Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to refuse subsidised private school fees

435 replies

itsbritneybitch92 · 27/02/2022 10:17

My SO and I are turning 30 and are finally planning a family (as we’ve been together since we were 18!). We are not quite on the same page about state vs private education.

We are both in a well respected profession with competitive university entry requirements, 5-6 years of university study and a decade of further training and postgraduate exams. So we have both achieved very well in life. Our household income is high (we earn the same) but nowhere near enough to afford two children in private school alongside other necessities. We are in London.

I grew up in London a single parent family in a 1 bedroom council flat. My mum was a nurse and worked 6-7 days a week, even through school holidays until I was 18. I went to state schools.

My SO grew up in the largest detached house in the surrey hills that I have ever set foot in with a parent who is the CEO of a major finance company. You can imagine the rest from here.

As I grew up relatively “poor”, I like to work for things myself. I’m not a fan of handouts. If I want something, I save hard for however long, I see how I can make it fit into my budget. If my SO wants something, his parents will offer it to him. And why shouldn’t they? They’ve worked so hard to provide for their son. My SO never asks for anything though.

His parents recently helped us with a £350k deposit on a £950k house. I added £25k into this which was my entire life savings since I was born. I felt so uneasy with this at first but honestly his parents are amazing, they treat me like their daughter and I was grateful for this massive jump onto the property ladder for our future family. But SO and I agreed that this would be only handout from his family.

Now, his parents are offering a lump sum to cover 50% of private school fees for two children until university. We haven’t calculated how much this is as it varies by school but from what I have googled, one term can be £30k.

SO and I aren’t sure what to do. I want to refuse, SO wants to accept for a few years. He feels that a good education is guaranteed in a private school. I feel that we can find a good state school and supplement with extracurriculars and memories e.g. holidays etc. 50% of private school fees for two children until 18 for us will still be a massive stretch. Also it’s silly to put kids in private school then suddenly switch them to state school.

I don’t like the idea of our children growing up thinking that their grandparents paid for their housing and their education and also, my mother can offer very little. It feels unbalanced. I also really don’t want snobby kids.

OP posts:
Sceptre86 · 27/02/2022 13:39

It's a tough one. It depends on the schooling in your area tbh. I'd check it out now. How are the primary schools and the high school? Is it good pastorally, you want your kids to be happy at school as well as get good grades. If the schools are good and remain so I would say no. If the high school isn't great I would take them up on the offer for high school. You've achieved just as well as you so despite coming from a more humble background. Your children's experience won't be the same as yours anyway, they will be living on a two parent household for a start, in an expensive home with probable access to better schooling. They will have had one up from you from birth and I think you should come to terms with that. Afterwards it is a very generous offer, your inlaws sound like nice people who won't interfere so it's up to you both. I don't think the decision needs to be made right now as you don't know how long it will take you to get pregnant and what your children will be like. Some need more support than others and might be better catered to in a warm, state school than a more rigid environment in private school. You can't possibly know until they arrive. I'd say to your inlaws that it is a lovely offer but you don't want to make any big decisions until the children actually arrive.

Autumndays123 · 27/02/2022 13:37

@itsbritneybitch92

My SO and I are turning 30 and are finally planning a family (as we’ve been together since we were 18!). We are not quite on the same page about state vs private education.

We are both in a well respected profession with competitive university entry requirements, 5-6 years of university study and a decade of further training and postgraduate exams. So we have both achieved very well in life. Our household income is high (we earn the same) but nowhere near enough to afford two children in private school alongside other necessities. We are in London.

I grew up in London a single parent family in a 1 bedroom council flat. My mum was a nurse and worked 6-7 days a week, even through school holidays until I was 18. I went to state schools.

My SO grew up in the largest detached house in the surrey hills that I have ever set foot in with a parent who is the CEO of a major finance company. You can imagine the rest from here.

As I grew up relatively “poor”, I like to work for things myself. I’m not a fan of handouts. If I want something, I save hard for however long, I see how I can make it fit into my budget. If my SO wants something, his parents will offer it to him. And why shouldn’t they? They’ve worked so hard to provide for their son. My SO never asks for anything though.

His parents recently helped us with a £350k deposit on a £950k house. I added £25k into this which was my entire life savings since I was born. I felt so uneasy with this at first but honestly his parents are amazing, they treat me like their daughter and I was grateful for this massive jump onto the property ladder for our future family. But SO and I agreed that this would be only handout from his family.

Now, his parents are offering a lump sum to cover 50% of private school fees for two children until university. We haven’t calculated how much this is as it varies by school but from what I have googled, one term can be £30k.

SO and I aren’t sure what to do. I want to refuse, SO wants to accept for a few years. He feels that a good education is guaranteed in a private school. I feel that we can find a good state school and supplement with extracurriculars and memories e.g. holidays etc. 50% of private school fees for two children until 18 for us will still be a massive stretch. Also it’s silly to put kids in private school then suddenly switch them to state school.

