Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say think a roast dinner can be a cheap meal?

237 replies

HuffyPuffyStuffy · 27/02/2022 15:43

I grew up eating roast dinners, always on a Sunday and often midweek too. I don't always cook a roast on a Sunday now but we always have a least one roast dinner a week. I mentioned to a newish friend earlier that I was cooking a roast today and she was teasing me about being "posh" and that she only has a roast on special occasions a roast costs so much!
I tried to say that a roast can be a cheap meal and she thought I was lying when I said that today's meal for four (2 adults and 2 teens) would cost under £6.00 and that we would have leftover meat for tomorrow. Obviously, a big joint of sirloin beef or a new season leg of lamb would be expensive but I couldn't get her to accept that a roast dinner could be cheap! I was so miffed I costed it out .........

1.5 kg joint of pork shoulder (Aldi) £4.21
Potatoes - roasted (Wonky Morrisons) 25p
Parsnips - roasted (Aldi) 20p
Carrots - boiled (Aldi) 15p
swede - boiled (Aldi) 20p
frozen peas (Morrisons) 30p
Stuffing made from leftover bread, half an onion and herbs from garden. 15p
Gravy - made from meat juice, plain flour, veg water.......10p

£5.56 for the roast

I didn't use my oven today. Meat was roasted in the slow cooker, potatoes and parsnips cooked in an air fryer and the veg cooked in my pressure cooker.

If you did a roast today how much did it cost?

OP posts:
maddiemookins16mum · 27/02/2022 17:56

@euniceanddudley

Or it can be cheap because a 3 for £10 meat deal means that you can feed your family when you might not otherwise be able to afford meat.
This 100%. For some families, a deal like this (I get a 1.2kg chicken, a 1kg pork joint and a 600 gram of minced beef in my 3 for £10), means I can do pretty decent meals. I accept the meat is inexpensive, I simply cannot afford chickens that cost £15 each. For me to be able to feed my family a lovely roast dinner (and it was), makes me proud and happy.
WeaverofWords · 27/02/2022 17:55

It can be done very cheaply but I would worry about that animal & the ethical standards of its rearing. I don’t like to see cheap, crappy meat strewn across supermarkets and think it’s shocking that it still goes on.

Kumbaya12 · 27/02/2022 17:54

@jb7445

Surely it just depends on whether a roast is a standard/weekly thing for your family or not?

I don't cook a roast often but when I do I make it basically like a Christmas dinner - allllll the trimmings. To me it feels like a special meal so yeah, it is usually quite expensive. I can see how making it like you say in the OP would be a lot cheaper (but I would be saddened to be served a roast like that in all honesty Blush)

Yep, roast meat + gravy, potatoes and boiled meat is really easy to make. It feels a bit special as we wouldn't normally roast a whole joint or chicken, and a lot more meat is eaten as it's the centerpiece (rest of our dishes are veggies based flavoured with meat if it makes sense). But I still wouldn't call it a proper 'roast'. To me that's what we make for a proper Christmas dinner with stuffing, Yorkshire puddings etc. And that takes a lot of effort.
Mulhollandmagoo · 27/02/2022 17:53

I agree that a roast can be cheap! We use frozen veggies too so even cheaper - I know they're not for everyone but we don't mind them.

I don't wanna sound like a massive MN twat, but a roast chicken does do two meals in this house, but there is only two adults and a toddler here 🤣

TheChosenTwo · 27/02/2022 17:53

Forgot all the things like onions, garlic, lemons, herbs etc that go under and around the chicken while it’s roasting but I don’t do the cooking Grin

whiteworldgettingwhiter · 27/02/2022 17:52

I agree with you! Potatoes and veg are cheap. A chicken is £5 in Tesco. Yorkshire puds are about £1.

TheChosenTwo · 27/02/2022 17:50

We’re having roast chicken tonight.
Chicken - £16
Potatoes £1.50 (roasted in goose fat - 30p?)
Pigs in blankets - sausages £4 streaky bacon £3
Parmesan parsnips - £3
Chard gratin - £5 ish?
Kale £2
Gravy - £2 ish? Fresh stock tub with splash of wine and the meat juices
Sweetcorn £1
Yorkshire puddings (use our own eggs
) so £1 for milk and flour? Maybe less…

Could definitely be made cheaper but not prepared to skimp on a) animal welfare or b) quality.

Inextremis · 27/02/2022 17:50

Today, we're having an €11 half leg of Irish lamb, with roast potatoes, honey roast parsnips, Yorkshire puddings, carrots, and broccoli, with gravy and mint sauce. There are three of us. I estimate the veg, flour, egg, etc. came to around €5 for the amount I've used, so €16 for the meal, or just over €5 each. Probably the most expensive meal of the week, but not too bad. I have no idea how much electricity it's taking (am cooking it as I type) to cook.

On a separate note, I bloody love Paxo stuffing - not with lamb, though!

Fairislefandango · 27/02/2022 17:47

Wow - some people are being really weird about the OP's roast dinner. I can't fathom why anyone would assume that just because she made a standard roast with a normal selection of commonly-used veg, that her roast wouldn't be delicious or her gravy would be watery Confused.

Dh usually cooks the roasts in this house, often similar veg etc to the OP's. He is an excellent cook, makes stunning roast potatoes and delicious gravy from scratch using homemade stock. A roast does not need to be fancy to be delicious. It just needs a competent cook.

Georgyporky · 27/02/2022 17:47

It can certainly be cheap if using chicken or pork, & Aldi beef is good quality & a lot cheaper than Sainsbo etc.

