Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Earnings v Household chores

145 replies

Notdishwashersafe · 27/02/2022 20:07

Is there an income level where you would be happy for your OH not to do a single thing round the house?

Say, they had the big job earning £200k would that be enough for you to be happy to take it all on or is it still reasonable to ask that they pull their weight at home?

If not, is there a figure (£300k/ £400k or whatever) or would you expect someone living in your household to contribute to its smooth running regardless of the £££ they bring in?

OP posts:
NotMyDayJob · 28/02/2022 10:27

My H earns over £200k (although I'd class him as a high earner not a super high earner compared to some here). He still helps out with day to day chores (dishwasher etc) but we do have help around the house, not everyday so we both need to keep things ticking. When he's working late or away then he does less but that doesn't take away from the fact I work full time too. He's very happy to buy in whatever help we need, but we're not in a housekeeper every day territory. The key thing for me is engagement with our DD. If he was not taking her to parties without an extremely good reason (we generally take turns) that would be a deal breaker for me. Staying out to get out of bedtime etc, I'd leave him. If he doesn't feel up to bedtime we talk about it (again we try to take turns). I've actually just started mat leave but there is no expectation I'll necessarily do more, certainly not initially. In fact he's asked me what other help we need. So in answer to your question, no the amount your husband earns doesn't allow him to check out of family life. Especially if you're working too.

ByHook0rByCrook · 28/02/2022 10:18

I wouldn't be in a partnership with the person, then, would I? If home can't be egalitarian then nowhere can. I'd rather be single and poor than stuck in a wealthy marriage whilst carrying all the mental load. No.

formalineadeline · 28/02/2022 10:18

@G5000

all the bills, Mots etc op? That takes up a lot of time

No it doesn't. If your DH has convinced you that 'dealing with bills' is a full time job and equivalent to daily cooking, cleaning and childcare, you've been had.

If it wasn't so tragic, it would be funny how many men manage to convince women that all the occasional ad hoc quick jobs are really difficult and time consuming and of course more than equate to the daily and weekly jobs required to keep the family alive and healthy.

Taking the bins out, bills, MOTs, mowing the lawn, putting up the odd shelf, etc - quick, easy, occasional jobs that in no way whatsoever equate to daily food prep/cooking, shopping, parenting, caring for children, cleaning, etc.

Taking the bins out is one of the easiest chores there is - no wonder so many men claim it as theirs to get out of actually time consuming or difficult responsibilities. "Oh no, I couldn't possibly cook a meal for my family, I already spent two minutes this week taking the bins out and I am exhausted."

Jamnation · 28/02/2022 10:16

it's about mutual respect, mutual support, teamwork though, isn't it? It's a marriage, it's meant to be a partnership.

www.google.com/amp/s/www.huffpost.com/entry/she-divorced-me-i-left-dishes-by-the-sink_b_9055288/amp

Comms are clearly not great - I wouldn't accept 2 parties at the same time without checking with DH about covering both. But it's not surprising that's broken down a bit when DH just expects to OP to do every single task he just doesn't fancy. That isn't how partnerships work. OP imagine he was working with a colleague at the same grade as him - would he treat that colleague as he treats you? Weirdly, if not then at least you have something to work with! I would maybe think about re-establishing the equality of the partnership, taking back the respect.

Cinnabomb · 28/02/2022 10:08

DH earns about £400k equivalent, we love abroad. We have about £15k/month after tax. However because of the specific nature of his job his hours are capped and it’s not that stressful. If he has an easy day, he will do dinner and bath/ bed time. He will do odd bits like general wiping surfaces or the high chair etc. We have a cleaner but no other nanny etc as where we live we don’t really need one. However for years prior I was the high earner and still did 100% of the household stuff, so the dynamics change as the situation does. I wouldn’t appreciate the mindset if he refused to lift a finger, as I still think both partners should be present for children regardless of earnings.

shinynewapple22 · 28/02/2022 10:08

@OfstedOffred

It's not about what he earns it's about the hours we each work outside the home.

DH earns double what I do. I work about 2/3 the hours he does overall, so I tend to pick up about 2/3 the household chores and he does the other 1/3.

