Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is it to be expected/accepted that parents will favour their daughters and daughters children?

93 replies

Weekendvibes · 27/02/2022 14:15

I get on perfectly well with my in laws. They are nice enough people and could be far worse going by some of the horror stories I read on here.

But one thing that's becoming more obvious is how much they favour their dd (and other grandchildren (sil) and her children.

We have boys and sil has girls and the warm welcome that sil and her dds get compared to us is so blatantly obvious. Mil and fil faces light up when they see them and they are greeted with such a warm tone of voice and hugs and kisses. We get a simple hello.

They help sil out a lot financially and also with childcare, they are always talking about how hard up their dd is and how she is struggling. This is despite sil and her dh having a bigger income than us and less outgoings. I know all this because my in laws tell us a lot about their finances. I'm not sure where they've got the idea that we are well off compared to sil.

Whenever we go to mils, she has bought her granddaughters little gifts such as clothes, comics, costume jewellery, packs of socks and pants, not for birthdays or Christmas just random gifts that she's seen, but doesn't buy any of this for our children.

When we see in laws mil spends most of the time telling us about her dd and granddaughters down to every bowel movement her granddaughters have had. Nieces are lovely but mil in particular doesn't show any interest in our sons and changes the subject of I try to tell her anything they've been doing.

Our dc are a few years older than sils dc and when ours were small, we were always expected to attend lots of activities which they wanted to do that weren't child friendly or were at inconvenient times even though it was a huge pain. Now that sil has children everything revolves around her dc and sil is never to be expected to put herself out. Even down to what food the granddaughter will eat. We weren't ever afforded any of this consideration.

Fil openly criticises dh and I and he can be really cutting to dh even laughing at his appearance, of course it's all supposed to be 'a joke' but he would never do this to sil.

Dh is expected to be the doting older brother and drop everything at a moments notice but it would never be reciprocated.

I find it all quite hurtful. I don't think dh has ever noticed but he is always trying to impress his parents and win their approval and I've realised that he started to become irritated by in laws always making out that sil is hard up.

I've heard people say that grandparents are always closer to their daughters children is it just one of those things you have to accept.

OP posts:
cptartapp · 27/02/2022 18:00

SIL got a £10k house deposit and all her wedding paid for whilst DH got nothing. It was no surprise her DC then got bigger and better Xmas and birthday presents etc over the years, and prioritised for babysitting. My nephews have given away loads of 'secret' info. FIL once even called her DC 'ours.'
Very hurtful. We don't see a lot of them tbh whilst SIL is now so beholden.

MadMadMadamMim · 27/02/2022 17:29

Not in my experience. And my DM certainly doesn't favour me. My DB is her obvious favourite child and the golden boy.

I suspect some parents have 'A favourite' - but whether that is a son or a daughter is fairly random. And some parents don't treat their children or grandchildren equally. But it isn't 'to be expected' in my opinion.

Weekendvibes · 27/02/2022 17:22

It does sound like it's child favouritism rather than a boy/girl thing.

One thing that really hurt was at the start of the pandemic, fil rang dh and gave him a real telling off. He told dh that sil was very upset and scared and dh hadn't bothered to ring her to offer her any support. He went on and on about how dreadful her situation was going to be.

The thing was we were just as upset and scared, our situation wasn't any different to theirs, in fact it was much much worse. No one offered us any support or phoned us. It was no different.

It was absurd the way he told dh off.

It certainly wasn't the first time he'd behaved like that towards us/dh but it was the day the scales really fell from my eyes.

OP posts:
MsTSwift · 27/02/2022 17:18

Anecdotally I know several situations where the Dd is difficult and the mil gets on far better with their dils.

scornrufibarbis · 27/02/2022 17:10

My Mil a definitely favours SIL. SIL only has boys and one of them hurt one of children (physical act of violence) DH was expected to sweep it under the carpet and not upset SIL by taking a stand against it (SIL and MIL refuses to even apologies that our dc was hurt) DH had it out with MIL and she said thy she would chose SIL and her children over DH and our children. She also made it clear that she would have chosen SIL over BIL and his children too.

