Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Making my teen girl do her room

85 replies

Kyiv · 27/02/2022 13:51

Just that, really?

Back to school tomorrow, told her all half term that she had to do her room. She chose instead to ignore it until the last minute, despite regular reminders. She said she's not a baby and she can manage her own time. I said fine, that'll be the case then until Sunday, when you'll absolutely have to do it if you haven't already. Lots of eye rolling, huffing, but that was the deal.

Sunday. She's not done a damn thing. I told her to do it. She reeled in disbelief because she HAD. MADE. PLANS and I don't understand her or her life etc etc. Her friends are coming to knock for her and they're going out. I said no, that's not happening and that she would be staying in to tidy her room.

Fucking MELTDOWN! Screaming about how I don't understand her, she needs to be with people who do, it's her room, she can organise her stuff however the hell she wants, she's not cleaning to my standards, when SHE says it's clean, it is CLEAN, and that's when she's going out.

She half heartedly pushed crap into drawers, rubbish into corners and then said she was done. I said she wasn't. She sent me a message then telling me I was horrible and that I was keeping her prisoner and she hates this house etc.

Aibu to still tell her she can finish her room and I'm not having this attitude just because she's been asked to do something and can't actually manage her own time at all

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
SirVixofVixHall · 27/02/2022 20:51

@AlexaShutUp

I would pick your battles, personally. As long as it isn't a health hazard, does it really matter if her room is a mess? It's her room...
I agree with this.
speakout · 27/02/2022 20:41

Just close the door,
Don't sweat the small stuff.
There are many many things that a teen can do much worse than have an untidy bedroom.

CrotchetyQuaver · 27/02/2022 20:38

You're doing the right things OP.

I'd have gone nuclear about the calling me a bitch to look good in front of her friends. I think I might have gone nuclear there and then and forcibly dragged her back from going out with her friends.

She thinks you're a bitch, well show her what a bitch you can be when you're angry and make her life hell for being a horrible disrespectful brat.

Unfortunately with some girls it's a real battle of wills to see who cracks first. By the time she was 20 my DD1 was nice again, but it was very difficult getting there, her know it all attitude got her into a few serious pickles on the way. Guess who she needed to help and support her every time it went tits up? The long suffering mother. Never had the problems with DD2 thank goodness.
She'll get bored of sighing dramatically at some point, whatever you do, do not back down, it'll be worse next time if you do and this is a battle of wills you must win.

ukborn · 27/02/2022 20:00

When she returns snd on a day you are both in a reasonable mood, and there's a couple hours free, why not say 'tell you what, I know tidying is a pain, so let's do your room together'. Hopefully she will accept. Afterwards, all clean and tidy, laundry on, say something like 'it feels so much better to have a clean space, do you think you can keep it like this'? It probably will sink into a mess again, but instead of getting in to another shouting match, tell her it's a matter of respect for herself and respect for you and her father who pay for everything. If that gets you nowhere, stop doing anything - not her laundry or whatever. Leave her to it - you helped, showed her how, but if she really won't help herself let her wallow in her own filth.

Notanotherwindow · 27/02/2022 19:44

Do it. Post photos on social media of how disgusting it is and tag her. Shame her in front of her friends. Never mind the WiFi, take the phone off her. If she won't give it up, take the charger. The data and cocky attitude only lasts as long as the battery.

poetryandwine · 27/02/2022 19:04

Hi, @Kyiv -

The real story is in your drip feed, particularly your DD audibly referring to you as a bitch to her friends. But also that her room is a disaster area and needs much more than a tidy.

Good on you for finally putting your foot down. But why did it take so long, and why is there no mention that she must apologise to you? She was insulting you to your face. (IMO what she says about you in truly private circs is not your concern.)

Recently there was a thread from a stressed mum who seemed to be reacting too personally to her 13 y.o.’s thoughtlessness with the hot water. But your DD is trying very hard to engage you and you are ignoring the personal aspect (as far as we know).

Kyiv · 27/02/2022 18:45

She got in at 4. I changed the WiFi password, told her it's not being given to her until her room is sparkling clean. She is currently laid on her bed, staring at the ceiling and dramatically sighing every few minutes, so loud that everyone in the house can hear her. Dh has told her that this if she'd be ashamed to have it showcased on the social media app she tends to live on, she'd better clean it up fast. She's still not moved.

