Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say think a roast dinner can be a cheap meal?

237 replies

HuffyPuffyStuffy · 27/02/2022 15:43

I grew up eating roast dinners, always on a Sunday and often midweek too. I don't always cook a roast on a Sunday now but we always have a least one roast dinner a week. I mentioned to a newish friend earlier that I was cooking a roast today and she was teasing me about being "posh" and that she only has a roast on special occasions a roast costs so much!
I tried to say that a roast can be a cheap meal and she thought I was lying when I said that today's meal for four (2 adults and 2 teens) would cost under £6.00 and that we would have leftover meat for tomorrow. Obviously, a big joint of sirloin beef or a new season leg of lamb would be expensive but I couldn't get her to accept that a roast dinner could be cheap! I was so miffed I costed it out .........

1.5 kg joint of pork shoulder (Aldi) £4.21
Potatoes - roasted (Wonky Morrisons) 25p
Parsnips - roasted (Aldi) 20p
Carrots - boiled (Aldi) 15p
swede - boiled (Aldi) 20p
frozen peas (Morrisons) 30p
Stuffing made from leftover bread, half an onion and herbs from garden. 15p
Gravy - made from meat juice, plain flour, veg water.......10p

£5.56 for the roast

I didn't use my oven today. Meat was roasted in the slow cooker, potatoes and parsnips cooked in an air fryer and the veg cooked in my pressure cooker.

If you did a roast today how much did it cost?

OP posts:
WeaverofWords · 27/02/2022 20:17

Sorry, typos/autocorrect

WeaverofWords · 27/02/2022 20:16

@RosesAndHellebores

Do the people.concerned about animal welfare on this thread have similar concerns re human welfare relating to some of the clothes they buy and not just the cheap ones either?
Absolutely! Don’t you? I didn’t used to, but the past few months have been a real eye opener. If I don’t need clothes, I don’t buy them. If I do, I used secondhand shops or. Less often, ethical retainers. But I still wear clothes from when I was 18! Or stuff passed on from others.
mrsm43s · 27/02/2022 20:15

[quote gogohm]@scottishnames

Many people cannot afford £16 for a chicken. There's posts here suggesting that a roast dinner cannot be tasty because the ingredients aren't organic, that paxo (or own brand) stuffing is rubbish and instant gravy is an abomination - eat what you want but don't say the op's or my toast dinner doesn't taste great.

The op's opening gambit was a roast doesn't have to cost a fortune, it doesn't despite the fact you can choose to spend more.[/quote]
I agree with you that a roast doesn't have to cost a fortune if you use the lowest quality ingredients. But it is more expensive than other meals made with the lowest quality ingredients.

It costs a lot with the highest quality ingredients, and more than many other meals using the highest quality ingredients.

A roast using value products and the cheapest available meat costs more than sausage and mash using value products and the cheapest available meat and more than spag bol using value products and the cheapest available meat and more than value pizza and chips and beans and more than value chicken nuggets and mash and peas etc etc.

Regardless of which quality/price point you shop to, a roast tends to be towards the more expensive end of meals of the same quality level.

Mum2jenny · 27/02/2022 20:12

Personally I will not buy a chicken unless it’s free range, as for pork it must be uk raised and not danish.
If I can’t afford the meat,I do not buy it.

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 27/02/2022 20:09

@scottishnames

PicAChew Am of course very sorry if members of your families have problems. But that's not the case with the vast majority. As the old saying goes: 'Hard cases make bad laws' - it's not the exceptions that matter, but the norms. The norm should surely be that we don't have to commit acts of horrible cruelty - as defined by the RSPCA, not me - to eat.

And for heaven's sake stop calling people who care about animal welfare snobbish. It's just not true and it devalues whatever else you have to say.

There are two intertwined discussions going on here.

One is about animal welfare and cheap meat.