I think income comes into it if someone can pay to outsource a lot but you can't outsource much mental load or parenting.

Agree with this. DH and I had similar earning jobs but I dropped to part time after having DC - therefore I did the majority of child care and household tasks .

As another posters have said - if either of us had had very high earning roles then tasks such as cleaning and gardening would have been outsourced .

SlipperyLizard · 28/02/2022 10:06

I used to work with men (lawyers) who would, as far as I could tell, deliberately stay in the office until they knew bedtime would be done. I don’t work in a sector that requires long hours, which is why I think it was deliberate. They are also the sort to complain about how little their wives now earn (having taken a joint decision that she would opt for less work or a lower paid job).

I despised them for it.

For reference, I am by far the higher earner and still think that DH & I should be jointly responsible for housework & childcare.

Chely · 28/02/2022 10:02

Not about money.
I allow dh to get away with doing very little household stuff because he works away and doesn't get much time at home. I am a sahm though, I would expect more from him if I was working too or he was home more often.

mizzo · 28/02/2022 10:00

He claims he hoovers but I know for a fact this has not happened in 2022 (this was his justification for not increasing the cleaner's hours). He honestly thinks he pulls his weight

You shouldn't need his permission to increase the cleaners hours.

G5000 · 28/02/2022 09:56

all the bills, Mots etc op? That takes up a lot of time

No it doesn't. If your DH has convinced you that 'dealing with bills' is a full time job and equivalent to daily cooking, cleaning and childcare, you've been had.

PrimroseTheSmooth · 28/02/2022 09:53

I agree with @Jvg33.

I think some men focus too much on efficiency in a very literal way and are inclined to think "ah well, if DW has got the domestic side covered, I can best contribute by spending longer at work to get that bonus I'm hoping for" (or whatever). They don't see that time spent with their partner and children is beneficial for everyone, even if it's not maximally efficient to have two parents around when one could probably cope. A bit of positive encouragement can go a long way in helping them see that that they will also be making a much-appreciated contribution simply by being around and doing the ordinary day-to-day bits of life.

No way of knowing whether OP's husband is in this category, of course, but he might be.

pointythings · 28/02/2022 09:52

@Jvg33

Who deals with all the bills, Mots etc op? That takes up a lot of time. I know things sounds difficult to do when you are annoyed at your partner but it is a fake it until you make it scenario. Positive enco
Bills and MOTs take up a lot of time? Really? This single parent has been doing all of that stuff since day 1, including holding down a full time job, both while H was alive and afterwards. What a ridiculous thing to say.
Jvg33 · 28/02/2022 09:26

[quote Totalwasteofpaper]@Jvg33
😅😅😅
Are you the OP's husband or just a general handmaiden?
Maybe share a few links about how to submit to your husband effectively to "help" the OP

healthychristianhome.com/submissive-wife/

👍👍👍[/quote]
I'm no slave in my home. My husband loves spending time with his kids. Honestly, I know it's hard when your partner has annoyed you etc. You are more likely to get what you want with someone using positive encouragement.

PrimroseTheSmooth · 28/02/2022 09:25

DH earns many times the amount suggested. He doesn't do much round the house because he works long hours- 8am-10pm is pretty typical and it's sometimes much later. He also has a lot of international travel. However, when he is here and not working he certainly does his part of the day-to-day stuff (loading the dishwasher, setting the table or whatever).

He doesn't do proper cleaning (scrubbing the loo, hoovering etc) but neither do I. We have a cleaner twice a week who does all the cleaning and ironing. I do all the cooking, admin and household management, child wrangling etc and switched from a job with long hours to a 9-5 role in order to do so. DH does the gardening because he enjoys it and it's a way to de-stress: if he didn't, we would get a gardener. It works for us.

OP, I don't think being a higher earner gets you off household chores but I do think long hours are relevant: clearly if someone is working late every night, they have less time to clean etc.

What struck me about your posts is less that your DH earns a lot or works long hours and more that you suspect he's using work as an excuse not to engage in family life. I would find that extremely frustrating. Sounds like you need to talk to him about his prioritising work at all times, and about the fact that you also work. However, no one on here can tell you whether he's actually taking the piss and staying longer at work than necessary or doing work in order to get out of chores at home.

