Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say MIL can't see DS on his birthday

342 replies

ncforthisone22 · 27/02/2022 09:02

It's DS birthday next month. It falls on a weekday. We are doing a softplay party for family and friends the weekend before and a birthday tea with his school class at home on the day starting at 3pm. I didn't want to try to combine the events as too many people.

MIL has been invited to join us at either or both events. She doesn't want to come to the softplay as it's "not her thing" and the birthday tea is during working hours. She has told DH that she will come to our house after work (6.30pm) on DS birthday so that she can give him her presents and spend some time with him.

I really feel this doesn't work for us. The kids are in the bath by 6.30 and DS will be exhausted after a morning at school plus an afternoon party. The house will be a tip and the idea of MIL arriving just after we've Gorran rid of 20 3 year olds fills me with dread.

For context, MIL has form for only ever doing things on her terms.

AIBU to say no to a post party visit?

OP posts:
Folklore9074 · 27/02/2022 13:37

I guess only you know your MIL and what is best for your child but before you raise it and make this a thing just consider if this is the particular hill you want to die on. Its annoying if its a pattern but it is just one day.

AdriannaP · 27/02/2022 13:36

Don’t be so uptight. He is not going to spend time with granny at softplay! Just let her come and see him. One evening of late bedtime won’t hurt him.

On side note - you are hosting 20 3 year olds! 😳 Good luck

Handsnotwands · 27/02/2022 13:36

@ncforthisone22

I don't have a big history with MIL but this is a pattern. Every plan we make has to be exactly what suits her, regardless of whether it's convenient for anyone else
Seems you have a lot in common
TheRideOfYourLife · 27/02/2022 13:35

@Easterbunnyiswindowshopping

Post party he ain't going to bed at 6 30 ish.. Yabu for thinking that. Invite granny. Pour yourself a glass. Let dh deal with the aftermath.
Agreed!
DinoWino · 27/02/2022 13:34

YANBU. At first I was on the fence but your latest post describes the softplay weekend thing much much better. THAT is the family party and time for her to see him. She’s free she’s just choosing not to attend. A lot of GPs would happily sit with a cuppa and enjoy watching all their grandchildren playing together and chatting to the parents. That is special in itself. It’s not a massive public soft-play area. The update on the party at home timing also put me more in favour of YNBU. Your 3 year old WILL be tired post party. He’ll likely have calmed by 6:30 and be in need of a bath and bed. Mine would sleep quickly from exhaustion and I’m be craving sitting relaxing myself at the end of that busy day. If you MIL comes at 6:30 with the expectation that he’ll open and PLAY with her gift we’ll that bedtime totally thrown abs there goes you relaxing evening too!! Selfish of her. She’s ample opportunity to see him around his birthday.

I don’t understand people’s need to see them on “the day”. We see relatives whenever suits us (and them!) around about the birthday. Sometimes that will be the day itself but more often than not it will be a few days or a week either side. My DC can then take time to enjoy each visit and open gifts in front of the giver etc. Otherwise it’s squeezing everything into one day for the sake of it. What about when you child is older and wants to do things with friends? Will the be expected to be available on THEIR birthday to granny? Nonsense.

YANBU tel MIL you full expect your child to be settling for bedtime by 6:30 so she can see him 5-6pm, or at the family softplay or at another point on the weekend.

Migrainesbythedozen · 27/02/2022 13:30

@Gizacluethen What really pisses me off about mumsnet is that you're getting a bollocking now for not letting her do whatever she wants despite it inconveniencing you. But afterwards when you complain about what a nightmare it was getting him to sleep and the house is still a tip because you couldn't tidy up because he was over tired and kept misbehaving and how it's totally put a dampner on the day and you were looking forward to getting him to bed and relaxing with a glass of wine you'll then get a bollocking for NOT standing up for yourself and letting her come when you knew it was inconvenient.

Exactly, OP is the one being inconvenienced by a spiteful and manipulative MIL, and now OP is the one being made out to be the bad guy for not #BeingKind (at her expense) by people who do not bother to read all the OP's posts.

