Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is it to be expected/accepted that parents will favour their daughters and daughters children?

93 replies

Weekendvibes · 27/02/2022 14:15

I get on perfectly well with my in laws. They are nice enough people and could be far worse going by some of the horror stories I read on here.

But one thing that's becoming more obvious is how much they favour their dd (and other grandchildren (sil) and her children.

We have boys and sil has girls and the warm welcome that sil and her dds get compared to us is so blatantly obvious. Mil and fil faces light up when they see them and they are greeted with such a warm tone of voice and hugs and kisses. We get a simple hello.

They help sil out a lot financially and also with childcare, they are always talking about how hard up their dd is and how she is struggling. This is despite sil and her dh having a bigger income than us and less outgoings. I know all this because my in laws tell us a lot about their finances. I'm not sure where they've got the idea that we are well off compared to sil.

Whenever we go to mils, she has bought her granddaughters little gifts such as clothes, comics, costume jewellery, packs of socks and pants, not for birthdays or Christmas just random gifts that she's seen, but doesn't buy any of this for our children.

When we see in laws mil spends most of the time telling us about her dd and granddaughters down to every bowel movement her granddaughters have had. Nieces are lovely but mil in particular doesn't show any interest in our sons and changes the subject of I try to tell her anything they've been doing.

Our dc are a few years older than sils dc and when ours were small, we were always expected to attend lots of activities which they wanted to do that weren't child friendly or were at inconvenient times even though it was a huge pain. Now that sil has children everything revolves around her dc and sil is never to be expected to put herself out. Even down to what food the granddaughter will eat. We weren't ever afforded any of this consideration.

Fil openly criticises dh and I and he can be really cutting to dh even laughing at his appearance, of course it's all supposed to be 'a joke' but he would never do this to sil.

Dh is expected to be the doting older brother and drop everything at a moments notice but it would never be reciprocated.

I find it all quite hurtful. I don't think dh has ever noticed but he is always trying to impress his parents and win their approval and I've realised that he started to become irritated by in laws always making out that sil is hard up.

I've heard people say that grandparents are always closer to their daughters children is it just one of those things you have to accept.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Superhanz · 04/03/2022 09:36

No, your MIL sounds like a shit GM.

If you have a brother do your DPs prefer your children over his?

It's definitely not the norm.

MessedOfTimes · 04/03/2022 01:13

Have to agree with PPs remarks about it being a “Golden Child” issue. My mother is like this with my brother (he’s the eldest and only boy of five children - if that even means anything 🤷🏻‍♀️), and he doesn’t even have kids, whilst my other siblings and I have four children between us.

FrothyB · 04/03/2022 01:00

Some people just have a gender preference which can manifest itself to an extreme level.

My family on my fathers side were a little crazy in general. My Dad was the younger child with an older sister, but his Mother almost refused to accept him as hers, supposedly telling the midwife to take him away, because she didn't have a little boy, she had had another girl. She was seemingly a very difficult woman, falling out with her eldest daughter for years at a time and not speaking. She treated my Dad quite harshly also, despite him essentially worshipping the ground she walked on, especially in her later years.

I was the first Grandchild, who was welcomed despite being male. When my cousin arrived 2 years later however, a little girl, it was quite evident who the favourite was. That's not to say I was treated badly, it was simply clear that my cousin was held in higher esteem. She could do no wrong.

My Mums family on the other hand, 3 Sisters and my Grandmother, had no favourites that I am aware of, amongst her children or grandchildren.

Bunty55 · 04/03/2022 00:58

Both my son and daughter have children and I love them all. There is no favouritism from me at all even though my daughter lives with me.
My own mother was a horrible woman who had favourites. It ruined my childhood and when it started to affect my own children I cut her off.
She could do it to me but no way was she doing it to my precious children. What kind of person behaves like this??
Not me.

AnnesBrokenSlate · 04/03/2022 00:49

It's not something I've witnessed in my family or friend's circle. My parents had a great relationship with my DB's DCs.

Sometimes it can be life circumstances. Maybe they have more time or disposable income now than they had when your DCs were smaller.

regjamesanddemons · 04/03/2022 00:43

@regjamesanddemons

A daughter's a daughter for life, a son's a son until he meets his wife.

I don't know if it's expected per se but it's definitely what I have witnessed and if I'm absolutely honest, I have one DD and knew she was going to be an only child and inwardly I had that thought when she was born so glad she's a girl since I'm only having the one Blush

Must clarify, only because I do believe that's how it goes, tend to be closer to the wife's family when people get married.
regjamesanddemons · 04/03/2022 00:42

A daughter's a daughter for life, a son's a son until he meets his wife.

