Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to refuse subsidised private school fees

435 replies

itsbritneybitch92 · 27/02/2022 10:17

My SO and I are turning 30 and are finally planning a family (as we’ve been together since we were 18!). We are not quite on the same page about state vs private education.

We are both in a well respected profession with competitive university entry requirements, 5-6 years of university study and a decade of further training and postgraduate exams. So we have both achieved very well in life. Our household income is high (we earn the same) but nowhere near enough to afford two children in private school alongside other necessities. We are in London.

I grew up in London a single parent family in a 1 bedroom council flat. My mum was a nurse and worked 6-7 days a week, even through school holidays until I was 18. I went to state schools.

My SO grew up in the largest detached house in the surrey hills that I have ever set foot in with a parent who is the CEO of a major finance company. You can imagine the rest from here.

As I grew up relatively “poor”, I like to work for things myself. I’m not a fan of handouts. If I want something, I save hard for however long, I see how I can make it fit into my budget. If my SO wants something, his parents will offer it to him. And why shouldn’t they? They’ve worked so hard to provide for their son. My SO never asks for anything though.

His parents recently helped us with a £350k deposit on a £950k house. I added £25k into this which was my entire life savings since I was born. I felt so uneasy with this at first but honestly his parents are amazing, they treat me like their daughter and I was grateful for this massive jump onto the property ladder for our future family. But SO and I agreed that this would be only handout from his family.

Now, his parents are offering a lump sum to cover 50% of private school fees for two children until university. We haven’t calculated how much this is as it varies by school but from what I have googled, one term can be £30k.

SO and I aren’t sure what to do. I want to refuse, SO wants to accept for a few years. He feels that a good education is guaranteed in a private school. I feel that we can find a good state school and supplement with extracurriculars and memories e.g. holidays etc. 50% of private school fees for two children until 18 for us will still be a massive stretch. Also it’s silly to put kids in private school then suddenly switch them to state school.

I don’t like the idea of our children growing up thinking that their grandparents paid for their housing and their education and also, my mother can offer very little. It feels unbalanced. I also really don’t want snobby kids.

OP posts:
moretrumpetplease · 27/02/2022 12:40

I went to a state school, with an arsey name because of what it used to be. My parents didn't pay a penny and I still came out with AAAAB and AAAB - I'm now I'm a secure, well paid job. My advice? Save half the money you'd whack on a private education and give it as a house deposit - nobody has ever given a flying fig about my schooling, just what I'm capable of.

Baystard · 27/02/2022 12:38

I think you're missing the point OP. It sounds like your DPIL are doing a positive thing in supporting you and your husband now, rather than sitting on their assets and you only benefitting once they've died. On their part, if they can afford it, it sounds like proactive tax planning.

PrimroseTheSmooth · 27/02/2022 12:34

I'd break it down-

  1. do you have an absolute objection to private school? Doesn't sound like it.
  1. do you have an absolute objection to GP funding half? Again, doesn't sound like it.
  1. would the private schools available to your DC offer them significantly more than the viable state options? This is the key, I think, and you won't know the answer until you actually have DC, know what sort of school is likely to suit them, have researched all the options, understand what state schools will be open to you etc. A lot of people on here saying that state is better or private is better- the fact is there are some superb state schools and some rubbish ones, ditto private schools. You need to think about comparing actual schools not systems (given 1 above).

Do the GP need an answer now? Could you say that you really appreciate their offer and can you all discuss it again once you have DC and are thinking about schools? (I'd also do a bit of research now, especially as you don't want to get caught out by admissions deadlines, which can vary wildly in the private sector.)

GirlOfTudor · 27/02/2022 12:34

You're not even pregnant yet, and you're thinking about possibly sending kids (that don't exist yet) to private schools that wouldn't potentially happen for YEARS. You could take years to get pregnant. All this is incredibly premature. A lot could happen if/when this situation arises.

Also the £350k 'help' with a deposit?!?! On an almost million pound house?! As a FIRST home?! Jesus.... How the other half live.....

You've done amazing well to become a doctor through hard work and coming from humble beginnings. That IS amazing! The rest?? First world problems.

Musmerian · 27/02/2022 12:34

OP 30k per term is for boarding at really top end schools. I teach in a highly academic day school in a city and school fees are £15 k per year. I know that’s not the only issue but it’s as well to have the facts to hand.

