Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Mandela Effect

361 replies

GrandTheftWalrus · 27/02/2022 19:26

Just been reading up on this and it's fascinating.

One of mine is the monopoly man not having a monocle, I could've swore he did.

Anyone else have any good ones?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
12
OldTinHat · 28/02/2022 07:12

@WestendVBroadway Hawaii Five O - omg!!! Mind blown...🤯

Claymorekick · 28/02/2022 07:08

@Fridafever

People who thought Mandela died in prison - do you have a memory of an alternative SA leader for that period or just a gap?
I was at university when I could swear Mandela had died so not really aware of foreign leaders in any way so never really had any thoughts on who the SA leader was or was not.

Besides, in my world, he died before he became leader so there wouldn't have been a gap.

sashh · 28/02/2022 06:59

@OhWhyNot

Mine is a sad one. I remembered watching the tragedy of Hillsborough unfold

But I am not a football fan and no one is my household was a Liverpool or Nottingham Forrest supporter more likely the racing was on and interrupted by the news and we then watched it

But in my memory I am watching the match and can see players looking into the crowd and we are discussing it at home saying something seems wrong. I think this is quite a common experience

Also the same with seeing the second plane fly into the Twin Towers. Few of us would have seen this live as it happened but so many are absolutely sure they did

I think these are such common false 'memories'.

I was in the kitchen with the radio on and there was an announcement that there had been a pitch invasion, then back to the music, then it was something more serious, that's when I, and probably half the country put the TV on.

BUT the games was being recorded to be shown later so the news and other programs showed the start of the trouble, the game being stopped and the unfolding horror.

So, you, like most of us able to understand at the time did see both the live pictures and the news coverage and they have blended.

With the twin towers, I think I saw the second plane hit, watching live TV and seeing the towers collapse, but again I don't know if I did see the plane hit or if the news footage which put things in chronological order.

I'm half convinced I saw the first plane hit because of the footage but no one was filming at that time, it's only by accident there is any footage at all.

I can remember the first series of Friends had different opening credits but there is nothing on-line about it and no-one else remembers it. It ended with them sitting on a sofa with their backs to the camera and one of them turned the lamp off but they were outside. Weird.

It's the end credits

It was recreated in Ghosts

SickAndTiredAgain · 28/02/2022 06:45

I definitely saw the second plane fly in live. I was watching it on TV with my Mum and we were looking at the smoke coming out of the first tower then saw the plane crash into the second one. Definitely didn't imagine it! It was live on the news.

I think the Mandela effect with 9/11 is actually to do with the first plane, not the second. Lots of people swear they remember seeing it hit the tower on the day, but there was no footage of it available then - which makes sense given it was 2001 so people couldn’t tweet it etc, and no reason for news stations to have cameras pointing at it. So the news didn’t get footage until later - by coincidence there were a handful of people filming anyway and caught it. But lots of people are sure they remember it.

There was footage of the second plane because of course by then there were lots of news cameras pointing at it.

Zonder · 28/02/2022 06:42

@Fridafever

People who thought Mandela died in prison - do you have a memory of an alternative SA leader for that period or just a gap?
That's what I was wondering. Or did they think he was dead until he got released?
TheNeverEndingOver · 28/02/2022 06:42

@ButtercupOfFlorin

Queen most definitely sing ‘of the world’ in We Are The Champions - very easy to have checked this!
We’re talking about the final line of the song.
OverByYer · 28/02/2022 06:25

@Vanellopee

I find these interesting, but none of the common examples resonate with me.
Same here
Fridafever · 28/02/2022 06:21

People who thought Mandela died in prison - do you have a memory of an alternative SA leader for that period or just a gap?

YetAnotherCupOfTea · 28/02/2022 04:28

@tothesea

I can remember the first series of Friends had different opening credits but there is nothing on-line about it and no-one else remembers it. It ended with them sitting on a sofa with their backs to the camera and one of them turned the lamp off but they were outside. Weird.
Could this have been one of the “Chums” bits on SMTV with Ant Dec and Cat?
RavenclawsRoar · 28/02/2022 03:57

I used to obsessively watch the oops I did it again video by britney when it came out and she never had a head set. She usually had those headsets in live performances and often wore catsuits (maybe even the same red one as the video) so I think people just picture her that way. Also the official doll / barbie always had the headset with each costume.

user976327855 · 28/02/2022 02:16

[quote PinkButtercups]@VelvetChairGirl why are you being so rude and so defensive over a pack of bloody golden wonders cheese and onion. Also, walkers cheese and onion are top tier.[/quote]
This

JaneJeffer · 28/02/2022 01:34

@tothesea

I can remember the first series of Friends had different opening credits but there is nothing on-line about it and no-one else remembers it. It ended with them sitting on a sofa with their backs to the camera and one of them turned the lamp off but they were outside. Weird.
PyongyangKipperbang · 28/02/2022 01:24

I just remembered one of mine......that Clive Dunn was dead many many years before he was.