Migrainesbythedozen · 27/02/2022 13:27

@Hobbesmanc It's obvious from the tone of the posts that MIL isn't welcomed or liked by her DIL. Shame really
Well you know what, that tends to happen when the MIL is difficult person and a manipulator who always has to have the agenda of everything to suit her. Maybe read the OP's posts and it will be very apparent why the OP might not like her that much. Pretty obvious that MIL has caused issues and is reaping what she sowed.

Migrainesbythedozen · 27/02/2022 13:24

@LassoOfTruth

Is she the type of granny who would help with bath time, read him a bedtime story? If not then I see your point but you might have to grit your teeth just this once. At least she wants to spend time with him!
The OP has already said in her posts on this thread, that are easily found, that the granny won't do bath time. MIL doesn't want to do bathtime. All she wants to do is play with him; *ncforthisone22 Sun 27-Feb-22 09:21:23 DH did suggest the nanny bath time option, but she wanted to do presents (and playing with presents) and went down the line that some PP's are taking "surely one late night won't hurt". I just don't think that's what's in DS's best interests. He is a bad sleeper and upsetting the bedtime routine or timing throws him off. Just for once I'd love her to just make things easier not harder.*
Gizacluethen · 27/02/2022 13:23

The thing is. I'd have a totally different response with my mum and even PILs possibly. If I gave MIL direct instructions to do a calm bedtime routine she would, she wouldn't directly go against me and hype him up. And my mum would give him a present, have a cuddle and a song then send him to bed while she cleaned up.

You've clearly said that not what she's going to do though so don't ruin his birthday pandering to a grown woman. It'll work perfectly the way you've planned it. He'll have a lovely day and go to sleep easily with everyone feeling chill and happy and you can relax and tidy up 9nce he's in bed. I wouldn't change that for anyone.

Migrainesbythedozen · 27/02/2022 13:23

@Friendofdennis

Let grandma come over on his birthday as she has asked It sounds as if you are making her feel unwelcome But perhaps there is more to your relationship than we know
@Friendofdennis If you actually bothered to read all of the OP's post and replies on this thread, you would have seen that yes, there definitely is more to their relationship.
forrestgreen · 27/02/2022 13:22

Make sure a toy that you by ds is a bath toy.
At 6:25 announce you're running his bath and ds can play with toy.
At 6:30 as ds if he wants dg to watch him in the bath??...

I'd reiterate to her
A come to soft play and watch ds have fun
B come to his party and watch ds have fun
C come after the party but ds will be in the bath at 6:30.

I'd want a firm bedtime too, mine would just continue to wind themselves up until sleep would be impossible. Which isn't kind to them.

Migrainesbythedozen · 27/02/2022 13:20

@UniversalAunt

‘ He is a bad sleeper and upsetting the bedtime routine or timing throws him off. Just for once I'd love her to just make things easier not harder.’

He’ll be excited because it’s his birthday & he’s had 20 three year old kids round for a party, fat chance anyway he’ll stick to bedtime routine or your timings.

Grandmother comes round to see him for calming bath time, hugs & cuddles, & bedtime story. Oh look another present!

Where’s mum? Having a well earned feet-up drink in the kitchen after the party waiting for the Deliveroo for the adults, incl MiL who has been at work & come round specially to see her DCC.

Do yourself a favour, don’t look a GiftGrandma in the proverbial…

@UniversalAunt Are you another one who didn't bother to read all OP's posts before replying? MIL doesn't want to do bathtime. All she wants to do is play with him; ncforthisone22 Sun 27-Feb-22 09:21:23 DH did suggest the nanny bath time option, but she wanted to do presents (and playing with presents) and went down the line that some PP's are taking "surely one late night won't hurt". I just don't think that's what's in DS's best interests. He is a bad sleeper and upsetting the bedtime routine or timing throws him off. Just for once I'd love her to just make things easier not harder.
Gizacluethen · 27/02/2022 13:19

@ncforthisone22

Gosh lots of replies I can't come back to everyone individually. It looks like I'm being unreasonable.