I don't know if it's expected per se but it's definitely what I have witnessed and if I'm absolutely honest, I have one DD and knew she was going to be an only child and inwardly I had that thought when she was born so glad she's a girl since I'm only having the one Blush

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 03/03/2022 23:11

Well if they're the type of parents to treat their daughter differently they will treat their daughters children differently

My parents have been careful to treat my brothers children exactly the same as mine

Stopsnowing · 03/03/2022 22:28

And has made clear she prefers girls to boys

Stopsnowing · 03/03/2022 22:27

My dm favours dd over ds. I hate it.

Easterbunnyiswindowshopping · 03/03/2022 22:21

In hindsight I accept that sil literally threw her dc at her dps. There was no ils asking for lots of time /expecting overnights/choosing her dc over mine etc. It was expected FROM sil that it was happening. Ils had no time for my dc at all.
Also my thinking is that ils could feel it would be overstepping to ask dil for unsupervised time with dc whilst your own dps would just ask. Whatever YOUR relationship is with ils will reflect how they are with your dc..
Imo.
Still resent those ils now and dc are late 20's!

Gindrinker43 · 03/03/2022 22:03

My MIL did exactly this. As my DS got older they recognised it themselves and often commented on it. They just didn't bother with her, she could have had a great relationship with them especially as she was widowed and lonely but she brought it on herself.

Throwntothewolves · 02/03/2022 22:40

It is an awful thing to do and it's abusive, even once the children are adults. My PIL favoured their daughter over their sons throughout life. It has had a lasting affect on my husband to the point where he suffers from depression, which is rooted in how he was overlooked in favour of his sister as a child. I doubt his parents even realised they were causing him so much distress, but he will never fully recover from it.
It is so important to feel you really matter to those who are supposed to love you.

Curlysue212 · 02/03/2022 22:19

I feel your pain OP. Its awful and hurtful but the only thing you can do is create a little distance emotionally so that it doesn't hurt as much. I live very close to PIL. SIL and family live next door to them. MIL has practically raised SIL's two children. She buys them clothes and toys, gives them pocket money, takes them on foreign holidays, feeds them (they eat breakfast and lunch there daily) and has even bought their Santa stuff. My kids barely get a look in. There is no real interest in them or anything they do. The only way I can keep my kids from getting hurt is to create distance so that they can't see the hierarchy. Ultimately, it's PIL who are losing out. My girls are super and we've made sure that they have full and happy lives so that they won't ever feel they've missed out.

JudgeJ · 02/03/2022 13:43

@DiddyHeck

I've heard people say that grandparents are always closer to their daughters children is it just one of those things you have to accept.

Well is your mum closer to you and yours?

It's certainly accepted on MN that 'her' mother has more rights etc than 'his' mother, maybe her perceived attachment to her daughter's children is as a result of this, have you tended to look more to your family and now this is the consequence of that?
AlternativePerspective · 02/03/2022 07:00

Tbh it’s traditional for the bride’s parents to pay for her wedding, and even though that doesn’t always happen these days, I wouldn’t uphold that as favouritism more than tradition.

Also women are generally closer to their mothers so it stands to reason that the grandchildren will often be closer as wel. You only have to look at the number of anti in law threads on here to see that many women resent the inlaws’ place in their lives and this in turn can lead to a different balance in the relationship with the GC as well…

In the OP’s case though it sounds as if SIL was the golden child growing up and before there were children in the picture, so this is naturally going to follow.

Fedupbuyer · 02/03/2022 06:47

Yes,my iL’s will never babysit our dc’s but they watch sil’s dc at least 3 times a week,they gave her a deposit to buy a house,we got zilch,they are also paying for her wedding abroad,we didn’t even get a card!oh an they also expect us to cough up 5k to go to said wedding next year!

Trinacham · 02/03/2022 06:41

Definitely not the case on my side of the family. My mum loves my Nephews and fussed over them just the same as she does my Nieces and now my son. Whether it will be on the in-laws side, will have to wait and see!

EmilyEmmabob · 02/03/2022 06:29

My MIL says that you're always closer to your daughter's children so even if that wasn't true she's made it so! SIL has the youngest children, before she had children MIL would need her 'permission' before she'd spend any time with us. Now that we all have children MIL sees SIL's children almost every day and hasn't seen ours since Christmas. It's like she wants that stupid idea to be true and uses it as an excuse. SIL's behaviour has been very poor which has made it difficult for MIL to fit in the time to spend time with us. Now it has got to the point where I don't even try,

DH and his brother are older than SIL, they were pretty much brainwashed into believing that life revolved around SIL and so put up with it. It's caused a lot of conflict, DH even brought up the issue with MIL who admitted it but refused to see an issue. At that point I gave up, I feel like she doesn't even see me and the DC as family.

