Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Different between MLM and Pyramid scheme - are any MLMs ok?

59 replies

JustAnotherDayWorkingAtHome · 28/02/2022 09:16

So can someone help me with the above. I found out about some products I liked the sound of but when I looked a bit closer it looks like the company is an MLM. This set alarm bells ringing. Do any of these MLM companies actually sell a legitimate product and are morally sound? I am just now instantly skeptical about something I thought sounded really good.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
YouOKHun · 05/02/2023 15:33

@Jennybeans401 a lot of Usbourne books are also cheaper elsewhere - in reality the reps are the customers. So many people have dropped out of MLM because of the cost of living and the realisation that it’s a hopeless way to make money. This has lead to Usbourne rebranding. They’re about to change their name (I forget what the new name is). This will lead to a new crop of victims who don’t do any due diligence and don’t really connect it to Usbourne. They will experience all the classic problems your friend has had. MLM is a waste of time at best, at worst it’s extremely damaging to people. I really recommend people look at Talanted Ladies Club articles, MLM Lies Exposed on FB and the Anti MLM Coalition website.

Jennybeans401 · 05/02/2023 06:26

A friend of mine sells Usborne books but she says it's hard and can't make a living from it. Her dh is the breadwinner.

She also said that it's very hard finding the books in stock to order them for customers so they have a group where consultants have to ask each other of they can find x book. She said it was frustrating!

whumpthereitis · 05/02/2023 01:10

Because pyramid schemes are illegal, MLM founders got around that by selling shitty products, even though there is no difference in principle: getting people to pour all their money in the hope that they too will get rich as a result. Aka, ‘speculate to accumulate’. It’s not about the product, what they’re selling is a dream.

Hugely popular with Mormon housewives, and in fact you’ll see a lot of MLMs began in Utah (the laws of which are favourable for MLMs, due to lack of regulation of the industry).

LikeAStar1994 · 05/02/2023 01:05

They're all scams. End of.

I refuse to support anybody involved in these. I've been invited to many groups and to 'Like' many pages and so on. I'm so confused by how the person's friends and family don't even tell them it's all a con. But the most likely scenario is they don't know themselves.

Luredbyapomegranate · 05/02/2023 00:54

JustAnotherDayWorkingAtHome · 28/02/2022 09:21

So this sales person says she doesn't make any money from recruiting people....so in that sense it doesn't sound like a pyramid scheme but it has many of the hallmarks of an MLM

She will get a cut off the products you sell.

They are all basically the same

Stay away, or at least keep your eyes open and don’t spend more money than you can afford to loose

ecosystem · 05/02/2023 00:48

If you like the products, go ahead. All companies cost their products to afford their infrastructure, uplines, supervisors, line managers, area managers, managing directors. MLM of not.
Just don't be taken in by misleading claims eg being the only provider of 'pure' essential oils - all reputable, suppliers offer neat essntial oils, However, I find DoTerra oils very expensive and I do research costs as I use essential oils in my work, so like quality and fair price.

YouOKhun · 04/03/2022 12:27

@AuntieStella you’re right Avon doesn’t have expensive products like many MLMs and if someone is a retail customer who has never signed up as seems to be the case with @Aprilx then it’s easy to see why April thinks the reaction is over the top. It’s quite rare that people are pure retail customers and they don’t get damaged.

Unfortunately the reaction to MLM and what it does to people who sign up, isn’t over the top at all with regard to what happens to people who sign up to “sell products” as it’s almost impossible to make money for the vast majority. There’s a huge deception going on about the nature of these businesses which rely on recruitment. Anyone selling product alone is very likely to lose money over all, but people are never given the truth of it and no MLM in the U.K. is required to publish the reality of the losses. Lots of people may be happy to earn small amounts of money on a sporadic basis or lose a bit because they buy more than they sell, but this is not how MLM is sold to people and most enter into MLM very much needing income from it and banking on it being a solution. There’s a lot of bullying of people once they’re in an MLM which can make it difficult to leave too.

Like all scams it attracts people with few options by positioning itself as a solution to whatever someone needs to solve. I’ve seen it damage some very vulnerable people and watched one MLM deliberately target MH patients in one facility where I worked.

Re Avon, you might find this article interesting www.talentedladiesclub.com/articles/is-avon-really-a-better-mlm-or-is-it-a-pyramid-scheme/

AuntieStella · 03/03/2022 07:26

@Itsnotover

Knowing what I know, I always avoid anything that is MLM nowadays. Not least because you will always be overpaying for a relatively inferior product.
I don't want to sound like I'm defending Avon (pending clarification on when they started requiring reps to buy stock), but there's no way their goods can be described as over-priced!
LadyPenelope68 · 03/03/2022 07:22

Same shit, unethical setup just with a different name.

Aprilx · 03/03/2022 07:01

I have been buying most of my cosmetics from an MLM for nearly a decade now. No issues whatsoever, I have no interest in setting up myself as a seller and nobody has ever even hinted that I should look into it. I simply go to a website and order as and when I need, same as I do for anything else. I think there are some over the top reactions on mumsnet.