The softplay party is 4x nct children plus half a dozen family children (MIL's other grandchildren). It's a small softplay room which we have hired exclusively with a separate room for tea and cake for everyone. It's hardly softplay hell although I accept it would not be all about MIL spending one on one time with DS.

For the tea, its his classmates coming for a play and run around for an hour, followed by sandwiches and cake. They'll be gone by 5, ready for us all to wind down before (pre)school the following day. They are all 2-3 and spend 3 hours at pre-school each morning, I don't think a 2 hour afternoon commitment is that out of the ordinary for anyone. If MIL wanted to come immediately after the party, that would work, but by 6.30 we will have calmed down and be starting bath/bed routine. One night does make a difference for us with a bad sleeper.

And to those asking if I work. Yes I do, and I've taken the day off. MIL would be welcome to visit at a different time on a weekend if that suited her better, but it has to be on the actual day

Absolutely not unreasonable. The softplay part sounds perfect for her to spend time with her whole family. Coming 1.5hr after a party. When he's settled and ready for bath and bed to hype him back up again is just not viable at all.

What really pisses me off about mumsnet is that you're getting a bollocking now for not letting her do whatever she wants despite it inconveniencing you. But afterwards when you complain about what a nightmare it was getting him to sleep and the house is still a tip because you couldn't tidy up because he was over tired and kept misbehaving and how it's totally put a dampner on the day and you were looking forward to getting him to bed and relaxing with a glass of wine you'll then get a bollocking for NOT standing up for yourself and letting her come when you knew it was inconvenient.

Why should she come just because she wants to when you don't want her to and think it'll make your life harder? I don't understand why people think you should suck it up and make your life more difficult for her.

Herewegoagain84 · 27/02/2022 13:18

In theory if you had a reasonable, helpful, flexible MIL then I would say YABU. But I gather from your posts that she sounds like she does things on her terms / may be purposefully awkward. If that’s the case I get where you’re coming from, as her attitude will make you feel more resentful/resistant to her plans. If you truly think it’ll cause more issues than it’s worth (perhaps she’s not the sort of granny that helps with bathtime/bed etc), of course put your foot down - it’s your house / your DC and she’s been invited to two other events. If she’s usually helpful and not going to make snarky comments about untidy house etc, your DC will cope with a quick visit before bed, I’m sure.

UniversalAunt · 27/02/2022 13:14

‘ He is a bad sleeper and upsetting the bedtime routine or timing throws him off. Just for once I'd love her to just make things easier not harder.’

He’ll be excited because it’s his birthday & he’s had 20 three year old kids round for a party, fat chance anyway he’ll stick to bedtime routine or your timings.

Grandmother comes round to see him for calming bath time, hugs & cuddles, & bedtime story. Oh look another present!

Where’s mum? Having a well earned feet-up drink in the kitchen after the party waiting for the Deliveroo for the adults, incl MiL who has been at work & come round specially to see her DCC.

Do yourself a favour, don’t look a GiftGrandma in the proverbial…

Hobbesmanc · 27/02/2022 13:12

@hdjdjehhdhdvsv

*hellithurt

Got what an awful MIL making an effort to see her DGC on his birthday* She isn't making an effort though, she could go to softplay or his party and she doesn't want to make the effort to do either of those things. why should this little boys parents be expected to host 3 separate meetings for one birthday?

and why shouldn't a little boy be allowed a party with his friends incase his grandparents don't want to attend?

OP if you want peoples real responses, you should have said 'family member' or 'close relative'. As soon as you say mil you become an evil, blocking bitch.

Be available when you are available and don't ever feel bad for putting your child before an old lady.

Old lady? Gosh what a mean and ageist post. She's in full time work and presumably has very young grandkids if they're all at soft play. She might still be in her forties

It's obvious from the tone of the posts that MIL isn't welcomed or liked by her DIL. Shame really

LassoOfTruth · 27/02/2022 13:10

Is she the type of granny who would help with bath time, read him a bedtime story? If not then I see your point but you might have to grit your teeth just this once. At least she wants to spend time with him!