I was commenting on the other, which is the vegetables people might have with a roast. I mentioned food snobs because a few people who've contributed to this thread and who clearly don't have to worry too much about their food budget have turned up their noses at the idea of having cheap, seasonal root vegetables and frozen peas because they're not organic and also because the OP cooked them in a nice straightforward way, nothing unduly fancy, but perfectly tasty ways to eat veg with gravy and meat or equivalent.

My point is that comments like that will make some other posters feel inadequate because (a) they can't afford fancy imported veg, (b) they worry they are letting their families down by not buying organic and (c) they don't have the time or the cookery skills or facilities/equipment to do anything fancy and now feel others are looking down on them, and none of this will do anything to encourage people to buy and cook more vegetables.

GenderCriticalTrumpets · 27/02/2022 20:09

We can't stand supermarket joints so I buy from the butchers which costs more, but I think it's worth it. So our beef today was 15 quid. Worth every penny it was belting. I made yorkshire puds, roast potatoes, roast carrots and cheesy leeks.

RosesAndHellebores · 27/02/2022 20:07

Do the people.concerned about animal welfare on this thread have similar concerns re human welfare relating to some of the clothes they buy and not just the cheap ones either?

scottishnames · 27/02/2022 20:02

goghm I could not afford £16 for a free-range chicken. So I don't have it. There's nothing snobbish about that. There's no law to say that we have to eat roast meat. There are plenty of other delicious things to eat.

If people choose to eat cheap meat that involves cruelty in production then, I am sorry, I have said and I will say that I think that is wrong.

You are perfectly correct, the OP did ask whether a roast could be cheap. Yes it can. But at what price for other living creatures? But I think that the OP's double post is weird and possibly intentionally provocative.

worriedatthemoment · 27/02/2022 19:57

Also a proper roast has yorkies , maybe cauliflower cheese etc
Decent meat joint
Otherwise my midweek pork chops , potatoe and veg qualifies as a roast

worriedatthemoment · 27/02/2022 19:55

With 4 of us we never have chicken left over i mean 2 of us have a breast each and other 2 a leg , that leaves 2 wings and but if scrap , not sure how people get 2 meals etc out if it unless having couple slivers of meat
I mean i would cook of a couple chicken breasts and slice and divide by 4

gogohm · 27/02/2022 19:53

@scottishnames

Many people cannot afford £16 for a chicken. There's posts here suggesting that a roast dinner cannot be tasty because the ingredients aren't organic, that paxo (or own brand) stuffing is rubbish and instant gravy is an abomination - eat what you want but don't say the op's or my toast dinner doesn't taste great.

The op's opening gambit was a roast doesn't have to cost a fortune, it doesn't despite the fact you can choose to spend more.

CarrotSticks2 · 27/02/2022 19:51

Also shocked that someone earlier on this thread tried to pass off Greek chicken breasts and mash as a roast!

CarrotSticks2 · 27/02/2022 19:50

Come on how many friends have criticised the cost of your dinner? Does anyone call a roast dinner posh?

Genuinely think I could tell my friends I was having lobster and fillet steak and they wouldn't call me out for spending too much on my dinner. Its just something you don't comment on. Now there's 2 newish friends criticising the cost of posters roasts (a fairly standard British Sunday meal). Who both mysteriously serve the same veg and grow their own herbs/make their own bread!

OrlandointheWilderness · 27/02/2022 19:47

We make stuffing from scratch, cheap and no additives etc. I'd rather eat plain pasta than low welfare/foreigner meat. Cheapest we have is roast game which I get free from my bf when he has been shooting. Veg grown in garden, homemade stock. It's pence then.

SunshineCake1 · 27/02/2022 19:45

Use a food mixer to make breadcrumbs. Or maybe freeze the bread and bash it while frozen. I wonder if that would work.

londonrach · 27/02/2022 19:43

It's a cheap meal. Always been

Sswhinesthebest · 27/02/2022 19:41

Nothing beats homemade stuffing. You need an egg and butter with the leftover bread, onion and dried sage though.

