Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu to think solar panels are a good investment with rising energy prices?

54 replies

Ghostofchristmaspasty · 27/02/2022 19:04

Just that really. Been thinking about getting some for a while and with electric rises surely it's a good move?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
vdbfamily · 31/08/2022 00:12

get a quote from Power- Aid Limited. He is my a relative of mine and totally trust worthy. He had won awards for his company in Africa which he has now left the locals to run and he is back here in UK.
We got 10 panels and 2 batteries and with no VAT ( plus family rate of extra 10% off) we paid about£9,000. First month we had a message from energy company dealing we need to significantly reduce our direct debit. You have to get used to using your post whilst the sun shines so leave dishwasher to the morning and laundry etc. In the evening, the batteries then power the laptops/ desktop/ TV etc
My husband had air con unit going all day on his office and costing him nothing in power when it was so hot. He was very excited about that. He reckons were will be paid off in 5 years if prices stay high . It remains to be seen what our winter bills will be like but with a summer like this one and the amount of extra that we sell back, I would be surprised if we are paying anything at all.

Paniniandsalad · 30/08/2022 23:48

Just to update I'm the OP but NC frequently. I've done lots of research and chasing quotes since I posted this.

My research shows now with batteries to store energy and electric vehicles, as well as the ever increasing cost of energy solar is a good investment. Also my DH has since changed to wfh permanently.

I just got my first quote after 6 months of hounding companies. Wish I'd started much much earlier!

Maria1982 · 28/02/2022 22:45

Hi OP - saw this and thought of you!
www.theguardian.com/money/2022/feb/28/solar-panels-a-ray-of-hope-as-energy-prices-go-through-the-roof

As to recommendations for installers, it really depends on where you are. We used Cambridge Solar and they were great, but no good to you if you're miles away!

TonTonMacoute · 28/02/2022 19:46

Solar in the U.K. does work but it never really operates at its full potential. This might not be a problem as long as you are getting enough electricity for your own needs.

There is a problem with sourcing panels, the cheapest ones from China are made using Uighar forced labour, so you may want to look out for that.

The lithium ion batteries have been raising a lot of safety concerns and there have been cases of them exploding and catching fire, which is then very difficult to put out. I haven't heard of any cases here, but many experts are worried.

All things to check carefully before you commit.

Ghostofchristmaspasty · 28/02/2022 19:36

@Hopeisnotastrategy that was another reason I thought too. The global situation is so unstable - Russia/ climate change. It's all pushing me towards the decision quicker than it would have.

OP posts:
Hopeisnotastrategy · 28/02/2022 19:01

Another point in their favour no one has yet mentioned is security of supply. If there's a power cut, or if there should need to be any electricity rationing next winter, you are sitting pretty. Interesting to hear batteries are becoming more mainstream now, that's good news.

Ghostofchristmaspasty · 28/02/2022 18:11

Interesting replies, thank you all. I think I will start by getting some quotes.

Any recommendations for installers?

OP posts:
SallyLockheart · 28/02/2022 07:23

4kw array. Generated over 11kw yesterday. Yorkshire. SSE/SSW split of panels. Nearly 10 years old and generating expected levels of KW each year.

AWorriedMum · 28/02/2022 06:36

I think they’re a con. I’ve had my solar array for 3 years, it’s on the ground, full south, correct angle and they produce 50% of the amount of electricity they’re supposed to. (A calculation of what they could reasonably be expected to generate was made at the point of sale). I got the expensive ones, i.e not with “Christmas tree light effect”, so if one panel has a tiny bit of shade for a couple of hours, the others will not stop generating. I’m so gutted - only 50% of what I was expecting! I doubt I’ll recoup my initial outlay over the lifetime of these panels.

womaninatightspot · 27/02/2022 23:11

@Fedupsotired

Someone told me that every 3/4 years you need to pay £3000 maintenance but don't know if that's true!
Solar panels are largely maintenance free. Mines have a 20 year guarantee but the inverter only came with a ten year guarantee so may need to replace at some point. I've had mine nearly 6 years no maintenance atall.
BookwormButNoTime · 27/02/2022 23:05

PV panels / tiles do not need direct sunlight - just "daylight". Of course they create more power on bright clear days, but they can generate electricity even on a cloudy day. Combine with a battery as others have mentioned.

We are doing a new build (six bedroom house). With the right insulation levels, air source heat pump, solar PV tiles and a battery, the estimates are coming in that our electricity bills will be in the region of £50 a month - a third of what they are in our three bedroom terrace house.

Maria1982 · 27/02/2022 22:41

All these people saying solar panels are rubbish because we are in the U.K.- nonsense!

We have solar panels on our roof (no garden). Today we have generated 8kWh, and consumed 14kWh - having washed and used dryer on two loads of laundry, plus cooked in the evening. I mention the dryer because it’s a noticeable energy consumption point.