Itsnotover · 03/03/2022 06:27

Knowing what I know, I always avoid anything that is MLM nowadays. Not least because you will always be overpaying for a relatively inferior product.

AuntieStella · 03/03/2022 06:24

Most people lose money in Avon these days @AuntieStella. There are no territories like in the old days when it was direct selling. It means the market is totally oversaturated. Avon people overbuy stock and can’t sell it - take a look on eBay or FB marketplace sad it’s impossible to make money unless you recruit a large downline and make money from their purchases

Yes, that's a massive change: since when did Avon Ladies have to pre-buy stock? Because the joining fee always used to be really small (just checked website and there's a choice of two welcome Welcome Kits at £10 or £30, and then the rest is making/fulfilling orders by catalogue or own URL for website

You never did make much by just selling - couple of hundred quid per campaign tops usually.

I don't sell Avon, but do buy it. And if they really have changed and are requiring reps to buy stock then I'll be thinking again

HelloBunny · 02/03/2022 22:53

First time I heard of Do Terra was a newly divorced woman of my acquaintance, who was hard up for cash. Exactly the sort of person MLM targets... She was in a sad place & thought this might be the answer.

YouOKhun · 02/03/2022 22:46

@AuntieStella

The only MlM that I don't mind is Avon.

Good products, competitively priced and some very chea.

No weird cultishness, and pretty transparent about what you wouid make if you onoymsell and don't also recruit.

Also, everyone knows what they are and what they're about

Most people lose money in Avon these days @AuntieStella. There are no territories like in the old days when it was direct selling. It means the market is totally oversaturated. Avon people overbuy stock and can’t sell it - take a look on eBay or FB marketplace :( it’s impossible to make money unless you recruit a large downline and make money from their purchases.
YouOKhun · 02/03/2022 22:42

I know you’ve made a decision about Doterra @JustAnotherDayWorkingAtHome and concluded it’s dodgy but I thought I’d include a few more resources for anyone coming across this thread. Doterra and Young Living are awful companies, all MLM are awful but there is a special place in Hell for these two. Both Doterra and YL were fined in the US in 2014 for claiming their oils could cure Ebola! These weren’t claims of misguided and desperate reps but lies straight from HQ. There is independent research that shows that 99.6% of sign ups to MLM lose money once the expenses of trying to make it work are included - it’s a scandal they continue almost totally without regulation in the U.K.

www.MLMtruth.org
www.talentedladiesclub.com/articles/much-money-can-make-doterra/
www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/episode/p076n2hg
www.talentedladiesclub.com/articles/are-mlms-pyramid-schemes-and-other-questions-you-need-to-ask-before-joining-one/

JustAnotherDayWorkingAtHome · 01/03/2022 16:58

I watched the Netflix documentary (Un)Well, I did not think DoTerra came off well in it. Thank you for the recommending it.

I have already had my first voice message from the rep....I am ignoring.

OP posts:
ThatLibraryMiss · 28/02/2022 14:48

If you want essential oils I can recommend id Aromatics in Leeds. They have a very wide range of oils and a good turnover so their oils are fresh. Their prices are good. It's a long-established slightly hippy-ish little shop, not a chain certainly not an MLM.

Staryflight445 · 28/02/2022 13:46

Follow Hattie Rowe on tiktok op.
She explains figures, and general facts as to why these companies are awful.

Ariela · 28/02/2022 12:46

If you're looking to sell essential oils, then I'd look to an ethical company that wholesales, and set up your own brand/shop.

Lots out there with good traceability/story behind the products eg neoils.com/

JustAnotherDayWorkingAtHome · 28/02/2022 12:22

Yes they do @ForTheLoveOfSleep that was one of the first alarm bells...

OP posts:
ForTheLoveOfSleep · 28/02/2022 12:15

Oh my god they actually reccomend you ingest the oils!

Shortpoet · 28/02/2022 12:09

@JustAnotherDayWorkingAtHome

I am not being recruited, I just saw a demo of the products.
If you’re watching a demo of any MLM then you are being recruited.

Sign up and get 25% off is how it starts.

JammyCandy · 28/02/2022 12:01

I would avoid as you will probably end up getting hounded

I went to a beauty party a while ago hosted by a Temple Spa rep and I’ve been so badly hounded since it would put me off going to anything like that again !

The party was marketed as her being a small local beauty therapist just trying to make some money during Covid (party was a virtual party in line with Covid rules before anyone jumps on me!)

SliceOfCakeCupOfTea · 28/02/2022 11:55

@SeasonFinale

OK so you asked. Everyone said avoid.

But you are still arguing that it seems OK.

What thread are you reading?
LizDoingTheCanCan · 28/02/2022 11:23

[quote TigerLilyTail]I don't personally have experience of DoTerra, but I found this well balanced article that seems to answer a lot if your questions.

aromessential.com/best-oil-brands/doterra/[/quote]
An article full of affiliate links is not well balanced!