Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say MIL can't see DS on his birthday

342 replies

ncforthisone22 · 27/02/2022 09:02

It's DS birthday next month. It falls on a weekday. We are doing a softplay party for family and friends the weekend before and a birthday tea with his school class at home on the day starting at 3pm. I didn't want to try to combine the events as too many people.

MIL has been invited to join us at either or both events. She doesn't want to come to the softplay as it's "not her thing" and the birthday tea is during working hours. She has told DH that she will come to our house after work (6.30pm) on DS birthday so that she can give him her presents and spend some time with him.

I really feel this doesn't work for us. The kids are in the bath by 6.30 and DS will be exhausted after a morning at school plus an afternoon party. The house will be a tip and the idea of MIL arriving just after we've Gorran rid of 20 3 year olds fills me with dread.

For context, MIL has form for only ever doing things on her terms.

AIBU to say no to a post party visit?

OP posts:
Migrainesbythedozen · 27/02/2022 15:25

@Sirzy

I have read all the posts but I still think the OP is being stubborn just for the sake of it. She wants to spend time with her grandson opening his presents with him, is that really bad?
@Sirzy Because the MIL stubbornly demands it be ON his birthday. The MIL can open presents with him the day after, or afternoon before. She is just too stubborn and has to have it her way. Reading all the posts shows the MIL is the stubborn one who has to have everything her way with zero thought to anyone else. It's not even about the grandson, it's all about her. The posts show this.
Sirzy · 27/02/2022 15:22

I have read all the posts but I still think the OP is being stubborn just for the sake of it. She wants to spend time with her grandson opening his presents with him, is that really bad?

naomi81 · 27/02/2022 15:22

@naomi81

I'd just let other half deal with his mother and son for the night, and just excuse myself to get all the tidying up done in peace ✔️ even miss the bath etc, just make sure he's in bed when she leaves. My mil is the same, her way or no way 🤷‍♀️ she's like that with everyone so I don't take it personally.
Actually I would turn it in to a real positive and be overly greatful, that it would really work for you all for her to come then as you can get everything tidied away whilst she opens presents with her grandchild. She might hate the fact that you think It's a great idea and not come 😂
Migrainesbythedozen · 27/02/2022 15:19

@ilovemyboys3

Are you just being difficult because she doesn't want to do what you want her to do. Kids could go in the bath 20-30 minutes later and maybe she could help? Feels like your punishing her because she won't go along with your plan
@ilovemyboys3 Read all of the OP's posts. The MIL is the one being difficult because OP won't do what MIL wants her to do. MIL said she won't do bath time. Read all of the OP's threads and you will see the MIL is being difficult and manipulative.
ilovemyboys3 · 27/02/2022 15:02

Are you just being difficult because she doesn't want to do what you want her to do. Kids could go in the bath 20-30 minutes later and maybe she could help? Feels like your punishing her because she won't go along with your plan

frazzledasarock · 27/02/2022 14:57

And thank god my MIL has compassion and common sense and would not demand we allow her to impose like that.

DC will have a lot of birthdays many on weeks days we always have a nanny birthday celebration on which weekend she chooses for DC’s birthday. FIL does the same comes over on the other available weekend. And mine are similar ages to yours and the only grandchildren and the absolute darlings of their grandparents eyes.

BlondeWidow · 27/02/2022 14:53

@ncforthisone22 She'll just turn up anyway.... You do realise this, right?!

frazzledasarock · 27/02/2022 14:53

Your MIL sounds like hard work.

I’d carry on with bath and bed and if she turns up tell her to read him a bedtime story. I really wouldn’t let my dc open presents at bedtime as they’d want to play and then would not sleep till gone 9 which would mean several wakings in the night as they’d be overtired which makes my DC cranky and difficult and then I’d have a screaming tantruming child in the morning who would not be willing to do anything.

I could handle that on a weekend not on a weekday when I need to be in work on time.

melj1213 · 27/02/2022 14:47

YABVU - I would never stop anyone from wanting to see DD on her birthday unless they literally turned up in the middle of the night.

I can understand MIL not wanting to come to soft play - my DD is now 12 and I managed to avoid the soft play stage because we lived abroad until DD was about 6/7 and soft play wasn't really a thing where we lived so I've never really seen the appeal, it's always so loud, busy and overwhelming whenever I have been in one. I have been the "family supervision" at soft play for younger family members parties and I don't think I ever spent more than about 5 minutes with the birthday child because they were so busy enjoying their friends/playing/eating etc so it's not really quality time.