I mainly use paxo though, because it’s a faff making the breadcrumbs. Nowhere near as nice.

scottishnames · 27/02/2022 19:39

PicAChew Am of course very sorry if members of your families have problems. But that's not the case with the vast majority. As the old saying goes: 'Hard cases make bad laws' - it's not the exceptions that matter, but the norms. The norm should surely be that we don't have to commit acts of horrible cruelty - as defined by the RSPCA, not me - to eat.

And for heaven's sake stop calling people who care about animal welfare snobbish. It's just not true and it devalues whatever else you have to say.

PickAChew · 27/02/2022 19:32

And on our plates with our sparrow sized free range chicken, we had bog standard dirt cheap savoy cabbage. Nothing sad about it at all. It's bloody delicious.

JackieCollinshasnoauthority · 27/02/2022 19:30

@ThunderSnowDrop

Twins separated and brought up independent of one another but with symmetrical lives.
Clones!
PickAChew · 27/02/2022 19:29

@Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g

Amazing how a topic like this will bring out the food snobs. People in the UK generally don't eat enough vegetables, and there are plenty of families really struggling at the moment with rocketing fuel and food bills, so cheap veg is the only veg they can afford. Those who believe that only organic vegetables are safe and nutritious are creating needless anxiety in the people who can't afford to buy organic veg and can't grow their own. Cheap vegetables are absolutely fine. Frozen veg can also be excellent and a great convenience.
Quite. DH and would be happy to eat very little meat, if we were struggling. Can't say the same for the two autistic young men in the family, though. If we took the meat out of Ds2 's diet, he'd be existing on bread, cake, chips, peanut butter and fried egg for breakfast because that's in the rules. It's a huge struggle to keep any weight on him, as it is.

Animal welfare is important to me. The welfare of my children is more important.

And we are not in the US and do not routinely pump our livestock full of hormones.

Rosebel · 27/02/2022 19:23

I usually do a roast on Sunday, didn't today as we were at my mum's house. For 2 adults, 2 teens and a toddler with meat leftover for Monday it's about £10-£12.
I don't see it as an expensive meal.

TrendingNowt · 27/02/2022 19:21

A chicken roast is our go-to when we have very little until next pay day.
Cheapest of everything, bubble and squeak and/ or soup with leftover veg depending how much you do. Can get another 2 meals out of kitchen. Chicken pie and broth for example.

WeaverofWords · 27/02/2022 19:20

@florianfortescue

You can have a cheap roast if you don't give a shit about animal welfare. It should not be the norm to pay bottom dollar for meat, particularly pork. It's shit for the pig and it's shit for the farmers. I'd rather have a vegetarian roast, god knows there are enough alternatives out there. It is perfectly possible to feed your family without buying animals that have had a miserable, short life in terrible conditions and/or shafting the farmers that rear them. Billions of people around the world cannot afford to eat meat every day. I hate this idea that high welfare meat is only for the wealthy middle classes - it's not, you just have to care about it.
This. Cheap shit meat going into my body? No thanks.

We are fucking up our planet. The ability to save it begins with small decisions. Made by us, everyday. It’s not just the big Things like whether Putin will use nuclear weapons or not.

I want my kids to see more of this planet in their lifetime and so I’ve stopped buying cheap meat. I was a victim, too, of the 3 for £10 offers. Meat at every meal. Must recycle the Mumsnet chicken. I am a foodie and will roast lamb every Sunday, cheap joints available at Asda, special offer at Waitrose on certain days of the week. But an alarm bell has gone off good n proper in my head recently.

Yes, it’s possible to have a cheap roast. But if we carry on like this, there will be no planet for our kids to live on.

scottishnames · 27/02/2022 19:16

gogohm It's nothing at all to do with being snobbish. Why on earth would you think it is? It's about caring for living, feeling creatures.

I can't afford posh meat. And I don't care for meat anywhay, though that is NOT the point. Even if I liked meat, I would HATE to think that what I was eating caused really dreadful suffering. Because that is what most cheap meat relies on.

But it's just such a cheap (ha) and lazy thing to say that such welfare feelings are only the preserve of 'snobs'.