OP posts:
Brefugee · 27/02/2022 18:45

I think you need to take charge of this. Two things:

  1. the state of her room and
  2. calling you a bitch

for 1: frankly at this stage i'd go in with 2 bin bags: 1 for the rubbish, 1 for anything i could grab that has value to her. On this one occasion I'd get all the crockery out and wash it.
Rubbish bag in the rubbish bin. Bag of "valuables" would be locked away somewhere, car boot, garage, somewhere she can't get her hands on it.

When she comes back you outline the rules again: you aren't going to tidy, no laundry service and if she puts any crockery in the room, no more cooking until it comes back

  1. Change the wifi, grounded for a day (next Saturday) and it extends for every day she doesn't apologise

As for the future state of her room? Just ignore it. Don't go in there but don't let her have her friends in their either.

lunar1 · 27/02/2022 18:42

My teenager wouldn't be seeing his friends for a long time if he called me that.

Kyiv · 27/02/2022 18:35

@Hopefulsunrise

Consistency is key here and separate tasks so it's not overwhelming. Everytime she goes upstairs "bring your cups down when you are next coming down" everytime until cups are down. Chip away at it gently but firmly and she will do it and it will become a habit eventually. Its important if it's really not just mess but hoarding and a health hazard that she learns that looking after her room and her own private space is actually self care not a chore. Buy a nice houseplant for her room or windowsill. Caring for and having responsibility for something else is useful.
I've been wasting my breath for three years with this. Honestly.
OP posts:
Ginger1982 · 27/02/2022 18:30

@TempName01

I think this is really normal for that age, don’t bag up her stuff, don’t be too hard on her! I would offer to help with the room this time, put some music on and blitz it together.
Really? I was her age once and never lived like that.
nancybotwinbloom · 27/02/2022 18:05

Calling you a bitch?

Change the internet password
No pocket money.
No lifts etc.

I'd be Inclined to be a bit of a bitch.

She needs to apologise.

Jamnation · 27/02/2022 18:04

@WalkingOnTheCracks

I'd separate the issues...

Tidying the room - admin. Nag, persuade, enable, be persistent.

Calling you a bitch in front of friends - total no-no. Confiscation of phone, cutting off of money supply, removal of laptop, possibly crucifixion.

This. Be clear on what you're going nuclear on.

With bedroom tidying I tend to supply binbags etc, and time requests with stuff you are doing for them anyway. Could you go and blitz your room for 20 mins while I cook your diner, then we'll sit down and watch Apprentice. My parents left me to it and I'm still messy and an epic procrastinator, so I tend to err on the side of scaffolding still for my own DC.

Graphista · 27/02/2022 17:37

The way I did it with dd was she got her pocket money/allowance sat midday. If her room wasn't clean and tidy at that point - no money

If she backchatted - grounded for one day

Kept pushing it - more days grounded, loss of pocket money, phone etc

Yes pick your battles but a room that isn't a health hazard is one of them!

She hasn't paid for any of the items in there and isn't the one who would have to pay to replace anything damaged as a a result of her laziness.

She's done marginally above the bare minimum and I've let her go out until 4pm when she must come back and finish it without massive drama. She walked up to her friends and very audibly said "lets go somewhere away from this bitch."

Sorry op but you're being an absolute pushover!

If my dd had spoken of/to me like that it would have been an instant 2 day grounding - no arguments

She was also already doing her own laundry at this stage following an argument re my apparently washing the wrong school jumper which looked to me exactly identical to the other in the laundry!

Grounded here meant home and school only, no phone, no friends over, no personal screen time, early bedtime.

Dd was no angel but she wasn't half as bad as some!

She's 21 now and away at uni and much tidier than she was here, the younger flatmates are annoying her with their mess - karma! Grin

But yea you have to have clear boundaries and certain behaviour is NEVER acceptable to let them away with.

You need to toughen up op

Perrymenopausal · 27/02/2022 17:16

Dd (same age) always has a messier room than I would like. But it’s messy not rancid. It gets to a certain state and then she’ll tidy it and the cycle continues. I’d step in if it’s in the state you described. My mum used to give me a set time to do it and anything not done was binned, I learned the hard way.