As for your DSs actual birthday - she cannot attend the actual party as she is working, so I don't see why it would be so bad for her to come after work, spend a little bit of time with DS, have him open his present and then go to bed a bit later. We don't know your MILs work situation but she may not just be able to take the day off like you have. Where I work our holiday year is April to April so by March I rarely have any holiday leave left (and as we can't carry it over March is usually impossible to get holiday unless you book months in advance becauae everyone is trying to use up the odd days they still have left) and I wouldn't expect to have to book a whole day's holiday to see a family member's child on a work day, as J assume was your MILs reasoning too.

Unless you're going to dripfeed that your MIL works 9-2 and could come over in the afternoon then it's not unreasonable that she wants to come over after work - if she works 9-5 then to allow her to finish work, go home and get DSs present/get changed (esp if she has a work uniform) and come over to your house I don't think it's unreasonable for her to say she will be at yours by 6.30 ... you could ask her to come ASAP after work but depending on her commute and the distance between your houses, she may not be able to get there much earlier whether she wants to or not.

ShowOfHands · 27/02/2022 14:45

I've read all the posts so hope I'm allowed to comment.

It's his birthday. She wants to see her grandson open his present. I'd just say "fine, see you then, please bear in mind that we will be doing xyz at these times so you might have to pitch in with bath time but otherwise we're looking forward to seeing you". It doesn't have to be about battles and boundaries and standing grounds or locking horns.

naomi81 · 27/02/2022 14:26

I'd just let other half deal with his mother and son for the night, and just excuse myself to get all the tidying up done in peace ✔️ even miss the bath etc, just make sure he's in bed when she leaves. My mil is the same, her way or no way 🤷‍♀️ she's like that with everyone so I don't take it personally.

5128gap · 27/02/2022 14:20

So 20 3 year olds with all the disturbance and over excitement that will cause is fine, but one woman wanting to see her grandchild on his birthday is an insurmountable nuisance? Neither of the events you have planned allow for any one on one quality time for your MIL and DS, which obviously wasn't your priority, but its understandabke she would like it. At soft play she'd be just hanging round in a noisy (rather unpleasant to most adults) environment catching the odd glimpse of him. She's not around for the other party. YABU.

UnconditionalSurrender · 27/02/2022 14:13

I'm another who thinks she should go to the soft play and see all the other members of the family. But then I have PIL who do whatever suits them despite how much it inconveniences me. I'm pretty sure they do it on purpose as a sort of power play. Plus they wouldn't help if they did turn up on DC's birthday. I have boundaries now.

Migrainesbythedozen · 27/02/2022 14:06

[quote mugoftea456]@Migrainesbythedozen I'm not suggesting MIL turns up and takes him straight for a bath. Open presents. Spend half hour playing and having a cuppa. Then do bath time. Life if too short to fall out over stupid things like a kid going to bed an hour late one day a year.

[/quote]
You still haven't read the OP's posts, @mugoftea456 . The MIL refuses to do bath time. Regardless of that, the OP has clearly put up with a lot from the MIL and as she said, she just wishes the MIL would make her life easier for once, not harder. Why is it always on the DIL to #BeKind at her own expense and inconvenience herself, when MIL always has to change the agenda and inconvenience everyone? Why can't the MIL not do these stupid things? It's not just 'going to bed an hour late', it is that MIL is continually deliberately messing the OP around and making everything harder for her. It's the principle of the thing.

Fantasea · 27/02/2022 14:05

OP, stand your ground and create some boundaries now, I speak from bitter experience with MIL who had to be pandered to, everything was about her. Your son is 3, if you give in this time then next year etc. she will be 'oh but I always see DGS on his birthday'. You say in your OP, 'she has told DH...' Told? Why do her wishes trump yours? You've offered 2 alternatives which she has declined, so she doesn't automatically get her choice. Of course, she wants to see DS open his present but that can be any day, he's 3! She could just as easily do that on her next scheduled visit and have her own quality time with him then.

