Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Not want MIL living with us

265 replies

Seema1234 · 28/02/2022 05:59

Our youngest is due to leave home next year.

ILS have no assets (ILs went bankrupt about 20 years ago) and they live in a council house now after losing their home. No reason other than they are hopeless with money and for t hemselves into loads of debt.

MIL has been complaining about her husband (DHs stepdad) for about 20 years. It comes around in full circle and whilst I acknowledge he's a pain , she has never done anything to change her situation.

Yesterday she told DH that she intends on leaving her DH but can't as she has no where to go as no assets. DH then offered for her to move in here once DS goes to university next year. Confused

For context, there is no abuse going on as far as I know. Her DH is just selfish and sometimes she gets fed up of it. I get that.

Im not one of these who dread the children flying the nest Grin. I've had it all planned, looking forward to having the house back to ourselves. .
We wanted to sell up in a few years and maybe buy somewhere smaller. We had plans to travel, lots of weekends away and want to live in a particular place for a year.

Now MIL is going to scupper all of that. Once she's here that will be it. She's 75 now , so that could be another 20 years of me looking after an elderly woman who has nowhere to go.

I just feel Angry. Their financial screw ups have had alot of impact on us over the years. They turn to us whenever they want money, which has been alot.

I'm hoping it won't happen , but she texted me yesterday to thank us as now she knows she can leave stepdad.

Aibu?

OP posts:
Toddlerteaplease · 28/02/2022 12:46

I'd be seriously pissed off that your husband agreed to it without asking you. I'd be moving out if she moves in!

NowEvenBetter · 28/02/2022 12:45

People prattling on about how they personally would care for their own parent, in completely different circumstances and it’s cultural for them. Irrelevant to the OP. Contributes zero to the thread and has derailed it.

NowEvenBetter · 28/02/2022 12:43

Topic for its own thread then.

Motherofgorgons · 28/02/2022 12:42

@NowEvenBetter

Why not start a thread about culture or whatever it is yous are derailing the thread with? Ffs.
I will when people stop comparing this to FGM. FFS. And culture isn't "whatever it is". I will discuss what I want, thanks.
downtonabbeyfan1234 · 28/02/2022 12:40

@Motherofgorgons that's great to hear. My DS has told me some of his friends parents have explicitly forbid moving out to uni. Made me feel a bit sad.

NowEvenBetter · 28/02/2022 12:39

Why not start a thread about culture or whatever it is yous are derailing the thread with? Ffs.

Motherofgorgons · 28/02/2022 12:37

[quote downtonabbeyfan1234]@Motherofgorgons I also thought in asian culture the DC stays at home and commutes to uni?

Rereading this thread from the start makes me realise how wrong and stupid I was. Sorry OP, YANBU.[/quote]
Mine won't be, most likely. I didn't have an arranged marriage either. We come in all models:)

godmum56 · 28/02/2022 12:36

@herehere22

WOW so he's taken the decision to invite her without ASKING YOU????????????

I'd just tell him " she won't be moving in " that's that no explanations needed.
If he wants to live with his mummy then he can go rent somewhere with her and move in with her.

yup this. DO NOT threaten to move out. If anyone moves out it should be him.
downtonabbeyfan1234 · 28/02/2022 12:35

@Motherofgorgons I also thought in asian culture the DC stays at home and commutes to uni?

Rereading this thread from the start makes me realise how wrong and stupid I was. Sorry OP, YANBU.

affairsofdragons · 28/02/2022 12:31

Tell your DH it's a Hard No from you and that she is not welcome to move in ever. It will be a marriage ender if he tries.

If he wants to house her, he can move out and rent a flat somewhere with her, but she's not living in your home with you. you did not sign on for that. And you can proceed with a divorce.

Motherofgorgons · 28/02/2022 12:30

@kittykutty I agree that the unquestionable duty towards parents is not a good thing. Many of my friends from this culture are absolute slaves and the OP's support of her inlaws for years seems excessive.

As OP hasn't returned, I guess we don't know if there are indeed cultural reasons. I can see many Asian men just saying yes to everything their mother suggests without thinking twice out because of sheer emotional blackmail.

autienotnaughty · 28/02/2022 12:25

@downtonabbeyfan1234 taking care of yes if needed and you are happy to do so. It doesn't sound like mil needs taking care of more a free house. And it would definitely need discussing first.

herehere22 · 28/02/2022 12:23

WOW so he's taken the decision to invite her without ASKING YOU????????????

I'd just tell him " she won't be moving in " that's that no explanations needed.
If he wants to live with his mummy then he can go rent somewhere with her and move in with her.

kittykutty · 28/02/2022 12:22

@downtonabbeyfan1234

Okay talk about it etc. Why is adult children taking care of their elderly relatives such a bad thing?

She doesn't need 'help' she just made bad life choices ie. debt. So it's not like someone getting ill without it being in their control. She's only 75 and could live there for ages. It's op's mil not her mother. She already borrows money from them and can't support herself.