It's the sheer simplicity of it I like.

For me, it's the easiest meal to prepare. No seeking out recipes, checking for ingredients.

Just bung things in the oven at set intervals, steam some greenery, gravy from meat juices & that's it.

Chishnfips · 27/02/2022 17:43

If you didn't use an oven and nothing was roasted how have you cooked A Roast?

LetHimHaveIt · 27/02/2022 17:39

God knows I've a horror of the Mumsnet 'massive salad' and virtuous eaters in general, but I'm stunned by the number of people who seem to think OP's isn't a proper roast because it's got loads of veg.

And there's nowt wrong with packet stuffing. Love a bit of Paxo in balls. Goes properly crunchy. Can't abide stuffing that clings to the roof of your mouth.

TheHoptimist · 27/02/2022 17:34

We have 1-2 roasts a week

Meat varies from £5 chicken to £25 aged beef. But local- know which farm and welfare standards

carrots- basic
frozen peas
broccolli- basic
roast potatoes - buy by the sack
parsnips - whichever in stock
Yorkshires-loads
true foods gravy ( I can make but they do it better and are local)
sausages - love a good sausage

optional
additional veg depends on season

Divebar2021 · 27/02/2022 17:33

How can a chicken be sold for £3-£4? The farmer must be earning pence on that and god alone knows what life the chicken’s life is like.

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 27/02/2022 17:28

Amazing how a topic like this will bring out the food snobs. People in the UK generally don't eat enough vegetables, and there are plenty of families really struggling at the moment with rocketing fuel and food bills, so cheap veg is the only veg they can afford. Those who believe that only organic vegetables are safe and nutritious are creating needless anxiety in the people who can't afford to buy organic veg and can't grow their own. Cheap vegetables are absolutely fine. Frozen veg can also be excellent and a great convenience.

CrimbleCrumble1 · 27/02/2022 17:24

I do chicken, stuffing, carrots, parsnips, roast potatoes, Yorkshire and gravy. Half the time pigs in blankets as well.

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 27/02/2022 17:22

@jb7445

Surely it just depends on whether a roast is a standard/weekly thing for your family or not?

I don't cook a roast often but when I do I make it basically like a Christmas dinner - allllll the trimmings. To me it feels like a special meal so yeah, it is usually quite expensive. I can see how making it like you say in the OP would be a lot cheaper (but I would be saddened to be served a roast like that in all honesty Blush)

Meat, gravy, stuffing, roast potatoes and several other vegetables would make you sad? Goodness me.

Our Christmas dinner isn't much more involved than that. We do have bread sauce and cranberry sauce as well as gravy, and we have chipolata sausages and sausagemeat stuffing, which we wouldn't bother with at any other time of the year. On the odd occasion I do a traditional roast it would probably be:

Roast meat of some sort, probably lamb or chicken, or a nut roast
Gravy
Roast potatoes always
Roast parsnips almost always
And probably carrots, mashed swede, at least one green vegetable (ideally Brussels sprouts but when they're out of season cabbage or broccoli instead), maybe peas, maybe cauliflower

It's lovely, very filling, and there will be lots of leftovers to save cooking the next day and probably at least one other day. Win win.

mrsm43s · 27/02/2022 17:19

Of course a roast can be cheap. Any meal can be cheap if you use cheap low quality ingredients.

What you've described is the cheapest, lowest quality of version of a roast possible. It's still a lot more expensive than the cheapest, lowest quality version of a tomato pasta bake, or frozen pizza and value chips or cheapest sausages and mash and cheap veg which are a comparable standard in other meals.

My roasts are not cheap. They include high quality good cuts of meat, King Edward potatoes roasted in goose fat, a range of high quality organic veg, red wine gravy or similar, a range of condiments. And generally its served with a bottle of wine and a homemade pudding. I'd prefer to have a delicious good quality roast every few weeks than a poor quality one every week.

Of all the meals I cook, my roasts are one of the most expensive ones. The only meals that are more expensive are probably fillet steak or more expensive fish.

ToadyInAHole · 27/02/2022 17:16

I live in a flat and have a couple of pots of fresh herbs, you don't have to have a herb garden!

1forAll74 · 27/02/2022 17:08

Your friend is a bit out of touch, saying roast dinners are posh, and expensive, of which are not. She probably might fork out £ 20 plus, on a takeaway meal, one that you dont have any idea what has gone into it !

CeleriacOfTheNight · 27/02/2022 17:07

[quote CarrotSticks2]You are definitely the same poster OP, maybe you should stop talking to friends about the cost of your roasts!

Here is the original thread:
www.mumsnet.com/Talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/4365588-to-think-that-a-roast-dinner-isnt-necessarily-an-expensive-meal-to-cook[/quote]
I thought I was seeing things Grin

Making up pretendy arguments with friends, about the cost of a dinner is bonkers!

5128gap · 27/02/2022 17:07

Yes I find it the least costly meal I make. No need for extra bits and bobs for sauces, or for the side dishes they expect with certain 'cheap' dinners such as garlic bread and salad to go with with pasta, which ramp up the cost. Even cheaper now we don't eat meat too!

luxxlisbon · 27/02/2022 17:06

It can be a cost effective meal but how cheap largely depends on the ethics of the meat, however some of the comments are hilarious…2 carrots for 5 adults? I am not a big eater but some of these portions must be so sad.

ouch321 · 27/02/2022 17:06

Your assumption that we all have herb gardens is....amusing.

Some of us flat dwellers don't even have gardens.

Bytrgrewd · 27/02/2022 17:05

I meant content not price. Splash out a bit more obviously