This is in late February! In May/June when days are longer we can easily generate enough to cover most of our energy. Except if we charge the electric car! That uses a lot of power.

OP - the incentives aren’t as good as they used to be (govt removed them), but you could start by getting a couple of quotes from reputable local solar companies.
They should produce a payback period calculation for you. If I remember correctly ours were estimated to pay back for the initial investment in 10+ years, but that was with energy prices 4 years ago!

Babamamananarama · 27/02/2022 22:33

Santas yep good. They programme it to charge during cheap rate electricity period overnight. It's all about how you use and programme it. I know a few people with them now who really rate them.

Santaslittlemelter · 27/02/2022 22:30

@Babamamananarama

'The UK is a bit pathetic for solar, sadly'

Bollocks. My parents got 8kwh off their panels yesterday. In February. Their daily usage is about 10-11kwh so that is not bad at all. And because they have a battery they can store that power to use into the evening rather than sending it back into the grid.

How is their battery working out? It’s pretty new technology but I’m thinking of getting one.
Santaslittlemelter · 27/02/2022 22:30

I got them 6 years ago. They have a 20yr warranty. They cost me about 4k. I’ve already earned more than 4k on them (gov payments, free energy and payment for overage into grid).

But the bulk of my earnings are from gov payments which have dropped substantially since I got mine. So people will find it much harder to break even quickly.

Babamamananarama · 27/02/2022 22:29

'The UK is a bit pathetic for solar, sadly'

Bollocks. My parents got 8kwh off their panels yesterday. In February. Their daily usage is about 10-11kwh so that is not bad at all. And because they have a battery they can store that power to use into the evening rather than sending it back into the grid.

Santaslittlemelter · 27/02/2022 22:27

@SecretSquirrel111

Can be hard to sell a house on with them, overrated.
No, it can be hard to sell a house with them if you’ve rented the panels. Not if you’ve bought them.
DdraigGoch · 27/02/2022 22:26

@londonrach

Very hard to sell your house. Some solar panels you give the company your roof. In the UK unlikely to get the money back due to lack of sun.
If you pay the capital up front rather than using one of those dodgy finance schemes, then there are no issues of that sort.

UK schemes generally pay back the capital in 10-15 years (probably quicker at the current electricity prices). Warranties often last for 25 years and the solar panels can still be functioning after 50 (though the inverter will need replacing).

Prices for selling to the grid are much less than you might have got under the old FiT money-printing scheme but given what unit prices are now (which aren't likely to drop), you still benefit hugely from free electricity.

Daylight is enough, it doesn't need to be direct sunlight. Even a north-facing roof isn't that bad, with only a 30% drop compared to south-facing so it may be worth getting that done at the same time. After all, costs such as the scaffolding and connecting up the system will be broadly the same whatever the size of the installation.

muckandnettles · 27/02/2022 22:15

I'd just like to also add that you don't actually need full sunshine for your solar panels to generate power. Ours do quite well on normal days. We've had them now on two houses and really like them. At our last house we could charge our car purely on solar for about 6 months of the year.

deadlanguage · 27/02/2022 22:04

@londonrach

Very hard to sell your house. Some solar panels you give the company your roof. In the UK unlikely to get the money back due to lack of sun.
Unless you live on Shetland or install panels on a north facing roof or something you will make the money back. Martin Lewis estimates for current energy prices and export payments it would take about 13 years for someone in the midlands. Their lifespan is 25-30 years. I’d love to buy a house with solar panels, as it would save me the cost of installing them myself! I wouldn’t buy a house with an EPC lower than C nowadays.
Carbiesdreamhouse · 27/02/2022 21:11

Are wind turbines old hat now? We live on a hill where it's usually windy even on hot days. I always wonder if a wind turbine would be a good idea.

CandyLeBonBon · 27/02/2022 21:04

Christ there's some nonsense on here

londonrach · 27/02/2022 20:57

Very hard to sell your house. Some solar panels you give the company your roof. In the UK unlikely to get the money back due to lack of sun.

saleorbouy · 27/02/2022 20:55

OP are you talking about Solar electric or solar thermal?

Technosaurus · 27/02/2022 20:44

Re the selling issue - I have experience of this

If you own the panels outright, it's not a problem at all

If you get them installed on a "lease" arrangement (ie don't pay for them up front, someone else does it and you pay them back over time or via feed in) then the installation company put a charge on the house. In effect a percentage of your roof is not 100% yours and mortgage companies get iffy about lending on it. Sounds ridiculous but had a house sale collapse over this. Only option was the buy the installer out of the contract, and they quoted us a five figure sum.

I would also say the latter situation is much less likely now as the government grant and feed in tariff has stopped. So most people
(not all) getting them now would buy them outright, in which case it's not a problem to sell on.

Swipe left for the next trending thread