I think all the stuff about never lifting a finger at home is a red herring. You'd need multiple full time staff to do this which most people would find both unaffordable and undesirable.

eurochick · 28/02/2022 08:54

You are asking the wrong question. This isn't about money. He needs to participate in family life or leave. At the moment he is just a dead weight.

Totalwasteofpaper · 28/02/2022 08:51

@Jvg33
😅😅😅
Are you the OP's husband or just a general handmaiden?
Maybe share a few links about how to submit to your husband effectively to "help" the OP

healthychristianhome.com/submissive-wife/

👍👍👍

Jvg33 · 28/02/2022 08:42

*Positive encouragement wins the race. Please can you come with us to X, I really want your company. It will be more enjoyable with you there etc

Jvg33 · 28/02/2022 08:39

Who deals with all the bills, Mots etc op? That takes up a lot of time. I know things sounds difficult to do when you are annoyed at your partner but it is a fake it until you make it scenario. Positive enco

pitterpatterrain · 28/02/2022 08:37

Yup he sounds like a muppet

I can just imagine that conversation with DH … “according to some bloke as I earn over X I no longer need to do anything at home…” 🤣

Your value and contribution to the household isn’t defined by wage

SushiGo · 28/02/2022 08:25

Absolutely not.

Chores aren't about money, and while hours worked will inevitably play a part (everyone should have equal rest time) but it's also about setting good patterns and lessons for your children who are watching your parenting dynamic and how much respect you have for each other.

Totalwasteofpaper · 28/02/2022 08:25

You are still working 9-4 Confused
That's hardly a part time job...!

He is not being fair at all!!!!

Can you go back to your" proper" well paid career? I would be looking at options honestly as talking isn't working with him.

Totalwasteofpaper · 28/02/2022 08:20

@FlippityFlippityFlop

Short answer NO - everyone living in the house should be involved in smooth running of the house.

Long answer - if one partner is bringing in 200k+ AND the other is a SAHP then the person at home should do more of the organising (I would also expect on this salary that quite a few things would be outsourced - i.e. having a cleaner/nanny etc). Obviously the split of who does what changes if both partners work out of the home. And weekends should definitely be shared whatever the situation. Just because one person in the partnership earns more doesn't absolve them doing anything - if that's what they want then they should employ a housekeeper/maid/cook!

This.

Your husband sounds like he has totally checked out of everything and abdicated responsibility entirely to you.

This wouldn't be okay for me at any salary level in theory.

In reality if it was my lovely DH and he was earning £1m + a year and we could outsource EVERYTHING (I mean hire an FTE nanny housekeeper, driver, gardener)
I'd probably make my peace with him not helping run the house. HOWEVER Attending family events (eg the days with your family) and being part of family life would be non negotiable at any salary.

200k in London isn't enough for him to check out.
I earned that now and still unstack the dishwasher, clean the bathroom. And pick up dog poop etc #TheGlamour

whysoserious123 · 28/02/2022 08:11

@whysoserious123

Wages are irrelevant, the amount of hours relevant

Standard working hours for whatever wage I would expect help from either them and or a cleaner

Lots of working hours then I'd expect solely me to do it and or a cleaner if we could afford the help

When I say lots I mean LOTS not 8-6 over 5 days a week
whysoserious123 · 28/02/2022 08:10

Wages are irrelevant, the amount of hours relevant

Standard working hours for whatever wage I would expect help from either them and or a cleaner

Lots of working hours then I'd expect solely me to do it and or a cleaner if we could afford the help

stuntbubbles · 28/02/2022 08:08

This isn't about money, this is about being a dick.
This! DP earns twice as much as I do and he still does 50/50 nursery runs and bedtimes, and despite long hours is perfectly capable of finding the time to clean the dishwasher filter or run a hoover around. And when he had a long commute he’d still take the howling demon baby from me the moment he stepped in the door, because all day with a howling baby trumped a day at work and a train journey.

There’s no amount of money he could earn that would make me like and respect him if he felt the money earned him a get-out-of-family-life pass. Yes, we’d pay to outsource stuff, but he’d still need to do the share of admin for the outsourcing – who books, pays and preps for the cleaner? That sort of thing.