Apparently he was only in his 40's when he played Cpl Jones in Dad's Army, which lead to a lot of people thinking he must have died a lot earlier than he did.

blameless · 28/02/2022 01:15

Flying the Union Flag upside-down is a very discreet distress signal.

Thanks for the Mandela reminder - wondered why you never hear Free Nelson Mandela on the radio any more ... it's actually just called Nelson Mandela, so I even caught myself out.

PyongyangKipperbang · 28/02/2022 01:15

I have a friend who writes quizzes for a job and he did HUGE research into the We Are The Champions thing.....and it was never an official version but became known because of Live Aid.

I am fascinated by the Mandela Effect. I have had many of those although oddly, never the Mandela one :o

KellsBells77 · 28/02/2022 01:11

@needmoreshinys

I think the 52 States of America comes from the fact that in schools they use to teach its 50 States of America and Alaska and Hawaii instead of Its 50 States of America including Alaska and Hawaii
The theft of Hawaii made It 50.

Hopefully the Hawaiian people gain their independence (and soon). The great Hawaiian singer and sovereignty activist Israel Kamakawiwoʻole (most famously sang “Over the rainbow”) sadly never got to see his land become free, but hopefully those who are alive today will.

Sunsetzs · 28/02/2022 01:10

A yellow cheese and onion packet actually makes sense.

Blue for salt and vinegar makes sense because if the association with fish and chips and sea salt and the sea.

Not sure what actually "makes sense" for a green packet. Something with the word pickle in it, because pickles are green? But then usually the flavour is pickle onion and they are... Not green. Hmm

Brown makes sense for BBQ, pink for prawns works, and that darker brownish pink for smokey bacon.

MatildaJayne · 28/02/2022 01:09

Golden Wonder and Smiths were the competing crisp manufactures of my childhood and salt and vinegar was blue, cheese and onion green. Then Walkers took off with their reversed colours. So not a false memory, rather people being too young to remember the older brands dominance changing to Walkers.

Alway knew there was 50 states, 50 stars. Hawaii 5 - oh helps with that. 52 weeks in a year and 52 cards in a deck, though.

I can clearly remember Nelson Mandela being freed and becoming President of SA. Remember the news coverage, it was fantastic!

I’ve never actually seen Snow White all the way through, just clips on Disney Time. Mirror, mirror was how the fairytale was translated, though.

Freddy Mercury did sing, ‘of the world’ sometimes.

Some of the others are just common misquotes which become more famous than the original.

knitnerd90 · 28/02/2022 01:07

A lot of Americans remember the Monopoly man (Rich Uncle Pennybags) as having a monocle. Supposedly it's mixing it up with Mr Peanut, who does.

amitoooldforthisshit · 28/02/2022 01:05

@TheFoldOx

Far be it for me to add to the confusion/argument, but the best cheese and onion crisps come in a yellow packet...
ohh ghastly horrible stuff, tastes like dried puke in a packet, off with you
ItsAlwaysThere · 28/02/2022 00:58

@AliceMcK

April Levine music video to Sk8ter boy. I swear the original video has the girl sat at home with a baby watching the boy on mtv and her in the crowd at his concert. But no search can find that video. Lots of people remember it, others don’t.
I remember that
TheFoldOx · 28/02/2022 00:58

Far be it for me to add to the confusion/argument, but the best cheese and onion crisps come in a yellow packet...

Mandela Effect
ItsAlwaysThere · 28/02/2022 00:58

@OmgIThinkILikeYou

My main one is Britney Spears absolutely had a headset in the oops I did it again video. I remember it vividly!
She did in another video
FredWinnie · 28/02/2022 00:57

I remember Mandela dying in prison too

I also remember (and this one is really crackers) feeling utterly confused when the sign of a heart attack suddenly became shooting pain in your right arm and your heart was in the middle of your torso, not on the left

I only just about adjusted to this weird fact, and then it switched back again to left arm and left side, where it is now, (I hope)

Vanellopee · 28/02/2022 00:50

I find these interesting, but none of the common examples resonate with me.

Swipe left for the next trending thread