Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask for other solutions to my in laws up-sizing problem

236 replies

LoHicimosAmigos · 27/02/2022 09:07

Just wondering if there was something I hadn't thought of. My mother in law is not in a good place right now, signed off work with depression, saying that she doesn't see the point in living anymore. I'm trying to help her from a practical point of view. She also speaks to me about it as everyone else shuts any discussion of emotions down.
Lots of her depression stems from their house. She LOATHES her neighbours, hates the area and it's too small. Adult sons still live it home so that's four adults in a two bed. Parking is a nightmare. She works just round the corner but hates her job, yet she needs to work and can't drive so says it's the only job she can do. The boys fight constantly, partly because they're men in their thirties who still have to share a room.
What she thinks will solve the problem is buying a three bed house. So a room for both sons. However selling a two bed will not buy you a three bed in the same area without getting a mortgage which they don't want and at sixty plus I can see why.

The only options I can see are that she considers buying a three bed in another area, further from work and therefore finds a new job. Or she tells the sons she is giving them until this date to move out and she can buy a lovely two or one bed in the area of her choice, maybe give up work and have a better standard of life.
I think this is a much better idea. She refuses to 'kick them out' but everyone would be happier. One son has given up work altogether as he only needs money for the odd take away. The other is saving but also has a brand new car. I think they need independence, the whole house is so full of tension and depression as if this is not how any of them imagined life. They all love each other but need some space.
I'd love to know if there are any government schemes, initiatives etc to help older people buy a bigger house or help children to move out but keep a share of the capital or something similar.

OP posts:
ginghamstarfish · 27/02/2022 10:27

No wonder she's depressed! She needs to boot her sons out and downsize to a 1 bedroom home, with lower bills, cheaper to run, easier to look after, and no room for guests.

viques · 27/02/2022 10:25

@LoHicimosAmigos

Also in defence of my BiL's, they have had no help in anyway with money to move out. Most people of my generation have had some help with deposits as we are the third generations of home buyers. That makes a big difference! My in laws are the first generation, meaning they didn't inherit a substantial amount whilst already being homeowners, which could then be passed to their children. Im not saying all get this but a lot do.
If they are in their thirties then they have had at least ten years of active working life to save. If they had then pooled their savings there would be enough for a deposit on a flat or a small house even, depending where they are in the country. Of course, this is pie in the sky since they have hunkered down at the bank of mum and dad and are enjoying their inheritance before they inherit it if you see what I mean.
BluebellsGreenbells · 27/02/2022 10:24

I agree with PP you clearly are trying to save this family. They don’t want to be saved.

trackerby · 27/02/2022 10:21

You're wasting your time OP. Two men in their their thirties, sharing a room and fighting all the time. Your ex, their brother is unstable, and what's FIL got to say about any of this?

Far too many issues for you to resolve OP. I wouldn't even try.

Chloemol · 27/02/2022 10:19

@LoHicimosAmigos

I agree but it's not easy for young men, either share a room in a shared house or stay at home and save for their own place, which I imagine is what they intended to do.
But they are not, or at least one of them isn’t as you say he hasn’t got a job

They are in their 30s so if this was the idea then surely they would have done this by now, and certainly wouldn’t have given up a job or bought a new car

Tough love is needed. She needs to put the house in the market if she doesn’t like it and find somewhere she likes. She does not take into account what her sons want, rather she tells them they need to find somewhere

However could it be that actually she could stay where she is if the sons move out as the atmosphere would get better? So she gives them a date to leave by

LaChanticleer · 27/02/2022 10:19

I'd love to know if there are any government schemes, initiatives etc to help older people buy a bigger house or help children to move out but keep a share of the capital or something similar.

This idea - this entitlement - is what really irritates me in your thinking.

As if sharing a house is just too hard for two able young men. If that's the way your family thinks ... no wonder we're in a mess.

Totalwasteofpaper · 27/02/2022 10:18

The key thing that struck me in your OP was this

My mother in law is not in a good place right now, signed off work with depression, saying that she doesn't see the point in living anymore. I'm trying to help her from a practical point of view. She also speaks to me about it as everyone else shuts any discussion of emotions down.