NuffSaidSam · 27/02/2022 12:33

@AlexaShutUp

Why on earth do people keep telling the OP to get married. Can't they read? She's already married, and it isn't really the point of the thread in any case!
Reading comprehension is at an all time low it seems.
TrendingNowt · 27/02/2022 12:33

You don't have children.
Fertility is on decline from here. You could be struggling with IVF for thr next 10 years.
Stop stressing about hypothetical children. If you fall pregnant, consider it at the time you're looking around nurseries.

DietrichandDiMaggio · 27/02/2022 12:32

@MzHz

You say they’re lovely in-laws, and as long as there are no strings attached then you would be an idiot to refuse!

As for state primary then private secondary, daft idea, as they will make friends at primary level who may go on to same secondary level

My ds went to a different secondary school to his friends and hasn’t made close friendships at his new school in all the 5 years he’s been there

All his friends are from his primary school in our local area. Which is good from a pick up and drop off point of view but I wished he had made friends at school because it would have improved his experience there, and who knows his performance

Lots of children don't go to the same secondary school as their friends from primary school, whether they go state, primary or both, and I'm pretty sure the vast majority manage to make friends at each school.
OkThenJustChill · 27/02/2022 12:32

I would have no issue accepting the money as long as it had no strings. I come from a working class background and my DH is upper middle class. His parents have made lots of contributions towards our wedding, renovation work and our DS. I do feel awkward about it sometimes but I understand that from their perspective they just want to put their money to good use. What better way is there to spend money than on loved ones? My DH's siblings have also recieved support and it would be unfair to not allow DH to have financial support too.

Your feelings might change or at least soften when you actually have children. You'll realise that you would do anything and everything to give your child the best start in life. Your children will learn their values from their parents and having a hardworking nurse as a granny is also going to help keep your children grounded too!

HundredMilesAnHour · 27/02/2022 12:31

@itsbritneybitch92

We said that would be the only one. It’s difficult to get on the property ladder, it’s not hard to send a kid to school.
That sounds like a convenient excuse. You couldn't have got on the property ladder for £600k?! Of course you could. You chose to take the extra money and get a more expensive property. So how is private school different? You want to have principles but you also compromise them when it suits you. There's nothing wrong with that bit it's a bit late to be doing the holier-than-thou thing.
AlexaShutUp · 27/02/2022 12:30

Why on earth do people keep telling the OP to get married. Can't they read? She's already married, and it isn't really the point of the thread in any case!

ThymePoultice · 27/02/2022 12:27

So you’re not married? Who exactly was the enormous deposit gifted to? How is the house ownership set up? Who would the equity go to in a split?

I wouldn’t rush into DC, or anything else, until you be and your DP have addressed equality in the relationship.

ConsuelaHammock · 27/02/2022 12:26

My advice
1 . Get married
2 . Wait until you’ve had a baby before you worry about schooling.

DietrichandDiMaggio · 27/02/2022 12:24

Except she does, specifically, in her OP. "We are in London."

I somehow missed that - I just saw that she grew up in London. As I presumed they were in London anyway, my comment stands.

BuanoKubiamVej · 27/02/2022 12:23

I would recommend "state till 8" and assess the situation when your eldest is 7 years old.

Whilst it is true that some kids will thrive at any school, and perhaps there are kids for whom private school is a waste, there certainly are kids who won't thrive without extra nurturing. Supplementing what a state school can offer with extra tutoring is not a cure-all - some children simply don't have the capacity to spend extra tine studying on top of what is offered at school (eg consider someone with sensory issues connected to neurodiversity, or someone with a talent for music or sport who needs all their extracurricular time for that, not for catching up with inadequately taught maths) so absolutely must have their main schooling be top quality.

I felt strongly that my DC wouldn't thrive at a comprehensive secondary and we saved up as much as possible during the primary years and are accepting a modest grandparents contribution to scrape together fees for a good selective independent school. It's not remotely snobby. The kids don't think they are better than anyone else but they are able to focus on their work without their teachers having to spend most of their time on crowd control of the disruptive students who don't want to learn who are there at every state school. DC very clearly happy and thriving. Meanwhile I am hearing from the parents of kids similar to my DC who went to the comprehensives are experiencing bullying and other difficulties due to the lack of the supportive and studious education environment that we are luckily managing to provide for our DC, so I am confident that we made the right choice.

blueshoes · 27/02/2022 12:23

Just take it for your not-yet-conceived dcs.

You would be a hypocrite and selfish to-be-parent if you accepted the house deposit for yourself but denied your unborn dcs the gift of a rounded education for personal reasons which sound frankly chippy. This is about your identity so figure that out but don't arbitrarily deprive your dcs. Don't forget that your dh has a say in how the dcs are schooled as well.

