that back either.

TheTurn0fTheScrew · 01/03/2022 10:14

yes, a relative. about £800 which I know doesn't sound like a fortune but I was a student with a p/t job at the time. I got them a second credit card on my account, which was supposed to be to help them through a temporary financial crisis. once they had access to the card I was quite able to see how they'd got into that particular hole in the first place.

So I'm another one who's learned the lesson not to lend what you can't afford to give. I do "lend" the odd tenner here and there now, because I am in the fortunate position of not having to count every penny, and so mentally write it off, and am pleasantly surprised if I see it again.

Mindymomo · 01/03/2022 10:01

Lent £400 to friend to buy new car, this was years ago. She had 4 children so needed a car desperately. First mistake was to say, pay me back when you can, but thought that as she and DH were both working it wouldn’t be long. In the meantime they took family holidays abroad with no mention of the loan and we saw them regularly. Then out of the blue some 5 years later, they repaid the money.

GilesRupert · 01/03/2022 09:55

I lent a friend a lot of money (around 2k) a long time ago which she hasn't paid back. We're still friends and it doesn't impact on our friendship other than I wouldn't lend her money now. I lent it knowing there was a risk I would never see it again. I lived with her at the time and could see how genuinely hard up she was. Trying to get her to pay the money back at the time would have destroyed her. I've written it off.