You have kids yourself and I am guessing you work so this is another layer of stress and I imagine it weighs heavily and you want to help.
But you can’t because they are entrenched in years of enmeshment.

Your focus is on practical solutions but even you call out some of the dysfunction going on here.

You can argue it all you like but I think you know It is just not normal to be mid 30s and at home with no sizeable deposit especially when it’s overcrowded (I understand it if you have your own wing with en suite and what not)
I imagine she is their skivvy and cooks and cleans for them…
Her job is nonsense. Millions of people use public transport to get to work she could find a new job if she actually wanted to effect change.
That said, I am sure her life is quite miserable but it’s important to note she is to some degree choosing this.

The family clearly don’t have money to burn yet the DBIL has a brand new car (I am firmly middle class and 30s all our friends are homeowners NONE of them buy new cars all have used)
They aren’t adequately housed yet shop at Waitrose weekly. (Our household income is firmly in the £100k+ bracket and we don’t shop there weekly when we do it is comfortably 2.5x cost of our normal shop)
None of this is normal.

Your MIL sounds like she wants to be seen and heard by the men around her who are oblivious and indifferent to the hardship and sacrifices she has makes for them. You are her only port in a storm so she vents at you.

Your DHs family sound dysfunctional and enmeshed at best and you would be surprised but they may even turn on you if you try and upset the status quo.

Tldr
Your BILs are infantiled and enmeshed and it’s not healthy.
you can’t fix it

ThoseFestiveLights · 27/02/2022 10:17

Sorry so many typos there! But yes there are part ownership retirement flats.

It depends on the value of the house. I assume she has a pension?

LaChanticleer · 27/02/2022 10:17

I agree but it's not easy for young men, either share a room in a shared house

Good Lord! I shared houses until my early 30s, when I could afford to move to my own place. I then managed to buy a (tiny) place and had a lodger to help me pay the mortgage (15% mortgage interest was fun).

It's absolutely normal for young people to share houses as adults.

Your DH needs to help your MiL move her sons on. Can your DH intervene with his brothers. Their dissatisfaction is entirely of their own making.

Your idea that she "upsizes" and gets a mortgage or fucking benefit scrounging gets Government support??? ! It's bonkers - sorry, I know you're trying to find solutions, but WHY would you think that stretched councils or us taxpayers should fund your able-bodied young brothers in law to laze about not working and buying take-aways?

Unless this is entire story is a wind up. The more I think about it, the more likely that is.

ThoseFestiveLights · 27/02/2022 10:16

There are some retirement flats where they do a part-ownership but effectively then keep your capital. Not dodgy - at the luxury end of anything.

You need to work out the sums - eg value of hour and what’s needed for a flat for the boys and for your mil.

Are the boys on council housing wait lists?

What does your mil really want?

TrashyPanda · 27/02/2022 10:15

[quote LoHicimosAmigos]@TrashyPanda yes and they're usually horrible too. I had one telling me 'have you not thought about getting a better paid job?' when I work full time for the NHS? I mean yes we could all leave but then where would that leave the country? [/quote]
Err - you are demonising thousands of people with that statement. And going way OTT.

It is their job to manage benefits etc according to Government policy. They don’t make up the rules.

If you apply for benefits you don’t qualify for, they can’t bend the rules for you. Or your MIL. You need more money - what are they supposed to say?

newbiename · 27/02/2022 10:15

@LoHicimosAmigos

I didn't mean it was the role of the taxpayer, I meant sort of like a retirement home has a different market value, could there be anything like that where you could buy a retirement home and then get a large chunk to put into a deposit for a flat, which you still retain if it needs to be sold for care costs in the future.
What does this mean?
TheDoveFromAboveCooCoo · 27/02/2022 10:14

The men need to leave. The jobless one needs a job and they can go rent a flat together.

(I have 2 stepbrothers aged 33 and 36, youngest has never worked in his life, eldest can't hold a job down for longer than a couple of months. Both still living at home and spend all their time growing ridiculous beards and playing on x box and collecting and painting weird little action figures. Their mum had enough and moved out to live with her new DP but is still paying the mortgage and bills on the house - MUG!!)

Can I just say how lovely it is to read a post from a DIL actually concerned about her MIL and wanting to help her!