Others are right that if you don't accept it, a big chunk of that amount is likely to go to the taxman as inheritance tax. Perhaps you would feel more comfortable with that.

Swear · 27/02/2022 12:23

It depends a lot on your local state schools. I'd probably ask the GPs to put the money into an account for the children, while the children went through state primary, and would then use that money to finance a good and as non-snobby as possible private school. I don't mean that I'd expect the GPs to finance 100% of secondary private - just 50%. The money "saved" for primary school could maybe be put in an ISA to be used for a house deposit when the children are older. Much better value than a private primary education, and less snob risk for the primary years.

TimeToMakeACupofTea · 27/02/2022 12:22

As far as I’m concerned, my responsibility as a parent is to get my daughter the best possible education I can obtain for her. That may well be a state education; however, if the best option was a private school and I could afford it, then that’s what I’d go for. If my in-laws offered money to facilitate that option, I’d take it.

blameless · 27/02/2022 12:22

The boarding schools that are household names can cost £50k per year by the time school trips and extras are factored in, day fees are significantly less.
I'm not sure that the money is the real issue here - it certainly might make it feel like the OP has been bought and paid for - but I sense that the OP is more worried about feeling an outsider in her own immediate family.
There is time to get your head around some of these issues and negotiate/navigate a future direction that you can find peace with. Until you see what local provision looks like in your area, I would be loath to dismiss the offer of help, lots of state schools are struggling to find staff who can afford to work in them.

Fairislefandango · 27/02/2022 12:21

I generally think private education is overrated

It is very easy to say that if you have guaranteed places at a truly exceptional state school, or if you don't know what you're talking about.

It is very easy to dismiss as snobby a parent's desire to send their children to a school where the other kids' aspirations are high and behaviour is excellent if you have not experienced the realities of sending your own dc to a poor or even an average comp. It's also very easy (and a lazy stereotype) to dismiss those students as snobs as well.

I'd love for you to spend the day with a random selection of the kids I've taught in comprehensive schools and the kids I've taught at private schools. I'm pretty sure I know which ones you'd consider more tolerant and less prejudiced. Obviously I can only speak for the 10 or so schools I've worked in, but still...

Blondeshavemorefun · 27/02/2022 12:20

@itsbritneybitch92 - I don’t get the diff in in-laws helping you by giving you a 1/3 towards mortgage /house v in-laws spending less on their grandkids schooling

Fwiw I worked as a nanny for 20yrs. Many dc I looked after went to private from 3 , equally some went to local state school

I don’t think that is necessary to do private nursery to 11

State till 11 then private if need be

@User112 you are my area. Indeed good schools. My brother went to judd

KerryWeaver · 27/02/2022 12:20

It would appear that by accepting such a large deposit on your family home you are willing to accept your PILs largesse for yourself but are unwilling to allow your children to do so.

In this situation, I would have kept my financial independence and not accepted the deposit. After all who wants snobby neighbours?

However, I would also recognise that my children are their grandchildren. I would have allowed the grandparents to pay the school fees.

Is there a reason that they are only paying half the fees? Somehow, I suspect that this might not work with their inheritance tax planning.

I know I would have preferred them to pay the full school fees but not pay the deposit.

StartingGrid · 27/02/2022 12:20

If this is all you have to worry about, perhaps you should take up a hobby.

mam0918 · 27/02/2022 12:18

I wouldn't send my kid to a private school no matter how rich I was (unless it was due to needing it because of disability and public schools not being able to provide access or services needed).

I don't believe for one second it leads to smarter kids or 'better education'.

I went to a shitty public school (a really bad one) and I have 2 degrees, 1 being a medical degree and the people on my course were from all kinds of backgrounds (most NOT from private education) and all equal in intelligence to have made it onto the course.

If private schools made a difference to education we would have more competent politicians lol.

I do believe 'private schooling' feeds into the class system and everything that's wrong with society though.

Parents virtually bankrupting themselves because as with this thread if they say they 'don't want to' for any host of reasons they are accused of being shitty parents and not caring about their kid's future - society is really just chasing the Jones rather than putting their kids first.

Cherryblossoms85 · 27/02/2022 12:18

It's a tough one for sure. I used to say that I'd be happy to send the kids to private secondaries, because our area has horrific state schools, as in police regularly called. I thought private primaries were snobby and wouldn't teach my kids what the world really is. I'm changing my mind quite quickly as the eldest foes into year 4. The reaching is just so bad. He can barely write. Seems like they expect parents to actually do the teaching after school and they just watch videos in school. So....I would take the money. But totally agree about the imbalance.