WhatAHexIGotInto · 27/02/2022 14:04

[quote Migrainesbythedozen]**@MNHQ* really need to make a rule that people cannot reply without reading ALL of the OP's post/replies on a thread. Or put it in the rules to join, or something you click on to say you've read all the posts, before you press send. This is getting way beyond a joke now. FFS, OP has only posted 6 times on this thread, surely it's not so much of an effort to click See all* and read only the OP's post/replies before posting on here? Jesus Christ, is 6 posts too much to read? F8ck sake! Hmm[/quote]
My apologies @Migrainesbythedozen, I was reading on my phone and inadvertently skipped the subsequent pages after the first one.

mugoftea456 · 27/02/2022 14:02

@Migrainesbythedozen I'm not suggesting MIL turns up and takes him straight for a bath. Open presents. Spend half hour playing and having a cuppa. Then do bath time. Life if too short to fall out over stupid things like a kid going to bed an hour late one day a year.

labyrinthlaziness · 27/02/2022 14:02

@ncforthisone22

I don't have a big history with MIL but this is a pattern. Every plan we make has to be exactly what suits her, regardless of whether it's convenient for anyone else
You can never properly explain this sort of thing, written down it always looks petty, but I know what you mean - basiclly she is just a PITA and you are sick of it being one way?

I would leave it with your DH, it is his mother, and say to him if she comes round at bedtime then you want him to do bedtime and you will pop out.

Sometimes you have to just leave them to it.

Migrainesbythedozen · 27/02/2022 13:48

@MNHQ really need to make a rule that people cannot reply without reading ALL of the OP's post/replies on a thread. Or put it in the rules to join, or something you click on to say you've read all the posts, before you press send. This is getting way beyond a joke now. FFS, OP has only posted 6 times on this thread, surely it's not so much of an effort to click See all and read only the OP's post/replies before posting on here? Jesus Christ, is 6 posts too much to read? F8ck sake! Hmm

WhatAHexIGotInto · 27/02/2022 13:47

I would gladly hand over DS to her for presents, bath time, whatever, while DH and I tidied up after the party. He'll be tired and grumpy anyway so it could do you a huge favour. You say it's not your DSs best interests but that's not quite true is it. You just want things to happen your way, which is fine, but your son's best interests could definitely include a loving grandparent.

MrsLargeEmbodied · 27/02/2022 13:47

@saraclara
someone on the ward when ds was born offered to take a photo, i didnt want to disturb ds so it was only of me and dh, also squirming Blush

Nanny0gg · 27/02/2022 13:46

So, if she goes to softplay she'll be with her other grandchildren and family

Perfectly reasonable

Migrainesbythedozen · 27/02/2022 13:44

@mugoftea456

You are being difficult. Gran can do bath/story/bed and you a DP can clear the house up. I would be specifically asking my MiL or mum to do this to help us out !
Oh ffs @mugoftea456 not yet another poster. Are you another one who didn't bother to read all OP's posts before replying? MIL doesn't want to do bath time. She doesn't want to help clean up or do anything. All she wants to do is play with him; *ncforthisone22 Sun 27-Feb-22 09:21:23 DH did suggest the nanny bath time option, but she wanted to do presents (and playing with presents) and went down the line that some PP's are taking "surely one late night won't hurt". I just don't think that's what's in DS's best interests. He is a bad sleeper and upsetting the bedtime routine or timing throws him off. Just for once I'd love her to just make things easier not harder.*

READ ALL THE OP'S POSTS BEFORE REPLYING.

mugoftea456 · 27/02/2022 13:41

You are being difficult. Gran can do bath/story/bed and you a DP can clear the house up. I would be specifically asking my MiL or mum to do this to help us out !

saraclara · 27/02/2022 13:41

I was that routine bound parent for a period, and I still, 35 years on, feel awful about my mumzilla moment. We only saw my parents maybe every couple of months. We were visiting and staying overnight, and my mum said that her best friend would like to pop over to see the baby for the first time (baby was probably about six months old). We said fine, and agreed a time just before bath time. The friend didn't arrive so we started bath time (this was way before mobile phones). The friend then arrived, having been held up by a road closure following an accident.
My mum asked if we could bring the baby downstairs afterwards so the friend could see her. And we said no. BlushBlush because our routine is that DD didn't come downstairs again after bath, but straight into her cot.

I can feel myself wincing and blushing now. I can't believe how badly we treated that friend and humiliated my mum. I promise that we loosened right up not long afterwards, but when I read OPs like this one, it all comes back to me.

Please don't be me 35 years ago, OP. Routine isn't everything, and people who love your child matter too.

I'm still blushing having written that.

Swipe left for the next trending thread