Also I'm from a similar background. The unquestionable duty towards parents is NOT a good thing at all. You're expected to care for your parents (just because they chose to have sex and have a child) whether they were nice people or not. Parent treats you bad? It's your mother, you have to treat her well!

IamtheDevilsAvocado · 28/02/2022 12:19

@downtonabbeyfan1234

Okay talk about it etc. Why is adult children taking care of their elderly relatives such a bad thing?
Cos it means (often) women end up having no life outside caring responsibilities... And many of us... Don't WANT this
downtonabbeyfan1234 · 28/02/2022 12:14

Re-read OPs posts. Yeah I was in the wrong.

But I don't think the entire concept of living with elderly relatives is all that bad. Especially if they help with child care.... but that IS NOT the case here.

Migrainesbythedozen · 28/02/2022 12:10

@Motherofgorgons That's good that it works for your family then. OP's situation seems very different.

Pluvia · 28/02/2022 12:08

I'd text her back saying 'Apparently DH said you could come and live with us. He was trying to be kind but he didn't discuss it with me and had no right to make such an offer. The arrangement he's offered doesn't suit me. If you want to leave your husband we'll help you do that — but you're not moving in with us.'

If she's experiencing domestic violence/ coercive control then she needs to speak to the council, tell them that she needs to leave, and ask for help. They may be able to find her a place in some kind of sheltered housing. Otherwise she can divorce her husband and then, as a single elderly person with no assets, apply for housing.

I would be having very strong words with my partner if they, without any discussion, made this kind of offer. His behaviour is completely unacceptable and indicates a worrying lack of respect for you. Good luck.

Abracadabra12345 · 28/02/2022 12:06

@autienotnaughty

Also my kids came back loads when they were at uni and moved home after til could afford not to. I would say sorry but no.
Same here.
Motherofgorgons · 28/02/2022 12:06

Oh multi-generational living is not the same as FGM, for god's sake. One of the reasons why my SIL happily lives with my MIL is because my SIL is a busy doctor working odd hours and my MIL helps with childcare., cooking, cleaning and so forth.

Obviously this does not apply to the OP, but the black and white attitudes on this thread are a bit OTT.

Motherofgorgons · 28/02/2022 12:04

[quote Migrainesbythedozen]**@Motherofgorgons* I have deduced this from her name but I could be wrong. I am not saying she should do any eldercare. Just that it may be more complex than just saying no.
My own DH and I have decided that we will take care of my mum in our home ( because she is easy to live with) and his sister will take care of his mum ( who helps with childcare) while he makes long visits to give her a break. But we hope that neither will be going into a home. Obviously most people can't do this and should not be expected to.*

Whatever happened to your mother/the women learning to live on their own two feet? This is 2022, I could understand it if it was the mid 1900s. Some elements of some culture truly need to change/be stopped.[/quote]
She is in her mid 70s and lives alone now and does everything on her own- on the internet- which she has learnt to do in the pandemic. I am talking about when she is in her 80s or if she has some kind of sudden illness and can't live alone. We are lucky to have room for her, which OP likely does not. It is probably relevant that she is very good company, and was a fantastic mother, going above and beyond to help me out in every life crisis.

My mother-in-law could not manage to live alone as she is not educated and can barely read English. There are still women in 2022 who did not have the benefit of an education. I have to admit that if I had to live with my MIL, I couldn't manage it because she is a very difficult woman. But my sister in law likes to live with her and they help each other out. Cultures are different.

midlifecrash · 28/02/2022 12:02

So he has invited her, without asking you. Probably thinking if she comes to need care, you will do it, and that will make him feel generous and caring.

I would kill him.

CallyfromBlakes7 · 28/02/2022 12:02

My mum had this. She told my father there was no way my grandmother was moving in. She (my mum) was all the bitches in creation, but grandmother went into a home. We had a two bedroom bungalow at the time so there really wasn't room and I was at university so hadn't moved out properly.

Just say no.

Migrainesbythedozen · 28/02/2022 11:58

@downtonabbeyfan1234

I'm looking at it from the husbands view. It's his mum, the woman who raised him. Ok yes it's very U OP was not told or consulted.

If your mum was in trouble would you not help?

In many cultures it's normal to have multiple generations living together. Helps share costs etc.

@downtonabbeyfan1234 I'm looking at it from the husbands view.

And that's the problem! Why aren't you looking at it from the WIFE'S point of view??? After all, she is the one that will be cooking, cleaning, wiping the MIL's arse. She is the one who will have her life impacted! Her husband won't lift a finger! And yes, it may be normal in many 'cultures' (so is FGM) that doesn't make it right. And it should not be supported or encouraged. It's clearly not OPs culture, or the culture of most of us. And the OP doesn't want her life changed because DH's mother is a user and bludger. Time his mother took responsibility for herself instead of going through life bludging off everyone else.

downtonabbeyfan1234 · 28/02/2022 11:53

I'm looking at it from the husbands view. It's his mum, the woman who raised him. Ok yes it's very U OP was not told or consulted.

If your mum was in trouble would you not help?

In many cultures it's normal to have multiple generations living together. Helps share costs etc.

Swipe left for the next trending thread