Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Mandela Effect

361 replies

GrandTheftWalrus · 27/02/2022 19:26

Just been reading up on this and it's fascinating.

One of mine is the monopoly man not having a monocle, I could've swore he did.

Anyone else have any good ones?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
12
NippyWoowoo · 28/02/2022 09:33

@DoorWasAJar

Looney Tunes was Looney Toons, for me as a child. I know for a fact Febreeze was spelled like this and not Febreze Hmm

Just don’t know why.

Both of those are answered by psychology. The brain automatically 'fills in the gaps' so to speak and corrects extra words, fills in omissions, fixes spelling and grammar. Both of your example make sense, because you were watching 'toons and 'breeze' is the correct spelling.

A lot of Mandela effect instances are examples of this

AliceMcK · 28/02/2022 09:26

@tothesea

I can remember the first series of Friends had different opening credits but there is nothing on-line about it and no-one else remembers it. It ended with them sitting on a sofa with their backs to the camera and one of them turned the lamp off but they were outside. Weird.
I remember this but I didn’t start watching friends until years after it came out. I think I remember this from a rerun or possibly a documentary or something else relating to the show. It may even have been a music video. I lived overseas for years where friends was constantly replayed over and over so it may have been there I saw it but I definitely remember seeing it somewhere.
sashh · 28/02/2022 09:25

tothesea

How odd, did you mention the desert? Or did I misread? You just mentioned the sofa and the light, that's in the credits.

AliceMcK

Unless you were watching Irish TV, the match wasn't on live, it was being recorded for Match of the day but was being shown live on an Irish TV channel.

But then that could be another false memory or indeed the Mandela effect?

AliceMcK · 28/02/2022 09:15

@OhWhyNot

Mine is a sad one. I remembered watching the tragedy of Hillsborough unfold

But I am not a football fan and no one is my household was a Liverpool or Nottingham Forrest supporter more likely the racing was on and interrupted by the news and we then watched it

But in my memory I am watching the match and can see players looking into the crowd and we are discussing it at home saying something seems wrong. I think this is quite a common experience

Also the same with seeing the second plane fly into the Twin Towers. Few of us would have seen this live as it happened but so many are absolutely sure they did

Absolutely with Hillsbourgh. My Dad was very much a racing man and it was always on in our house, though he liked football so could have had the game on too, even if it wasn’t his team playing. Anyway I remember walking downstairs, we had open plan stairs that came into the lounge, I remember standing next to my dad and the players watching the crowds. The images I have in my head of that day aren’t available anywhere, but I’m guessing that’s because of all the coverup and media (The Sun) shit show that happened afterwards.
MarshaBradyo · 28/02/2022 09:12

The 52 states one is so odd

I’m sure I remember being corrected when I was a child re 50 as two had been added

How are so many thinking this?

Onionpatch · 28/02/2022 09:10

I also thought new zealand moved in relation to Australis when i looked at a map a couple of weeks ago

KnobJockey · 28/02/2022 09:03

I thought I remembered the 2nd plane flying in live too. To be honest, I remember awful scenes on the day of people leaping from one of the towers to their death, as it was live, and I thought that the news channels had censored that and the second tower being hit from future viewings, for good reason.

throughtheair · 28/02/2022 08:57

The laughing cow now has cheese triangles in its ears rather than earrings

KrisAkabusi · 28/02/2022 08:54

@SickAndTiredAgain

I definitely saw the second plane fly in live. I was watching it on TV with my Mum and we were looking at the smoke coming out of the first tower then saw the plane crash into the second one. Definitely didn't imagine it! It was live on the news.

I think the Mandela effect with 9/11 is actually to do with the first plane, not the second. Lots of people swear they remember seeing it hit the tower on the day, but there was no footage of it available then - which makes sense given it was 2001 so people couldn’t tweet it etc, and no reason for news stations to have cameras pointing at it. So the news didn’t get footage until later - by coincidence there were a handful of people filming anyway and caught it. But lots of people are sure they remember it.

There was footage of the second plane because of course by then there were lots of news cameras pointing at it.

There's a fascinating study in America where every year the same 1000 Americans are asked for their memories of 9/11. The memories are changing over time to fit in with public perception of what people think happened, like the second plane example. Memory is very very fickle and cannot be trusted over time.
queenofarles · 28/02/2022 08:46

Yes I always thought there were 52 states .

Also in the poster of Uncle Sam , his hat is blue and white! Not red and white , everyone thinks it’s red and white for some reason.

My personal one and for many others I spoke to about is from Don McLeans American pie song,
"The Lennon/lenin read a book on Marx."

It’s A quartet practiced in the park , not The quartet practised in the park , so it changes the whole interpretation of this line , he is not actually talking about the Beatles Shock

SamphiretheStickerist · 28/02/2022 08:44

@ReeseWitherfork

Just listened to We Are The Champions on Spotify and it ends on the word "champions". No "of the world". But the Live Aid version adds it at the end.
This. He added "of the world" because it made sense, for the occasion.