The way she spoke to you would be a confiscation of her devices. That is way worse than the state of her room imho.

Peachy7 · 27/02/2022 17:16

My dad would not have let me out on day 1 unless it was done, and every day after until it was done to his standard. His house, his rules!

Topseyt · 27/02/2022 17:11

My teens always lived in a mess, but one thing I was rigid on was that food and drink was never allowed in the bedrooms, so that crockery didn't just disappear up there never to emerge again. I also refused to rewash clothes that I knew hadn't been worn since the last wash. DD3 was the main culprit for that, and I just handed those straight back to her. She got the message eventually.

A chaotic bedroom I can cope with as I just shut the door (I am a "pick your battles" type usually). However, a stinky and rancid one as you describe I would find totally unacceptable too. I don't think I would have let her go out at all because she isn't even adhering to any basic standards.

I wouldn't permit the burning of incense or candles because they are such a huge fire hazard, and that has to be even worse in a shithole of a room. So I would ban those forthwith.

If I had ever heard any of my teenagers calling me a bitch as yours did then I would have called them straight back (yes, in front of their friends too) and grounded them immediately.

The teenage years are hard. Teenagers are boundary pushers. I am rather relieved to be all but through those years now, as my youngest is 19.

NoLongerTroels · 27/02/2022 17:04

This is a battle I choose not to fight.
Dd (17) her room is a right mess. I close the door on it. She will clear the floor so we can vacuum occasionally, and we have clamped down on taking food in there, so far she is complying with this. Other than that it's a mess. My sister was the same, once she got her own place she made a complete U turn and was very fussy.

IWentAwayIStayedAway · 27/02/2022 17:01

Being called a bitch in this house would mean phone contract cancelled, no wifi, room contents in bin bag. And that would be just the start.

TempName01 · 27/02/2022 17:01

I’m not saying the behaviour is good by the way just that it sounds like typical teenager.

TempName01 · 27/02/2022 16:53

My room was always a state too, being yelled at never compelled me to tidy it, it would just make me more stubborn.

Lovemusic33 · 27/02/2022 16:50

My room was similar at that age TBH 😬

Both my DD’s are untidy, both have ASD which makes things even trickier. However they do bring their washing down when asked and will tidy up if I instruct them, If dd2 refuses then I threaten to go in with the bin bag.

Nanny0gg · 27/02/2022 16:48

@TempName01

I think this is really normal for that age, don’t bag up her stuff, don’t be too hard on her! I would offer to help with the room this time, put some music on and blitz it together.
Normal?

In what world? I appreciate I am considerably older but I would most definitely have been knocked into next week by my mild-mannered father (who never raised a hand to me) if I'd called my mother a bitch.

None of my children's rooms were EVER in that state (untidy yes, squalid, no) and food wasn't allowed in them anyway. Nor would they ever have called me a bitch (in my presence).

After an apology I might supervise and suggest ideas and methods but I'd be buggered if I'd make a party out of it

TempName01 · 27/02/2022 16:42

I think this is really normal for that age, don’t bag up her stuff, don’t be too hard on her! I would offer to help with the room this time, put some music on and blitz it together.

Notanotherwindow · 27/02/2022 16:32

And you let her walk out after the bitch comment?

Like fuck would I have that from anyone never mind my own child. Get up there with a bin bag and dispose of everything. If she can't keep it clean it obviously doesn't matter to her so just bin it all. And yes she absolutely DOES need to keep it up to your standard in YOUR FUCKING HOUSE.

I'm actually furious on your behalf OP. Who the hell does she think she is? Spoilt, entitled little madam.

I'd have sent her straight back and told her to bloody stay there until she can be a civil human being and she'd have fuck all in the way of tech until she learned some manners. I'd not have dared speak to my mother like that, I'd have been walloped into next week and grounded indefinitely.

When she gets home, take her phone and tell her she can earn it back by apologising to you, cleaning her room and sorting the attitude problem. If she can't keep her private space clean then she wouldn't have one. Take the bloody door off if that's what it takes.

Swipe left for the next trending thread