I can't make her care. When she and DH maintain that this isn't about caring I remind DH that my family is huge and I never once felt left out by my Grandparents, and neither did my cousins. My grandparents had a mix of sons and daughters. I think my DH knows he can't change things and so chooses to ignore it for the sake of keeping the peace.

lugeforlife · 27/02/2022 23:11

I agree with a pp that if there is a close mother/daughter bond before you are pregnant that does give an increased sense of intimacy from the get go - I love my mil but she wasn't the one I sobbed down the bone to during my miscarriages or who tried to help me get my boobs in the right position for bf. My mum was my back up birth partner (dh hospital phobic so I needed a back up) but hell would have frozen over before that was mil.

cutebutstabby · 27/02/2022 22:54

My MIL openly admitted she felt closer to her daughter's Dsons than our Ddaughters even though her son sees her more often than her daughter does and we gave her the first grandchild. She saw all the grandchildren
equally when they were younger so no excuses to treat then differently or feel differently. All kids are grownups now but I haven't ever forgotten it tbh and thought it was a nasty insult to her very helpful kind son. Nasty to say it let alone think it.

Powaqa · 27/02/2022 19:32

Growing up my dB was the golden child in my family but once we both had children, I became a lot closer to my mother and spent a lot more time with my parents and consequently so did my children. I got on with my PILs but didn't see them as often. That was down to my ex DH to arrange, not me. It was the same with my DB, his vhildren saw her parents more than my parents and even though all the children are adults now, each set of Dg have a much closer relationship with their maternal grandparents. .
I have a grandchild now and my Dd , SIL and grand Hill live with me so o am extremely lucky and have a fantastic relationship with all 3 of them. I often say that my SIL should take my grandchild to see his parents, but he doesn't and his parents never visit despite frequent invitations but they are all over her cousins who are the children of her daughter.
It's just the way it seems to be.

ChocolateMassacre · 27/02/2022 18:11

@NumberTheory

I think, in general, people have very gendered expectations about their children and their parents, even more so than they might for friends, and this often leads to quite different treatment sons and daughters. I don’t think it always results in daughters being treated better. But with the way caring generally falls on women in society and the way women tend to be much more active in maintaining social networks, it is common that a mother will have a closer bond with their daughters.

That bond between a mum and her daughter is often strengthened when grand children come along in a way that relationships with sons (or in-laws) aren’t. There’s a lot of intimate support and sharing that can be provided by a mother to her daughter who’s pregnant or recently given birth that would not be as welcome from a MiL (nor as comfortable being shared with/provided to a DiL) and that isn’t need by a son who’s about/just become a father. Then the help that can be provided when children are younger is often asked for by daughters - because son’s tend to take on less of the caring for babies work and provided by the women’s mothers because it’s easier to ask your mother than your MiL and probably grandmothers are more likely to respond positively to requests from their daughters than their daughters-in-law because they are already closer.

If women didn’t do the bulk of child rearing and there wasn’t a biological burden that only women shoulder then I think the skew towards daughters being closer would be less true. But in the society we live in, I think it’s to be expected, really.

But as I say above, closer doesn’t necessarily mean more favourably, though in your case, OP, it does seem that way.

I agree with this. In some cases, there is favouritism but in many cases women still do the bulk of the caring work for children. They are likely to involve their own parents to a far greater degree than their PILs. If men don't step up and get involved, organise stuff or take the DC to visit their parents, they can't then complain about the lack of a bond between their DC and paternal grandparents. It is not for the mother to organise this. Now actually I like my PILs and do organise stuff with them sometimes but I'm clear with my DH that I expect him to organise most things with PIL. That does mean my DS sees my parents more often and is probably closer to them as a result.
GreekGod · 27/02/2022 18:10

We have the exact same situation. DH's parents are like this. FIL is actually awful at times - making it so blatantly obvious. I just ignore it for a quiet life and funnily enough, it makes us closer as a family and the 3 DC stick up for each other whenever there is clearly favouritism with the other GC. The sad thing is that only DH keeps trying to prove himself to his DF as if it would make any difference - they favour DD and that's it but DH would never admit it.

Squidlydoo · 27/02/2022 18:03

I think the relationship between MIL and DIL and that DIL relationship with own mother is a factor here.

If a daughter is very close to own mother and the grandparent/grandchild relationship is strong, MIL can sometimes feel less included.

Family dynamics are complex beasts though