But the album track ends with a wonderful uncertainty, as if the refrain will carry in forever, self congratulatory and sheer Freddie.

SliceOfCakeCupOfTea · 28/02/2022 08:39

@tothesea

sashh and others I’m not talking about the credits that everyone knows. I’m talking about different opening credits. All I can remember is that they were outside but in a desert type setting rather than the fountain. I guess it doesn’t count as a Mandela effect as no one else remembers it. But I could swear on it. I remember noticing when it changed.
But it was set in New York, why would they be in a desert? I'd love to see the version you remember!
tothesea · 28/02/2022 08:36

sashh and others I’m not talking about the credits that everyone knows. I’m talking about different opening credits. All I can remember is that they were outside but in a desert type setting rather than the fountain. I guess it doesn’t count as a Mandela effect as no one else remembers it. But I could swear on it. I remember noticing when it changed.

covetingthepreciousthings · 28/02/2022 08:36

@Mollysocks

Mine are that I could’ve honestly sworn the cartoons ‘Looney Tunes’ were ‘Looney Toons’ as I remember thinking as a child, the ‘toons were shorts for cartoons. I can even see it written ‘toons in my mind.
Yes this!
Mollysocks · 28/02/2022 08:23

Mine are that I could’ve honestly sworn the cartoons ‘Looney Tunes’ were ‘Looney Toons’ as I remember thinking as a child, the ‘toons were shorts for cartoons. I can even see it written ‘toons in my mind.

IsAnybodyListening · 28/02/2022 08:18

Like others, I saw some of Mandelas funeral on TV as a kid. I remember thousands of people turning out, lots of bright coloured clothing, a huge procession. Even my DM telling me who he was in life etc...I even remember these railings around a building with people standing on.

Except apparently that didn't happen according to the rest of the world.

Slidey23 · 28/02/2022 08:08

C3PO has a silver right lower leg when most of us think he was all gold!

Shock
beastlyslumber · 28/02/2022 08:05

@FatOaf

He wasn't the leader of SA when he was in prison.

But the people who think he died in prison presumably think he was dead throughout the 5 years he was president of South Africa.

Not necessarily. I presume people think he died in prison and were surprised when he was released.
dworky · 28/02/2022 07:55

@MrsPelligrinoPetrichor

Cheese and onion crisps were in a green packet I swear....apparently they weren't.Confused
They always were until Walkers flipped the colours.
FatOaf · 28/02/2022 07:55

He wasn't the leader of SA when he was in prison.

But the people who think he died in prison presumably think he was dead throughout the 5 years he was president of South Africa.

FatOaf · 28/02/2022 07:52

Also, St John's Ambulance actually being called St John Ambulance troubles me

When people were referring to Covid research coming out if the USA (which has had 50 states since 1959), they kept referring to "John Hopkins University". It's Johns Hopkins University.

St John ambulance is a descendant of the Sovereign Military and Hospitaller Order of St John of Jerusalem, of Rhodes and of Malta (Knights Hospitaller), one of the military monastic orders founded during the crusades. This is why the cross of St John is referred to as a Maltese cross. It's an ambulance service operated by the Order of St John (St John Ambulance), rather than an ambulance belonging to St John (St John's Ambulance).

beastlyslumber · 28/02/2022 07:50

@Fridafever

People who thought Mandela died in prison - do you have a memory of an alternative SA leader for that period or just a gap?
He wasn't the leader of SA when he was in prison.
OldTinHat · 28/02/2022 07:34

My head hurts after reading all of these!

ChristmasFluff · 28/02/2022 07:32

I have a few Mandela effects, and yes, some I could put down to misremembering.

But some of them I can't. For instance - Australia is now in the wrong place. I was completely astounded to see Australia is now positioned so that New Zealand is at 4 o'clock, not 2 o'clock. This doesn't even make sense, because it makes New Zealand the true 'Land Down Under'.

And Australia used to be miles from any other land except Tasmania. Now there's loads of islands close to it at the top.

This isn't just that I didn't know where Australia and New Zealand were - I'd grown up with a very clear picture of them, thanks to school maps, geography etc. When I found out, I ran to check my globe - and I swear it had changed! I'd have noticed if Australia had been in the wrong place before!

Asking other people where on the clock New Zealand is in relation to Australia, my experience has been that amongst people around my age (mid-late50s) there's an even split between 2 o'clock and 4 o'clock. Around my son's age (20) it is all 4 o'clock.

VelvetChairGirl · 28/02/2022 07:29

[quote PinkButtercups]@VelvetChairGirl why are you being so rude and so defensive over a pack of bloody golden wonders cheese and onion. Also, walkers cheese and onion are top tier.[/quote]
I am being me if you think I am rude thats your problem