Weekendvibes · 27/02/2022 17:00

@aSofaNearYou I know what you mean there are always two sides to every story.

But I can only say that my pov dh has been nothing but a good person. Without saying too much incase mil or sil are on here. Dh has done a lot for all of them over the years. He has helped them so much.

I've always been kind and respectful to them and we have never had a crossed word but it is getting more and more noticeable that they favour sil and her children and that they don't treat dh or the dc the same.

It's not my place to pull them up on any of this. I stick up for dh when fil criticises him but I do it gently so as not to cause a ruck.

Not really sure what the solution is I'd like to think that they don't realise what they're doing.

OP posts:
BorderlineHappy · 27/02/2022 16:53

I have only boys.
When my D's and his gf were expecting I did my best to help them out.
They lived with me at the time.

They moved out and I was the only one who visited.
Her DM didn't even turn up for DG birthday.

Now they live beside her DM I have basically been cut back.

She spends most of her time with her DM,only time they ring us is when they want a lift.

I blame my D's as well.
We life 20 minutes away and haven't seen them in weeks.
It hurts.

Bromse · 27/02/2022 16:46

Confused I don't see why. I suppose some do but then some parents favour one child over another, regardless of their sex. Another factor could be where you live in proximity to the grandparents; if one child lives around the corner with their family and sees their parents regularly they are obviously going to have a closer relationship than with another who lives far away. That doesn't mean they don't love them as much!

aSofaNearYou · 27/02/2022 16:39

I think it just sounds like golden child syndrome, and it doesn't sound very pleasant. I also hate the thing you've described between men where they just tear each other down.

The one thing I do always think when I read these threads though is I wonder what the respective kids behaviour is like... that never seems to be touched upon, so might be something to consider.

But it does sound like there is preexisting favouritism for SIL over DH.

ThunderSnowDrop · 27/02/2022 16:33

I'm hoping for such diplomacy skills!

ThunderSnowDrop · 27/02/2022 16:33

Tbh my mum has a very easy relationship with one of my siblings, they are just so compatible really. Even through the teenage years. By contrast I just wanted away from my mum at that age!
She has always worked hard at being fair though and this has extended to the grandchildren
So it can be done!

Pugfostermum · 27/02/2022 16:26

My DH has a sister and brother. Both sister and brother have a boy and a girl each.

Their mother (DH’s mother) is always posting about how wonderful her daughter’s children are, how beautiful, how clever. Photos of them up in the house.
The son’s children don’t get a look in - it’s very noticeable to me!

AvonCallingBarksdale · 27/02/2022 16:21

I meant DH’s DSiS is their favourite Hmm

AvonCallingBarksdale · 27/02/2022 16:20

My PiL have never made any secret of the fact that DH’s DS is their favourite. DH and his DB are way down the line Sad. By extension of this, DSiL’s husband is the chosen one and their DC are the fave grandchildren.
Poor DH just accepts this and explains it away by saying his DSiS was the youngest and the only girl Confused

Frolicinameadow · 27/02/2022 16:11

I would stop subjecting your kids to this and encourage your dh to get some therapy. If he’s feeling he needs to prove himself to his parents still, it’s obvious this behaviour has gone on all throughout his childhood. And him speaking to them won’t change anything. I’d be willing to bet they’d gaslight him into thinking it’s all in his head/only a bit of a joke/whatever other emotionally abusive excuse they come up with.
Fwiw my parents don’t see my children, they dote on all the other grandchildren and mine are ignored.
My husbands parents are incredible. They go out of their way to spend time with our kids, think of activities, to show them how loved and cherished they are. Ours are the youngest of 10 grandkids and they are the same with all of them. They are generally wonderful loving people and I will be eternally grateful for the love they surround our children with. When they see them they exclaim their greetings as though the kids being their is the highlight of their week. Everything is put down to concentrate on chatting to them and showing such interest. It’s so lovely and on my more emotional days has brought me to tears. It’s a stark difference to the complete lack of interest from my own parents.

CantChatNow · 27/02/2022 16:10

I think it’s just general favouritism. My parents have 2 daughters and it’s like this with my sister.