Friendofdennis · 27/02/2022 13:10

Let grandma come over on his birthday as she has asked It sounds as if you are making her feel unwelcome But perhaps there is more to your relationship than we know

Migrainesbythedozen · 27/02/2022 13:10

@334bu

*MiL has already been given the suggestion of doing bathtime and putting her grandson to bed and she still isn’t happy. OP is not unreasonable to tell MiL to do one.*

I would have thought that being able to spend one on one time with grandson, putting him to bed, reading a story etc, would be welcomed by most grandmothers. OP is not being unreasonable but grandmother is.

Yep.
Migrainesbythedozen · 27/02/2022 13:09

@Gazorpazorp

MiL has already been given the suggestion of doing bathtime and putting her grandson to bed and she still isn’t happy. OP is not unreasonable to tell MiL to do one.
Exactly. People on here never bother to read an OP's actual posts before responding.
HumunaHey · 27/02/2022 13:07

@dottydodah

You say MIL has been invited to a Soft play party.well fairly obv this would not be her "thing" and a party for 20 children! Neither would appeal to me either .Plus the party is during work time .DS is likely to be high as a kite after that ,so maybe DGM coming over may help .Surely an hour or so would be OK .She can read him a story and sit with him while you clear up/have a G and T to recover ?
FFS it's not about the GM. It's a party for a little boy. It's not about where it "would appeal" to someone else.

I've been to plenty of weddings, parties, etc. that didn't appeal to me. I still showed up to support and be with people I care about. I also love sitting back and watching my DS play with his friends. You see their personality really shining through. I'd have thought a GM would like that too.

I didn't know it was the done thing not to go to a loved one's celebration just because it wasn't your thing.

Migrainesbythedozen · 27/02/2022 13:05

@Kitkat151 You don't think MIL is reaping what she has sowed? She is clearly from all the OP's posts, a very difficult and manipulative woman who wants have the agenda all her own way and isn't interested in helping out the OP. Maybe you should read (all) of OP's posts again.

DearlyBeloathed · 27/02/2022 13:04

@zurala

I'm so surprised by the vitriol on here! YANBU OP. My children also need bedtime to be as routine as possible, and especially did at 3, and I wouldn't even let my own mum (who is lovely and helpful) come at 6.30pm let alone someone unhelpful. And my mum wouldn't even suggest it because she knows the routine is important and puts the children first.

Your mil has a number of options:
Attend the soft play party
Come at 5pm on the birthday itself
Meet up another day to do gifts

It really doesn't need to be on the actual day itself, my children almost never see grandparents on the day because we live far apart so we do a weekend, sometimes it's weeks away from the birthday itself and that's fine! The children enjoy an extra birthday celebration and grandparents get an occasion that works for them.

Your mil is being unreasonable and making it all about her and i honestly don't understand all the replies castigating you. There's a huge difference between a playdate and tea after school, and someone arriving at bathtime!

Come at 5pm on the birthday itself

When she's still at work?

knittingaddict · 27/02/2022 13:03

@ncforthisone22

DH did suggest the nanny bath time option, but she wanted to do presents (and playing with presents) and went down the line that some PP's are taking "surely one late night won't hurt". I just don't think that's what's in DS's best interests. He is a bad sleeper and upsetting the bedtime routine or timing throws him off. Just for once I'd love her to just make things easier not harder.
So you would never be flexible with his night time routine, ever? Not for anything?

I was a strong supporter of routine when my children were little, but you sound a far too rigid about it. It does come across that this is because it's your mil. When are you giving your child their presents? At softplay or at your home party or on a separate occasion? I think it would be nice for your child's grandmother to have a bit of time with him on his birthday and see him open his presents from her.

HumunaHey · 27/02/2022 13:02

I think the varying opinions are related to how important it is to see someone on their actual birthday.

I personally don't think it's that important for a DGM to see DGC on the actual birthday, so I really think OP is not BU.

Also, it seems DGM is able to come sooner than 6.30 but she's choosing that time which she must know that, with a toddler, the later it is, the more inconvenient.

Swipe left for the next trending thread