I don’t like the idea of our children growing up thinking that their grandparents paid for their housing and their education and also, my mother can offer very little. It feels unbalanced. I also really don’t want snobby kids.

How are you turning 30 with 16 years of university education and post graduate exams? Did you start university at 13?
2Two · 27/02/2022 13:36

How much do you know about state school education? I used to feel like you, till our oldest child went to a supposedly outstanding secibdart academy in a middle class area. Classes were large and constantly noisy, and although discipline purported to be strict it mostly stretched to enforcing petty uniform rules rather than doing anything about constant low level bullying (on and offline) and sexual harassment. Academics were nothing to write home about, either. DC's friend who had quite severe dyslexia really struggled to get anything like adequate support, because the school was too cash-strapped. We gave up and took DC out after a couple of years, and never regretted it.

BurntO · 27/02/2022 13:33

YABU to be overthinking this at this stage. These discussions are important but if you can’t afford the other 50% comfortably then you can’t afford it at all. This is all many years away, everyone’s circumstances may have changed by then. Pointless pondering for much now

Singlebutmarried · 27/02/2022 13:33

But this handout isn’t for you.

Someone upthread may have already said this but the grandparents paying the school fees whether via a trust or whatever would be very tax efficient for them, so it makes financial sense on their part.

maltesers99 · 27/02/2022 13:33

The deposit you accepted is more than the value of the average UK home! So you can't be that unwilling to accept help. Also you say you are worried about your kids being snobs..and yet your OH went to private school- is he a snob?! Why would your children be if they went to private school?
It's all hypothetical anyway at this point, until they are born it's not worth fretting about.

ThymePoultice · 27/02/2022 13:32

If you’re happy to take £350k for the most important transaction, then “I prefer to save for things myself” stance becomes silly.

Also, if you’re prepared to turnover child rearing to his family, then your DC won’t be your own, anyway, so why quibble about school fees?

If you genuinely want your independence, get out now. Your life will not be your own, and your not-yet-conceived babies have already been claimed.

Herewegoagain84 · 27/02/2022 13:32

Having read through your posts, more generally I think you need to slow down in general. The biggest thing about having children is the inability to control/plan so much. You’ve said how many days PIL will look after them, and that maternity will be “as short as possible”. Honestly, you have no idea how you’ll feel after having a child - you may want a longer leave / you may have a sick child that requires longer leave / you may have a child with SEN. You may decide you don’t want PIL looking after them regularly / perhaps one of them may get sick and can’t. Just so many variables at this point. You can’t overplan this - biggest lesson for having children.

Empressofthemundane · 27/02/2022 13:32

You are part of a new family now. To really be part of it requires give and take. Accepting help makes you vulnerable, you aren’t really part of the family if you can’t be vulnerable sometimes. They may need your help on some way down the line, too.

If you disagree on principle regarding private schools that is another matter.

If your in-laws don’t spend this money on private schools now, will it just come to him later as inheritance? Perhaps the money is more useful sooner than later. The next 20 years is when you will have big expenses and big responsibilities if you start having children.

thanktor · 27/02/2022 13:32

My children been state (very good) and private (absolutely superb)

I’d pimp myself out to my FIL and indeed my MIL of them contributing meant they could continue at private

ChateauMargaux · 27/02/2022 13:31

I see you haven't been back for a while but if you have children.. don't automatically assume that in addition to pregnancy and maternity leave, it should be you that downshifts to 3 days per week. The world is structurally stacked against you in terms of your long term earning potential, when it becomes clear that you will be having children you will see you husbands earning potential outstrip yours. His old boys network and his lack of uterus are already in his favour... even the odds and let him drop to 3 days per week. You are in one of the few career where you have the possibility to continue earning your high salary... don't trip yourself up and hand the race to your husband where you would be more in debted to him and his family. Also don't assume that your inlaws will provide childcare.. did wealthy CEO of a finance company actually do ant child care for his own kids? I would wager not. If his wife was a SAHM she has already sacrificed a huge amount for her husband and children, set her free and allow her to have quality time with her grandchildren rather than the groundhog slog of childcare where she will be told what to do by her son and daughter in law. You have two decent salaries... you can afford childcare. If your husband doesn't like the idea of nursery, he can stay home with them or get a nanny. Your mother has given you a fantastic set of opportunities .... show her the best possible gratitude by keeping all the advantages she has given you and be an amazing role model for the next generation which places women and men in the family on equal footing. Take the offer of school fees by all means but don't have them dictate how it is spent... let them work out what 13 years for 2 kids looks like and spend it how you want... cheaper schools... secondary only... split between 4 kids... whatever.