MintyFreshBreath · 27/02/2022 16:06

My mum is definitely not like this we me and my sister. I’ve got one son and my sister has got two daughters. She loves all the kids equally and for different reasons. I’ve never felt like a second class citizen for having a son 😂

SoupDragon · 27/02/2022 16:03

My parents definitely weren't closer to my children than to my brother's nor did they favour them. It's only an issue if your parents are the sort of people who do that kind of stuff.

NumberTheory · 27/02/2022 16:01

I think, in general, people have very gendered expectations about their children and their parents, even more so than they might for friends, and this often leads to quite different treatment sons and daughters. I don’t think it always results in daughters being treated better. But with the way caring generally falls on women in society and the way women tend to be much more active in maintaining social networks, it is common that a mother will have a closer bond with their daughters.

That bond between a mum and her daughter is often strengthened when grand children come along in a way that relationships with sons (or in-laws) aren’t. There’s a lot of intimate support and sharing that can be provided by a mother to her daughter who’s pregnant or recently given birth that would not be as welcome from a MiL (nor as comfortable being shared with/provided to a DiL) and that isn’t need by a son who’s about/just become a father. Then the help that can be provided when children are younger is often asked for by daughters - because son’s tend to take on less of the caring for babies work and provided by the women’s mothers because it’s easier to ask your mother than your MiL and probably grandmothers are more likely to respond positively to requests from their daughters than their daughters-in-law because they are already closer.

If women didn’t do the bulk of child rearing and there wasn’t a biological burden that only women shoulder then I think the skew towards daughters being closer would be less true. But in the society we live in, I think it’s to be expected, really.

But as I say above, closer doesn’t necessarily mean more favourably, though in your case, OP, it does seem that way.

Narutocrazyfox · 27/02/2022 16:00

It's a funny one OP, but I think you're definitely onto something. I have a feeling it may be age related, and to do with very old fashioned ideas of matriarchal family structures. My grandmother (late 90s,now!) has always bought additional things for and clearly favours my children over my brother's. Fortunately it's in very subtle ways and so my SIL has not noticed. When queried, she says well they're (my SIL's) children, and they have their own grandparents. Basically, she sees my children as more important in the family chain because I'm their mother, and directly her granddaughter, whereas my SIL is not a blood relation.

It's mad, but it makes sense to her. And she's 96 and hard as nails so no-one wants to argue with her!

Keepitrealnomists · 27/02/2022 15:59

Definitely golden child syndrome. I'm a daughter and I get on much better with my in IL as they treat everyone the same. My mum told me when I had my son 'there is nothing like having a son' 🙄 I do t see her that much, she doesn't support me in any way. I am very independent and have done much better then her in my life which I am sure she hates, my brother on the other hand sees her regularly and relies on her financially (we are late 30s BTW) when I speak to her on the phone all she talks about is how wonderful my nieces and nephew are 🙄 as a result my son isn't interested in her and they are not close. My father pretends he's interested but isn't. A few afternoons 3-4 times a year is all he can manage, he doesn't live close by and was never there for us growing up so I am not surprised not do I care. Concentrate on the people that love and support you, thats normally not blood relations!

SisterAgatha · 27/02/2022 15:56

I will never forget the day my MIL brought out two matching dresses and handed them to her two other granddaughters in front my my girl.

She said to me mummy, where is my dress and I said Nanny where is my daughters dress? Then to my child it’s ok Mummy will buy you one that’s even more special.

Cue intense interest in my kids for approx 5 days before they go back to being bastards.

Freddiefox · 27/02/2022 15:51

I think it’s the granddaughter aspects rather than the daughter.

I have boys, and see my mum more than my brother, but she goes on and on about my niece all the time.

She finds her easier, and has more in common with her. She’s quieter. I wonder if it’s that aspect.

Neenawneenaw76 · 27/02/2022 15:33

Twats!

Neenawneenaw76 · 27/02/2022 15:32

No I don't think it's normal but maybe understandable in some situations. My in laws love our kids and obviously try so hard not to have favourites but they are a bit closer to SILs kids, just because they're closer to their daughter than their son. To be honest she does make more of an effort with them than DH does. Your in laws are just tears.