Meandmini3 · 27/02/2022 10:14

This sounds awful. They’re grown men and need to get a life asap and stop ruining their mother’s! I had zero help with buying my first home other than having a below average paying job at that time. Renting or sharing a house are all better options than sponging off a parent.

Seeline · 27/02/2022 10:11

I think if you are wanting advice specific to your circumstances we need some answers!
Are the brothers actually able to work? If not presumably they receive some form of benefits?
Where is your FIL? What are his views on this?
How does your DP feel about his brothers sponging off his mum and having a detrimental impact in her health?

Hiphopboppertybop99 · 27/02/2022 10:11

@LoHicimosAmigos - are you drip feeding here?

Your OP sounds like your 2 BILs are simply taking advantage of their parents by living with them - which is some way is contributing to your MILs depression?

Are you now saying there are reasons and / or barriers as to why 2 men in their 30s are not living independently, with jobs, either alone or with their own families ? Because I think this has generated the type of responses you've had.

If the latter is the case, then perhaps it is assistance programmes for the sons that maybe more appropriate rather than something for your MIL.

PonyPatter44 · 27/02/2022 10:09

The issue is not that MIL needs to earn more money. It sounds like the job she has is very suitable for her. The issue is that she can't seem to put her foot down. She has enabled two lazy boys to become two lazy men, and now everyone is reaping the consequences, her included.

I am now wondering if there is going to be some enormous dripfeed coming about why these two wasters can't find work. Have they both got massive MH difficulties, or no arms and legs, or conjoined twins?

frazzledasarock · 27/02/2022 10:09

They’re grown ass men not ‘boys’ both men need to be in work and get a place of their own, they’ll probably have better luck buying/renting something together. Probably in a cheaper area.

Your PIL need to give them a deadline to leave.

And it’s really nothing to do with you. Nothing you can do. Will any of the adults involved care for or listen to your advice?

And nope I didn’t get help from my family to move out. I moved into a less desirable area into a place nobody else wanted to buy. So I got a home.

BluebellsGreenbells · 27/02/2022 10:09

I have very small children and it's kind of hard for me to imagine ever kicking them out either

Why? Do you not want them to be independent and have successful relationships? Do you not want them to spread their wings and fly?

I still remember desperately wanting to leave home and live by myself and I sincerely hope my children feel the same!! It’s how it should be.

anniegun · 27/02/2022 10:08

@MichelleScarn

love to know if there are any government schemes, initiatives etc to help older people buy a bigger house or help children to move out but keep a share of the capital or something similar.

I think a lot of people would love a scheme like this this! Can't imagine there is one.
How long have the sons been working for?

There is - its called shared ownership www.ownyourhome.gov.uk/scheme/shared-ownership/
BusinessMindThoughts · 27/02/2022 10:06

The brand new car that one of the sons had bought would've been the equivalent of a good chunk of a deposit or several months' rent. You must know this.

EmbarrassingHadrosaurus · 27/02/2022 10:06

One son has given up work altogether as he only needs money for the odd take away. The other is saving but also has a brand new car. I think they need independence, the whole house is so full of tension and depression as if this is not how any of them imagined life. They all love each other but need some space.

If someone's health, sanity, sleep, work, or self-esteem are suffering because other adults are leveraging it for free time or freeloading they're being abused. Whatever the form of abuse, it will not get better on its own. It's not an accident.

They're all in a very damaging environment and cycle that needs to be broken. The men need to negotiate what they're going to do for themselves.

The MiL may needs some support but for herself alone. The sons need a specific time at which they need to move out and make their plans accordingly. The one with the new car may have to sell it to cover his costs but it was his choice to go with the car rather than save. He may wish to arrange housing with his brother but I should doubt it but that's their decision.

AuntieMarys · 27/02/2022 10:05

Lazy fuckers.

TonytheDog · 27/02/2022 10:04

She should kick them out, leave her job and get a lodger in who pays the going rent.

RitaFires · 27/02/2022 10:04

Seeing as you work in social care you can probably find out what supports are available for BIL's mental health issues and what steps he needs to take to access them.

You can also suggest to new car BIL that sharing a room with someone with mental health issues can't be easy and wouldn't he better off having his own space and sending him links to rooms or flats available in the area.