DisforDarkChocolate · 27/02/2022 13:30

I'd feel uncomfortable but if I thought it was the best option for my children I'd take it and think of it as an early inheritance.

thanktor · 27/02/2022 13:29

* They’ve basically bought us a house and they’ll effectively be raising our children*

Hmm

I Regard raising my children a touch more than my financial contribution to their home and education

battenburgHatday · 27/02/2022 13:29

@Beamur

Say thank you. Have a baby. Look into the options available to you for schools and then decide. You may feel differently about this once you have children.
I think this is perfect advice

Good luck OP

TheRideOfYourLife · 27/02/2022 13:28

I also really don’t want snobby kids

YABU for saying this, because it would be like me saying "I sent my DC to private school because I don't want kids with a chip on their shoulder". Just because a tiny minority people who use/went to state schools are inverted snobs with chips on their shoulders about "snobby" people doesn't mean they all are.

I can see pros and cons to everything else (though I'd bite their hands off if I were you, as school fees have been crippling me for the best part of 20 years now).

I think YA also BU for making such concrete plans about your children, maternity leave, childcare etc when you are not even pregnant. You or your "SO" might suffer from infertility. You might suffer from PND which means you can't go back to work quickly. You might suffer trauma while giving birth which has the same effect. You might have a child who is disabled and needs to be cared for 24/7. You might not get a place at a state school which is anything better than 'failing'. There are so, so, so many things that can happen before you get to the state/private discussion. If I were you, I would TTC first and take it from there.

Herewegoagain84 · 27/02/2022 13:26

No schools are £30k a term… I would graciously say thank you, and then perhaps decide once you’ve actually had children / understand their needs (eg they may thrive in a smaller environment and if you have the funds to send them to small private, then great) etc. You may not be living in the same place, and if you are, are you happy with the local schools? Have you been round any privates? (Would be very early to look). I think I just wouldn’t worry about it at this stage.

Hankunamatata · 27/02/2022 13:25

You say even 50% of fees would be a stretch for you to pay then no I wouldn't consider it. I'd rather be home more for kids especially teens than having to work to pay school fees

Lunificent · 27/02/2022 13:25

I work in an independent school. It’s very typical for grandparents to pay fees. I think, in your situation, I would accept the offer.

Ellmau · 27/02/2022 13:23

Another thing to think about if it's being given as a lump sum, is (a) what if inflation ends up putting [half] school fees above the value of the lump sum; and (b) are there any tax implications?

GatoradeMeBitch · 27/02/2022 13:23

People actually saying there's no point discussing this until the children are here, yet if the children were here and she and her DP were arguing about this the first question on the thread would be "You really should have discussed this before you had a kid..."

I think you need to discuss the whole lot. Marriage would be a sensible idea before you have children. Your DP is at a large advantage financially, and if you break up you and any children will probably have an easier time of it if you are married. Then, do you actually want two children? After that, education.

Also, try and drop your squeamishness and issues around money. It's just a tool. It doesn't have to be emotionally and negatively loaded. If his parents want to help, as long as it's not in a controlling way, let them, and enjoy it.

KatherineJaneway · 27/02/2022 13:22

Beginning to feel like I’ve married well rather than done well for myself.

Don't let your ego stop your DC from having a good education.

Jedsnewstar · 27/02/2022 13:21

You haven't even got kids yet!!

The money is being offered for now though so your point is irrelevant

EthelTheAardvark · 27/02/2022 13:18

A child can attend a decent state school and then attend private tuition as needed

But how can you guarantee your child getting into a decent state school? The better the school, the more popular it will be, so you need to ensure that you live practically next door to guarantee getting in - and what do you do if you get settled next to a good school and it goes downhill, as does happen quite often? Grammar schools tend to be very competitive.

perimenofertility · 27/02/2022 13:16

You’ve bought a 950K house. Even with that chunky deposit and your savings, you’ve obviously got huge enough salaries to get a sizeable mortgage - you can afford to pay for your own children’s education.

WhyOhWine · 27/02/2022 13:16

I suspect this is inheritance tax planning by your PILs, i.e. making gifts now which are then not taken into account as part of their estate on death (assuming they survive 7 years). That is very sensible (and recommended) planning on their part, and from your (your DH's) perspective involves receiving some of the money at an earlier stage when it would likely be more useful.

So from that point of view i see no difficulty in accepting cash gifts from them, However, i would only do so on a basis that did not give them control. So i would accept money for a house deposit so long as they did not then expect to be able to decide which house or where I buy.
Similarly, in relation to this gift i would not accept it if it enabled the PILs to dictate what school my DCs went to. However, if it turns out at the time that the state options available to you are not ideal for your DC for whatever reason, it would be great to have the possible fall back of private school - it is a nice luxury to have the ability to weigh up the pros and cons of different school options without money being a real factor.

So in your case i would accept this gift but only on the basis that the funds would be used towards private schooling if you decide that is the best option for your DC at the time and will otherwise be used for the benefit of their education even if they don't go to private school (e.g. extra curricular, tutoring, school trips, ultimately university fees).